Scottish Independence Essay

568 words - 3 pages

Scottish independence- pros and cons from the economical point of view
Essay
Recently the Scottish referendum and especially the economic consequences of Scottish independence became one of the most interesting and controversial world topics.
The most common view is that Scotland needs the rest of the UK and the economic and social factors of independence would be too great to deal with. Many people think that going independent is an extremely large economic gamble and will lead to many unwanted consequences - lack of national resources, economic crisis because of investors’ uncertainty, higher tax and interest rates, currency problems, change in the economic and political relationships with European union and other countries.
In its unity with the UK, Scotland is part of a very powerful, rich and influential state. This confers all kinds of useful economic ...view middle of the document...

Economists say an independent currency would be so problematic that it would dissuade investors, affect fiscal policy (government spending and taxation), monetary policy (interest rates), policies related to financial stability. A new Scottish currency would also increase the costs of trading with other countries (including the rest of the UK) and potentially expose Scotland to exchange rate fluctuations.
According to the Institute for Fiscal studies more spending cuts and tax rises would be needed to ensure fiscal sustainability in an independent Scotland. They say that Scotland's immediate fiscal position would be in a worse state than the rest of the UK, because government spending per person is significantly higher in Scotland and mainly because of higher spending on public services rather than benefits.
Many Scotsman believe that Scotland will have full access to oil presently shared amongst Britain and this will bring more money and make Scotland a petro-dollar paradise equivalent to Norway. Scotland would get a 90% geographical share of North Sea oil and gas fields based on the division of the UK's territorial waters after independence. But many of the North Sea rigs are at the end of their life and production levels are falling. Once the oil runs out Scotland will have less to sustain its dreamy wealthy future. The ability to attract major industries – manufacturing, IT, finance – to the country would be diminished by independence, for all the reasons listed above, endangering thousands Scottish jobs. Investors hate uncertainty and a Scottish “Yes” vote means lots of it.
All things considered, Scotsman decided to keep the promise of the union, realizing the uncertain consequences of becoming independent. The economic and social problems as a result of independence would have been too deep to be solved in a year or two. If become independent Scotland will need decades to become economically stable and worldwide accepted country.

Other Papers Like Scottish Independence

Constitutional Reform Since 1997 Has Not Gone Far Enough. Discuss

1093 words - 5 pages Parliament has formed, in particular their call for independence with a referendum scheduled to take place in September 2014. Additionally, the West Lothian Question remains, which pointed to the fact that Scottish MPs to sit in Westminster Parliament and vote on matters that only relate to England, although English MPs do not sit in Scottish Parliament and do not vote on Scottish matters. Devolution is also not entrenched and therefore can still

Discuss the Issues That Separatism Has Brought to Different Areas of the World

1063 words - 5 pages outcasts and largely ignored in terms of welfare by the Turkish state. On the other hand however, not all separatist movements end in turmoil and conflict. The Scottish National Party is an excellent example where separatism is being solved peacefully, their methods include marches, protests and voting, most notably the recent Scottish independence referendum, which was narrowly, defeated 55-45 in favour of a non-independent Scotland. The motive

To What Extent Has the Location of Sovereignty in the Uk Changes in Recent Years?

1099 words - 5 pages retrieve any power devolved however, devolution is an evolutionary process and it would seem increasingly impractical that Westminster really could consider dissolving the Scottish Parliament when it has now been in operation for ten years and has a direct mandate from the voters to govern them. If the Scots then went onto vote for independence, in the referendum that Alex Salmond proposed, then Westminster’s claims to sovereignty would be further

Has Constitutional Reform Since 1997 Gone Too Far?

1577 words - 7 pages Kingdom and as a result that devolution was an essential reform, yet parties such as the Scottish National Party feel that more needs to be done to provide the devolved bodies with greater influence over their regions and remain unhappy with the decisions made. Conversely many deem devolution as a step towards the eventual breakup of the United Kingdom, they deem the 2014 Scottish referendum on independence as a key example of how it has failed

Parliamentary Sovereignty

1935 words - 8 pages the UK constitution derives from. In 2005 The Constitutional Reform Act (‘CRA’) ‘reinforced the principles of the separation of powers and independence of the judiciary by removing the judicial powers’ yet is hindered of effectiveness by the EU granting sections 2, 3 and 4 of the HRA causing a fusion and not a separation of powers. Prior to this in ‘Madzimbamuto v Lardner Burke 1969’ Lord Reid held that: ‘Due to the formation of the UK

