This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Research Assignment

2391 words - 10 pages

Critiquing Research
According to Webster (1985), to research is to search or investigate exhaustively. He also states that it is, “A careful or diligent search, studious inquiry aimed at the discovery and interpretation of facts.”
The piece being critically reviewed is an article by Dr Ann Seed (1995), “Crossing the Boundaries – Experiences of neophyte nurses.”
Readers sometimes assume that if a report was accepted for publication; the study must be sound (Polit & Beck 2004), unfortunately this is not always true. In order to determine the quality of the work, a critical review is needed. This work will use the Model for Critical Appraisal of Studies by B Roe (1993).

The Introduction ...view middle of the document...

Most quantitative research pieces have aims and objectives, some qualitative do not, and have themes to explore instead (Polit & Beck2004). According to Justham (2007), a good introduction to research should have purpose described; in this piece there was not, so the relevance of this study is not made clear either in the introduction or within the title.

Research Design
Faucault (1976) and Elias (1978) state that boundaries are breached during hospitalization, Seed felt this important enough to warrant research. A qualitative approach may be used when little is known about a subject and the researcher may have few pre-conceived ideas about the subject or about the data which will be gained. The aim is more likely to be inductive (that is, moving towards theory) rather than testing theory (Roberts & Wilson 2002). By using a qualitative method, Seed could investigate and conclude using the collection of data in which to base a theory or derive a conclusion, known as empirical evidence (Sommer & Sommer 1991). The research is described as having a longitudinal perspective which enables the reflection of the neophytes’ views changing with passage of time (Seed1994).

Seed explains that the students’ views were collected by participant observation and interview, and analyzed by employing grounded theory.
Grounded theory strategies were first reported by the sociologists Glaser & Strauss in 1967. They developed the GT research method in an attempt to bridge what they perceived as a gap between theory and research. GT emphasizes the process of generating theory by systematically collecting and analyzing data concurrently. As the study is exploring the feelings and thoughts of the students’ experiences and these specifications are immeasurable, a quantitative method would not investigate what the researcher wanted to reveal and would not be appropriate but a qualitative methodology is appropriate with the use of grounded theory, it is worth mentioning that Qualitative methodology is sometimes criticized for being unscientific (Cassell et al 2005). Seed states the methodology used in the study are described elsewhere, so the reader can only assume which methodology the author chose.

The Sample
“A sample is a finite part of a statistical population whose properties are studied
to gain information about the whole,” according to Webster (1985). Seed does not explain how and why the cohorts were chosen. The reader can assume Seed used ‘neophyte’ nurses so she could see how they progressed throughout their training. There is no explanation of why she chose the size (23) or why uses the amount of males/females that she did. There are no discussions regarding the recruitment
process. It is not unusual for researchers to have different opinions as to
sample size calculations; the process should always be reported. This allows the
reader to make their own judgments as to whether to accept the researchers’
assumptions (Bartlett et al 2001)....

Other Papers Like Research Assignment

Research Methodology Assignment

3385 words - 14 pages , quantitative methods are more convenient for the research of the costumer’s attitude towards Lidl and EDEKA, which will be presented in chapter four. The following chapter will only describe quantitative methods. Qualitative methods like in-depth interviews, group interviews and focus groups, un/participant observation, Delphi technique etc.,19 due to the preferred research philosophy of the author and the word limitation of this assignment

Research Assignment Part 1

841 words - 4 pages Janocha, Steven January 10, 2014 Research Assignment Part 1 1. Why Windows Server 2008 does come in different versions? What is the significance of each version? Windows Server 2008, as well as other versions of Windows, comes in different versions for different uses. Not all users need the same thing in an Operating system. Some just want it for the basics, like printing, the internet

Marketing Research Assignment 1

1663 words - 7 pages Assignment 1 Red Bull Female Perspective Focus Group Marketing Research Introduction: For over 26 years, Red Bull has manufactured and sold energy drinks. With over 40 billion cans consumed and sold in over 166 countries, Red Bull is currently the number one energy drink brand consumed worldwide, but as new energy drink companies emerge and the market saturates, it is important to retain a competitive edge. A report conducted by Nielsen

Research Assignment 1

1188 words - 5 pages Research Assignment Part 1 What are some of the changes in Microsoft Windows Server 2008? As with all great Microsoft products, Windows Server 2008 spares no expense when it comes to being the forefront of server operating systems in the world. There are five different versions of the Server 2008 OS; the Web edition, Standard, Enterprise, Datacenter and Itanium. The Web edition can only be installed as physical or virtual and needs 4GB of RAM

