Racial Profiling Or Racist Profiling? Essay

1506 words - 7 pages

According to the Encarta Dictionary, Racial Profiling is the assumption of criminality among ethnic groups without probable cause. Since the September 11, 2001, Al Qaeda attack on the World Trade Center, racial profiling has been the temporary tactic used to stop terrorism. After more than ten years since implementing this practice, the Transportation Security Administration (TSA) has made little progress. Some American citizens are still skeptical of Middle Eastern and Muslim people even though TSA has caught no terrorists through racial profiling. Although racial profiling has the potential to catch terrorists, it should not be used because racial profiling can justify terrorist acts, it ...view middle of the document...

He is stating a fallacy; it is faulty generalization to assume all terrorist acts come from the Middle East. Fishman, later in his essay, mentions “Aum Shinrikyo, the Japanese sect,” and the “’all-American guys’ like Timothy McVeigh and Terry Nichols,” (528) who have committed acts of terrorism. If TSA does not have the ability to analyze all people in an airport it needs to come up with better safety procedures, other than racial profiling, to keep the United States safe from terrorists.
Terrorists believe there is something intrinsically wrong with their enemies, so treating their ethnic group like criminals will only give terrorists more reasons to hate the United States. Terrorists will justify their acts when people in their ethnic group become second class citizens who are alienated from the rest of the population. Racial profiling will cause minorities to become second class citizens (Debate). The profiled group’s way of life will change because of the special treatment they will be receiving. Profiling, the act of analyzing and classifying somebody, and singling out the terrorist type will only cause real terrorists to find another issue with the United States. Racial profiling alienates people who would want to help, but are a part of that profile (AbiNader, 530). People who originally want to fight terrorism will not like the unfair treatment they are receiving. Some will even resent it and try to hinder the security procedures since they know they will automatically be considered a suspicious character based on the race they were born into. Alienating Muslims and Middle Eastern people will not make them feel welcome to the United Sates and they will resent the way they are treated and possible become more dangerous.
According to Jean AbiNader, founding board member of the Arab American’s Institute, “racial profiling presents more complications than solutions,” (530). It will not improve airport security since investigation works well; terrorists can learn to beat the system, and broad screening of everyone makes airports safer. Investigation after a committed crime is more useful to prevent future crimes than racial profiling (debate). Investigating a previously committed crime can give clues that lead to a terrorist or terrorist group. The discovered clue could be what is needed to take down a terrorist group or thwart future terrorist actions. Terrorists will do whatever they can and eventually learn to beat the system (AbiNader, 530). They will dress and behave different than what their profile suggests and it will be harder to find and possibly more dangerous. Terrorists can recruit from other terrorist groups that don’t fit their profile. This will increase the number of people in the terrorist network and profiling will be useless. Airports would be safest if TSA did a broad screening of everyone. Every person who walks through airport security should be subject to the highest security procedures. Non-Muslims will not feel...

Other Papers Like Racial Profiling Or Racist Profiling?

Racial Profiling Essay

803 words - 4 pages think that in order to get the criminals off the streets it is okay to use racial profiling if they are using it in the right way. I think that if I were to see a truck or car with big rims and someone that gets out of the car is all tattooed up and is taking a smoke, I honestly would accuse them of being in the wrong and would be okay if a cop were to come and search them to see what they are getting themselves into. If a person is being suspicious

Racial Profiling And Stereotypes Essay

1283 words - 6 pages Racial tension has been part of America ever since the civil war. Today we have a different issue with race which is called racial profiling. Over the years the relationship between the police and community of color has gone bitter do to racial profiling. America’s society today tends to be tainted by racial profiling and stereotypes. These issues can cause great effects on our society. Racial profiling or stereotyping could diminish how a

Racial Profiling: Injustice?

1013 words - 5 pages Sajel Lala Mrs. Caloutas Sophomore English 28 January ‏2003‏ Racial Profiling- Injustice? "Either the United States will destroy ignorance, or ignorance will destroy the United States" (qtd. in Lhaman Jr. 1). Used daily in the lives of many of the world's populace, racial profiling demoralizes copious amounts of people in countries all over the world. Among those are ethnic groups such as Arabs and other Middle Eastern individuals. These

Racial Profiling By Law Enforcement

782 words - 4 pages Just what is racial profiling? Racial profiling is a law enforcement and security agency practice that encourages officers to stop, search, and investigate people based on race, ethnicity, nationality or religion. While racial profiling is most commonly committed against ethnic minorities, many instances of racial profiling occur in reaction to specific crimes, making any racial or cultural group subject to more intensive scrutiny by the

