This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Should People Seeking Government Assistance Be Required To Take Drug Tests?

1652 words - 7 pages

Should people seeking government assistance be required to take drug tests?
On August 22, 1996, President Bill Clinton signed the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Act, also known as the Welfare Reform Bill, into effect ending welfare as it had been known for many years. “This law transformed the traditional entitlement to cash welfare under Aid to Families with Dependent Children (AFDC) into a transitional program, Temporary Assistance to Needy Families (TANF), which requires most recipients to work after two years of receiving assistance, or, at state option, even earlier, with few exceptions. After 60 months of receipt during a lifetime, a recipient is ...view middle of the document...

“This bill is both compassionate and addresses the fact that if they have a drug problem, it’s going to be very hard for them to keep a job,” Osmond said.” (Davidson, 2012)
The Way Out (2012) article states: “Realistically, random drug testing for welfare recipients won’t save the state any money at first. In fact, people can expect costs to rise as a large number of people are herded into treatment. But if the goal is to get people off drugs, this is certainly one way to do it. Randomly testing a section of the population that is not normally tested for drugs would be a good way to reach these people. Then, as more and more of them get the help they need, we can expect fewer and fewer welfare recipients to fail the tests. Based on the response this story is getting so far, many taxpayers would prefer to have their money go toward real treatment for people, rather than free handouts that do nothing for the drug problem.”
Those opposed to drug testing people seeking government assistance believe it is unconstitutional and that the poor (people receiving government assistance) do not necessarily have a higher proclivity to using drugs than the working classing.
According to the Utah ACLU Issue Brief entitled “Drug Testing of Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF)”: “Drug usage among TANF recipients is no different than that in the general population. According to a recent study done by the University of Utah's Social Research Institute, 4.6 percent of those who receive assistance indicated drug addiction. 11 This is similar to statistics about Utah's general population. According to the Division of Substance Abuse and Mental Health's annual report in 2008, 4.9 percent of Utahn's were classified by the study as “needing treatment for drug and/or alcohol abuse.”

The most critical question posed is the cost effectiveness of drug testing welfare recipients. Drug testing is expensive! According to a Times Idea case study on drug testing the poor:
“Drug-testing laws are often touted as a way of saving tax dollars, but the facts are once again not quite as presented. Idaho recently commissioned a study of the likely financial impact of drug testing its welfare applicants. The study found that the costs were likely to exceed any money saved.
Other estimates include the cost of increasing staff to monitor or administer the tests, as in Maryland and Missouri. Idaho’s estimate includes the cost of making programming changes to the State’s information system. Florida’s law and Alabama’s proposal require the applicant or recipient to pay for the up-front costs of the drug test, though both would reimburse those who test negative. Most estimates do not incorporate costs relating to increased substance abuse treatment utilization or to increased child welfare interventions.
Examples of costs used in State cost estimates include:
* Purchasing the drug tests, including initial and retests
* Laboratory fees
* Staff...

Other Papers Like Should People Seeking Government Assistance Be Required to Take Drug Tests?

All Tertiary-Level Students Should Be Required To Be Competent In A Foreign Language

694 words - 3 pages Name: Richard Nattoo 1005015Topic: Whether or not tertiary-level students should be competent in a foreign languageNarrowed Topic: All tertiary-level students should be required to be competent in a foreign languagePurpose: To convince tertiary-level students that being competent in a foreign language is beneficial to their future careersThesis: Although some may disagree, all tertiary-level students should be required to be competent in a

Should Same-Sex Marriage Be Legalized Federally With All States Required To Comply?

808 words - 4 pages sanctity of marriage. Another reason it should be legal is because marriage is not only a human right, but it is also a civil right. I don’t see why the other 13 states shouldn’t be required to comply with the legalization of same-sex marriage. Many argue that the legalization of same-sex marriage would require more government spending and less revenue, but that is incorrect. The country’s economy would benefit from the legalization of same

Should Audits For Pay Gender Be Required Of Eeoc

1857 words - 8 pages employers with government contracts and the lack of the majority of employers conducting their own audits and providing the data to the EEOC shows that voluntary compliance is not working, which means that a mandatory audit should be required for employers with over 100 employees. Audits for employers with over 100 employees are needed to help narrow the gap in pay between genders because of the impact of the lower wages for women

Should School Uniform Be Required All Through 12th Grade

712 words - 3 pages Colegio Vista Hermosa Sección Secundaria Inglés Debate Should school uniform be required all through 12th grade Clothes are a way of expressing yourself and standardized school uniforms could be a major obstacle for self expression and self discovery. Schools should not require students to wear uniforms so they can self-express properly. Self-expression is an important part of human development and some experts believe that not

