Role Of Judiciary Essay

545 words - 3 pages

Question 2

The judiciary plays a crucial role in the development of common law, the following analyses highlight these roles: first, although the judges do not technically make laws albeit they do through the interpretations of statute law and the reinterpretation of the common law. Second, they contribute to the development, clarification and reform of the law.

Historically the role of the judiciary in the development of the common law could be traced back to the time of King Henry II who reigned from 1154 to 1189. One of the reasons, why he was dubbed ‘father of the common law’ is that he established common law by creating a unified court system ‘common’ to the country through incorporating and elevating local custom to the national level, ending local control, eliminating arbitrary remedies and ...view middle of the document...

Basically, court hierarchy, binding precedent and accurate law reporting are important tools to the system of precedent.

In order to assist with the interpretation of the statutes law, the judiciary have developed a number of approaches: the literal rule, the golden rule, the mischief rule, the purposive approach. All methods slightly differ and the judiciary do not always agree on methods to interpret the law, but once interpretation is established, it may set a precedent for later cases.

The importance of accurate law reporting in the system of precedent cannot be over emphasized, it enables for legal principles to be collated, identified and accessed. There are many sources of law reports: Year Books (1275-1535), private reports (1535-1865), modern reports (1865 to present) to mention a few.

However, not every court case sets a precedent. The facts of a case report can be divided into two categories: Ratio decidendi, Latin means, the reason for the decision.  A ratio decidendi,  is a platform which the court used to ruling in the way that it did every case brought before the judge binding precedent. The court of Appeal decision,  (Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Co Ltd (1892)), ruled that there was legally enforceable agreement.

Obiter dictum, Latin means ‘along the way’ does not form part of the binding precedent, but persuasive authority that might be considered in later cases.

Arguments for the doctrine of precedent include consistency and fairness in the law, certainty, flexibility and efficiency.

Lord Mackay, former Lord Chancellor argues that a rule of law based on the system of precedent provides certainty, consistency and uniformity. Things are constantly changing in this day and age; therefore, the benefit of precedent can thus be a weakness by allowing law to be predictable. The disadvantages of doctrine of precedent: uncertainty, unconstitutionality and fixity.

Other Papers Like Role of Judiciary

To What Extent Are Judges Politically Neutral?

593 words - 3 pages The Judiciary and Civil LibertiesAssignment 3:To what extent are judges politically neutral?In theory there should be no 'political' role for judges, but in practice there is. Ministers and their departments can break the law, MPs can be charged with breaking laws about election expenses and civil servants can be charged with handing over secrets about their political 'bosses'. A member of the judiciary has to decide whether they will be charged

The Role of Government in Policy-Making

817 words - 4 pages The Role of Government in Policy-Making Holly Regan HSM/240 January 26, 2014 Terra Harris The Role of Government in Policy-Making There are three branches of government established by the U.S. Constitution which are: the legislative branch, executive branch, and the judicial branch. The purpose for these three branches of government is to establish the individual and combined powers of each branch, while reserving the rights of each

Judicial Reforms in India

4227 words - 17 pages Filling of Vacant Posts in Judiciary Judicial appointments and promotions need to be streamlined to ensure that posts do not remain vacant for any length of time. Appropriate institutional structure may need to be created that will estimate the posts likely to fall vacant in future and take the necessary steps in anticipation. The role of High Courts, Supreme Court and Administration may need to be redefined to make the process transparent, fair

Murmuring Judges Stage Directions

1720 words - 7 pages the prisoners to help them become moral citizens. However with this point being made many characters within the play that are part of the Judiciary System are immoral and show many signs of corruption. The most prominent character is Barry who got Gerard put away for longer because of his Irish heritage. This corruption did have an effect on prisoners, 58% of the prison population within the 1990s were re-offenders according to statistics. This

written assignment

600 words - 3 pages should not do. (2) The founders were ,also framers of the Constitution, practitioners of centuries-old common law. As known, common law legal system is characterized by case law, which is law developed by judges through decisions of courts and similar tribunals.The founders were steeped in incremental change by the judiciary and they believed that, with the careful interpretation by the judiciary, the document they drafted would be flexible over