Racial Profiling In Law Enforcement

1459 words - 6 pages I have prepared to share. Thesis What is Racial Profiling? Racial profiling occurs when law enforcement targets someone for investigation on the basis of that person’s race, national origin, or ethnicity. It has been a very heated issue for the past few years now. Race and location are very dominant characteristics that authorities look at when engaging in this type of profiling. There is so much news of how certain races are being abused

Racial Profiling in New Jersey

1044 words - 5 pages The topic of racial profiling amongst minority individuals in the state of New Jersey has been a heated issue for the past several years. This department has been charged with numerous allegations of racism and is the main focus for racial based events in police departments nationwide. Although racial profiling amongst police officers in the state of New Jersey has been a major issue for many years, it has not been until recently that action has

Smart Profiling Is More Effective Than Racial Profiling

1256 words - 6 pages ). Zakaria admits that racial profiling is currently being used and even he uses his personal experiences as evidence. However, he feels that because terrorist groups are comprised of mostly Arab-Muslims, there is reason to engage in racial profiling. Yet, Zakaria then seems to counter his own assertion by listing off four people of non-Arab descent that have or could have caused great damage through terrorist plotting (Zakaria 311). In identifying

Racial Profiling and Male African Americans

1955 words - 8 pages profiling. WHAT IS RACIAL PROFILING? One of the most important civil rights facing our nation today is racial profiling. The main source of those accused of racial profiling are police officers. In the eyes of citizens, racial profiling by a police officer can be defined as “any police-initiated action that relies on the race, ethnicity or national origin rather than behavior of an individual or information that leads the police to a

Racial Profiling

1090 words - 5 pages Abstract Law enforcement is supposed to uphold the law. When filling out reports and documents it is imperative that all information be added and nothing or no one be left out. As a member of the internal affairs department it is ones duty to uphold the law and to protect those that cannot protect themselves. If it is ones job to write a report and one is ignorant to the facts of what they are reporting then they should read all the

Racial Profiling in the U.S. Criminal Justice System

1045 words - 5 pages dating back to a number of centuries ago. The history of racial profiling is ingrained in a number of historical events that cast African Americans in an inferior light. In 1704, South Carolina created the first slave patrol in which white men oversaw black slaves on plantations as well as hunting down fugitive slaves. Black Americans, most of which were slaves had to produce passes as proof of having permission not to be in plantations, or if

A Justification Paper For The Use Of Racial Profiling

1348 words - 6 pages Racial profiling, the police practice of stopping and searching of blacks because of their race, in the course of drug-interdiction efforts and combating crime, has become one of the most highly-charged racial issues in America. However, this issue that divides our nation along black and white lines, should not be an issue at all. Racial profiling is nothing more than a sensible police technique where police employ the laws of probability to

Related Essays

Racial Profiling Essay

2239 words - 9 pages profiling best decribes the situation where police arrests, questions or stops the person on the basis of race (Cleary 5). In regards to the racial profiling, the concern about it is erupting in the entire nation (Harcourt 18). Racial profiling is considered as the use of the individual’s ethnicity and race through the law enforcement personnel. In many of the jurisdiction, the practice of such acts is considered as illegal and controversial. United

Racial Profiling Essay 934 Words

934 words - 4 pages their jobs. Racial profiling can be defined as “any police-initiated action that that relies on the race, ethnicity or national origin rather than behavior of an individual or information that leads the police to a particular individual who has been identified as being, or having been, engaged in criminal activity (Jost)." There are two types of racial profiling, hard and soft. Hard profiling uses race as the only factor in assessing criminal

Racial Profiling Essay 263 Words

263 words - 2 pages Running Head: RACIAL PROFILING Racial Profiling: Examining the Relationship between Race and Law Enforcement. Liberty University Wendy Thomas Abstract Law –a binding custom or practice of a community: a rule of conduct or action prescribed or formally recognized as binding or enforced by a controlling authority. Enforcement –the act of enforcing, to carry out effectively. These words together create a strong force in communities

Racial Profiling Essay 1605 Words

1605 words - 7 pages heighten needs for security, law enforcement scrutiny, and improved policing standards and technology it is a misnomer and often quickly used to characterize an agencies or officers action. Riley v. California: Effect on Proactive Policing Racial profiling is a longstanding and deeply troubling national problem despite claims that the United States has entered a “post-racial era.” It occurs every day, in cities and towns across the country, when law