Research Methodology Assignment : Dummy Plan

868 words - 4 pages RESEARCH METHODOLOGY ASSIGNMENT A Dummy Plan by:- Aditya S. Biswas No: 2009003 Submitted to:- Prof. Prasanna Salvi Situation Analysis Belief was launched in 1987 as an independent Market research fieldwork agency specializing in conducting high quality fieldwork for consumer, institutional, & rural research on a nation wide scale. It wanted to test whether it was employing the technique of using surveys correctly. It

Intro to Programming Unit 1 Research Assignment

697 words - 3 pages Unit 1 research assignment 1 1970’s 1) Pascal, Creator, Niklaus Wirth. The specific motivation behind this language was to encourage good programming practice using structured programming and data structuring. 2) SQL (Structured Query Language) designed by, Donald D. Chamberlin, and Raymond F. Boyce. The motivation behind this language was designed for managing data held in a relational database management system. ( RDBMS) 3) C

A Research Assignment Based On: ‘Laptop Revolution’

1223 words - 5 pages A Research Assignment based on: ‘Laptop Revolution’ by Professor Abdul Bayes (Published in ‘The Daily Star’ on 10th February, 2010) Prepared by: Khosnur Jahan Asmaul Husna Madia Sultana Hasanul Qader Mirza Hasib Kaisar Prepared for: Md. Safayat Hossain Lecturer Department of A & IS University of Dhaka Group Members: | Name | ID no. | 01. | Khosnur Jahan | 13092 | 02. | Asmaul Husna | 13093 | 03. | Madia

Module 3: Assignment 2: Interview And Background Research

1068 words - 5 pages with no regard for authority or rules. A person with antisocial personality disorder will think there is nothing wrong with them, but blame everyone for his or her problems. Module 3: Assignment 2: Interview and Background Research 3 Causative factors of the disorder There are two general causes for antisocial personality disorder, genetics and environment. Personality disorders start developing early in life, usually from

Unit 1 Research Assignment 1: Exploring Programming Languages

604 words - 3 pages Unit 1 Research Assignment 1: Exploring Programming Languages NT1420 In the late 1960’s Simula was invented by Nygaard and Dahl as a superset of Algol 60, this was the first language designed to support object-oriented programming. Then between 1969 and 1973 C was developed by Dennis Ritchie and Ken Thompson at Bell Labs. Smalltalk was created in the mid 1970’s that provided a complete ground-up design of an object-oriented language, and

Res/110 Research Assignment

854 words - 4 pages Savannah: To Pet, Or Not To Pet Myra T. Styles University of Phoenix RES/110 3/11/10 Abstract When you think of a Savannah does a city, grasslands, or a seaport may come into mind. Some people have heard of this new kind of breed of cat and some may be amazed to her about this new wonder. This will introduce you to a new type of pet that is sweeping the nation and yet banned in certain states because of the unknown and what if factors

Research Project 1 Assignment

2935 words - 12 pages  Robin Wilkins ACCT 511 Advanced Business Law for Accountants Liberty University Fall 2014 Professor Dean Poirier Abstract Contract law is an understanding that structure commitments that are enforceable by law. The primary parts of an agreement law are shared consent, thought, limit, and legitimateness. Contract Law spreads contracts; along these lines, the undertaking will start with an exchange

Related Essays

Research Assignment

598 words - 3 pages Tone Rogers IT 221 Research Assignment Part 2 & 3 11/16/11 The purpose for Global Names Zone in Windows Server 2008 DNS is to aid retirement WINS. Keep in mind that it is not a replacement for WINS. Also it is not intended to support the single-labeled name resolution of records that are dynamically registered in WINS, records which typically are not managed by IT administrators according Microsoft wizard. According to

Nr439 Research Database Assignment

1661 words - 7 pages Research Database Assignment Form Type your answers to the following questions using complete sentences and correct grammar, spelling, and syntax. Click Save as and save the file with your last name and assignment, e.g., NR439_Research_Database_Smith. Submit to the Research Database basket in the Dropbox by 11:59 p.m. MT Sunday at the end of Week 4. The guidelines and grading rubric for this assignment may be found in Doc Sharing. Name

Research Method Proposal Assignment

690 words - 3 pages Research Methods Assignment 1. The research question is whether exposure to sun and listening to familiar music affects a person’s mood. 2. The research hypothesis is that a person who is exposed to the sun and listens to familiar music would be in a better mood than a person not exposed to the sun and listens to unfamiliar music. 3. The population of interest for the research could theoretically include all group ages and their

Assignment Research Methodology

1177 words - 5 pages SECTION 1: INTRODUCTION | | 1.1 Scientific vs non-scientific knowledge | A researcher in South Africa has seen that potential employees who has previously worked in the Northwest and applied for positions in Gauteng companies tended to submit CV’s that contained very limited information. He thus hypothesised that all applicants from Northwest submit incomplete CV’s. | 1.2 Ethics in research | A researcher is interested in studying the