This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Rhetorical Analysis Of The Things They Carried

1590 words - 7 pages

Michelle Zhang
Dr. Bloomquist
2/13/2015
Rhetorical Analysis

A Whole New World: Construction and Destruction in The Things They Carried
While the Vietnam War was a complex political pursuit that lasted only a few years, the impact of the war on millions of soldiers and civilians extended for many years beyond its termination. Soldiers killed or were killed; those who survived suffered from physical wounds or were plagued by PTSD from being wounded, watching their platoon mates die violently or dealing with the moral implications of their own violence on enemy fighters. Inspired by his experiences in the war, Tim O’Brien, a former soldier, wrote The Things They Carried, a collection of ...view middle of the document...

” (118)

Because his description of the man follows the passive pattern of “his (body part) was (attribute),” O’Brien’s own presence in the story fades. In the last line, O’Brien avoids saying that he inflicted this wound upon the soldier, instead merely stating that “it was this wound that had killed him,” purposely constructing this sentence to remove his own agency from it. The sentence itself is lengthy and repetitive, punctuated only by commas between the numerous descriptions. He does not use first person to explain his guilt and confusion, but it begins to take a rhythm: the choppy descriptions emphasize his compromised mental abilities as a result of the killing, repeating the same basic passive structure to reveal his biting guilt and fixation with the man he has killed. O’Brien does not actually state who this man is until farther down the paragraph; while we can infer that the chapter is about the man he killed from the title, we do not get verification that this is for sure “the man I killed” (119) until he begins to spin a history for him, showing that he does not even admit to his actions until later. Since we are not given an emotional first person narrative confrontation with the moral implications of his actions, the lack thereof and the repetitive structure illustrate the psychological shock that O’Brien faces. This authorial silence reflects the inevitable silence of Vietnam that forces soldiers to confront the horrible realities of destructive battle and guilt that many soldiers experienced due to war.
At the same time, O’Brien struggles with destructiveness of the conflicting images of violence and peace in death through the juxtaposition of the imagery of the dead man. While “his one eye was shut, the other eye was a star-shaped hole.” The dead man has one shut eye that resembles a peaceful sleep, while the other side is obliterated by the grenade into a star-shaped hole. The image of the star-shaped hole in the dead soldier’s eye represents the hopes that he once had when he was alive: “He hoped the Americans would go away. Soon, he hoped. He kept hoping and hoping, always” (119). Furthermore, “his right cheek was smooth and hairless,” an image of untouched innocence that contrasts with his left cheek, which was “peeled back in three ragged strips,” destroyed by the violence O’Brien inflicts upon it. The juxtaposition of the butterfly that settles on his chin and the fatal wound on his neck, “open to the spinal cord…blood…thick and shiny” illustrate the complexity and ambiguity of the unnaturalness of war, depicted by the image of the dead man’s wrung neck, contrasted with the ironic peace and naturalism of death in the image of the fragile butterfly. These select images are also those that O’Brien chooses to fixate upon and develop throughout the chapter as he struggles to comprehend the moral implications of his actions. The innocence of the “slim, dead, almost dainty young man” is further reinforced when O’Brien...

Other Papers Like Rhetorical Analysis of the Things They Carried

The Things They Carried Essay

353 words - 2 pages The character I have chosen is Lt. Jimmy Cross from the story “The Things They Carried.” Jimmy Cross is the leader of Alpha Company in the war of Vietnam, although he seems like he is not part of it. “He had difficulty keeping his attention on the war […] but then he would slip away into day dreams, just pretending, walking barefoot along the Jersey Shore” (p.279). This quote clearly shows that he was living in a parallel world between the war

The Things They Carried Essay

799 words - 4 pages The Things They Carried In Tim O’Brien’s The Things They Carried the theme of courage is explored through soldiers fighting a new kind of war in Vietnam, a jungle war. The war is unlike any previous war and brings about fears that no man has faced before. The fears spark courage in some and cowardice in others. O’Brien does not define courage in so many words, but he gives examples. The examples are several short stories which are the basis

“the Things They Carried”

793 words - 4 pages The Things They Carried One of the most compelling and intriguing conflicts introduced in “The Things They Carried” is the battle within Tim O’Brien’s conscience. This impossible struggle inside Tim’s mind has poisonedhim to experience tremendous guilt and anger which ultimately creates a deeper meaning to just a simple book. In this conflict, O’Brien’s struggle of his true feelings can be viewed as a superior quarrel among the

Quotes the Things They Carried

869 words - 4 pages load of gear and weapon. Despite this, he carried one of the heaviest things of all, which is the responsibility of his men. (That is why he falls into the fantasy world…he feels lighter there.) Lt. Cross carries the letters Martha has written to him as well as two photos of her and a pebble she found on beach and sent to him. Text promotes the intimacy of two rather than the separation, as described “it was the aloneness that filled him with

