This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Racial Diversity In Jury Selection Essay

704 words - 3 pages

Racial Diversity in Jury Selection
Barbara Sigler
Unit 3
American Intercontinental University

The selection process of juries was designed to select citizens that were equal peers of the person involved in the trial. However, many disparities exist and the selection process at times seems to be disproportionate relating to race or ethnicity. Reform of the legislature would benefit those that are not being properly served.

It is the right of every citizen in this nation to have his or her case decided by a fair and impartial jury. The selection of the jury panel is one of great importance and one that can have a great effect on the outcome of the case. ...view middle of the document...

It was only after Batson v. Kentucky that the court lowered the burden of proof necessary for defendants to successfully make the case that the prosecution’s peremptory use was biased by race (Sommers, 2009).

After researching this subject, it is my opinion that mostly evidence depicted shows that unfortunately there seems to be some kind of bias in every jury selection. Jurors are arbitrarily selected from the electoral register, meaning that anyone that is a registered voted may be summoned to appear for jury duty. Research indicates that there have been substantial variations in the structure of juries since 1972. However, to this day, it seems that there is still to be an inadequate representation of women and ethnic minorities. In review of the criminal courts, Lord Justice Auld determined that notwithstanding the modifications of previous decades, juries still lacked diversity and that the e community and its citizens were not adequately represented. The jury system is responsible for the arbitrary selection of jurors and are not selected based on their gender or ethnicity, however, Justice Auld suggested that in...

Other Papers Like Racial Diversity in Jury Selection

Law, Majuries Advantages and Essay

4920 words - 20 pages selection: Lay people Whether a true representation of society is appointed. Juries: Not everyone in society is eligible to be summonsed for jury duty. For those who are it is said to be their civic duty. Hence, a total representation of society is not achieved. `POOL' of available people LIMITED TO: ∑ Only those who are on electoral register ∑ Who fulfil the age and residence requirement ∑ And who are not disqualified, excused or

Case Report/Case Study Outline

948 words - 4 pages employees in question must survey the organization’s diversity and determine if discrimination is involved. If a majority of employees are over 40 then the discrimination is not clearly obvious. However, if the employee population is less than forty years, than the question of discrimination is clearer. Racial discrimination can also be possible within the scenario. The discussion questions states that all four employees were African-American.  The

Workplace Diversity: a Contribution to Organisational Success

2377 words - 10 pages employees. To acknowledge the advantages of workplace diversity, any organisation should take care in ensuring equal abilities for recruitment and selection of employees with diverse characteristics, as well as their training and professional development; when these areas are taken into account, an organisation with a diverse workforce will be able to enjoy improved adaptability, new idea generation, and a wider range of services. Equal

New Jim Crow Introduction and Chapter 2 Analysis

595 words - 3 pages to the number of imprisoned people, and turns against the African American people who are criminalized even more. Not only are the criminals victimized but this also affects the innocent ones too and all the poor people who have been denied representation. In this chapter Alexander has also pointed out about selection of jury and the injustices presented by all-white juries. At no time did I really think of the selection of jury in terms of

Review on Diversity Training

3798 words - 16 pages resource management practices, and other human resource management functions such as recruitment and selection, performance appraisal and remuneration and career management should introduce and include diversity management correspondently, and all the practices from top to the bottom should be in accordance with the organizational strategy. Effective diversity training plays a very important role in the enhancement of employee and organizational

Diversity Audit in Mental Health

5251 words - 22 pages Behavioral Health System Facilities. At the same time, organizations are faced with understanding the importance of valuing differences and instituting effective diversity management initiatives as counter measures to protect themselves from such negative consequences as lawsuits, loss of competitive advantage and diminished legitimacy in the eyes of the customers they serve. The increase in females and racial minority

Nmental Health Audit

5253 words - 22 pages racial minority entrants in the work force, along with employers concerns about motivating and obtaining satisfactory levels of performance from a diverse group of employees, has created an urgency to understand and recognize the value of differences (Soni, 2000). Although literature on diversity has increased, few Mental healthcare management articles have published original research on the subject of racial and ethnic diversity

Mental Health Audits

5204 words - 21 pages Behavioral Health System Facilities. At the same time, organizations are faced with understanding the importance of valuing differences and instituting effective diversity management initiatives as counter measures to protect themselves from such negative consequences as lawsuits, loss of competitive advantage and diminished legitimacy in the eyes of the customers they serve. The increase in females and racial minority

Diversity in the Workplace

2645 words - 11 pages takes place in all employment practices: hiring, promotion, demotion, transfer, recruitment, termination, rates of pay or other forms of compensation, and selection for training. Every employee has access to Company-sponsored educational, training and recreational activities” (Commissioned employee handbook). The ACE Limited section of the handbook declares: “We at ACE are committed to providing an environment in which diversity is

Racial Discrimination

587 words - 3 pages unwanted conduct related to race has the purpose or effect of violating an individual's dignity or creating an intimidating, hostile, degrading, humiliating or offensive environment for that individual victimisation: unfair treatment of an employee who has made or supported a complaint about racial discrimination. In very limited circumstances, there are some jobs which can require that the job-holder is of a particular racial group. This is known


2404 words - 10 pages particular court at the time.The second type is normally only granted during 'exceptional cases' which involve national security where part of the evidence is likely to be heard in camera and terrorist cases. This is to make sure you're not a complete head-case and used to be in the IRA or something equivalent. Some people argue that this is interrupting the randomness of jury selection normally expected.Majority verdicts have been allowed since

Related Essays

Diversity Issues In Criminal Justice Essay

2562 words - 11 pages make their selves and that the person the color they are is not their fault either. Back to racial disparity, there are four reasons to why racial disparity continues to flourish. These reasons are: prosecutorial discretion, ineffective assistance of council, and procedural bars, venue, and jury selection, as well as potential racism by jurors. According to ( Tabak, 1999) “these reasons apply in cases in which the death penalty may be sought

Criminal Justice Essay

1292 words - 6 pages is unique because there is a starting point, finishing point, and steps in between. Every step is crucial and there is no room for error. The writer is going to discuss all of these steps in detail, and will also provide in depth analysis of constitutional trial rights enacted during a trial. One of the most important steps in a jury trial is jury selection. “First, the court or a jury commission creates a master jury list of all eligible

Racial Disparity In Sentencing Essay

1914 words - 8 pages illustration when describing minorities originating from a smaller minority community of his or her racial minority. An example is the case of Johnny Lee Gates, a Black male on trial for accusations of rape and murder of a White female with a jury of White individuals, and the public defender fails to object to the selection process of the jury panel (Tabak, 1999, p. 6). Venue and jury selection is another problematic stage of racial disparity in

Sulc Tegal Writing Trial Brief Essay

2970 words - 12 pages conviction makes it all too clear that racial prejudice is alive and well in American. Although she is allegedly blind, Justice still sees color. Darryl Hunt, and African-American male, was convicted by an all white jury. Throughout the trial and on into deliberation one juror made inappropriate racist comments.  Within the first few hours of the trial the other jurors overheard him saying “that is too ghetto” in response testimony given by the