School Uniforms Essay

621 words - 3 pages

School Uniforms

Until President Clinton called attention to the issue in his State of the Union address, mandatory public school uniform policies were sporadic local occurences. A few school districts had been quietly experimenting with uniforms for years, but the issue caught President Clinton's eye after the Long Beach, California school district released some numbers suggesting that after only one year, its mandatory uniform policy had not only brought about significant decreases in vandalism and fighting, but had also led to higher test scores. Now that the President's endorsement has elevated school uniforms into the realm of federal education policy, a question needs to be answered: Are uniforms a good idea?

The most concise response to this question is, nobody knows. The superintendent of the Long Beach School District claims that the district's self-generated data showing decreases in certain forms of student misconduct is proof that ...view middle of the document...

First, although President Clinton said he supported uniforms "if it means that teen-agers will stop killing each other over designer jackets," the Long Beach policy, like virtually every other uniform policy in the country, applies only to elementary and middle school students, and not to teenagers. While younger children may be amenable to uniforms -- might even like them -- teenagers are different. It's axiomatic that adolescence is a time when young people strive to express their uniqueness and individuality in many different ways, and especially through fashion. Of course as several political cartoonists have pungently observed, teens are already in uniform -- baggy pants, T-shirts and baseball caps worn backward. But these are "uniforms" of teens' own choosing, and not fashions dictated from above. School administrators and teachers know that teenagers are sure to rebel against uniforms policies; that's why so far they've been reluctant to impose them at the high school level.

Second, for a public school uniform policy to be legal, it has to have an opt out provision. Every child in this country has the right to a public school education, and that right cannot be conditioned upon compliance with a uniform policy. Some parents and children will have religious objections to uniforms. Others won't want to participate for aesthetic reasons. If given a choice, it is hard to imagine that most or even many teenagers will opt to wear the uniforms.

Beyond these practical considerations, the call for school uniforms is not constructive because it is a Band Aid solution to a set of serious problems that defy easy answers. There is something profoundly cynical about our political leaders promoting uniforms in the face of crumbling school buildings, overcrowded classrooms, and dwindling education funds. The debate over uniforms is a diversion. Attractive, modern and safe school buildings, small class sizes, schools with well stocked libraries, new computers and an array of elective courses like music, drama and art -- those are the kinds of changes that would produce long lasting and dramatic improvements in student deportment and achievement. But of course that would require us to invest, rather than disinvest, in our public school system.

Other Papers Like School Uniforms

School Uniforms Essay

1061 words - 5 pages Before school uniforms were even thought of children use to wear their regular clothing to school. It did not matter what they wore as long as they got their education. There were even some cases where children wore the same clothing to school each day, because their parents could not afford to buy new ones. However, when school uniforms became known and began to become popular, schools began to turn to them. Schools saw wearing school uniforms

Rubuttal Of School Uniforms Essay

345 words - 2 pages Article Rebuttal Amanda Gapski BCOM/275 October 1, 2012 Kim Hinton This is an article that is in favor of school uniforms. It claims that uniforms offer safety in the environment and helps stop competition about clothes (Boutelle, 2007). It does offer some good, albeit rhetorical, claims for uniforms. It lays claim that uniforms offer “uniformity” so that children are easier to keep track of in on field trips and allows administration

Argument Against Wearing School Uniforms

1150 words - 5 pages Argument Against Wearing School Uniforms Theirs is an ongoing discussion in the nation about school uniforms, whether or not they help with behavior problems and scores (“An Argument Against School Uniforms”). Kade A., A sixth grade student, when asked about school uniforms she said, “no, I don’t like them because they are uncomfortable and makes her and maybe the people around feel like their wearing church clothes all the time” (“An Argument

In Favor Of School Uniforms

1258 words - 6 pages Whether people like it or not, uniforms are here to stay in modern society. They are seen everywhere, from schools to policemen. Uniforms are a requirement for life. In professional work settings and careers they are expected. On this basis, why wouldn't they be used in a school setting? School uniforms prepares children for their futures. Parents and elders are filled with pride when they see the future generations in clothing that highlights

Final Proposal: Pro School Uniforms

999 words - 4 pages students dress more inappropriately to school, and do not follow their set dress code. With schools having set uniforms, bulling would decrease, and it is said that academics rise, violence reduces, it is a money saver for parents, and better prepares the student for the work force in the future. Also when a school has a uniform it helps the community look more appealing to those looking to buy a home there. Problem Statement Uniforms should