The Things They Carried Essay

1484 words - 6 pages The Things They Carried EssayThe past would be unknown if it weren't for stories. Cave art, drawings in the ground, and fossils, all told stories that allowed us to figure out what the past was like. Eventually, humans evolved, creating legitimate languages allowing for a more mature form of story telling: writing. When a story is read or told, the characters in the story are brought to life in our head; and the speaker or reader delivers

Things They Carried

740 words - 3 pages get picked up by the chopper and it made me think they all carry a slight emotional burden of hopelessness. Feelings were you don’t know when you will be out of war, when you will be home, and if you will get picked up from the chopper. The burden of love because Jimmy Cross is battling with his emotions and imagination of him and Martha together. The burden of fear because all these men carry things that help them not to be scared anymore, or

Book Review On The Things They Carried

1670 words - 7 pages The Things They Carried- Book ReviewIn The Things They Carried, author Tim O'Brien conveys his experience and feelings about the Vietnam War through a collection of stories. Each narrative is comprised with vivid description telling us about one of the soldiers of the Alpha Company in Vietnam. One of the significant concepts in this novel is the importance of certain objects or feelings carried and used by the soldiers to survive the war

Motifs in the Things They Carried

683 words - 3 pages factors for fighting in a war—but concern over what his family and community will think of him if he doesn’t fight. This experience is emblematic of the conflict, explored throughout The Things They Carried, between the misguided expectations of a group of people important to a character and that character’s uncertainty regarding a proper course of action. Fear of shame not only motivates reluctant men to go to Vietnam but also affects soldiers

A Literary Analysis Of “Do Not Go Gentle Into That Good Night” And “The Things They Carried”

2138 words - 9 pages A Literary Analysis of “Do Not Go Gentle Into That Good Night” and “The Things They Carried” ENG125 Sharon Linne January 26th, 2015 Sources of conflict provide a unifying factor that enables an audience to relate to a literary work’s respective authors on a psychological level. This is particularly important when an author seeks to place his or her audience in their own perspective. A strong case for the conflict of individual

Tim O'Brien's Zeugmatic Novel, The Things They Carried

1536 words - 7 pages Tim O'Brien's Zeugmatic Novel, The Things They Carried An early example of zeugma comes from Quintilian, the ancient Roman rhetorician, who cites the following from Cicero: "Lust conquered shame, boldness fear, madness reason," where the verb "conquered" is understood to also govern the final two phrases in the sentence (Crowley 203). The 18th century, an age of great rhetorical knowledge on the part of writers and preachers (and at

Sadness and Tragedy in Antigone and the Things They Carried

863 words - 4 pages Dani Kaiser December 3, 2015 3rd period Sadness and Tragedy in Antigone and The Things They Carried Tinged with sadness and tragedy, both Antigone by Sophocles and The Things They Carried by Tim O’Brien show reactions of characters to tragedies. These great moments of sadness in both books reveal the inner traits of many characters. In Antigone, Antigone reacts to her tragic life. In The Things They Carried, supporting character Mary

Related Essays

The Things They Carried Essay

949 words - 4 pages In the book "The Things They Carried," Tim O'Brien describes a group of soldiers marching through Vietnam. He does this by describing the items that each of them carries with him during the war. The things that the soldiers carry with them are both physical and emotional items and what these things are depends upon the individual soldier. They carry the basic "necessities" for survival and the bare minimum to make life as livable as possible

The Things They Carried Essay 1138 Words

1138 words - 5 pages Symbolism in stories is dependent on how the author writes, the title, and the characters. Titles in literature are very important to the symbolism of a story an example of this is Tim O’Brien’s “The Things They Carried”. As the story goes on it shows not only the literal meaning of what they carried but also symbolically the burdens that they had mentally. In the literal sense O’Brien talks about what different members of a platoon in Vietnam

The Things They Carried Essay 1212 Words

1212 words - 5 pages The Things They Carried written by Tim O’Brien is a postmodern novel that details the daily activities of Alpha Company (a platoon of soldiers) throughout the Vietnam War. O’Brien depicts the harsh realities and terrors associated with war and the harsh effects soldiers are faced to deal with on an ongoing basis. Given the time frame and settings of both these chapters at first glance, “The Lives of the Dead” and “In the Field” appear to be

The Things They Carried Essay 703 Words

703 words - 3 pages Joey Cav 12/17/13 The Things They Carried During the Vietnam War, the fighting men carried many things. They ranged from guns, ammo, comic books, toilet paper to even Kool-Aid. They carried these things to help them fight the enemy and for comfort, but not all of these things helped these men. They also carried thoughts, memories, and even emotions about the war, and their life in general. While carrying all of these things, they were