3282 words - 14 pages law is not made by the judiciary- Sabyasachi Mukharji, C.J. Whenever legislature enacts any law, in spite of keeping everything in mind and putting in their best efforts, it cannot visualize all possible situations in the future to which that law requires application. In today’s world everything is constantly changing. Nothing is static. As a result new situations develop and therefore law has to be interpreted accordingly. Herein, the role of

Judicial Overreach

1926 words - 8 pages court added: “It is the duty of the executive to fill the vacuum by executive orders because its field is coterminous with that of the legislature, and where there is inaction even by the executive, for whatever reason, the judiciary must step in, in exercise of its constitutional obligations under the aforesaid provisions (Article 32 read with Article 142) to provide a solution till such time as the legislature acts to perform its role by

Cause of Terrorism Against Israel

956 words - 4 pages visible enemy, as a result war broke out between Israel defending against many Arab countries and Terrorist groups. Known as the Arab-Israeli war, this war would last less than a year with the Israelis finally fending off the Arabs. Israel has been a major target for terrorist organizations in the Middle East because their virtues are freedom, independent judiciary and woman’s rights. Freedom is the condition of being free; the power to act or

Assess the Strengths of the Uk Constitution

756 words - 4 pages . Firstly, the UK constitution, being uncodified, means that it is flexible and can be easily adapted to changing circumstances, which could include referendum use and the continuous changing role of the House of Lords. The UK constitution is often called 'organic', which means that the constitution is rooted in society, and consequently means that when society and it's values change the UK constitution can adapt and change to society, without delay

Reforms to Improve Justice Delivery System

2967 words - 12 pages in Judiciary Judicial appointments and promotions need to be streamlined to ensure that posts do not remain vacant for any length of time. Appropriate institutional structure may need to be created that will estimate the posts likely to fall vacant in future and take the necessary steps in anticipation. The role of High Courts, Supreme Court and Administration may need to be redefined to make the process transparent, fair, smooth and fast. D

Parliamentary Sovereignty

1935 words - 8 pages . However, “These developments do not fundamentally undermine the principle of parliamentary sovereignty, since, in theory at least, Parliament could repeal any of the laws implementing these changes.” Theoretically or not legally, the option is there to regain full sovereignty, as the only criticism a government could face, would be that of a political nature. For under the separation of powers, the role of the judiciary, is merely to interpret

Related Essays

Legal Aid For Refugees And Asylum Seekers. The Role Of The Judiciary

2005 words - 9 pages ACCESS TO JUSTICE AND LEGAL AID FOR REFUGEES AND ASYLUM SEEKERS; WHAT CAN THE JUDICIARY DO? Introduction Asylum seekers, regardless of their immigration status, are human beings, with fundamental and basic rights, needs and aspirations. Refugees and asylum seekers are a diverse group with one thing in common; they are subject to forced migration, and are fleeing from persecution in their countries of origin. A refugee is defined as any person

Assignment Paper

935 words - 4 pages Judiciaries Focus upon the idea of law enforcement and statutory interpretation. Link the judiciary to the concept of the rule of law and thus to the constitutional importance of an independent judiciary in a modern liberal democracy Role – law enforcement, statutory interpretation, legality of government decisions, application of EU and HRA, protect citizens rights and liberties and potential for involvement in political process (note reduced

Body Of Government In Malaysia Essay

2143 words - 9 pages ) greattalexander 5) Malik Imtiaz Sarwar. (2004). Corruption: The Role of the Judiciary. The Journal of the Malaysian Bar. Deputy President, HAKAM 6) Miss Junaida Hj Ismail. The Executive.

The Role Of Government In Policy Making

914 words - 4 pages Assignment: The Role of Government in Policy-Making HSM 240 Public Policy Development in Human Services Axia College Instructor: Amy Randle Student: Marlo Palmer July 23, 2010 Assignment: The Role of Government in Policy-Making Human service organizations are governed by a legislative and judiciary system. The judiciary system decides what policy is legal and illegal, and can require the executive or legislative branch to fix it