“School Class Differences In Educational Achievement Are The Results Of Factors Within Home”

1680 words - 7 pages

“School class differences in educational achievement are the results of factors within home” only?

Differences in educational achievement can be assessed through three forms of stratification; social class, ethnicity and gender. Moreover, the main factor s which spill light on the matter are both the home and school factors.

For instance, the picture of academic achievement by social class is consistent. The survey of Halsey, Heath and Ridge (1980) showed that boys from the service class (top strata) had 40 times more chance of attending a public than a boy from the working class. Even after the abolition of the tripartite system, with 1944 Act, the chance of a working class boy to ...view middle of the document...

Nevertheless, Blackstone and Mortimore argue that the fact that working class parents go less often to school, do not necessarily suggest that they are not interested in their wards’ education but instead, are unable to do so, as their manual jobs involved more longer time than non- manual work.

A variant of Douglas and Feinstein’s approach, is adopted by the American sociologist Herbert H. Herbert (1967) who argue that the ‘the value system of the lower classes creates a self-imposed barrier to an improved position’. He outlined the following differences between the working and middle class value systems- members of the working class place a lower value on achieving high occupational status, on education, and believe there is less opportunity for personal achievement. Hyman did, however, agree that not all members of the working class did share those values and that a sizeable minority did not share them.

Another important point, the British sociologist Sugarman (1970) emphasized, is that middle class and working class subcultures (cultures within a culture with some norms and values distinct from those of the minority of the whole) contain different attitudes and orientations which may account for class difference in educational achievement. He claims that working class subculture emphasizes fatalism- involving the acceptance of the situation rather than efforts to improve, immediate gratification- enjoyment of the pleasures of the moment rather than sacrifices for future reward, present-time orientation reduce the motivation for academic achievement and ultimately collectivism which involves loyalty to the group rather the emphasis on individual achievement which the school system demands. Thus, the subculture of pupils of working class background places them at a disadvantaged position.

Basil Bernstein, an English sociologist, suggested that class differences in speech pattern which he distinguished two forms of pattern which he termed as restricted code (kind of shorthand speech) and elaborated code (explicitly verbalizes many of the meanings that are taken for granted in a restricted code). The first operating on particularistic standards while the latter on universalistic standards. For instance, Bernstein’s research involved showing children from different classes, cartoon pictures which told a story and asking them to write down what was happening. Children who were used to elaborated code could write the story in full details so that the pictures were not needed to understand. Working class children who used a restricted code, wrote the bare bones of the story, and pictures were vital to get an understanding. Thus, as formal education is conducted in elaborated code, this places working class children at a disadvantaged because they tend to be to be limited to restricted code. However, Harold Rosen (1974) attacks these arguments for generalising when Bernstein says that all working class children have a restricted code and...

Other Papers Like “School Class Differences in Educational Achievement Are the Results of Factors Within Home”

Class Differences In Achievement Essay

1277 words - 6 pages Examining class differences in achievement (1) external factors a) Explain briefly what is meant by the term ‘elaborated speech code’. (2 marks) The term ‘elaborated speech code’ refers to the language used by the middle class. It has longer, grammatically correct sentences and a wide vocabulary. It is a varied type of speech and may can communicate abstract ideas, in addition to this it is context free. b) Identify three policies that

Using Material for Item a and Elsewhere, Asses the Importance of Cultural Factors in Causing Social Class Differences in Education Achievement

1095 words - 5 pages Students that are in a working-class have the tendency to underachieve in school, in contrast to those students that are middle-class, this is due to external and internal factors. External cultural factors are claimed to be a key cause of social class differences in educational achievement according to various sociologist. These factors consist of Cultural deprivation, cultural capital and material deprivation. Students from working class

Outline and Assess the View That in School Factors Have the Main Influence on the Educational Achievement of Different Social Classes (50 Marks)

632 words - 3 pages Outline and assess the view that in school factors have the main influence on the educational achievement of different social classes (50 Marks) INSIDE - The Curriculum What is taught in schools disadvantages working class pupils. The knowledge taught in school is different to the cultural experiences of working class pupils. For example, History deals with the ruling class such as kings, queens and politicians, rather than the majority of

Applying Material from Item a and Your Knowledge, Evaluate the View That Gender Difference in Levels Achievement Are the Product of Factors Outside of School

680 words - 3 pages private school may achieve higher than a working class girl who goes to a state school, because of working class not being able to afford private school or locality issues and not being able to reach schools of their preference. To conclude, sociologists clearly suggest that gender differences in achievement are based on factors outside of school because these generally have the most impact.

