This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Respect For Persons,Beneficence, And Justice Essay

1756 words - 8 pages

Respect for Persons,Beneficence, and Justice

In July of 1974 The National Research Act was signed into law. Through this act, The Belmont Report was developed over 4 year period of time that included an intense four day conference followed by monthly meetings until it was completed in April of 1979. The Belmont Report sets out to define the ethical principles and guidelines for the protection of human subjects of research. The report was established prior to Barney Clark and the artificial heart and therefore was the guidelines that the doctors and researchers had to follow. The report highlights three essential ethical elements that are pertinent in human research and their ...view middle of the document...

The probability that the intervention would be successful

f. The feasible alternatives

g. The prognosis is the intervention/therapy is not given

5. Offer a recommendation

6. Ensure comprehension

7. Acknowledge any emotional reaction from the patient and respond

8. Validate the patient’s decision

9. Summarize

The case questioned the quality of the informed consent received from the patient. Two of the nine basic rules for obtaining valid informed consent might not exist in the Barney Clark case: Barney’s conditions and the information disclosed might not adequately validate the informed consent that he rendered. The lack of a valid informed consent can result in the prosecution of the physician in the court of law, which is detrimental to both the physicians involved in the case and the medical profession. Prior to the operation, Barney Clark’s condition steadily worsened. His heart beat feebly, his blood pressure dropped dangerously low, and he required oxygen supplementation. It was under these mentally and physically crippling conditions that he placed his signature on the consent form. In order to ensure Barney Clark’s competency, physicians must determine whether the influences arising from these conditions diminish his capacity for a valid consent. Physicians must also ensure that they have disclosed fully to Barney Clark all of the probable risks associated with the operation.

However a truly informed consent in research is difficult, more specifically when it comes to the disclosure of pertinent information. All of the pertinent information especially about the risks and benefits are not known. There are hopes and fears but no hard facts. The “reasonable volunteer” standard can be used in which the person is informed that the procedure is not fully understood and that it is experimental, therefore understanding that their participation is more for the advancement of knowledge than for their personal benefit. The term therapeutic misconception has been used in research, such that the patient still believes in the therapeutic benefit to them. However through interviews with Barney Clark prior to his death, it is evident that Mr. Clark was acting in an altruistic fashion. The chance to participate in the study was offered to Mr. Clark a month prior to the implementation, however he didn’t feel ready yet. As his conditioned worsened he decided to go through with the operation. He told his wife, "First of all, I don't think it will work. I'm weaker and more tired than those animals I've seen, and I don't think it's going to save my life. But I have been kept alive for the last year on medicines that other people have given their lives to give me. Now its my turn to pay those people back."5 He was then placed in the ICU and asked to sign the consent form. While it is argued that he signed the consent form in “great pain” it is evident that this was not a...

Other Papers Like Respect For Persons,Beneficence, And Justice

Describe Different Ways in Which You Would Establish Ground Rules with Your Learners, Which Would Underpin Behaviour and Respect for Others

516 words - 3 pages Learners of all ages require boundaries and rules in which to work within. By setting these out from the start of any training programme regardless of the length of the course (For example a one day course or an entire semester) you will create an environment of trust and respect which will enable learners to achieve their goals. By having ground rules in place that learners have been involved in the process of making, Ann Gravells (2006 p8

Why You Think It Is Important – and Part of Your Responsibility – to Promote Appropriate Behaviour and Respect for Others and Ways You Would Go About Promoting Equality and Value Diversity Through...

771 words - 4 pages Why you think it is important – and part of your responsibility – to promote appropriate behaviour and respect for others and ways you would go about promoting equality and value diversity through your approaches to education and training The most important task for teacher is to educate the learner. To do so the better learning environment has to be created in the classroom. Positive behaviour or good behaviour of students motivates

Capital Punishment, The Road To A Corrupt Criminal Justice System, Must Be Abolished For The Sake Of Society. The Death Penalty Is Unfair Towards Society Members, Such As Tax Payers, Innocent People,...

