This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

School Sport Injuries And Negligence Essay

1211 words - 5 pages

Every school year, millions of students participate in school sports. Participating in school sports has grown from an estimate 4 million students playing a sport in the early 1970's to about 7.7 million in 2011. Unfortunately school principals, athletic directors and coaches cannot guarantee that students will remain accident free while participating in any sport. In today's litigious world, schools, and staff can be subject to a lawsuit.
Over the past few decades, more tort cases have been filed. A tort concerns civil wrongs and address the duty, breach and injury sustained to one individual as a result of another's conduct. The premise is that a person who is injured could be ...view middle of the document...

By signing the wavier, the athlete agrees to relieve the school of any liability and assumes the risk related to that sport
Although schools are normally protected from liability, a student injured while playing school sports may allege a number of negligence claims against the coach: (1) failure to teach the player how to safely play the sport; (2) failure to warn the player of the possible risk of injury; and (3) failure to provide protective equipment.
When determining negligence liability against a coach when a player has suffered an injury, the question is did the coach have a duty to protect the athlete from the injury suffered? Coaches have a duty to teach their players the basic fundamental of the sport, the rules of the game, and techniques to avoid injury. Therefore, coaches may be found liable to their athletes if they either neglect to provide instruction or if they only provide minimal to no instruction to the players.
In Woodson v. Irvington Board of Education, the plaintiff, a football player, alleged negligence on behalf of the coaches caused him to suffer a severe neck injury while tackling another player during practice. He claimed the coach did not provide him with the proper instruction on how to tackle safely. The jury found the coaches negligent and awarded the plaintiff $6.5 million because there had only been one practice prior to the injury and he had not been taught how to keep his head up while making a tackle nor had he been told the importance of doing so.
In contrast, in Kahn v. East Side Union High-School District, the plaintiff, a junior varsity swimmer, alleged that the coach required her to dive in shallow water during a swim meet after receiving very little to no diving instruction. During the dive, she broke her neck when she hit her head on the bottom of the pool. The California Supreme Court held that although the coach did not show concern for the safety of the plaintiff, the coach did not intentionally injure the plaintiff.
Most people understand that there are potential dangers in any sport. However, many coaches and school officials are warning athletes of the possible dangers that exist so they will not be held liable for injuries suffered to their athletes. In Hammond V. Carroll County, a female junior made the varsity football team. During the first practice scrimmage she was tackled and received several internal injuries. She was hospitalized for a while and the doctors had to remove part of her pancreas due to a ruptured spleen. The plaintiff sued the school board claiming she was not warned of how severe injuries may be if she participates in...

Other Papers Like School Sport Injuries and Negligence

Synopsis of Tort Cases Essay

2374 words - 10 pages negligence. The opinions for the defendant are based on the Knight ruling, and playing sports involves an assumption of risk; therefore the participants are responsible for their own injuries. Scenario 2 The chain of events that occur in scenario two will call for an alarming amount of civil complaints and the possibility of two criminal actions. In the first part of Scenario two Anna orders a meal, takes her first bite and cries out in pain

Case Study on Negligence

2187 words - 9 pages Case Study on Negligence - Stella v Christine Stella can take an action of Negligence against Christine for her careless conduct regarding the slippery floor as well as the heating urn and steamer. She will be the plaintiff, and Christine, the defendant. Stella bears the burden of proof that Christine owed her a duty of care, but omitted to perform it, which caused her personal injuries and economic loss. The elements, including duty of care

Assumption of Risk

802 words - 4 pages negligence caused the plaintiff’s injuries.The sports injury doctrine, relating to 12 V.S.A. § 1037 “which established that there are inherent dangers to be accepted by skiers as a matter of law.” The motion for a new trial was denied and “ found that the sports injury statute applied to participants in any sport,” not just the operators. “While skiers fall, as a matter of common knowledge, that does not make every fall a danger inherent to

Written Report

1270 words - 6 pages , or partial fault disallows the damages in a contributory negligence jurisdiction. He is also, I would argue, be more than 50% responsible for his injuries and therefore in a State that had adopted a partial comparative negligence clause be unable to recover. Only if a State allowed for him to be more than 50% responsible and still recover would he be able to obtain any judgment. Again, that would only be if the school was found to have any