Politics Exam Paper

560 words - 3 pages hasn’t always involved high turnouts as throughout the history of the referendum there has been only a few high turnouts, with the majority being reasonably low. For example the 1973 referendum only had a 58% turnout however now we have seen a recent high in turnout with 85% of the allocated electorate voting in the 2014 Scottish Independence referendum. This shows how political participation may not all be bad and with referenda like this showing

Partnership Working

3072 words - 13 pages examples included community development and regeneration partnerships. Gone are the days of public organisations working autonomously to their own agendas and with little or no regard for the aims or challenges faced by other organisations. For some time partnership working has not only been recognised as an essential ingredient in achieving best practice but due to the fact that the Scottish Government perceives it as an essential

PSY/230 Character Evaluation

1365 words - 6 pages is a film that premiered in 1995. Braveheart, according to “Wikipedia” (2014), “epic historical drama war film directed by and starring Mel Gibson. Gibson portrays William Wallace, a 13th-century Scottish warrior who led the Scots in the First War of Scottish Independence against King Edward I of England” (Braveheart). When looking at the personality traits from The Big Five that the lead character, William Wallace, portrayed in the film

United Kingdom

1720 words - 7 pages explanations for trends. The key surveys included are: For adults, seven primary studies: the Continuous Household Survey (CHS), the General Household Survey (GHS), the Health Education Population Survey (HEPS), the Health Survey for England (HSE), the Health Survey for Wales (HSW), the Omnibus Survey and the Scottish Health Survey (SHS). All were large national cross-sectional surveys repeated on a regular basis, every one, two or three years

Referendums

1294 words - 6 pages Scottish Parliament while voters in Wales were asked whether they wanted a Welsh Assembly. The answer to both of these referendums was yes. Also, just recently: - Scotland has been called into play - the belief that the majority is wanting independence – that as a country it is able to sustain itself economically. A surge in the uprising from public unrest and politicians wanting control of the way they govern its people in terms of economic

Topics Countries

3973 words - 16 pages is Edinburgh, the capital of Wales is Cardiff, the capital of Northern Ireland is Belfast and the capital of England is London. I’d like to speak about Scotland. It is the second large part of the country which is situated in the north. It is washed by the North Sea, the Irish Sea and the Atlantic Ocean. It is separated from England by the Cheviots Hills. It is divided into Highlands, Lowlands and Uplands. The Scottish feel their

Related Essays

Scottish Independence Essay

2777 words - 12 pages Introduction Described as Scotland's "biggest choice since 1707" (McLean et al, 2013, p. ix), the upcoming referendum on Scottish independence will provide a pivotal event for the current and future populations of Scotland as voters get the opportunity to decide whether or not they are to remain a part of Great Britain or become an independent nation. As McLean et al (2013) have referenced, 1707 was a year of major importance in Scottish

Scottish Independance Essay

1121 words - 5 pages Scottish Independence David Carlin After the 1997 British General Election, New Labour was voted into power, referendums, on the devolution of power, were held in both Scotland and Wales, resulting for victories in the ‘yes’ camp. This resulted in the formation of The Scottish Parliament and the Welsh assembly for the first time in hundreds of years. There are those, including myself, who believe that Scotland should become completely

Land Use Scotland Essay

579 words - 3 pages Preamble: There is growing public discontent in the traditional land use structure in Scotland, which can be associated with the Scottish cultural predisposition for independence; and freedom from rule. Furthermore, the current economic situation has polarised popular opinion, globally; to an extent that global economic elite are vilified. Furthermore, as the disparity of landownership in Scotland is stark, there is a growing movement to

Wallace V Edward Essay

1959 words - 8 pages Jakub Kominka (261474) PhDr. Lidia Kyzlinková, CSc., M.Litt. English Social History I (1066—1707) 13 January 2010 Struggle for Freedom - Brosnachadh Bhruis Brosnachdh Bhruis, in Scottish Gaelic, means Scots, Who Have. It is a title of a poem very well known among Scottish people as it served for a long time as an unofficial anthem of Scotland. It mentions three most important historical figures during the war for Scottish independence