Russell’s Theory Of Descriptions Can Be Best Understood As A

1564 words - 7 pages

Russell's Theory of Descriptions can be best understood as a response to the shortcomings in Frege's philosophy. He sought a theory of language which, firstly, would avoid using or relying on any Fregean concept of Sinn and, secondly, would solve the "problem of existence" in a way that allowed the truth-value to be determined for all sentences without committing us to the existence of any reference less constituents.Central to both Frege and Russell's approach to language was the belief that "the apparent grammatical form of a sentence can mislead us about the hidden logical form of the proposition the sentence expresses." For Russell one of the key distinctions that Frege failed to make in ...view middle of the document...

e. "you would understand the meaning [of it] if you had never heard it before." In contrast, you would not understand the meaning of a name if you had never heard the word before "because to know the meaning of a name is to know what it is applied to." Russell's analysis allows that traditionally problematic sentences can be solved by rewriting them in a logically appropriate grammatical form. Let us reconsider the example of S: "The King of France is wise." According to Russell, anyone who asserted S would, in fact, be logically asserting the following three propositions: At least one person is the King of France.At most one person is the King of France.Whoever is the King of France is wise.In other words, while D: "The King of France" is the grammatical subject of S it is not the logical subject. Frege overlooks this distinction. D is not a logically proper name that stands in a subject-predicate relationship with "wise". In fact, logically speaking, S is not a subject-predicate sentence at all, but "a complex kind of existential proposition, part of which might be described as a 'uniquely existential' proposition." Since S is a conjunction of three propositions it follows that if one of them is false, then S is false. Thus Russell demonstrates how the truth-value of S can be determined without necessarily positing any existing object denoted by D.As I have portrayed it thus far, Russell seems to have been quite successful in presenting a solution to the basic problems of identity and reference outlined at the beginning of this essay, while avoiding the problems and shortcomings created by the basic Fregean theory of objective sense and truth-value-determining-reference.I wish to conclude by briefly examining the well-known critique of Russell offered by Strawson. According to Strawson, Russell recognizes only two ways in which sentences which appear from their grammatical structure to be about some particular thing can be significant. The first is that their grammatical form should be misleading as to their logical form, and that they should be analyzable, like S, as a special kind of existential sentence. The second is that their grammatical subject should be a logically proper name, of which the meaning is the individual thing it designates.In contrast Strawson denies that an expression used in "the uniquely referring sense" (e.g. a singular subject predicate sentence) falls into either of the two classes. He contends that there are no logically proper names and no descriptions in the Russellian sense. To support this claim Strawson introduces certain distinctions that he thinks Russell incorrectly overlooked.Firstly, he distinguishes between an expression used in the uniquely referring sense and a sentence beginning with such an expression. Henceforth I shall term both respectively expression and sentence simpliciter. Secondly, he distinguishes: (A1) a sentence (A2) a use of a sentence (A3) an utterance of a sentence (A1) refers to the...

Other Papers Like Russell’S Theory Of Descriptions Can Be Best Understood As A

What Is A Political Dictatorship And Why Can Lenin And Stalin Both Be Classed As One?

3554 words - 15 pages (later known as Lenin) can be classed as a political dictator because he gained power while being part of a political party.A member of Lenin's 'Bolsheviks' was called Stalin; another famous dictator of Russia.Stalin was a political dictator because Stalin promoted himself as Lenin's political heir at Lenin's death, and gradually outmanoeuvred his rivals. This was his political wit in manoeuvring people against each other, and as he didn't resort to

Explain How Theories, Such as Dependency Theory and World Systems Theory Can Contribute to an Understanding of Changing Patterns of Global Power (15 Marks)

619 words - 3 pages Explain how theories, such as Dependency theory and World systems theory can contribute to an understanding of changing patterns of global power (15 marks) The changing global power of countries can be difficult to understand as there are a variety of views and theories used in order to explain the shift. The recent developments of BRIC countries has an influence upon this and may be a reason as for why theories such as the Dependency theory

Define ‘Realism’ As A Nineteenth-Century Aesthetic Movement And Discuss To What Extent ‘Un Cœur Simple’ Can Be Described As A Realist Text

1385 words - 6 pages tell the story. For instance, in ‘Un Cœur Simple’, the narrator tells Félicité's life story without observations or criticisms, and in turn the readers must draw their own conclusions. The main reason that we can tell this novel is a realistic piece of work is because, as per usual, Faubert took inspiration from characters in real life and based people in the novel on these characters. René Dumesnil is quoted as saying that Félicité has

Can Economic Indicators Be Used As Effectve Comparators Between Nations?

