Progressive Tax Vs Flat Tax Essay

1269 words - 6 pages

Our present progressive income tax system requires a complete overhaul into a flat tax structure. Efficiency throughout all related markets would increase, reducing distortions, and creating greater than ever incentives to work and create capitalist opportunities. It also presents the potential of solving our country’s budget deficit issues. Our current system stymies innovation and the desire to persevere by forcing a higher tax bracket on those who earn more, causing more individuals to pursue avenues of evading taxation, either through legal or illegal means. Even though the flat tax appears as too burdensome to the poor – or as a contributing factor towards the establishment of a ...view middle of the document...

Adopting a flat tax would also eradicate the existing tax distortion “favoring non-corporate over corporate investment.” The flat tax eliminates the distortions in the code favoring debt over equity financing by businesses through eliminating the double tax on dividends. Family businesses would also be more stable under the flat tax through the elimination of the estate and gift tax. A flat tax would not eliminate the possibility of economic distortions, but with the flat tax, there would be a greater sense of efficiency, which allows for the maximization of social welfare.
Under a plan called the Hall-Rabushka flat tax, the United States would amplify the total annual production of goods and services created by six percent. This is from a composite of 3 percent from enhanced incentives to work and 3 percent from improved incentives for investment and capitalistic action. This would also be the outcome of spending time on the development of productivity rather than being preoccupied with exploiting tax-advantaged opportunities.
The best solutions to tax evasion are not punitive, but rather preventive. A flat tax would diminish incentives for officially authorized tax avoidance and unlawful tax evasion, thereby capably growing tax yields to the public coffers. Russia adopted a flat tax in 2001, which helped their economy prosper, pouring revenues into the government treasury by eliminating the profitability of tax evasion and avoidance. A flat tax would increase the number of taxpayers through the elimination of the Earned Income Tax Credit.
One fallacy of a progressive tax system is the difficult installation and maintenance of such a policy. Looking outside of the United States, more countries – such as Russia, Estonia, Slovakia, and Poland – have found economic stability through a flat tax program. In developing countries around the world, using a progressive tax system has proven difficult to accomplish. “The targeting of expenditures by individual or family unit income levels in these countries – as well as the level of the average tax rate – is more important for the post-transfer income distribution. ” This causes a high-yield proportional (or “flat”) tax system to have a larger equalizing impact than a low-yield progressive tax system.
The progressive rate arrangement prompts inescapable political demands by interest groups for special deductions, special exemptions, and special credit for preferential actions. This is true for taxpayers on either side of the income spectrum. Both low and high wage earners look for some type of incentive to lower their tax responsibility through the amount of salary either category makes. Both use different vehicles to arrive at that conclusion: lower income earners look towards earned income tax credit for relief, while higher income earners look towards “loopholes” to reduce their taxes (which include paying money to a tax professional to find...

Other Papers Like Progressive Tax vs Flat Tax

Basic Principles of a Sound Tax System

1225 words - 5 pages -income families pay a higher share of their income in taxes than upper-income families. Sales taxes, excise taxes and property taxes tend to be regressive. ■ Proportional or flat tax systems take the same share of income from all families. ■ Progressive tax systems require upper-income families to pay a larger share of their incomes in taxes than those with lower incomes. Personal income taxes are usually progressive. Horizontal equity is a

Tax Reform Paper

1725 words - 7 pages future income, therefore, future government revenues. In this paper I will highlight the pros and cons of flat tax, national sales tax, and the current tax system. Flat Tax Simplicity is considered a significant benefit of the flat tax system. One tax rate makes for easy calculation by the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) and straight forward payments from taxpayers. Because the flat tax taxes only one income, it is easier to understand

Tax Laws And Accounting

1448 words - 6 pages first time imposed a tax on individual’s incomes. In 1862, many taxes were raised, changed, and imposed; however, by the end of the war most of the new increased taxes were repealed. Almost 90% of all revenue was collected form excise taxes from 1868 to 1913 [ (Unknown, n.d.) ]. The 16th Amendment was imposed under the Constitution allowing Congress to impose direct taxes. This led to the first flat taxed imposed in 1894.Although this tax was

Itemized Deductions

3475 words - 14 pages reduction in the overall tax benefits of itemized deductions would not change the relative choice of deduction claims, limits based a flatdollar value cap likely would alter deduction claims and possibly tax filer behavior. This could happen if a tax filer has deductions that exceed a flat-dollar value cap, because the tax filer must make a decision about which deductions to actually claim. Even if a tax filer cannot claim a tax deduction for a

Lineberry Chapter 14 Part 1 Vocab Outline

1421 words - 6 pages , transportation, sale, or consumption of a good—for example, those on gasoline. 7. Progressive tax: A progressive tax is one that makes those with more taxable income not only pay more taxes, but also pay higher rates of tax on that income—some argue this is the fairest type of tax, because those who have the most money pay the higher rates. 8. Flat tax: A flat tax is one that allows everyone to be equally taxed on the same rate. 9. Federal

