Rebuttal Of The Cartesian Circle Essay

1258 words - 6 pages

The whole idea of the “Cartesian Circle” is an interesting case to look it. The main premise is that Descartes presupposes something, such as the existence of the all-perfect God, to prove that the premise is true, the existence of the all-perfect God. Many critics argue that he creates a circular argument, hence “Cartesian Circle” and with a circular argument nothing concrete is really being proven. According to the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Descartes argument can be broken down into two main steps (Newman). The first step sheds light in the Third Meditations, where Descartes makes arguments for the existence of an all-perfect God. The second step is where Descartes takes the now ...view middle of the document...

140). This is because an atheist can be deceived on matters and not realize this. Since they can be deceived they will always have doubt. An atheist could try and prove that God does not exist but “these proofs are quite unsound” and “will always be possible to point out their flaws to him” (Second Replies, DSW, p. 139-140). Essentially true knowledge only resides in those who believe in the existence of God.
Another objection is whether or not we can know for sure whether or not we are being deceived. How are we to know, as they say whether “their knowledge was as clear as the sunlight” (Second Objections, DSW p. 140). Some argue that this “clear and distinct knowledge” requires a sort of “clear and distinct explanation” (Second Objections, DSW p. 140). Based upon this how are we to know whether this is actual knowledge. For all we know it could be a very murky explanation thus creating a murky knowledge.
At the crux of Descartes response is the supreme being of God. He claims it is impossible for us to be deceived. If God is a supreme being as Descartes claims to have proved, then he “must be supremely good and true” (Second Replies, DSW, p. 140-142). A good and true God never would deceive us as people who believe in his existence. There is a reason God gives us this knowledge for he would not give it to us without a purpose. He would be a deceiver if it was his intention to cast some sort of doubt upon us. However, he has no such intention since he is an all-perfect and honest God.
A final objection is based off how we can be sure God exists because of our perception. Before we can even determine God exists, we need know what we perceive is actually true (Fourth Objections, DSW, p. 142). Essentially, Descartes argue that since what we perceive is true God exists. The critics would say that how are we sure what perceive is actually true in itself. For if God does not exist that is not true or if what we perceive is not true than God does not exist. In essence, Descartes argument is a circular one that uses the premise to eventually prove the premise itself.
Descartes claims that he is not making a circular argument. He claims to not be making the argument that because what we perceive is true that God exists. He actually is making the argument that only because what we perceive as true that the all-perfect God actually exists (Fourth Replies, DSW, p. 142-143). We are certain God exists because Descartes himself has proven this. He furthers his argument by saying that in...

Other Papers Like Rebuttal of the Cartesian Circle

Math Essay

7824 words - 32 pages MA1200 Basic Calculus and Linear Algebra I Lecture Note 1 Coordinate Geometry and Conic Sections υ MA1200 Basic Calculus and Linear Algebra I Lecture Note 1: Coordinate Geometry and Conic Sections Topic Covered • Two representations of coordinate systems: Cartesian coordinates [ሺ‫ݕ ,ݔ‬ሻcoordinates] and Polar coordinates [ሺ‫ߠ ,ݎ‬ሻ-coordinates]. • Conic Sections: Circle, Ellipse, Parabola and Hyperbola. • Classify the conic

Analytical Geometry Essay

1544 words - 7 pages parametric equations. The equation x2 + y2 = r2 is the equation for any circle with a radius of r. Distance and angle In analytic geometry, geometric notions such as distance and angle measure are defined using formulas. These definitions are designed to be consistent with the underlying Euclidean geometry. For example, using Cartesian coordinates on the plane, the distance between two points (x1, y1) and (x2, y2) is defined by the formula which

Rene Decartes

517 words - 3 pages Descartes b. Let X be being deceived by an evil demon c. Let Y be 2+2=4 Premises: 1) If Descartes doesn’t know that he’s not being deceived by an evil demon, then he doesn’t know 2+2=4 2) Descartes doesn’t know he’s not being deceived 3) Descartes doesn’t know that 2+2=4 Cogito Ergo Sum = I think therefore I am – ON TEST Cartesian Circle – 1) Anything that you clearly distinctively perceive is reliable 2) I have the perception that that

Instruments Used in Setting Out Asite

996 words - 4 pages such as road center lines, existing buildings etc. once the baseline has been checked , individual building can be located from it . Theodolite uses movable telescope to measure angles in both horizontal and vertical planes they are manual instruments that comes in two types , transit which rotates in full circle in the vertical plane and non-transit, rotation in half-circle.Using a theodolite at point A and sighting to the furthest end of the

