Robert Hughes' Culture Of Complaint: The Fraying Of American

1224 words - 5 pages

Robert Hughes' Culture of Complaint: the Fraying of American

Robert Hughes, a native Australian, spent twenty years in the United States and assumed many traits that are typical of Americans before publishing Culture of Complaint: the Fraying of America. His evaluation finds that America is a country more focused on appearance than reality. Americans would rather complain than change. Instead of analyzing the problem of American culture, Hughes attempts to present himself as an ideal critic, scholar, and journalist. He seems more concerned with reputation that academics. Like the work of Alexis de Tocqueville, which has remained the benchmark for the study of American culture since ...view middle of the document...

Political correctness warranted more attention for Hughes than it does in the national media today. It is quite telling that only five years after its publication this material is already outdated.

Throughout Hughes’ text the reader is bombarded with the tedious, albeit extensive, litany of his readings. He has “read a lot of books in the last forty-five years, since (he) became a conscious and addicted reader at the age of about nine” (107). However, instead of writing about works he is familiar with, he should write about what he has learned from undertaking this honorable hobby. For example, Hughes mentions a “claim made” by Eric Hobsbawm, the works of the late Herbert Gutman, Eugene Genovese, and Eric Foner, a “superb book” by Leon Litwack and a story by Nicholas Lemann, all in one paragraph (123). His commentary is suspiciously lacking original thought. After reading his book the reader is quite aware of his knowledge of literature, but unsure if he can apply it to the relevant problems in American culture.

Hughes offers no solutions to America’s cultural problems. He says that “no American university can assume that its first-year students are literate in more than a technical sense” (103). This is a problem, clearly, for a country that routinely graduates students from high school who cannot read. However, the problems in America do not need to be articulated they need to be solved. To do this people must become more knowledgeable about their society, its constraints such as gender roles and racism, and the mechanisms which perpetuate these problems such as ideology and hegemony. But, Hughes does not offer promising solutions, only negative comments.

Hughes does not see America in the larger picture. He thinks the problem facing American culture is that people complain, but do little to create change. In this idea, Hughes fails to recognize that people abuse power to prevent others from making change. This creates a cycle that is a result and cause of American apathy. Politicians can remain elected officials despite owning horrid legislative records because people do not expect much of them. “The art of not answering the question, of cloaking unpleasant realities in abstraction or sugar is so perfectly endemic to Washington by now that we expect nothing else” (27). However, some groups are successful in changing America into a country that is more suited to their wants. Anti-abortion groups, for example, have been successful in getting much legislation passed to restrict half the population’s right to privacy. Instead of complaining, these groups are politically active at the federal, state and local levels. Members of both sides of...

Other Papers Like Robert Hughes' Culture of Complaint: the Fraying of American

Dreams Of Blacks Deferred In The Poetry Of Langston Hughes

1766 words - 8 pages feelings that accompany the theme range from foreboding to anger to gloom, creating a sense of each in the reader. Hughes' poems are an effective comment on the experiences of blacks in Harlem and the dream that they share: a dream that, though deferred, still exists. Works Cited and Consulted: Barksdale, Richard. LH: The Poet and His Critics. Chicago: American Library Association, 1977. Dace, Tish. ed. Langston Hughes: The Contemporary

The Effect Of The Expansion Of Cotton Culture On Slave And Native American Population

496 words - 2 pages The Effect of the Expansion of Cotton Culture on Slave and Native American Population Overview: To understand the effect of the expansion of cotton culture on slave population. Intro: Cotton was a profitable crop, but was not grown on a large scale because of the slow and difficult process of removing seeds from cotton bolls in order to produce a usable fiber. Plantation owners determined slave labor was needed to operate the southern

The culture of India

1547 words - 7 pages claims of pervasiveness of caste and strict social hierarchy in modern India. Bayly notes that much of the Indian subcontinent was populated by people for whom the formal distinctions of caste and strict social hierarchies were of only limited importance in their lifestyles.[21] According to Rosser, an American sociologist, Americans of South Asian origins feel the Western perception of the culture of India has numerous stereotypes. Rosser notes

The Culture Of Marrige

1434 words - 6 pages Journal News in Westchester, New York. Blagodarova, O. (2003). Americans marry Russian women. what for?. The Tatarstan Izvestia newspaper, Retrieved from Americ Olga provides a Russian woman's side to the reasoning or rationality behind marring American men. It covers culture aspects and the dissatisfaction with Russian men. It further explains that compatibility of

