Same Sex Marriage And Religious Liberties: Essay

1634 words - 7 pages

In the United States, legalization of same-sex marriage has a long-standing history of opposition from religious circles. Some argue against the legalization of same-sex marriage based on their interpretation of the Bible’s stance against homosexuality (Dobson, O’Brien). Other opponents argue against the practice based on universal tenets of moral behavior, fundamental beliefs that are said to underpin our country’s existing laws and should not be eroded (George, Finnis, Friedman).
Increasingly, however, the arguments against same-sex marriage have turned to the legal realm, asserting that the practice threatens the right to religious freedom. Objectors use the U.S. Constitution and ...view middle of the document...

For example, forcing organizations such as religious adoptive services to place children in the care of a civilly-married, same-sex couple is viewed as contradicting the core values of that organization. The same changes are seen as affecting individuals such as religious marriage counselors, who would potentially risk legal penalties for denying service to same-sex couples.
Furthermore, opponents warn that legalization of same-sex marriage and changes to the civil definition of marriage would cause an avalanche of changes in other areas. Laws regarding employment, education, healthcare, and housing would be altered to accommodate same-sex couples. Such sweeping changes are viewed by advocates of religious freedom as further risking religious liberties of organizations and individuals relating to a range of businesses and industries. In essence, the legalization of same-sex marriage is seen as compulsory sanctioning of a lifestyle that goes against the fundamental beliefs of certain groups and individuals and, moreover, requires them by force of law to act contrary to their religious tenets. This scenario is viewed as a direct assault on religious liberties.
Advocates for same-sex marriage base their argument in the equal protection clause of the 14th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution. They contend that same-sex couples are denied the basic right of marriage. Their argument has been persuasive, and proved to advance the legalization of same-sex marriage in certain states. In the landmark case of Goodridge v. Massachusetts Department of Public Health in 2003, the Massachusetts Supreme Court ruled that it was a violation of the state’s constitution to deny any marital benefits to same-sex couples (DeLaet). Similar victories, though smaller in scope, were subsequently won in Vermont and New York.
These cases, and other victories achieved through the equal protection argument, were more often than not opposed by arguments over the actual morality of same-sex marriages. However, according to same-sex marriage opponents, the biggest flaw in the 14th Amendment argument for same-sex marriage is that it completely disregards religious rights as a legal factor and counter-argument. The issue of one Constitutional freedom disregarding another has become a more prevalent legal focus of opponents of same-sex marriage.
Although our laws and policies vigilantly uphold the separation of church and state, the institution of marriage is a bit of a slippery slope (Moody, Volokh). The role of religion has historically been intertwined with the role of marriage. It is no wonder that the matter of same-sex marriage yields such heartfelt advocacy as well as opposition. The issue contains all the ingredients for complex social and legal conflict: equal protection under the law, religious freedom, marital rights, notions of morality, and religious tradition.
Ironically, same-sex couples and their religious opponents actually share a commonality, that being a...

Other Papers Like Same-Sex Marriage And Religious Liberties:

Same Sex Marriage Essay

2256 words - 10 pages before proposition 8. Ballot Pedia’s 2008 research explains how proposition 8 is a statewide ballot proposition in California. The people of California voted for the illegalization of same-sex marriage. Though some people are against same-sex marriages for religious reasons, not allowing same-sex marriages is discrimination. Same-sex marriages should be legalized because the discrimination same-sex couples receive is emotionally traumatic, and

Same Sex Marriage Essay

693 words - 3 pages society, there was nothing amiss with homosexual love between men. Some ancient religious Assyrian texts contain prayers for divine blessings on homosexual relationships.The Almanac of Incantations contained prayers favoring on an equal basis the love of a man for a woman , a man for man and woman for woman. 3. Yes our country should legalize same sex marriage but since Philippines is a religious country I think it will be difficult to legalize

Same Sex Marriage

854 words - 4 pages Same Sex Marriage Today, the civil union between two males or two females is incredibly controversial, especially in the United States. There is ongoing debate regarding whether or not this type of marriage should be considered legal. Various legal, social, and religious groups have vocalized their stance on this issue. There are some people that feel strongly that same sex marriage should be banned as it may have a negative impact on society

Same Sex Marriage - 799 words

799 words - 4 pages neighbor cheats on their spouse, does not change the sanctity of their own marriage. The sanctity of a marriage is between the married couple, not the rest of the world. Same- Sex marriage is the same as any other marriage; a legal union that should be recognized by both federal and state governments. It is unfair for us to continue to discriminate against people for any reason. Religious or not, heterosexual or homosexual, male or female, everyone