The Importance and Benefits of School Uniforms

807 words - 4 pages The Importance and Benefits of School Uniforms Maria Del Carmen Flores Eng/147(BSAM1JQKU6) March 28, 2016 Becky Sutton The Importance and Benefits of School Uniforms The first reason for school uniforms can help save a lot of money in parents’ pocket. According to "School Uniforms Don’t Have to Cost So Much" (2013), (The annual cost for school uniform for parents is $249.00. According to "Back-To-School Shopping Costs: How Much Parents

Different Opinions of People About Wearing School Uniforms

603 words - 3 pages School Uniform Essay example: Should we wear schools uniforms? School uniforms are to show that schools have disciplined and smart kids. It shows it’s a respected and great school for kids to go. But others opinions are there is no real point to uniforms. They are a waste of money; you could be spending it on descent clothes that you would like to wear. Many people have different opinions on both positive and negative sides. This informative

School Uniforms Are Good for Students and Parents

1717 words - 7 pages School Uniforms are Better for Parents and Students Denise Smith Rasmussen College Author Note This written assignment is being submitted on December 11, 2014, for Sabine Meyer’s G124 English Composition course. School Uniforms are Better for Parents and Students School uniforms and dress codes have been a controversy among schools, private and public, since as early as the 1900’s. In 1932, for example, an Indiana high school

After years of desire for school uniforms, my wish was

536 words - 3 pages After years of desire for school uniforms, my wish was never granted. I believe that the dress code of school uniforms would be a great asset to Medina High School because of the students. Most students won't have to worry about what they are wearing. They are at school to learn about life and their future, not to impress their peers of how "cool" they look. What to wear today? That is the question that faces me every morning after my

This Essay Is About The Fairness Of Mandadted School Uniforms, And How They Infringe On Our First Amendment

793 words - 4 pages challenge the public schools and President Bill Clintonto show me concrete data that proves that uniforms will decrease or eliminate violence and killings at school. In my research, the data is simply not out there to support this idea. First off, all of the studies that have been conducted have been at the elementary level, not necessarily at the secondary level where the majority of the violence and gang activity lies. In the Long Beach Unified

The Government Of The United States Of America Has The Right To Make The Decision On Whether Students Should Have A Dress Code Which Mandates The Use Of School Uniforms

1290 words - 6 pages The Government of The United States of America has the right to make the decision on whether students should have a dress code which mandates the use of school uniforms.The government of The United States of America has the right to make the decision on whether students should have a dress code which mandates the use of school uniforms. The debates of whether use of school uniforms should be enforced have been going on for years. There are a

Related Essays

School Uniforms Essay

1266 words - 6 pages Angel Macias Professor Benham ENC1101 4/18/2013 School Uniforms Did you ever notice how the students in the school dress a little to revealing? Well school uniforms would help get rid of that problem so the students could concentrate more on school work. Wearing schools uniforms would help make students’ lives simpler. The students would no longer have to worry about what to wear every morning. School should be based on how the students

School Uniforms Essay

574 words - 3 pages School Uniforms School uniforms! Who likes them?! Not ME! Over the past years, school boards, teachers, parents have been pushing for uniforms. “students dress inappropriate” they say. “Boys sag and girls wear to tight or not enough clothing!”. Well students have the right to dress the way the want too. Let's face the music, children and teenagers are growing up much faster than anyone had expected. Their peers, family, home, music, and

School Uniforms Essay 1152 Words

1152 words - 5 pages School Uniforms and You Let's face the music, children and teenagers are growing up much faster than anyone had expected. Their peers, family, home, music, and television are all influencing them on how they behave and dress. The numerous ways students dress can reflect countless of messages such as the latest fashion trend, hand-me-downs, whatever is comfortable, or violence. I remember when I was in middle school. I did not wear the cutest

School Uniforms Essay 2322 Words

2322 words - 10 pages School Uniforms By Kendall Cole June 2014 AED/200 - CONTEMPORARY ISSUES IN AMERICAN EDUCATION Instructor: Christine Duhamel University of Phoenix Since the late 1990's school uniforms have been worn in mostly urban school districts across America. Initially, they were opposed by stakeholders, especially the students. School uniforms were accused of stripping students of their creative expression. After a while, uniforms were