This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Qui Tam Actions Seminar Paper

5740 words - 23 pages

SNITCHING FOR RICHES: WHISTLEBLOWER BOUNTIES AND THE $96 MILLION CHERYL ECKARD SETTLEMENT

Introduction
Bounties have been employed by United States government over the history of our Nation. As differentiated from rewards, which offer payment for accomplishment of a specific act such as providing information that leads to the capture of a particular criminal, bounties are tailored to encourage the services or actions by some class of persons in pursuance of a governmental purpose. One of the earliest examples in the United States is the grant of bounty land grants during both the Revolutionary War and Civil War. For the purpose of encouraging longer military service, this bounty system ...view middle of the document...

The focus of this paper will be on whistleblower bounties used to protect procurement and securities as enacted through the False Claims Act (“FCA”), the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 (“SOX”), and Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act (“Dodd-Frank”)(and collectively as “Acts”). Part I will lay out the framework of the whistleblower bounties as enacted under these Acts, including language of the statutes and the requirements placed upon the whistleblower in order to be eligible for these bounties. Part II will provide a discussion of Cheryl Eckard’s qui tam action against GlaxoSmithKline for violations under the FCA which resulted in the highest whistleblower bounty award to date, $96 million. Part III will examine how the bounty scheme under the FCA in the area of federal procurement has affected the strength and availability of whistleblower bounties as enacted in SOX and Dodd-Frank in the area of securities reform. Finally, in Part IV, I will give my opinion of the effectiveness of whistleblower bounties and whether they over or under incentivize whistleblowing.
I. THE SUBSTANTIVE LANGUAGE AND PROCEDURAL REQUIREMENTS OF THE ACTS
A. The False Claims Act.
The FCA is one of the earliest instances in the United States enacting a law to provide a whistleblower bounty. As enacted in 1863, the primary purpose was to combat fraud (war-profiteering) by suppliers of the United States during the Civil War by permitting citizens to sue on behalf of the government and be paid a percentage of the recovery. At this time, the statute provided that “the person bringing said suit and prosecuting it to final judgment shall be entitled to receive one half the amount of such forfeiture…”.
The FCA has undergone two major amendments, in 1986 and 2009, that have given more clarity to the law. In its most common uses, the FCA provides liability for any person who (a) “knowingly presents, or causes to be presented, a false or fraudulent claim for payment or approval”, or (b) “knowingly makes, uses, or causes to be made or used, a false record or statement material to a false or fraudulent claim” to the government. The FCA enforces this statute, in part, by allowing a private person, typically an employee or other agent of the violator with particular knowledge of a violation, to bring suit on behalf of the government, otherwise known as a qui tam action. This qui tam plaintiff, referred to as a relator, is entitled to a bounty between 15% and 25% of the settlement amount in the situation where the government proceeds with the action brought by the relator. In the case where the government doesn’t proceed with the action, the relator is entitled to between 25% and 30% of the settlement amount.
Traditionally there was a bar that limited a relator from bringing a qui tam action under the FCA and thus being qualified to receive any whistleblower bounty resulting from the settlement. The bar was basically two-fold. The allegations or...

Other Papers Like Qui Tam Actions Seminar Paper

Racism In Star Wars Essay

4074 words - 17 pages point of me choosing this movie is to show how blatantly unaware we are of its (race) existence throughout society by showing how it is overwhelming prevalent in a classic movie. Yet, before I go on, this paper is not intended to present George Lucas as a racist. In reality its purpose is to show the opposite, how we are ingrained with notions about races that are intertwined in the fabric of our society that continue to "reproduce social inequality

Marketing to the Bottom of the Pyramid

2550 words - 11 pages based on the fact that customers are the primary source of profit for most of the firms operating in the market (Tam, 2004). According to Churchill and Surprenant (1982), “customer satisfaction is an outcome of purchase and use resulting from the buyers' comparison of the rewards and costs of the purchase in relation to the anticipated consequences”. It is also defined in terms of an emotional state that usually arises in response of evaluating a

Ethical Delimas

1333 words - 6 pages behaviors in society that are considered unethical by most people’s standards. Then there are behaviors that are questioned, but legal. The purpose of this paper is to examine the practice of employees accepting gifts from vendors while in the process of bidding and the effects that it can have on an organization. If this were to happen, should employee involved be disciplined for their actions, and if not, how will it affect the overall synergy

Forensic Misconduct

1659 words - 7 pages enforcement officers away from their primary duties; therefore, justice cannot be served (Huff & Killias, 2010). This paper discussed forensic misconduct/What makes someone an expert witness, the actions of Dr. Pamela Fish and the cases of two men; Willis and Pendleton whose convictions were based on Pamela Fish’s erroneous “expert” testimony. References Bluhm Legal Clinic, Northwestern University School of Law. (n.d.). John Willis. Retrieved