1220 words - 5 pages economic indicators? Economic growth and GDP provides the means to improving the standard and quality of living, they do not guarantee it. Economic development can be a guide to progress of a nation but regional variations can distort the impact on the population as a whole. It has been noted that 'growth in GDP per capita exceeds growth in economic well-being' Thus well being is as much about perception as tangibles. People are as likely to be

Raising Teenagers Can Offen Be a Challenge

1252 words - 6 pages your relationship. Just as you do not tell your children everything you do, so things are consider to be left alone, so you and your children have your own privacy. If you notice warning signs of trouble you can invade your child's privacy until you get to the heart of the problem. Otherwise, it is a good idea alone your children to have some type of privacy, such as your children’s room, text, and phone calls with their friends. Knowing where

“in Considering the Process of Change in Relations Between Ireland and Great Britain in the Years 1815-1922, How Far Can the Irish Potato Famine (1845-1851) Be Seen as a Key Turning Point?”

2068 words - 9 pages was the first time the Irish question came to the attention of the British parliament and people; and O’Connell and his party was largely to thank for that as “whatever the final judgement on O’Connell’s party, there can be no doubt of its success as a political pressure group.” Catholic Emancipation also had a formative influence on Anglo-Irish relations. According to Fergus O'Ferrall “The manner of its achievement - the calculated

Can Anorexia Nervosa and Bulimia Nervosa Be Considered as Biological and Mental Predispositions or Rather as Consequences of Factors in Society?

4952 words - 20 pages the problem of anorexia is a dysfunction of the hypothalamus in the brain. This theory supports the argument that anorexia nervosa can be considered as a biological and mental predisposition as opposed to consequences of factors in current societies. Scientific research has found that the hypothalamus is invaluable for the management of eating. The hypothalamus has two main functions – the lateral hypothalamus is responsible for the production of

Examine the Argument That Places Can Be a Source of Inclusion and Exclusion for Specific Communities

890 words - 4 pages public as people roam and there are no vehicles. With the removal of the tram lines Market Street became a pedestrian zone thronged with your average shopper. On Market Street there are a rich variety of shops. There is a Tesco across from the Arndale shopping centre. It also has its share of department stores with Debenhams and Primark on the opposite side of tram lines. Through the Pedestrian zone there can be seen a variety of street

Critically Explore the Way in Which Violence Can Be a Source of Popular Entertainment

637 words - 3 pages Critically Explore the Way in Which Violence Can Be A Source of Popular Entertainment. The presumption of Violence is in are faces more than every before. Whether it is something that appears on television, something you have read or something that has affected you directly or someone you know. The latest type of violence that is notes by parents, police and the community is mobile violence, know as happy slapping, another type of violence

Micromarketing can be defined as.....Also uses the jelly belly company as example

599 words - 3 pages Micromarketing can be defined as tailoring products and programs or services to the needs and wants of individuals and groups, including local marketing and individual marketing. The term local marketing refers to tailoring brands and promotions to the needs and want of local groups, such as cities and neighborhoods. Individual marketing is tailoring the product or service to one individual, also known as "one-to-one marketing".Some examples of

“Evaluate the Extent to Which Freuds Theory of Psychosexual Development Can Help Us Understand a Clients Presenting Issue”

3515 words - 15 pages extent from the material of sexual excitations and is composed of instincts that have been fixed since childhood……The Multifariously perverse, sexual disposition of childhood can accordingly be regarded a the source of a number of our virtues, in so far as through reaction-formation it stimulates their development’ (Freud, Sigmund, (1959), On Sexuality, Three Essays on the Theory of Sexuality and Other Works; Edited by James Strachey, Penguin

Related Essays

Politics Can Be Understood Essay

1137 words - 5 pages sarcastic tones in order to create a piece of writing that is interesting yet informative. Readers are able to become more informed about politics and actually take an interest in what is going on. By writing articles that people can relate to, Goldberg is educating more people within the United States, which in turn means more well-informed voters. This is ultimately better for everyone. As a young columnist, his opinions may be new and different, but

In What Ways Can ‘King Lear’ Be Read As A Tale Of Forgiveness Over Grudges?

1268 words - 6 pages In what ways can ‘King Lear’ be read as a tale of forgiveness over grudges? Shakespeare’s ‘King Lear’ is a play filled with tragedy and misfortunes, all at the cause of power and greed. However, despite the cruel nature of many of the characters, namely Lear, a sense of truth and forgiveness is demonstrated at the very end of ‘King Lear’. Forgiveness can be defined as a conscious, deliberate decision to release feelings of resentment or

Put Forth A Theory On What It Means To Be Human And, As A Good Reader, Explain How We Might Read Frankenstein As An Example Of This Theory

1155 words - 5 pages Final Project : FRANKENSTEIN Question 4: Put forth a theory on what it means to be human and, as a good reader, explain how we might read Frankenstein as an example of this theory. You may use any philosophical stance : To err is to be human, to forgive divine. All knowledge is sorrow The strutcure of the mind in Freudian terms The biblical story of Adam and Eve Darwinian evolution Be

Can Legalization Of Drugs Be A Solution?

984 words - 4 pages CAN LEGALIZATION OF DRUGS BE A SOLUTION? YES. In order to succeed in today’s drug war, governments should legalize drugs. The Netherlands is one government which is applying legalization procedure properly and which has reduction in drug use. According to Trimbos Institute’s and also some other research, this reduction is mostly in more harmful and more hallucinogenic drugs which are LSD, amphetamine, heroin and reduction percentage is 30