Regulation Of Systemically Relevant Firms Essay

2256 words - 10 pages

Thomas E. Augustyn
Iowa School of Banking
2009 Intersession Project
Banking Regulation
There is one legislative issue which will be ultimately responsible for the future direction and degree of bank regulation. This issue is the management/regulation of the financial services industry that contains “systemically relevant” (aka “too big to fail”) firms. Management & regulation goals must be 3-pronged:
1. It must be strong enough to prevent the failure of “systemically relevant” firms (without artificial outside support)or provide for a less-traumatic winding down of a “systemically relevant” firm.
2. It must prevent the emergence of more “too big to fail” firms
3. It ...view middle of the document...

The current financial crisis is frequently called the worst since the Great Depression. And Gramm-Leach-Bliley is often cited as a cause, even by some of its onetime supporters.Yet the criticism is often vague, which means that anyone trying to understand the causal chain — how the end of Glass-Steagall led to the end of Lehman Brothers — will have a hard time doing so. To many banking experts, the reason is simple enough: namely, that the law didn’t really do much to create the current crisis. It is a handy scapegoat, since it’s easily the biggest piece of financial deregulation in recent decades. But one act of deregulation, even a big one, and the absence of other, good regulations aren’t the same thing. The root of the current crisis isn’t so much what Washington did, in other words, as what it didn’t do.
The point of Gramm-Leach-Bliley was to tear down restrictions, built by Glass-Steagall, separating banks that did risky investing from those that did basic lending. (The mingling of those two helped create a cascade of bank failures during the Depression.) Thus were born Citigroup, Bank of America and J. P. Morgan Chase, behemoths that owned bank branches, bought and sold stocks and shepherded corporate mergers.
But what else do those firms have in common today? They weren’t the ones that imploded, at least not first. While hardly unscathed, some of them are emerging as survivors amidst the wreckage. The first fatalities were firms that didn’t change all that much in the wake of Gramm-Leach-Bliley. Until their dying day, Bear Stearns and Lehman Brothers were both classic investment banks.
They got in trouble by making a series of risky new bets while Washington did nothing new to stand in the way. “What you’ve got,” said Robert Barbera, a Wall Street economist, “is a system that has gone wildly beyond the safety nets that were in place.” Financial firms chopped bad mortgages into thousands of little pieces and deluded themselves into thinking that the sum of the parts was safer than the whole.
Gramm-Leach-Bliley isn’t entirely blameless. For one thing, the mergers it encouraged left banks with more capital to invest; some of the capital ended up in that deluded subprime mortgage market. But the law doesn’t deserve the mythical importance it’s now accumulating.
Who, then, in Washington, is to blame? As it happens, it’s many of the same people who were behind Gramm-Leach-Bliley. The Clinton administration and Congressional Republicans failed to create a strong framework in place of Glass-Steagall. Democrats pushed for riskier mortgage lending, in an effort to expand home ownership. But surely the bulk of the blame lies with the policy makers and regulators who were on duty while the housing bubble inflated and Wall Street went wild — the Bush administration and Alan Greenspan’s Federal Reserve. Their near-religious belief in the powers of the market led them to conclude that the mere fact that a company was...

Other Papers Like Regulation of Systemically Relevant Firms

Financial Markets and Institutions Essay

1073 words - 5 pages -Banking Company (RNBC) IMPORTANCE • NBFCs perform a diverse range of functions and helps bridge the credit gaps. • They have served the households, farm, and small enterprise sector on a sustained basis. • A thriving, healthy and growing non-banking financial sector is necessary for promoting the growth of an efficient and competitive economy. • The difference between the banks and the NBFCs have blurred over the years. Regulation of NBFC’s

Consob vs Pcaob Essay

889 words - 4 pages consequence, under this regulation, it was required that the audit of private Italian companies’ financial reports be made by the Board of statutory auditors or by another body that may be selected among3: 1. Chartered auditors who are members of the Registro dei Revisori; 2. Audit firms that are members of the Registro dei Revisori or of the register kept by CONSOB (the Italian equivalent of US SEC) ** Current Italian regulation allows

Assignment 3 Market Model Patterns of Change

1559 words - 7 pages government regulation on insurance premium rates means that the industry overall will become less competitive, and prices will not be determined by industry supply and demand. The second factor is the number of firms operating. A larger number of firms means that industry overall prices will be reduced, reducing profit margins. The third is government provided health insurance. Such services by the government will affect the overall

