Red Light Essay

2507 words - 11 pages

Local officials and the companies that sell and operate them love red light cameras, which are not called cameras in the law. Nearly everyone else, not so much.

Why? Is Florida a hotbed of red light runners crashing into others? If you look at our traffic crash data over the past several years, you'll see that is not the case.

My background is law enforcement. I worked for two years as a Florida deputy sheriff and the remaining 23 years of my 25-year career with the Florida Highway Patrol, where I worked as a trooper, traffic homicide investigator, and squad sergeant, and retired as an investigations lieutenant. I currently operate a small lobbying firm in Tallahassee that specializes ...view middle of the document...

Or you may have read that the Hallandale Beach mayor claims a huge number of “violations.”

However, when crash reports, Department of Transportation crash data, and city records were reviewed, a different picture emerges.

In St. Petersburg, I asked for the data used to make the 60 percent reduction claim. I received 38 crash reports from a three-year period. Each involved red light running as the cause. When I broke them down by year, I found the first year had 6, the next one had 12, and the third one had 10. After the use of the automated for-profit devices, the number remained at 10. This caused the average to increase from 9.3 to 10, a 7 percent increase.

In Palatka, I reviewed DOT crash data for intersection crashes; it also included unincorporated areas. I learned the main causes of crashes were failure to yield and careless driving -- something I already knew after 25 years of Florida law enforcement experience. As with crashes throughout Florida, red light running was well down the list.

In Hallandale Beach, using the city's own records (available online), I found the mayor's claim of 321 violations was actually 172. I also determined that in 2011 the city spent more on automated for-profit enforcement than it took in, for a net loss to the taxpayer.

My study of several cities throughout Florida showed that automated for-profit law enforcement has failed to make any significant reduction in crashes. Is that not the sole reason to use it? Nearly without exception, local officials in Florida claim they use automated for-profit law enforcement for safety, not revenue. Safety is not measured in the number of "violations," which inevitably include far more of the less hazardous right turns than the very hazardous straight-through violations.

(Unlike any city using automated for-profit law enforcement, I publish the crash data I used to perform an analysis. If you'd like to examine my data, Google the term "Red light camera reference page.")

My conclusions are supported by really good evidence. All one need do is go to YouTube and you can find crash after crash all caught on camera – red light camera. If the devices worked, there would eventually be no crashes to capture.

What happens when we turn law enforcement into a for-profit operation?

Most would compare it to ticket quotas, which are illegal in Florida. The thought behind this law was that officers would write questionable tickets to increase revenue, so the Legislature made it unlawful for an agency to impose a ticket quota.

What we have with automated for-profit devices are non-Florida companies raking in millions. The way the system works is that the data (evidence) goes from the company's device to the company for processing. It is then sent to the local police. The company has a huge financial interest in these cases and no oversight to prevent misconduct.

Another problem in the for-profit aspect of the system is that intersections seeing a...

Other Papers Like Red Light

Seed Germination Essay

2520 words - 11 pages departmental style manual (Pechenik, J. A. 2004. A short guide to writing about biology. 5th ed. Addison Wesley-Longman Press.) for writing your laboratory report. The effect of light on seed germination A. Observation. Seeds of some species germinate in the light but do not do so well in the dark. The pigment phytochrome has two forms, Pr and Pfr, which absorb red and far-red light, respectively. Perhaps this pigment helps seeds detect the light. B

Ph Buffer Using Cabbage Indicator Essay

997 words - 4 pages green. Table 1 Color of Standard Solutions for Red Cabbage Indicator Buffer pH | Final Color | 2 | Bright pink | 4 | Soft purple/pink | 6 | Light purple | 7 | Not provided | 8 | Blue-green | 10 | Dirty green | 12 | Green progressing to violet | Discussion The hypothesis that red cabbage indicator solution can be used as an indicator of pH is supported. Color change occurred in each buffer that corresponded to expected results as shown

Five Guys Econometrics

1158 words - 5 pages interests. These points of desire for Ricky are blatantly highlighted by, once again, the color red: the red door to Lester’s house, the tiny, red light in his camera and the red brick wall in his beautiful plastic bag video. Ricky’s utter fascination with Lester’s bright blood also signifies the amount of knowledge he has of Lester’s final state of happiness and content before being shot. The rest of Ricky’s world is told through the bland, gray

Effects Of Wavelength On Elodea Densa Photosynthetic Activity

1394 words - 6 pages absorbing light. Light energy has the ability to excite electrons. These electrons move through a transport chain and are converted to different electron receptor molecules. These molecules then go through respiration to produce glucose and ATP. Not all wavelengths of light possess the same amount of energy though. In the visible spectrum, red light contains the least amount of energy, while violet light contains the most (Klein, 1992). The more