Should Business Take Responsibility to the Environment

1183 words - 5 pages for the world’s poorest. The United Nations is spearheading the creation of a dedicated fund to combat HIV/AIDS, malaria and TB. The goal is to raise $7-10 billion in new money each year for at least ten years. The new Global AIDS and Health Fund will quickly channel new resources, without undue bureaucracy, to projects that are proving to be effective. The approach is revolutionary and will reform the way in which we use development assistance

Why a Western Diet Is Unhealthy and What People Should Eat to Be Healthy

967 words - 4 pages Student: Sbraletta Matosinhos, Bruno Why a western diet is unhealthy and what people should eat to be healthy In recent years, the concern for health is increasing. The main factors contributing to the declining levels of health in the Western world are a lack of physical exercise, paired with an unhealthy diet. Although this sounds like a simple problem to fix, the vast majority of people are not actually aware of the dangers of a poor diet

Death Penalty for Drug Trafficking Should Be Abolished

1166 words - 5 pages encourages people towards violence in society CONCLUSION I. In conclusion, drug trafficking is indeed a heinous crime but that doesn’t mean that the convict should be sentenced to death. There is a better punishment which is life imprisonment that could secure the rights of the convicts as well as the justice system II. Echoing the words of a Member of the Indian Parliament in 1958 where he moved a motion to abolish the death penalty, and gave a speech , “Thou shalt not kill…we shall not kill, but we shall change the hearts”.

A Business Owner Should Not Be Able To Hire Or Fire Anyone Without Interference From The Government

802 words - 4 pages A Business Owner Should Not be Able To Hire Or Fire Anyone Without Interference From The Government Byron E. Hercules Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University   Abstract The recent economic downturn has forced many industries to change the way in which they do business in order to survive. Managers must find ways in which in to motivate their employees to overcome their employees natural resistance to change. Mangers must find ways to

Should Prostitution be Legalized and Regulated by the Government?

1045 words - 5 pages Should Prostitution be Legalized and Regulated by the Government? When we examine sex as a trade, the combination of philosophy, cultural precedence, religious influence and politics made each country select how to handle it in its own way. In Singapore, sex for money is open and commonplace. Denmark women can be legal prostitutes so long as it is not their sole means of income; Canada, France and Mexico allow it. Prostitutes must be

Should Vaccination Be Given to Children

1222 words - 5 pages vaccines are “unnatural” and do not follow their families religious remedies. These arguments cannot be argued because of the fact that we have our rights given to American in the 1st amendment. Families can just request exemptions to not take the vaccine. The government has no choice, but to give the exemption to the families due to the 1st amendment. Another reason that people may not agree with vaccination is that nearly all medicines have some kind

Should the Death Penalty Be Mandatory for People That Kill Other People

1557 words - 7 pages serious crimes such murder, treason, rape, or drug trafficking. Death penalty has long been the most debated issue throughout the world. Many people believe that death penalty should be legalized in order to provide justice for the victim, to reduce any further crimes, or to promote security. However, many other people are still holding their belief that death penalty should be abolished because it’s not the logical way to promote justice or to

Related Essays

Xbcom/275 Final Paper Should Welfare Recipients Be Required To Drug Test?

2448 words - 10 pages Should Welfare Recipients Be Required To Drug Test?Whenever there is an economic downturn, recession, or near-depression, the United States government looks for places to cut and for instances of waste fraud and abuse to help curtail spending and lessen the amount of debt it takes on. While spending on social programs like Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) is only a small part of the total of government spending (less than 2%) and

Should People On Welfare Be Drug Tested

1905 words - 8 pages most of the general public look at it from a financial point of view while people who receive benefits look at it from a constitutional point of view. The government court system and judges are not backing the drug testing idea because of the fourth amendment. In my personal opinion I am for people being drug tested who receive benefits or any assistance from government funded programs. The middle class worker has to be drug tested to work, earn

Should All University Students Be Required To Attend Classes?

620 words - 3 pages Trần Thị Mộng Trinh Topic: Should all university students be required to attend classes? The extent to what level of efficiency modern education system could perform in teaching students is always a heatedly debated topic. Among many suggestions that could improve learning efficiency, the necessity of attending classes has been argued frequently in recent years. Some people claim that attending classes is a must to students. Other

Should Parents Be Required To Vaccinate Their Children

1155 words - 5 pages Richard Chatham Chris Bishop Engl 1302 October 10, 2015 Should parents be required to vaccinate their children? Back in the 1990’s, people started becoming worried after many years about the mercury in the vaccines their kids were receiving. Then, in 1996, a former British surgeon and medical researcher, Dr. Andrew Wakefield put out a now disproved study linking the measles, mumps, and rubella vaccine to autism and bowel disease (Ferric C