2653 words - 11 pages is done to reduce crime.The death penalty is too risky to be incorporated into our justice system for the sake of society and its members. Of all the worries of the death penalty, the most compelling is the thought that an innocent person would be executed. There have been cases when an innocent defendant was sentenced to death, but are often saved at the last minute because new evidence was discovered. According to Richard C. Dieter, there has


5619 words - 23 pages . ***Deceased.     Table of Contents Ethical Principles and Guidelines for Research Involving Human Subjects A. Boundaries Between Practice and Research B. Basic Ethical Principles 1. Respect for Persons 2. Beneficence 3. Justice C. Applications 1. Informed Consent 2. Assessment of Risk and Benefits 3. Selection of Subjects   Ethical Principles & Guidelines for Research Involving Human Subjects Scientific research has

Code of Ethics Paper

1200 words - 5 pages nurses. The American Nurses Association is responsible for developing the Code of Ethics for nurses. The goals of the American Nurses Association is to protect the nurses and to teach nurses how to be a professional nurse and to respect the patients regardless of race, color, smell, or looks. The code of ethics says that a nurse should be professional in all relationships, should practice as a nurse using compassion and respect for each and


1501 words - 7 pages ? Ensuring that risks are reasonable in relationship to anticipated benefits. 1. Which of the following are the three principles discussed in the Belmont Report? Respect for Persons, Beneficence, Justice. 2. Which of the following is an example of how the Principle of Beneficence can be applied to a study employing human subjects?  Determining that the study has a maximization of benefits and a minimization of risks. 3. All of the following

Ethical Research

1082 words - 5 pages is now required reading for everyone involved in human subject research. The ETHICAL RESEARCH 3 Belmont Report identifies three basic ethical principles regarding all human subject research: respect for persons, beneficence, and justice. Respect for persons requires medical researchers to obtain informed consent from their study

Ethical Health Care Issues

1185 words - 5 pages inseparable. Nonmaleficence entails an ethical duty to do no harm to other individuals. The ethical conduct of euthanasia is justifiable by the utmost standards of nonmaleficence even if an issue may surface from the principle of “do no harm.” Euthanasia is not considered harm to an individual because many people view the pain and suffering for the duration of his or her life will represent more harm. Beneficence requires health care

Ethical Dilemma: Pregnancy Termination Wk 27 Gestation

2525 words - 11 pages of health in the care of individuals, families, groups and communities”(American Nursing Association, 2001,p.5). In our society there are values outlined in the United States constitution that provides the foundation for our society. The guiding principles of ethical decision making are autonomy, beneficence, justice, nonmaleficence and veracity.(Guido,5th ed). Client advocacy: Clinicians have an

Rough Draft

578 words - 3 pages . Research, however, has not consistently demonstrated access for disadvantaged persons, the accuracy of EHRs, their positive effects on productivity, nor decreased costs. Should beneficence be universally acknowledged, conflicts exist with other ethical principles. Autonomy is jeopardized when patients' health data are shared or linked without the patients' knowledge. Fidelity is breached by the exposure of thousands of patients' health data through

Sedation Verses Euthanasia

1672 words - 7 pages . The primary and basic ethical principles are respect for autonym, no maleficence, beneficence, and justice. Respecting a patient’s rights, values and choices are synonymous to respecting a person’s autonomy. A method that promotes and respects a person’s autonomy is an informed consent. A patient and family must be offered enough information and options to make up their mind free of coercion or external and internal influences in order for a

Related Essays

And Justice For All Essay

1089 words - 5 pages Kandie Moore Ethics in Criminal Justice Final Exam 4-27-11 “And Justice for All” I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. How many hundreds of times have each of us recited those words? Do we reflect on the meaning of the words embodied in that sentence, or is it like so many other things we say during the

Explain Why It Is Important To Promote Appropriate Behaviour And Respect For Others

1146 words - 5 pages (a) Explain why it is important to promote appropriate behaviour and respect for others? The lifelong learning sector offers an array of diverse personal and professional backgrounds evident in adult learners, along with the varied skills and abilities of those learners, which presents a range of challenges for any educator. Appropriate behaviour and respect are cornerstones in creating a positive and supportive adult learning space

Liberty And Justice For All: The Pursuit For Gay Rights

1518 words - 7 pages person they love. Shifting the country towards becoming a tolerant nation free of prejudice and demonstrative of its liberty and justice for all, homosexuals should have the choice to marry the person they love. Works Cited "Gay Marriage" ProConorg Headlines. N.p., n.d. Web. 05 Feb. 2014. . "U.S. Constitution." Constitutional Topic: Marriage. N.p., n.d. Web. 5 Feb. 2014. . “What Does the Bible Say about Gay Marriage / Same Sex Marriage?" N.p., n.d. Web. 5 Feb. 2014. .

Analyse Different Ways In Which You Would Establish Ground Rules With Your Learners, Which Underpin Behaviour And Respect For Others

742 words - 3 pages Assignment 1-T4 T4 – Analyse different ways in which you would establish ground rules with your learners, which underpin behaviour and respect for others. Recommended word count: 250-350 words. Caroline S. Clauss-Ehlers – “The ground rules are a contract that the class had created together to be applied for the duration of the course. The contract promotes discussion as it is based on the value of a mutual respect. Alan Mortiboys – “Ground