This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Religious Language Is Meaningless. Discuss (35)

629 words - 3 pages

Religious language is the lexis used to describe or discuss views in relation to religion. Religious language has many different forms and expresses multiple meanings encompassing a variety of situations such as worship, practice, dogma and doctrine. This however means religious language is subjective and raises debate over whether it is meaningless or not.

A collection of philosophers, the logical positivists, formulated the verification principle, which was developed by A. J. Ayer in order to combat the idea that religious language is meaningful. He thought that “God talk” was nonsense because it could not be verified analytically or synthetically. They believed that there were only 2 types of statements which are meaningful; tautologies (true by definition) and statements that can be verified by some kind of test. Following this theory, religious language is deemed meaningless because they believed it was metaphysical and there is no way to even test ...view middle of the document...

We cannot empirically prove that religious language is meaningful but we also cannot prove that the verification principle is, therefore it fails its own principle.

Anthony Flew also agreed that religious language was meaningless and claimed that “religious language dies the death of a thousand qualifications” but he didn’t agree with the ideas put forward by the verification principle. He felt that religion is full of assertions and followers that do not allow anything to counter their beliefs, like science does. Religion is too slow to raise their hand and admit they are wrong and therefore religious language is empty. He believed that if a statement is meaningful it must be capable of being falsified and there must be some decisive test that’d count against it. Phrases like “God has got a plan” are meaningless as there is no test that can falsify it. He used John Wisdom’s the Parable of the Gardener to strengthen his argument, saying that the person that believed in the “invisible” gardener was like a religious person that would not accept falsification.

Richard Swinburne developed a counter argument to both the verification and falsification principles, referencing the ‘Toys in the Cupboard’ story. He says that just because something cannot be verified or falsified, doesn’t mean it is meaningless because we understand it. Therefore, if religious language means something to other people and evokes a reaction it must be meaningful. Similar to this R. M. Hare retells an incident where a university student was convinced his lecturers wanted to kill him. This cannot be verified because the lecturers would be likely to deny it, however, this has a direct effect of the student’s life and created fear, therefore Hare believed it cannot be meaningless. He referred to this as a Blik, which is a world view – a particular way of seeing the world.

Religious language is symbolic and represents something different to everyone else. To say it is meaningless is subjective and can only be one person’s view, in the same way that saying it is meaningful is another someone else’s belief. In my opinion religious language cannot be meaningless because it effects many people’s lives in different ways and cannot be universally ruled as meaningless.

Other Papers Like Religious Language Is Meaningless. Discuss (35)

Philosophy Essay

2927 words - 12 pages Philosophy Critically assess the claim that all religious language is meaningless. (35) Religious language has been argued about by many philosophers with regards to whether or not the ways in which we speak about religion are meaningful. This issue of religious language is concerned with the methods by which man talks about God in conjunction with theist or atheist ideologies. For some, religious language is meaningful and full of purpose

Verificationism Philosophy Essay

1206 words - 5 pages The verification principle offers no real challenge to religious belief. Discuss. Religious believers suffer with a problem of needing to explain the meaning of religious language, and what such language means when talking about a transcendent reality called God. The verification principle claims that language is only meaningful if it can be verified by sense observation, empirical evidence or it is a tautology as these are non-cognitive. This

Online Shopping Vs. Traditional Shopping

533 words - 3 pages Term 1 MARKS RECORD 2013-2014 Student Name : Hanaa Atef AlAtieh Grade : Gr7 - F Student eSIS : 455425 School eSIS : 9163 Subject | Term Work | Term Assessments | Term Exam | | | | | | | Total Term % | GRADES | Islamic Education - Arabs | 35 | 31 | 30 | 27 | 35 | 31 | | | | | | | 89 | B+ | Arabic Language - Arabs | 35 | 32 | 30 | 26 | 35 | 30 | | | | | | | 88 | B+ | UAE Social Studies - Arabs | 35

To What Effect Is Myth to Conveying Religious Truths

1658 words - 7 pages statements are meaningless. If we don’t expect religious myths to be factually significant, their power relies in their metaphorical or symbolic sense. However, this can prove a disadvantage of using myth as religious language, fundamentalists claim that the Bible is nothing more than a ‘warm-hearted story’ if we strip the Bible of all meaning except for myths. Conveying religious truth through myth has many advantages, most importantly, it gives