Robert Davie - The Pleasure Of Love

672 words - 3 pages Robert Davies' essay, The Pleasures of Love is about what can be improved on, Or what can be done to obtain the pleasures of love. He shows that we should not follow the same footsteps as Othello and Desdomona, or Romeo and Juliet. Davies believed that Othello was a man that had too much passion, and his jealously eventually led to a miscommunication between himself and Desdomona, Othello did not even bother discussing the situation with

The Culture of the Didgeridoo

541 words - 3 pages spread across most parts of Australia. The word didgeridoo comes from the word bamboo. Some believe the didgeridoo is the oldest known instrument, from the Australian Aboriginal culture (Latin meaning “in the beginning”). Most researchers believe that the first ones were made from bamboo sticks but now are made from eucalyptus trees. Most of the Aborigine tribes came up with their own name for it. Some of the names are, artawin, garnbak

The Boston Teaparty And American Revolution: The Story Of George Robert Twelves Hewes. About The Book: "The Shoemaker And The Tea Party" By Alfred F. Young

907 words - 4 pages The revolution in America gained momentum as Britain continued to pass new taxes and send more soldiers to the continent. The American people, along with their anger over the Appalachian Mountain boundary, did not enjoy these new taxes. Their protests and demonstrations were initially only in defiance to the new laws, but as their patience was continually tested, their thoughts turned towards independence. Although the idea of independence came

Understanding the Role of Culture

561 words - 3 pages 7/23/2013 Case Study # 1 Week 2 Understanding the role of culture Culture can be a combination, of rules, beliefs, techniques, artifacts, language, and religion, when these things come together it influence the human mind. With influence of culture in the human mind, it impacts the way business is conducted. We then look into corporate culture, which is what defines how managers and employees conduct themselves in the workplace of

The Pleasures of Visual Culture

1733 words - 7 pages The Pleasures Of Visual Culture. In this essay I will be analysing the pleasures of visual culture, focusing on a paragraph concerning ‘Horror and suffering in art’ and using the 1994 Alex Proyas film ‘The Crow’ (see Appendix 1) to give examples of my points. Before I begin analysing the film I will first be looking at explanations of the terms ‘visual culture’, ‘aesthetic pleasure’ and ‘catharsis’. (Walker & Chaplin, 1997) Visual culture

Countering the Culture of Sex

900 words - 4 pages Countering the Culture of Sex Over the past twenty years teenage pregnancy and the spread of sexually transmitted diseases between teenagers have been growing problems in the United States. In two articles, “Countering the Culture of Sex,” by Ellen Goodman and “Moms have strong impact on teen sexual activity,” by Daniel B. Wood solutions are brought as to how we can solve these growing problems. One text spends its time picking at the

The Impact of Culture Conservatism

1295 words - 6 pages Table of Contents Issues…………………………………………………………………………………1 Facts………………………………………………………………………………….2 Analysis……………………………………………………………………………....3 Conclusions/Recommendations……………………………………………………...5 Issues 1) Explain why an individual investor might want to invest in an international growth fund? 2) Describe the risks associated with making an investment in an international growth fund. Identify the risks that would be common to domestic

Related Essays

Letter Of Complaint Essay

561 words - 3 pages . I prefer the locations to be nearby the hotel as we are not familiar with the place. Furthermore, I would also like to know if there are any historical sites or market nearby where we can explore more about the place’s history and local culture. You could send me the detailed information through email or fax no later than the 4th of July with the total cost of stay during the weekend. I look forward to hearing from you. Yours faithfully, A.G

General Format Of Complaint Letter Essay

598 words - 3 pages letter concise and professional. Send only photocopies of receipts and other documents, and retain all originals Keep a copy of the complaint letter for your records. Get other signatures In many cases, you can increase the effectiveness of your letter by getting several others to sign it with you. This is particularly the case when trying to influence or change legislation, denouncing material from the media, and so forth. Do not

The Transdence Of Women In American Culture

1478 words - 6 pages instance, the Female Medical College of Pennsylvania, which was established in 1850. By the 1910s, however, women were attending many leading medical schools, and in 1915 the American Medical Association began to admit women members. Throughout most of history women generally have had fewer legal rights and career opportunities than men. Wifehood and motherhood were regarded as women's most significant professions. In the 20th century, however

The Effects Of Television On The American Culture

1474 words - 6 pages CHANGES FOR THE BETTER Marilyn J. Holmes ENGL 101-B07 LUO (APA) Mr. Brian Powell Liberty University Changes For The Better “Through him all things were made; without him nothing was made that has been made” (John 1:3 New International Version). The environment is something that we as humans often take for granted. Making up everything that surrounds us, you would think that more of our population would take this blessing into more