Divine Omnipotence & Thomas Aquinas

1114 words - 5 pages definition, a circle is a geometric shape with no corners and a square is a geometric shape with four corners. Fundamentally, the states of being a square and a circle are mutually exclusive. Similarly, falsifying a necessary truth is impossible; it is a direct contradiction to what a necessary truth is by definition: something that cannot possibly be false. Therefore Aquinas’ response to the necessary truth argument would be that the argument is

Cad Tools

2932 words - 12 pages command requires four inputs from the user, the number of sides, a pick point for the centre of the polygon, whether you want the polygon inscribed or circumscribed and then a pick point which determines both the radius of this imaginary circle and the orientation of the polygon. The polygon command creates a closed polyline in the shape of the required polygon. This command also allows you to define the polygon by entering the length of a side

Курсовая В Labview

1502 words - 7 pages system, rotated with respect to the meridian at the map angle. Coordinates are usually read by the reading of the pointers in kilometers of traveled path from the point of departure and using the cross-track error from the desired track. АНУ-1 continuously produces the dead reckoning by integrating the components of the ground speed vector on the axis X and Y of a Cartesian coordinate system. To obtain the components of the ground speed

Bcom 275 Week 3

603 words - 3 pages ARTICLE REBUTTAL – GUN CONTROL 1 Article Rebuttal – Gun Control Xxxxxx Xxxxx BCOM 275 20 Mar 14 Ceasar I Elpidio Article Rebuttal – Gun Control For this assignment I chose an article titled “Data suggest guns do in fact kill people” (M.S., Sep 2013). The author of the article tries to use data to show a correlation between the prevalence of firearms with the amount of homicides committed by them. To support his

Descartes' Meditations

2176 words - 9 pages Descartes' Meditations In Descartes’ meditations, Descartes begins what Bernard Williams has called the project of ‘pure enquiry’ to discover an indubitable premise or foundation to base his knowledge on, by subjecting everything to a kind of scepticism now known as Cartesian doubt. This is known as foundationalism, where a philosopher basis all epistemological knowledge on an indubitable premise. Within meditation one Descartes

Apa Syphilis

657 words - 3 pages product was grown conventionally with the use of pesticides. If there are five numbers that starts with a nine then it means that the product was grown organically. Rebuttal – As far as non-organic foods go, studies show that some non-organic foods has the same nutrients as organic. According to organic products do not usually last as long as non-organic foods. Organic products produce may go bad quickly. Part 3 Pros – Organic foods

Short Essay on Vectors

1928 words - 8 pages vector is one which has a magnitude of 1 and is often indicated by putting a hat (or circumflex) on top of the vector symbol, for example .The quantity  is read as "a hat" or "a unit".  Let us consider the two-dimensional (or x, y)Cartesian Coordinate System, as shown in Panel 7. | Panel 7 | We can define a unit vector in the x-direction by  or it is sometimes denoted by . Similarly in the y-direction we use  or sometimes . Any two

Related Essays

Circle Of Kwoledge And The Statue Of Liberty

954 words - 4 pages For my opus I have decided to compare and contrast two unequivocal three dimensional statues: our treasured “Circle of Knowledge” and the famous “Statue of Liberty”. First we have the “Circle of Knowledge” which is located on the Mandeville campus of Northern Caribbean University (NCU), Jamaica. Presented as a gift from the graduating class of 2002 this towering 2.44meters statue, of a male and female student, was sculpted by Jamaica’s own

"The Wheel Is Come Full Circle. I Am Here." What Is The Audience Of King Lear Meant To Feel About Edmond At The End Of The Play?

1570 words - 7 pages 1. “The wheel is come full circle. I am here.” What is the audience meant to feel about Edmond at the end of the play? The Edmond presented to us at the close of play is a contradiction of all we know of him. Edmond is corrupt; malicious; jealous; bitter, and yet with his final moments, Shakespeare offers him a chance at redemption. Perhaps this is intended to suggest that no man is beyond salvation; perhaps a sop to the principle that all

The Circle Of Life: How The Ancients Begot Shakespeare, Who Begot Disney

2029 words - 9 pages Good artists borrow. Great artists steal. --Picasso William Shakespeare and The Walt Disney Company are two of the most beloved and famous storytellers of all time, but it is a well-known fact that the majority of their stories are not of their own invention. Excluding The Tempest, all of Shakespeare’s plotlines are borrowed from classical authors, prominent legends and histories, as well as many of his contemporaries (Gray 321-323

The Mind Body Problem Essay

1268 words - 6 pages With the number of brain injury cases observed and the continuous advances in neuroscience, this has proven to be strong evidence in supporting materialism. By defining what Cartesian dualists and materialists mean by the ‘brain’, ‘mind’, ‘body’ and ‘soul’, an argument on behalf of Cartesians dualists will be reached, that responds to evidence concerning brain injuries with the claims that the brain is only ‘an instrument of the soul’. This will