Outline Some Of The Ways In Which Cultural Deprivation May Lead To Educational Under Achievement For Working Class Pupils

290 words - 2 pages , knowledge and skills – that is the ‘right’ culture needed for educational success. Cultural deprivation theorists see three factors as responsible for working-class under-achievement. One factor being the lack of intellectual stimulation. Working class families are less likely to give their children educational toys and activities that will stimulate their thinking and reasoning skills, and less likely to read them. This effects their

Outline Some of the Ways Cultural Deprivation May Lead to Educational Under Achievement for Working Class Pupils (12 Marks)

547 words - 3 pages Cultural deprivation is the theory that many working-class and black children are inadequately socialised and therefore lack the 'right' culture needed for educational success e.g. their families do not instil the value of deferred gratification.Cultural deprivation is an outside school/home background factor that could affect the achievement of working class pupils as if their family do not place a high standard on education, the pupil may

America Is a Class Society, and the Differences Are Immense

1293 words - 6 pages America is a Class Society, and the Differences are Immense The ideal concept of American society is one in which all citizens are treated equal in every realm and situation. Class, race or gender does not divide the utopian America; everyone is afforded the same opportunities and chances for success. Unfortunately this idyllic country does not exist nor has it ever existed. In as much as the majority of the Country's population would attest

What Factors Need to Be Considered When Determining Whether or Not Identified Actions Are Within the Domain of Nursing Practice

799 words - 4 pages of patient’s outcome through the nursing managed center based on nursing research”. (DL, 1994) The American nursing association describes how nurses should think when deciding what factors are within the scope of practice. Questions to be asked are “who”, “where”, “why”, “what” and “how” of nursing. The guidelines are embodied in the nurse practice acts, rules and regulations, guidelines of the state and in the policies and procedures of the

What Are Factors Which Are Related To Academic Success In High-School Students?

501 words - 3 pages As a high-school student, getting your distinctions is the pinnacle of our tedious academic endeavors. Thus drowning ourselves in textbooks and piles of notes is what most of us resorts to do. However, an imperative questions should be asked ; does strenuous and long hours of studying truly guarantees the distinctions that we need and ultimately success in our life? Or otherwise, there are many other factors that contribute in determining the

What Do You Believe to Be the Most Important Social Factors (Both Inside and Outside the School) Which Prevent Learners from Realising Their Educational Potential?

1999 words - 8 pages learning potential. All the factors discussed prove to be relevant in preventing a pupil from reaching their full educational potential. Many are interlinked which makes it challenging to see whether one factor has more of an effect than another. Nonetheless it is clear the internal factors can be sorted out within the school environment. However it is difficult for a teacher to determine the external factors which affect a child from reaching their

Examine Sociological Views Of The Ways In Which Educational Policies May Affect The Achievement Of Pupils

860 words - 4 pages January 2003 – Examine sociological views of the ways in which educational policies may affect the achievement of pupils. There are many Educational Acts enforced in England to help improve and stabilise the education of young people in our country. With these acts in place it encourages more people to want to do well in school and it also helps to provide an education for those who are less fortunate and without it could not go to school

Related Essays

Assess The Importance Of Inside School Factors In Causing Social Class Differences In Educational Achievement

712 words - 3 pages Sociology explanations have suggested many different reasons for the class base differences in education achievement. Studies have shown that there is a 45% gap between classes in A* - C GCSE outcomes. It is suggested that the diversity in educational success between different classes are due to inside factors. These are factors within schools and the education system that could cause these differences. One internal factor is labelling. To

Assess The View That Factors Within Schools Are The Greatest Influence On Social Class Differences In Educational Achievement

1146 words - 5 pages find it hard to achieve within school because they will find it hard to focus in lesson. Despite in school factors, material and cultural deprivation some working class children still achieve in school because of the opportunities the school funds for them, as well as scholarships. All factors are a major part of the Social Class Differences in Educational Achievement.

Evaluate The View That Differences In Educational Achievement Between Social Classes Are The Result Of Factors And Processes Within The School

1376 words - 6 pages Evaluate the view that differences in educational achievement between social classes are the result of factors and processes within the school. Within school there are educational differences within achievement between social classes. Generally the middle class on the whole tend to do better and outperform the working class. Some of the reasons why are put forward by interactionists sociologists who believe that the difference is “a result of

"Internal Factors Within The Educational System Are The Primary Reason For The Improvement In Girls' Achievement" Discuss

1384 words - 6 pages "Internal factors within the educational system are the primary reason for the improvement in girls' achievement" Discuss. Girls achievements have improved over the years due to the external and internal factors of gender differences within achievement. Statistics show that since 1985 boys' and girls' achievements in school have both improved drastically in the percentage of pupils achieving 5 or more A*'s to C at GCSE level. However