This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Qualitative Critique Essay

1340 words - 6 pages

A Critique of a Qualitative Research Article:
Andropause Syndrome in Men Treated for Metastatic Prostate Cancer
Grand Canyon University

Purpose of the Study
Many people understand that women go through Menopause; it is not uncommon to hear a lady friend or a stranger say “there goes another hot flash” and then fan herself with whatever happens to be within reach. What many might be unfamiliar with is Andropause, or the equivalent of male Menopause. Andropause Syndrome in Men Treated for Metastatic Prostate Cancer: A Qualitative Study of the Impact of Symptoms (Grunfeld, Halliday, Martin, Drudge-Coates, 2011) , is a research article that talks about 21 men and their ...view middle of the document...

Beyond this, however, nothing is said about previous studies; if one wants to know about previous studies the references would need to be gleaned.
Areas of Nursing Practice. This research study does not appear to talk about nursing practices. While it talks about professionals helping those with Andropause to express their feelings and find ways to achieve help through different means, there is no direct mention of nursing applications. They talk a great deal about studies done on Andropause and treatment, but nursing practices could have been brought into the study as a way to also help those with Andropause. Nurses are at times the front-line, the eyes that see what medical doctors are often unable. This is an important aspect that was overlooked.
Study Design
It seems for the purposes of this study a phenomenological research method was used. The researchers state in the article that other studies have not utilized cognitive and behavioral aspects on men with Andropause and that their qualitative method will be used to “explore subjective experiences and allow an insight into individuals’ interpretations and beliefs” (Grunfeld, Halliday, Martin & Drudge-Coates, 2011). Considering the strength in which these statements were made, it seems safe to believe the researchers are very invested in knowing how the men feel and are not wanting to have explicit control over the research. The researchers are very knowledgeable about Andropause and its effects, but do not seem to allow that to influence their study. They were successful, however, in achieving the goal of their study, which was to “explore the experience and impact of Andropause symptoms, particularly hot flashes among men undergoing ADT for prostate cancer,” (Grunfeld, Halliday, Martin& Drudge-Coates, 2011.
The researchers initially chose interviews to gather data from the participants of the study. Those were loosely set up after talking with a psychologist, a nurse specialist in a urology clinic, and a urologist himself; in conjunction with these, established research was also consulted (Grunfeld, Halliday, Martin & Drudge-Coates, 2011). In some manner, these can possibly be considered using data, though not necessarily historic. During the interviews, questions were open-ended and researchers were interested in how Andropause interrupted the daily lives of the interviewees (Grunfeld, Halliday, Martin, Drudge-Coates, 2011). As well, they were careful to pay attention to the other symptoms that the participants might mention.
Three criteria were utilized when narrowing the sample: metastatic prostate cancer patients receiving ADT treatment for at least 3 months, ability to speak English well, and cognitively and physically well enough to participate (Grunfeld, Halliday, Martin & Drudge-Coates, 2011). Through a London teaching hospital 48 patients were chosen for the study and sent information on the study and an informed consent...

Other Papers Like Qualitative Critique

Research Critique Essay

1045 words - 5 pages  Benchmark - Research Critique Part 1 Meprina Joseph Grand Canyon University: NRS-433V 07/14/2016 Accidental falls account for 70% of all hospital accidents. The fall rate for inpatient hospitals varies from 1.4 to 17.9 falls per 1000 patient days (Vlahov, D., Myers, A.H., & al-Ibrahim, M.S. 1990). As healthcare providers, it’s our obligation to study and expand new ways to help keep our patients safe by maintaining a hazardless

Research Critique, Part 1 Essay

1234 words - 5 pages Research Critique, Part 1 Grand Canyon University: NRS-433V April 03, 2016 Research Critique, Part 1 While reading a research article, it is important to be able to critique the article properly. A thorough critique would enable the reader to make an educated opinion with regards to the scientific study. In this paper, a research article about urinary catheter removal after surgery will be critiqued. The problem statement, purpose and

Occupy Wall Street: Exploring Informal Learning About A Social Movement On Twitter

1528 words - 7 pages participation in a social movement" (974).The second research question involving the grouping of different perspectives into thematic categories was conducted using content analysis according to the qualitative research methodology. The results were grouped into six categories. #OWS tactics, Critique of #OWS, rational for #OWL, critique of critique of #OWS, connection to the social movement, and general educative. While not every single tweet could be

