Redemption As A Means To Salvation

2914 words - 12 pages

Redemption as a means to Salvation

Is the story of Jesus mainly about his death and a life that leads to it, or is the story of Jesus mainly about his life and a death that flows from it? On one view, it hardly matters: these are just two ways of looking at the same thing. On a more combative view, the difference is as great as night and day. Does the cross belong on the sleeves (and hearts) of Christians, as the glorious core of their faith, or does it belong in the repair shop, in need of drastic repairs, the primary Christian embarrassment for believers and an offense to outsiders?

The disagreement is not over Jesus’ death as a fact. Both sides largely agree about the reality and ...view middle of the document...

In Proverbs of Ashes, two feminist theologians make this case. They make it not with heated rhetoric but through a narrative intertwining their searing personal histories of abuse, depression, ministry and loss with reflections on where Christian beliefs have abetted the destructive forces in their lives and where they have been part of the healing.

Unlike many first-person approaches to controversial issues, the book’s net effect is neither bitter nor dogmatic. The authors’ honesty and vulnerability invite a genuine dialogue. Anyone who thinks there isn’t a problem should start here.

If Rita Nakashima Brock and Rebecca Ann Parker make a case against atonement in experience, Denny Weaver complements it with a case drawn from history. The Nonviolent Atonement is a full-scale attack on St. Anselm’s and others substitution theologies of the cross, and it also spells out an alternative, which he calls "narrative Christus Victor." The saving work of Jesus is his struggle against and victory over the structural evil powers of this world. Weaver adds "narrative" to the phrase Christus Victor because some might focus this battle entirely on Jesus’ death. Weaver’s point is that the saving work is one continuous story, in which the cross is just one moment.

A Mennonite, Weaver associates the elevation of the cross with the fall of the church. The rise of a theology of God’s redemptive use of punishment goes hand in hand with a church that learns to endorse the military force of a Christian state. His book also includes an impressive review of recent treatments of this topic by feminist, womanist and African-American theologians, perspectives that he weaves effectively into his argument.

If these two books call for a root-and-branch excision of atonement, The Glory of the Atonement is a collection whose writers bring a "don’t throw out the baby with the bathwater" caution. The former writers see the idea of atonement itself as an error. The latter collection see destructive effects sometimes flowing from faulty theological expressions. On the doctrine itself, the introduction quotes Emil Brunner: it is "the Christian religion itself; it is the main point; it is not something alongside of the center; it is the substance and kernel, not the husk."

The essays are careful studies of scriptural texts that bear on the topic and of major theologians who have developed it. The book is a handy way to engage the truly monumental tradition of substitutionary interpretation and a summary of the arguments for its prominence.

Robert Sherman and JoAnne Marie Terrell work carefully in the tangled ground between these two parties. Since criticism of atonement is often made in the name of the oppressed or marginalized, the African-American experience is of particular importance. In Power in the Blood? Terrell patiently works through the place of the cross in the history and faith of the black church.

This is an ambiguous story, for the theology of...

Other Papers Like Redemption as a Means to Salvation

What Being a Responsible Malaysian Citizen Means to Me

969 words - 4 pages Title: What being a responsible Malaysian citizen means to me. What does a responsible malaysian citizen mean? It means that you play a role as a citizen and you do what you are supposed to do, but not doing those stuff which will destroy your future or maybe the name of your country, ! For now, let us take note that common citizenship and equality, can also, potentially, help us to bring the community together. Malay is the sole official and

Examine the Effectiveness of Situational Crime Prevention as a Means of Reducing the Impact of Crime on Society

688 words - 3 pages they will be more likely to commit a crime. Therefore using CCTV and high security, there are less likely to be crimes as they do not want to risk getting caught. However Katz and Lyng put forward the idea of 'edgework' which argues that criminals also do it for the thrill of the act and that situational crime prevention actually encourages crime due to the risk involved that fuels the criminals adrenaline. However the use of situational crime

Knowledge As A Key To Wealth

798 words - 4 pages Knowledge as a Key to Wealth Googling and outsourcing are not merely buzzwords and popular terms of our times. They rather reflect technical and economic developments that have become a part of our daily lives. As information is available faster, this also changes the order of wealth. This aspect is, inter alia, discussed by Alvin and Heidi Toffler in their publication “Revolutionary Wealth”. But how does this new order of wealth differ from

Using Material from Item C and Elsewhere, Assess the Strengths and Limitations of Using Structured Interviews as a Means of Investigating Substance Abuse Among Homeless People. (15 Marks)

741 words - 3 pages Homelessness is regarded as a deviant lifestyle, often involving abuse of a range of substances such as drugs or alcohol. Some homeless people live on the streets. Some spend their nights in hostels that have open access. They may gain some social contact here, but hostels are often understaffed and have limited resources to help homeless people. Some homeless people are, or have been, involved in crimes such as robbery or violence. As a result