Legalizing Same-Sex Marriage

2443 words - 10 pages above policy. Although Obama is a Christian and he opposed to same-sex marriage due to his religious view, he supports the civil unions to provide more rights and benefits to same-sex partners. According to Belge (2009), Obama suggests the right of adoption for homosexuals. Obama thinks that the child will benefit from having a family regardless of the gender of the parents. It is because there will be a rising demand of adoption and this may

Legalizing Same Sex Marriage

943 words - 4 pages Legalizing Same Sex Marriage Kendra Brooks EN101 English Composition I Grantham University February 14, 2014 Should gay marriage me legalized? This has become a very trending topic in today’s society. I think the better question the people should ask is, why gay marriage shouldn’t be legalized? Homosexuals are human beings that deserve to get the same respect and have the same rights as others. There are some states that allow same sex

Same Sex Marriage - 918 words

918 words - 4 pages Why Same Sex Marriage Should Not Be Legalized In The United States Marriage is something that many dream of from a young age. The media romanticizes the concept of marriage, turning it into a goal to be realized. People hold this dream regardless of their sexual preference. Unfortunately, there are those who believe that not everyone should be allowed to marry. The three arguments are based on religion, family dynamic, and history. The

Same Sex Marriage - 726 words

726 words - 3 pages Same Sex Marriage Student Name University Affiliation Same Sex Marriage Currently, there is the heated ongoing debate whether to allow or reject same sex marriage. This have led to a rift between the conservative individuals and their progressive secularists, with the

Same Sex Marriage Essay

1478 words - 6 pages all of the talk of marriage litigation and 60 rulings in favor of same sex marriage, it would seem that the country is ready for the freedom to marry for all. Quite a lot of people feel that everyone should be able to get married, and have the same rights as same sex couples despite loving someone of the same sex. In April 2015, the question of whether same-sex couples nationwide should have the right to marry will finally get to be heard in

Same Sex Marriage - 866 words

866 words - 4 pages unions” yet many other states have forbidden same-sex marriages (Rauch, 2013). In 1996, the federal government passed the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA), which defined marriage as “…a legal union between one man and one woman” and that “No state shall be required to give effect to any public act, record or judicial proceeding of any other state respecting a relationship between persons of the same sex is treated as marriage” (Rauch, 2013

Same-Sex Marriage

1007 words - 5 pages CHANGING VIEWS OR JUST GOING “STRAIGHT” AGAINST IT? SAME-SEX MARRIAGE IN THE U.S. UNFOLDED IN THE SUMMER OF 2012. THE POLITICAL SUPPORT WAS VERY IMPORTANT. BUT DID SO MANY CHANGE THEIR VIEW OR DID THEY JUST OVERCOME THEIR FEAR? During the 1990’s in the United States there was a group of people who struggled to fit into the society and to be accepted. Homosexual men and women do not have many of the same rights as heterosexuals. One example

Related Essays

Marriage And Same Sex Couples Essay

1999 words - 8 pages religious dimension of marriage. Giving these rights to same-sex couples would not change the “church” dynamics in any way nor would it make any change their faith or religious practices. All couples, whether heterosexual or same-sex, would still be free to make their own judgments about what marriage mean in their world. For example in Catholic churches if you are divorced and remarried then your second marriage may not be recognized by the

Marriage: Same Sex Marriage Essay

1907 words - 8 pages united to a person of the same sex in a relationship like that of a traditional marriage ” (2012). I find this interesting because our federal government does not agree with the second part of this definition, which is the start of where things become extremely complicated. I can’t say that I disagree with either of these definitions and if I were to put it in my own words I would just define marriage as the union of two people into a formal

Same Sex Marriage Essay 2395 Words

2395 words - 10 pages California and Massachusetts will outweigh the state of Kentucky with civil liberty laws dealing with same sex marriage. First I will start by defining the term liberal. The term liberal means favorable to or in accord with concepts of maximum individual freedom possible, esp. as guaranteed by law and secured by governmental protection of civil liberties. ( Next, I will compare and contrast the same sex marriage

Same Sex Marriage Essay

1140 words - 5 pages Rachel Figueroa Lauren Grant ENC 1101 September 2012 For Better or For Worse: The Issue of Gay Marriage The legalization of same-sex marriage is a topic that has been argued in our society for several years. It is also a topic that has been opposed by many people not only because it can be hard to accept marriage between gay couples, but it can also be hard to throw away what is considered to be morals, tradition, the natural law of life and