Basel Norms

2934 words - 12 pages * Country Dependent – exposure to private sector * New Leverage Ratio * Volume-based ratio, not risk adjusted * Credit Conversion factor of 10% applies to unconditionally cancellable commitments * Cap on the build up of leverage * Safeguard against model risk and measurement errors * Systemic Add-on * Reduce risks related to failure of systemically relevant, cross-border institutions (SIFIs) * Decrease


8674 words - 35 pages (regulation, reputation and liability, discussed earlier). We consider barriers to entry more fully in paragraphs 4.12 to 4.15 below. We now assess, in turn, the arguments advanced for the potential procompetitive impacts of a cap on auditor liability. 4.8 The impact on barriers to entry and growth facing smaller audit firms 4.9 If the current liability position significantly impedes potential new entrants to the relevant market, the

Eco 550 Final Part 1

1145 words - 5 pages Course Managerial Economics & Globali Test Final Exam Part 1 (100 points) Attempt Score 96 out of 100 points This final exam consist of 25 multiple choice questions and covers the material in Chapters 9 through 12. Question 1 4 out of 4 points Correct The short-run cost function is: Answer Selected Answer: relevant to decisions in which one or more inputs to the production process are

Federal Reserve Indepence

1742 words - 7 pages Federal Reserve and the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp., and erect in its place a triumvirate of new regulators with sweeping, unprecedented powers. Nov 2009- Mr. Paul’s bill would require the Government Accountability Office, an arm of the Congress, to complete a wide-ranging assessment of the Fed’s financial operations by the end of 2010. The audit would delve into bailouts of individual firms, short-term loans to banks, currency swaps with

Managing Assets

2310 words - 10 pages • Institutionalization of Hedge Funds • Pension and Asset Pooling • Regulation • SAS 70 To learn about the services our member firms offer in the specific countries where you do business, use our Country/Region Selector (top left bar). For general descriptions of the services Ernst & Young member firms offer globally, read on. Assurance & Advisory Business Services Ernst & Young provides a full range of Assurance & Advisory Business Services. In

Pastle Factor

1676 words - 7 pages specific economic factors and the relative importance of the economy compared to, say, regulation or social trends will vary. Whilst we hope this book provides a good insight into the economy and the possible effects of economic change on a business these must be considered in the light of other macro and micro factors that influence a firms' decisions and success. | * |


2248 words - 9 pages in certain activities that entail excessive risk, and secondly, to provide financial firms with a set of incentives that would induce them to align their private objectives to social goals. Thus, regulation is meant to define the rules and incentives by which market participants must behave, but without constituting a barrier for the natural development of the industry. It was further stated by Stiglitz (2001, pg.16-17) that “the challenge of

Final Business Regulations

1129 words - 5 pages ., communication regulation and identify the applicable regulations if relevant) (5 points each) 1. Accredited Investor Under the JOBS Act individuals meeting certain income/net worth requirements are permitted to invest specified portions in JOBS Act-related IPOs. 2. Warning Letter Correspondence from the FDA advising a firm of a violation of the Federal Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act detected during an inspection or investigation

Related Essays

Squam Lake Report

4526 words - 19 pages to an effective prohibition on cash bonuses for participants in the government’s Troubled Asset Relief Program (TARP), and is leading us today towards more-sweeping regulation of compensation in financial services firms. [ (Murphy, 2009) ] Events like the mentioned above create a moral hazard problem. As a result, executives have an incentive to engage in risky positions as long as they will not bear the cost of their failure. This will

Memorandum Essay

1241 words - 5 pages inevitable, the regulation be made as cost effective as possible. Questions Presented and Summary of Recommended Forms: The Questions: Which form(s) of pending regulation are most likely to: 1. Allow United Concrete to predict most accurately its immediate costs of compliance? 2. Allow United Concrete to incur the lowest immediate costs of compliance? Recommended Forms: To make relevant comparisons to fully address the given request, it

Blurred Lines Essay

679 words - 3 pages Government regulation of securities exists so that firm’s cannot bloat their profits on their financial records. This in turn causes investors to invest money in them when they are not privy to their actual records. When people think of “shady” accounting the first thing that comes to mind is most likely the Enron scandal of 2001. “The Enron collapse illustrates that government regulation can lessen asymmetric information problems, but cannot

The Big Short Essay

1325 words - 6 pages , direct federal supervision of state-chartered banks, creating a federal charter for systemically important payment and settlement systems, creating unified oversight and regulation of the futures and securities industries, and establishing a federal insurance regulatory structure to provide for the creation of an optional federal charter. Although the Paulson Plan held off a major financial crisis and attempted to address many of the issues