Language and Memory

1148 words - 5 pages important to our survival as a species (Robinson-Riegler & Robinson-Riegler, 2008). Language is what the individual does to comprehend, speak, read, and write or just express their feelings (Robinson-Riegler & Robinson-Riegler, 2008). Without the ability to read or understand what this paper is about then it would be meaningless. With that being said and without the ability to speak an individual would not be able to state that this paper was easy

The Problem of Language in "All Quiet on the Western Front"

3828 words - 16 pages . Further, he is repulsed by the banal and meaningless language that is used by members of that society. As he becomes alienated from his former, traditional, society, Baumer simultaneously is able to communicate effectively only with his military comrades. Since the novel is told from the first person point of view, the reader can see how the words Baumer speaks are at variance with his true feelings. In his preface to the novel, Remarque

All Quiet On The Western Front

3452 words - 14 pages ofBaumer's pre- and post-enlistment societies. Baumer either can not, or chooses not to, communicate truthfully with those representatives of his pre-enlistment and innocent days. Further, he is repulsed by the banal and meaningless language that is used by members of that society. As he becomes alienated from his former, traditional, society, Baumer simultaneously is able to communicate effectively only with his military comrades. Since the novel is

Business Morals

1241 words - 5 pages language needed. Commitment at the top Ethics training is meaningless without top-level executives who walk the talk. When leaders consistently reward those who choose to do what is right, it helps to create an ethical culture more than anything else could. Moral courage Kidder (2001) describes moral courage as “the quality of mind and spirit that enables one to face up to ethical dilemmas and moral wrongdoings firmly and confidently, without

Business Morals

1233 words - 5 pages . Common language Employees need a language of ethics that allows them to communicate readily and comfortably about issues that are typically sensitive and difficult to discuss. Effective ethics training programs provide the common language needed

The Influences of English on Chinese

649 words - 3 pages tragedy of our rich culture. For the purpose of maintaing the identity of our language, rejecting the changes is meaningless and powerless. Instead, we should enhance the comprehensive national power especially the soft power. Only when we are stronger inside, will our language be more pure and our culture be more flourishing.

Meaning and Nature of Language

3084 words - 13 pages been claims that non-human primates like chimpanzees and bonobos are capable of comprehending human language (Benson et al., 2002; Brakke and Savagerumbaugh, 1995). However it is doubtful whether comprehension constitutes a comprehensive use of language. In this essay, we would discuss whether non-human animals are capable of commanding the comprehensive use of language by critically evaluating whether they show some of the design-features of

Related Essays

Religious And Ethical Language Are About Facts. Discuss

1534 words - 7 pages Religious and Ethical Language are about facts. Discuss. In order to analyse whether language, religious or ethical are about facts it is vital to define facts. According to Honderich a fact can be defined as the worldly correlation of a true proposition, in other words a state of affairs make a statement true or false. There are two main schools of thought as to how ethical and religious language is to be treated. The cognitivists argue

Discuss The View That Religious Experiences Must Be True Because There Is A Common Core To All Of Them

772 words - 4 pages Religious experience can conjure up a wide variety of images. Many claim having had experienced god in ways that ranges from saying a prayer, to attending a service in a place of worship, to hearing the voice of God. Through one perspective, religious experience is plausibly real and true especially for those who have experienced its reality. Through another view, validating any concept such as religious experience is an oxymoron of many

Question: Explain The Significance Of The Acquisition And Development Of Language To The Learning Process. “The Spoken Word Is The Most Important Form Of Communication Between Humans” Discuss

3017 words - 13 pages without speech, as it is probably our most important tool for communication, but it is not the only one. I aim to discuss the significance of the spoken word, the process of language development, factors affecting language development and how such factors may be overcome.Language acquisition is the process by which language develops in humans. The process of language develops in stages, and begins even before a child utters their first word. This

The Verification Principle Offers No Real Challenge To Religious Belief

1008 words - 5 pages “The verification principle offers no real challenge to religious belief.” Discuss [35] The verification principle is a significant concept used by many philosophers in order to determine whether a religious statement is meaningful or not. This was highly influenced by logical positivism: group of 20th century philosophers called the Vienna circle and was then further developed by British philosopher A.J Ayer. Religious language refer to