Short Paper – Healthcare Reform

836 words - 4 pages Seminar 3 Short Paper – Healthcare Reform Philosophy of Ethics Healthcare Reform According to Teitbaum & Wilensky (2007), policies developed in different industries form an integral part of how individuals perform various activities aimed at assisting the society. Signing of Patient Protection and Affordable Act by the United States by President Barrack Obama led to a lot of changes in the health sector. The introduction of healthcare

Thomas Green

1064 words - 5 pages Running head: THOMAS GREEN PAPER Thomas Green Paper Cotina Taylor Grand Canyon University-LDR 610 August 15, 2012 Thomas Green Paper A person’s success in the organization not only depends on his or her personality but it is also based on how well he or she resolves conflicts. To successfully manage interpersonal relationships in the corporate world the power and influential structures have to be understood within the organization

Hallyu in Vietnnam

3251 words - 14 pages Korean film had gradually altered the Chinese films. The Hallyu wave has strongly in infiltrated in recent years via the music from Korean idol. The K-Pop has influenced much to the young generation, which creates a huge impact on Vietnam. Although Korean wave affects variety aspects, this paper will partly analyze the effects of Hallyu on a fraction of Vietnamese’s culture. The domain that will be focused is the influences of Hallyu wave to

Human Resource Concepts

1191 words - 5 pages Running Head: COLLECTIVE BARGAINING Collective Bargaining Paper MMHRM591/Human Resources Seminar in Problem Solving Danielle A. Williams Collective Bargaining Paper Companies have created environments where employees are working hard but employees are not achieving progress in the area of money and benefits they would like to earn. The establishing of unions

The Characters of Gilbert & Sullivan: Real or Fiction

1215 words - 5 pages Cathy Caligiuri ENG 498: Senior Seminar Dr. Alanna Preussner Gilbert & Sullivan Research Paper 5 March 2013 The characters of Gilbert and Sullivan: Real or Fiction? Who inspired some of the famous, and infamous, characters of Gilbert and Sullivan? Although we will never know the exact answer to this question, it is one that has been very highly contemplated, and argued over, for some time. The characters that are most argued over

Is It Fair To Say That By And Large The Internet Is Unregulated? Why Or Why Not?

1978 words - 8 pages organisations. The little utilisation of such MSOs in the governance of Internet has led to the system failure in the current legal framework. The purpose of this research paper is to examine the nature of internet and explain the requirement of self-governance along with practical rules and regulations. Internet Industry has vast amount of knowledge and in order to create self regulation and practical rules, we need to have utilise knowledge from

Racial Profiling

2239 words - 9 pages States have decided to work on the issues related to the racial profiling, that how the ethnicity and race play a part in order to stop the injustice through the law enforcement in relevance to their jurisdictions (Welch 282). The term racial profiling is defined as the discrimination on the basis of the stereotypes (Harcourt 31). The racial profiling is explained in various ways, it has been used in almost every law enforcement agency. The paper

Related Essays

Marketing Viral Essay

8573 words - 35 pages Hotmail. En 1997, Jurvetson et Paper ont écrit un papier de recommandations décrivant les perspectives et le potentiel de croissance du tout nouveau service Hotmail, ainsi que ses capacités à véhiculer des messages de promotion. Hotmail est un service gratuit (caractéristique qui a grandement contribué à son succès, ce qui est souvent le cas avec les services en ligne), qui accompagnait chacun de ses emails d’une note en bas de page disant

Nsg Heritage Assessment Essay

1482 words - 6 pages , n.d) This paper focuses on the interview and assessment of three families from different ethnic and cultural backgrounds using the Heritage assessment tool. The heritage assessment tool is a resource to gauge the impact of a person’s culture and beliefs, actions and way of living in their day-to-day life. It is a useful tool in helping health care providers meet a patients needs with respect for their cultural beliefs surrounding health promotion

Southwest Airlines Case Study

1337 words - 6 pages STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT (MGT431) GUIDELINES FOR THE WRITTEN STANDARDIZED CASE ANALYSIS Overview and Background The introduction of your paper should acquaint the reader with the company being analyzed and demonstrate your ability to succinctly describe the company from a historical perspective. Take this opportunity to highlight key factors and past strategies, which have led the company to its present position. It is important for you

Research Proposal Essay

2131 words - 9 pages naming the author. Source:Diana Hacker (Boston:Bedford/St.Martin’s, 2007). This paper has been updated to follow the style guidelines in the MLA Handbook for Writers of Research Papers, 7th ed. (2009). Source: Hacker/Sommers (Boston: Bedford/St. Martin’s, 2011, 2007). Source:Diana Hacker (Boston:Bedford/St.Martin’s, 2007). tests, and in-store video surveillance. The difference, Lane argues,between these old methods of data gathering and