The Scarlet Letter

830 words - 4 pages The Scarlet LetterHawthorne used the colors red and black and used the states of darkness and light, to express character's emotions and the state of their spirit. Red portrayed passion and sin while darkness represented a poor state with self-denial, as well as representing simply evil. Light symbolizes a state of enlightenment, a refreshed spirit, as well as purity and freedom. The color black also represented evil, a state of rejection, and a

Western Red Cedar, a survivalist's commodity

624 words - 3 pages so even after a 1000 years it still looks as if it were only a couple years old. It is light weight and strong which makes it an excellent choice amongst loggers as it would be easy to transport. But these unique properties are not just to appreciate the beauty of this tree but it has many uses both personal and commercial. Western Red cedar is amongst the most useful trees in NorthAmerica. It is used to harvest timber. This timber is later

Looking at Animal Cells Lab - Science Probe 10

546 words - 3 pages Aim: Looking at Animal CellsMaterials: Microscope, cells information sheet, prepared slide of human blood, slide of epithelial cells.Procedure:1. Collect microscope from trolley.2. Set up microscope and switch on the microscope light.3. Scan blood slide and find dispersed field.4. Draw at least two types of white blood cells and a few red cells.5. Estimate size of cells.6. Do two red cells counts and multiply together then compare with white

Examining Blood Cells

587 words - 3 pages : • Prepared slides of human blood • Light microscope • Graph paper photocopied onto transparency PART A – MAKING OBSERVATIONS Method: 1. Draw up a table like table 5.3.2 2. Examine the blood smears provided and use the labelled diagrams provided to try to identify at least three different types of blood cells 3. Record your observations of a red blood cell and as many different white blood cells as you can identify Results Type of

Remote Sensing

1160 words - 5 pages . Later, it was learned that by placing a filter in front of the lens which would pass only a particular color of light, a black and white record could be made of the objects reflecting light in that range. For instance, an aerial photograph of a developed area with a red-passing filter would show bare ground and many man-made surfaces which reflect a significant amount of red light. Hence, this photograph would be useful for identifying

How Soap Cleans??

749 words - 3 pages . Vegetables and colors White light from the sun contains all the wavelengths, but when it impacts on an object some of its wavelenghts are absorbed and some reflected. An object is colored because of the light that it reflects. For example red objects reflect 'red' light, which is light with a long wavelength. Many vegetables and fruits are strongly coloured because they contain an especial kind of chemical compounds named carotenoids. These

Giving Wings to the Red Bull Market

3195 words - 13 pages Giving Wings to the Red Bull Market Table of Contents Table of Contents 2 Executive Summary 3 Issues in the Case 4 Rise of New Competitors 4 Lingering in New Product Development 5 Attracting Only New Youngsters 7 Data Analysis 7 Alternative Data Analysis 11 Recommendations 12 Action and Implementation Plan 13 References 15 Giving Wings to the Red Bull Market Executive Summary Red Bull has become a long-term

Related Essays

Red Light Camera Essay

2507 words - 11 pages Local officials and the companies that sell and operate them love red light cameras, which are not called cameras in the law. Nearly everyone else, not so much. Why? Is Florida a hotbed of red light runners crashing into others? If you look at our traffic crash data over the past several years, you'll see that is not the case. My background is law enforcement. I worked for two years as a Florida deputy sheriff and the remaining 23 years of

Blood, Veins, And Arteries Essay

563 words - 3 pages Blood, Veins, and Arteries In what way are veins really blue? People’s skin tone distorts vein color, as it absorbs blue light. “Subcutaneous fat only allows blue light to penetrate skin all the way to veins, so this is the color that is reflected back. Less energetic, warmer colors are absorbed by skin before they can travel that far” (Helmenstine). In other words, the skin filtrates light wavelengths differently and blue and red light have

Independent Light Photosynthesis Essay

1532 words - 7 pages starch in it rather than green, or blue. My hypotheses can only be supported if the red filter turns out to be black compared to the other coloured filters. I chose the red filter because, as the textbook shows the details of an experiment that, "chlorophyll a and chlorophyll b absorb strongly in the blue and red regions of the visible spectrum. The presence of chlorophylls make plants look green because they reflect and transmit green light, which

How To Make A Roosters Essay

566 words - 3 pages Threads n Scissors C:\Documents and Settings\User\My Documents\THREADS N SCISSORS\TS Design Files\TS081_Roosters 1 Page 1 of 2 Printed 1/23/2010 1. Savage Red 2. Crimson 3. White 4. Lemon Cream 5. High Noon 6. Flame Tree 7. Copper Dusk 8. Charred Orange 9. Charcoal 10. Pinkish Mauve 11. Light Cerise 12. Klondike Pale 13. Cedar Pitch 14. Russet 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. White Lemon Cream Pinkish Mauve Light Cerise