Exploring the Imapact of Verbal Abuse

1413 words - 6 pages Nursing Research Critique Paper Toni Bratt Spring Arbor University Nursing Research Applications NUR 452 Dawn Borgerson December 8, 2013 Nursing Research Critique Paper The purpose of this paper is to critique a research article exploring the impact of physician verbal abuse on perioperative nurses. This paper will identify the type of study, and the theoretical model/framework used in the study. It will also discuss sample size, and

Paper Report

536 words - 3 pages worth living, or rather can be and ought to be made worth living, and that in a given society, specific possibilities exist for the amelioration of human life and specific ways and means of realizing these possibilities. But advanced industrial society confronts the critique with a situation that seems to deprive it of its very basis. Contemporary society is capable of containing social change – qualitative change that would establish

Research Critique

1429 words - 6 pages  Breastfeeding Qualitative Descriptive Study: Research Critique Part 1 Fonda Robinson Grand Canyon University: NRS- 433V October 22, 2015 Thesis Nursing practice is based upon evidence and therefore research is essential to the profession, and the ability to read and understand research articles is something that is beneficial to all nurses. Nurses should be able to make appraisals and critiques of study

Article Critique: Gendered Pathways: A Quantitative Investigation Of Women Probationers' Paths

1163 words - 5 pages Article Critique In research methodology, feminist scholars blamed qualitative studies which many times failed to bring out the realities of women’s lived experiences (Price & Sokoloff, 2004). Although these experiences are unfortunate common struggles for women offenders, there seemed to be limited research that explored how those struggles in women’s lives seemed to affect their likelihood of recidivism. At last, the “pathways


1809 words - 8 pages • Culture George Ritzer Thesis based on the work of Max Weber • Bureaucracy • Rationality 4 dimensions 1. Efficiency 2. Calculability 3. Predictability 4. Control through nonhuman technology Organisational Behaviour 26 McDonaldization EFFICIENCY Workers follow steps in a pre-defined process. They are highly trained and closely supervised to ensure this happens CALCULABILITY Workers focus on quantitative rather than qualitative aspects of work

Research with Children and Young People

2305 words - 10 pages Research with Children and Young People | Paper Critique This essay will outline and evaluate the role of ‘Listening to Children’ (Walker, Crawford, & Taylor, 2008) in the current paper and reflect on other relevant research on the ‘voices’ of children and young people. Firstly it will discuss the methods which can be used to write a literature review, leading on to critiquing the research contained in the journal article. When beginning

Business Environment

4953 words - 20 pages /) 3.1 OVERVIEW: Critical Review of Data/Discussion The subsequent qualitative critique of reviewed literature outlined that as an expanding learning and training institution, Waltham Forest College provided a positive experience (ongoing future potential) for its stakeholders (clients) such as; Charles Hunt Investments, current (potential new) students, the college’s lecturers (tutors), other academic staff and the wider local community

How to Write Literature Review

1419 words - 6 pages your proposed study will make a contribution to the literature. This has two related parts. First, you want to show some deficiency in the literature. This may involve (a) some weakness in previously used methods, (b) builds on or extends previous research, and/or (c) shows how new knowledge will help theoretically or practically. Second, on the basis of your critique of the existing literature, show why your proposed study is the best way to

Related Essays

Critique Qualiative Research Essay

3287 words - 14 pages Professional Development: Critiquing Research The ability to critique (critically analyse and evaluate) research from both the qualitative and quantitative paradigms is an essential skill for occupational therapists. It is this skill, integrated with expertise gained from clinical practice that underpins evidence based practice (EBP). Although there are many definitions of EBP, Muir Gray (1997) defines it as “an approach to

Research Methods Essay

681 words - 3 pages Essay 1 – Research methods and Methodological Perspectives Different philosophical foundation create a division in social research methods into two key approaches namely qualitative method which is associated with interprevitism and quantitative methods which is associated with positivism. The main difference between these methodological approaches is that qualitative research is about the expression of meaning. Bowling 2002 defines

Research Assignment

2391 words - 10 pages not correct to take on qualitative research having pre-examined earlier works. The author does not discuss reasons why she has not included a literary review, although she has used 25 references and this shows she has read during her study. Seed made direct references to Elias (1978) stating, “Defecating in public becoming socially unacceptable around 1530” and so she obviously thought it important to use some other writers’ opinions

Assignment 2

1002 words - 5 pages . Reading well, critically, thoughtfully, and with purpose is fundamental to doing a dissertation. Business Administration scholars must critique and evaluate research reports because truth, such as it is in business administration, is the result of a collective, critical process. You cannot assess the state of knowledge in an area simply by collecting conclusions from research articles. A literature review is not simply a collection of reports of