This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Separation Of Power Essay

3418 words - 14 pages

SEPARATION OF POWER: A COMPARATIVE STUDY

INTRODUCTION
The research topic deals with the concept of „the separation of powers. The researcher would like to highlight the concept of separation of powers and then gradually comes to the point separation of powers in England and US. After that the researcher would like to articulate the separation of powers in India.
The doctrine of “the separation of powers” as usually understood is derived from Montesquieu whose elaboration of it was based on a study of Locke’s writings and an imperfect understanding of the eighteen century English constitution.
Montesquieu, a research scholar, conceived the principle of separation of power. He found ...view middle of the document...

But constant experience shows us that every man invested with power is liable to abuse it, and to carry his authority as far as it will go …. To prevent this abuse, it is necessary from the nature of thing that one power should be a check on another…”
Writing in 1748, Montesquieu said: “When the legislative and executive powers are united in the same person, or in the same body or magistrates there can be no liberty. Again there is no liberty if the judicial power is not separated from the legislative and executive powers where it joined with the legislative power, the life and liberty of the subject would be exposed to arbitrary control; for the judge would then be the legislator. Where it joined with the executive power, the judge might behave with violence and oppression. There would be an end of everything where the same man or the somebody to exercise these three powers.”
Though in the face of complex socio-economic problem demanding solution is a modern welfare state, it may no longer be possible to apply the separation theory strictly, nevertheless, it has not become completely redundant and its chief value lies in emphasizing that it is essential to develop adequate check and balance to prevent administrative arbitrariness.
It is very much essential to a democratic country for the smooth running of the government to protect the individual liberty and to avoid the confrontation among the legislative, executive and judiciary, the separation of powers in a check and balance form is highly needed so that three organ cannot trespass with the confined area of the other. But in a rigid sense it is impossible and in a balance and check form it is quite possible which makes filtration of the arbitrariness of the powers of other as because if any organ gets the three powers in hand definitely it becomes absolute and despotic which does causes the hardship of the individuals in a country and the idea of democratic value and constitutionalism would be jeopardized. With the changing needs of the society it is important that the reasonable restriction should be upon the executive, legislative and judiciary in a compartment form but not in watertight compartment form.

IDENTIFICATION OF ISSUES
Issue No. 1:
How far separation of powers is maintainable in accordance with intermingle of powers among the legislative, executive and judiciary?
Issue No. 2:
Whether in a rigid sense separation of powers is possible in a country like India?
Issue No. 3:
How far is it correct that separation of powers is a myth rather than reality?

COMPARATIVE STUDY OF THE SEPARATION OF POWER
(I) SEPARATION OF POWERS IN U.S.A.
The doctrine of separation of power is implicit in the American Constitution. It emphasizes the mutual exclusiveness of the three organ of the government. According to it, the legislature can not exercise executive or judicial power; the judiciary cannot exercise the other two powers.
The express letters to the U.S.A....

Other Papers Like Separation of Power

Palm Oil Pres Machine Essay

695 words - 3 pages ): through floating dry processing the fruit core and fibers separated. Fiber and other lighter stuff are blown appearance. 10.Palm oil mil process of crushing (crusher): stone cracked open grain separation kernel and shell. In hydrocyclone, the use of kernel and core-shell particle proportion to their separation. 11.Palm oil mil process of power house: the use of diesel powered generators and turbine generators, more environmentally friendly energy

Commentary on the Chong Fung Yuen Case of Right of Abode in Hong Kong

1528 words - 7 pages . These resolutions will be analyzed based on the effects on Hong Kong in the aspect of the constitutional framework, rule of law and separation of power. The Hong Kong constitutional framework bases on basic law. Though “One Country, Two Systems (OCTS) and high autonomy is ensured by the PRC, there are still restrictions, e.g. the removal of chief executive can only be performed if he is not able to discharge his duties or refusal of passing

Judicial Overreach

1926 words - 8 pages I The Judicial Activism and Judicial Over-reach has always been a live subject which brings out wealth of literature, add to our learning and provoke our thoughts to delve deep as to why judicial activism has to be availed as a tool for curing the sufferings of the masses at large. It is significant to notice that in every debate on the subject, the theory of ‘Separation of Power’ of three organs of the State is necessarily discussed. The

History 301

1176 words - 5 pages guaranteeing them certain rights were to be largely uninvolved in the daily lives of its citizens. It was expected that citizens govern themselves. The government would be responsible for protecting individual rights but was not meant to be the custodian of its citizens. The government was meant to protect not provide. Therefore, for the type of government that the founders envisioned, the system of checks and balances and separation of power worked