Eng 102 Essay

1286 words - 6 pages “unprepared player” that is more at risk (Patlak and Joy 3). Head injuries in soccer are real and the issue cannot be ignored any longer. One issue when dealing with soccer head injuries or any other sport for that matter, is the lack of reporting of head injuries. A coach’s job is to win as many games as possible (at least that is how most feel). This attitude or misconception can lead to permanent brain injury. If a star player on a team is

Civil Lawsuit

671 words - 3 pages company that manufactured the drug, not only listed the directions and possible side effects on the box as well as inside the box packing the drug, but also advertised through numerous TV commercials. Question Four: This case involves a claim against the defendant for injuries suffered by the plaintiff as a result of apparent medical negligence. Do you have any existing opinions or strong feelings one way or another about this situation? This

Exculpatory Clause


Is Your Head in the Game?

1208 words - 5 pages --player contact injuries among US high school athletes, 2005-2009. Clinical Pediatrics, 50(7), 594-603 Lincoln A, Caswell S, Almquist J, Dunn R, Norris J, Hinton R. Trends is Concussion Incidence in High School Sports: A Prospective 11-Year Study. Am J Sports Med. 30(10) (2011), accessed January 31,2011 Meehan WP, d’Hemecourt P, Collins C, Comstock RD, Assessment and Management of Sport-Related Concussions in United States High Schools. Am. J. Sports Med. 2011; 20(10)(published online on October 3, 2011ahead of print) Shaw, G. (2011). Football Tackles Concussion Risk. Retrieved from http:

Synopsis of Tort Cases

3448 words - 14 pages claim that his actions were authorized by the nature and rules of the game. Based on the facts of the case the claim will be resolved in favor of the defendant, opposing player. Football is a contact sport and players get injured and can foresee the occurrence of injuries within the boundaries of the game. Injured Fan v. Quarterback The quarterback drops back to throw a pass, and is hit by an opposing player, breaking the quarterback’s arm

Health Screening and Physical Activity

2402 words - 10 pages claimant must prove: that the defendant owed the claimant a duty of care; that the defendant broke that duty of care; that the claimant suffered injuries as a result of the breach of duty of care.’ (Goodey, 2008, pg.144) In this answer I will set out to establish whether or not David and Sarah have a case for a claim for negligence against the facility and in doing so I will look at who is at fault for the accident and the events leading up to

Palsgraph vs. Long Island Railroad Co

675 words - 3 pages defendant) due to negligence. While the jury and the appellate court found that the railroad guards had been negligent, the railroad company appealed to New York’s highest state court (Clarkson, Miller, Cross 2014) In my opinion, the major question proposed in this case is “what constitutes negligence?”. Although Palsgraf claimed that the railroad guards were the proximate cause of her injuries, one may see this case differently. One may argue that

Related Essays

Sport And School Essay

762 words - 4 pages It is believed that by playing a sport or engaging in sport related activates at school, students may build strong personalities and can help improve their physical fitness. These sport activities can also lead to positive educational and social values. Participating in sports can help children and young adults become more responsible, self-motivated, and even disciplined. Skills such as anger-management, attitude control and time management

Liability And Risks Of Nfl Concussions

906 words - 4 pages Encephalopathy, a disorder attributed to multiple concussions (Hanna). As a result, numerous class-action lawsuits have been filed against the NFL alleging “negligence, fraud, and concealment” (Brandt). Although the League has implemented new safety mechanisms and rules regarding head injuries, the main focus of the lawsuits is based on the NFL’s past failure to perform its legal duty of protecting and informing players about the true dangers and life-long

Research Paper On Cheerleading

1276 words - 6 pages injuries that result to the worst. Accepting cheerleading has grown upon many minds over the last few years, but honestly, it's entirely different with the hierarchy of the NCAA who makes the decision. As a former cheerleader for almost six years, I do not take this debate lightly. Always I was told that cheering was not a sport, and it made me quite furious. Honestly, I didn't know anything about cheerleading until I first tried out for the

Child Development Essay

1325 words - 6 pages parent, meaning that children are generally freer in how they can express themselves. Physical development refers to the ability of children to use their physical bodies and physical skills along with physical growth, characterized as motor development. One large aspect of physical development I found in my observation was under factors related to childhood injuries. Sport had hit himself in the face three times, said “ow”, and then started laughing