Tax Acct

1743 words - 7 pages History: * First tax in 1861 to fund Civil War * Repealed in 1865 * Income tax law passed in 1894 but rejected by Supreme Court * 16th amendment was passed in 1913 * 42% of revenue is raised from individual income tax * 40% from social security, 9% corporate income tax, 9% other Tax Structure: * Progressive tax structure: tax rate increases as the tax base increases * US income tax system is this way

Financial Inequality In America

1780 words - 8 pages code is so complex, over 54,000 pages to be exact (10 Outrageous Facts). One solution to this complexity is implementing a simple flat tax of 17%, as suggested by Steve Forbes instead of our progressive tax system (Online NewsHour). On the other hand, opposition to the flat tax argue that it will affect the poor more than the rich; this would be true, but in Steve Forbs plan there is a safety net making it to where a family begins paying the 17% tax

Tax Evasion In Canada

5622 words - 23 pages Allingham and Sandmo, examining this case. This theoretical model states that tax payers' source of income is same for all and their income are not reported to the tax department. According to the model, the tax rate on the individuals is considered to be flat. Moreover it states that, tax evasion depends on both size of the income that can be spent, and the change in the tax rate. Income that can be spent and tax evasion are positively related to each

Public Sector Economics

4463 words - 18 pages Public Sector Economics Exercises 1. Florida Taxation a. The 5.5% corporate flat tax levied in Florida is a PROPORTIONAL tax because it is based on gross income of corporations. This tax is levied at the identical 5.5% rate across all levels of gross income on corporations registered or doing business in Florida, so by definition, the tax is proportional. b. Florida’s 6% sales tax is REGRESSIVE since all consumers, regardless of earnings

Corporate Tax

4117 words - 17 pages . * Corporate tax rate does not change every year * Lowest marginal tax rate bracket is 15% and the highest marginal tax rate bracket is 39%. * Corporations with over $18,333,333 of taxable income are taxed at a flat rate of 35% * Rate schedule is progressive with modifications. * Controlled Groups – a group of corporations that is controlled or owned by the same taxpayer or group of taxpayers * Corporate shareholders

Value Added Taxes

1063 words - 5 pages necessities, which would hurt the poor. A value-added tax has a flat tax rate rather a progressive one. In general terms, a VAT on all consumption expenditures, with a single rate that is constant over time, would be relatively neutral compared to other major revenue sources (Mitchell). As mentioned above, America is one of the few nations without a value-added tax (VAT), but there is growing pressure to impose the levy. Some like the VAT because it

Related Essays

A Study On Progressive Income Tax A Case Study Of Us & Brazil

4066 words - 17 pages increases. The simplest form of taxation is the flat tax rate in which one constant tax rate applied to all regardless of income level. (D. Hyman, 2011) Progressive Tax Rate Regressive Tax rate Flat Tax Rate There have been numerous debates regarding the economic costs and benefits of the progressive income tax rate especially with regards to equality, efficiency and overall tax compliance and revenue collection. EQUALITY

James Vs Us Tax Court Case Brief

554 words - 3 pages JAMES V. U.S., 61-1 USTC 9449, 7 AFTR2D 1361, 366 U.S. 213 (USSC, 1961) FACTS: In this particular case, the defendant, Eugene C. James, embezzled money from both his union employer as well as an insurance company and failed to include these funds as gross income for tax purposes. The taxpayer disputed that the embezzled money should not qualify as taxable income as the funds were already required to be returned. James used a previous

Communications Essay

3130 words - 13 pages Heritage Foundation: http://www.heritage.org/research/reports/2010/12/the-value-added-tax-is-wrong-for-the-unit... Kolawole, E. (2011, October 21). The 9-9-9 plan vs. the flat tax. Retrieved from ideas@innovations: http://washingtonpost.com/blogs/innovations/post/the-9-9-9-plan-vs-the-flat-tax/2011/... Popular-Articles. (2013, August 13). Progressive Taxation System: A Brief Study On Its Pros And Cons. Retrieved from Credit Terms: http://www.credit-terms.com/tax/progressive-taxation.html Terrell, E. (2004, Feburary 1). History of the US Income Tax. Retrieved from Business Reference Services: http://www.oc.gove/rr/business/hottopic/irs_history.html

Midterm Test Essay

610 words - 3 pages . Sales tax. D. Social security tax  a The federal income tax is an example of a: A. Progressive rate structure. B. Proportional rate structure. C. Regressive rate structure. D. Flat tax structure  c Jake earned $15,000 and paid $1,500 of income tax, while Jill earned $40,000 and paid $3,000 of income tax. The structure of the tax their income is subject to is: A. Progressive. B. Proportional. C. Regressive. D. Flat.  d Jordan