Using Material From Item C And Elsewhere, Assess The Strengths And Limitations Of Using Qualitative Documents As A Means Of Investigating Suicide. (15 Marks)

511 words - 3 pages . However such great details does come with its limitations as so much information means that the sociologists has to look though so much. Not only this but you are going to need plenty of personal documents from lots of different people to be able to spot a pattern. Durkheim noticed that there were 4 different reasons as to why people commit suicide. These included egoistic, altruistic, anomic and fatalistic. Although Durkheim’s research was useful

Using Material from Item B and Elsewhere, Assess the Strengths and Limitations of Overt Participant Observation as a Means of Investigating Police Attitudes

1090 words - 5 pages Using material from Item B and elsewhere, assess the strengths and limitations of overt participant observation as a means of investigating police attitudes Overt participation is usually a method of research carried out by those from a non-interactionist perspective, even though it is something that does focus on some interaction. When investigating police attitudes we mean attitudes of the police towards those who commit crime or are those

Critically Evaluate How Imaging Departments Can Use Auditing of Their Radiology Reporting Services as a Means of Ensuring High Standards Are Maintained

4560 words - 19 pages ) detail a process for auditing reports for clarity and precision. A sample of reports are assessed by a checklist of criteria (Coblentz, 2002; and Godwin et al, 1996), which may be used as a means of self-assessment of reporting skills or to audit reporting performance by an independent assessor. This audit will identify any areas of the report where features of the standard are missed (Coblentz, 2002). Godwin et al (1996) suggests formal teaching of

Respect That You as a Soldier Owe to Ncos

1265 words - 6 pages standard, but to the very best of their ability. Soldiers and Department of the Army civilians (DAC) commit to excellence in all aspects of their professional responsibility so that when the job is done they can look back and honestly say, "I have given my all each and every day." Duty also means being able to accomplish tasks as part of a team. You must fulfill your obligations as a part of your unit. That means, for example, voluntarily assuming

Lifo to Be Accepted as a Costing Method

2406 words - 10 pages companies currently using LIFO as an inventory valuation method. In order to claim the tax benefits of LIFO, companies must also present financial statements using the same method, as required by the conformity rule (IRC section 472 [c]). LIFO is not permitted under IFRS, which means U.S. companies must switch from LIFO to first-in, first-out (FIFO) or average cost upon adoption of IFRS. Although only a small subset of U.S. companies currently uses

Illustration Essay: How to budget as a College Student

869 words - 4 pages Mayra Sanchez English 1302 Professor Walter Tete Illustration Essay: Illustrate how to keep a budget as a college student Budgeting essentially is something you have to do for the rest of your life. There are many ways to budget money as a college student. A lot of students do not have the need to budget as much as other kids do. Meal planning is a big importance in a college student’s life. Budgeting has a lot to do with

Is It Ethical to Use Woman as a Marketing Instrument?

1176 words - 5 pages Is it ethical to use women as a marketing instrument? Mass media plays a great part in our lives. Television, newspapers, magazines surround us everywhere every day of our lives. All of them are stuck with different kinds of ads. But how often do we pay attention to the real sense of those ads and the ways the advertisers try to sell various products to us? There have been growing concerns about and critics

Related Essays

Criticize The Use Of Strategic Planning As A Means To Achieve Organisational Objectives

996 words - 4 pages Criticize the use of strategic planning as a means to achieve organisational objectives. Strategic planning is the process by which managers of the firm analyze the internal and external environments for the purpose of formulating strategies and allocating resources to develop a competitive advantage in an industry that allows for the successful achievement of organizational goals Rothaermal (2012). Strategic planning cannot provide a

What It Means To Be A Christian

1260 words - 6 pages Patrick Trainor THEO – 104 What it means to be a Christian What it means to be a Christian; hmm. Prior to this class I thought I knew all I needed to know about being Christian: read the bible, attend mass, work hard, and be good to my family, the usual. After going through this course and reading more about the bible itself and conversing with those in the class I definitely feel more enlightened to what it takes to be a Christian. The day

Education: A Means To Enrich People’s Lives

2279 words - 10 pages every class I take and not focus on just the end goal. This is to ensure that I receive the greatest benefit for my life from of every class I enroll in (classes that I am paying a great sum of money for). To do this I need to view the information presented in all of my classes as a means to better myself as a person and that I must pressure my professors of these classes to show me how this information will enrich my own life when I cannot determine

Put Forth A Theory On What It Means To Be Human And, As A Good Reader, Explain How We Might Read Frankenstein As An Example Of This Theory

1155 words - 5 pages Final Project : FRANKENSTEIN Question 4: Put forth a theory on what it means to be human and, as a good reader, explain how we might read Frankenstein as an example of this theory. You may use any philosophical stance : To err is to be human, to forgive divine. All knowledge is sorrow The strutcure of the mind in Freudian terms The biblical story of Adam and Eve Darwinian evolution Be