Checks and Balance

633 words - 3 pages , instead of electing the judges themselves. These judges can stay in their position for life. The President can issue pardons or get out of jail free cards. Ford pardoning Nixon after Watergate is an example of this. Although the concept of checks and balances and the separation of powers are simple: the actual process of it is quite confusing. The reasoning is to prevent too much power to once particular branch. It’s like having a whole bunch of

Checks and Balences

863 words - 4 pages making a necessity for the separation of powers, and for checks and balances. Checks and balances is a system where the different parts of government have powers that can affect and control the other parts of government in order for the other branches cannot become too powerful. This is to prevent any branch of government from exerting too much power. Each branch of government has different powers and functions that they carry out, they are

Doctrine of Separation of Powers

3227 words - 13 pages 1st Internal Assignment Administrative Law The Doctrine of Separation of Power Clive D’souza 13010124119 Division B III Year Introduction: The Government of any country will be the agency or machinery through which the will of the people is realised, expressed and formulated. But for the will of the people to be so expressed, realised and formulated, there needs to be a well organized system which works together, jointly as well

John Locke the Blueprint

1017 words - 5 pages ; which make things such as property, liberty and life god given rights. Next, Locke influenced the spread of democracy by educating us on how the government is built by the people and for the people; therefore, we can vote to change the government or our representatives if we do not agree with its policies or fail to protect our rights as citizens. Last, in order to avoid arbitrary power by the government, Locke proposed the separation of powers

Business Law

380 words - 2 pages cause why they should not use the public library, and remanded the case. E. RATIONALE: It was stated within the case that if the library is a part of the school system, then clearly the board was bound to make such a separation. If it is not a part of the school system, then the board has the power to make such a separation as police regulation under the authorities. In the management of the public library authorized by the legislative acts

Michelangelo Sistine chapel how is it humanism

558 words - 3 pages is like that of an old shrew,The brush endlessly dripping onto my face,Has coated it with a multi-colored paving.Though as the paint dribbled into his eyes and down his face Michelangelo never lost sight of his inspiring design. The ceiling contains nine paintings illustrating the creation (Separation of Light From Darkness, Creation of the Moon, Stars, and Planets, and Separation of Land and Water), the story of Adam (Creation of Adam, Creation

Chromotography

3895 words - 16 pages Chromatography From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia Jump to: navigation, search Pictured is a sophisticated gas chromatography system. This instrument records concentrations of acrylonitrile in the air at various points throughout the chemical laboratory. Chromatography (from Greek χρῶμα chroma "color" and γράφειν graphein "to write") is the collective term for a set of laboratory techniques for the separation of mixtures. It involves

Related Essays

The Absence Of A Separation Of Powers In Britain Gives The Government Too Much Power

885 words - 4 pages ‘The absence of a separation of powers in Britain gives the government too much power.’ Discuss. 1c) Britain's govt. is too powerful due to its absence of a separation of powers. Britain’s executive, legislative and judiciary are fundamentally connected. Many are part of two or more these powers, such as the PM who is in both the executive and the legislature. Therefore a large majority can do as it pleases. The Govt. controls itself and can

Various Types Of Magnetic Separators In Mining Industry

872 words - 4 pages magnetic separation machine, flat ring strong magnetic field magnetic separation machine, SHP type wet strong magnetic field magnetic separator, and made ring wet strong magnetic field magnetic separator. (1) dry strong magnetic disc magnetic separator Dry magnetic separation machine is a common equipment and manganese iron equipment, the mainstream of strong magnetic separation JiXuan mine equipment. Divided into: a tube of three roller dry strong

Broken Family Essay

1014 words - 5 pages . This can change this attachment style and can make a child have feelings of anger, bitterness and confusion, which can alter the child's ability to form meaningful relationships. This is one impact that can take on adolescents, after a parental separation. When separation occurs, it’s very typical for adolescents to be unhappy and want their parents to remain together. That unhappiness can translate into low self-esteem, behavioral

Assess The Positive And The Negative Aspects Of The United States Political Framework Based On The ‘Separation Of Powers’

2589 words - 11 pages the hands of a single institution was denied 4. Article I of the constitution, specifically vests legislative power in congress, the executive power in the president (Article II) and the judicial power in the Supreme Court (Article III) 5. This division of power naturally created a system of checks and balances between the three branches of government. The separation of powers in the US has prevented the executive from becoming too powerful and