Problem Of Evil Essay

1181 words - 5 pages

The Problem of Evil-Iraneus and St Augustine
The biggest question people have about God, is ‘Why is there evil in the world?’ Many people, find it very difficult to understand why God, who is supposedly all powerful and benevolent, could allow such atrocities in our world. Indeed for this reason, find it very difficult to believe in him. Cancer, and people being murdered every day, could easily be stopped by him, if he is all powerful, but they aren’t. Hundreds of Thousands of people die in natural disasters, like the 2010 earthquake in Haiti for example, that caused so much devastation. And the question we all love to ask after these situations is, ‘Where was God in all this, and why ...view middle of the document...

This is why the Irenaen theodicy is sometimes referred to as the “soul-making theodicy,” a phrase first used by the poet John Keats.
Many people have responded to this theodicy, both agreeing and disagreeing with it, to an extent. For example Michael Tippet writing in his Oratorio ‘A Child of our Time,’ exploring why there is such evil and persecution in the world comes to the conclusion that says that only until we accept our inner darkness and come to ‘know our shadow and our light’ and the evil of the world can we ‘at last be whole.’
This was in general concurrence to the Iranaues, but many people have disagreed with his views. For example Michael Tooley, writing in the International Book of Philosophy, generally was under the belief that it was all very unsatisfactory. An omnipotent and omnibenevolent God, in his view, shouldn’t have to put people through such pain and suffering to make them develop. Something like the holocaust can never be justified by any positive reactions that happen after it, can’t be justified by people coming closer to God, as it was such an outrageous evil that God didn’t stop.
The other view, the one generally accepted and adopted by Christians is the Augustinian theodicy. This is based on the idea of original sin, and that God is completely blameless and detached from all the evil in the world. St Augustine believed that sin the moral evil was brought into the world by Adam and Eve, who were created sinless and perfect and with no defect or suffering, but they chose the path of evil and were seduced by the devil into eating the apple from the tree of knowledge. This knowledge they gained of good and evil that they had supposedly discovered through their disobedience brought about moral evil. Augustinian theologians Augustine believed that all of man was ‘seminally present in the loins of Adam.’ By his logic this meant that we all inherited Adams will and his corruptness. Natural Evil, like Earthquakes for example, are attributed as punishments for the fall of man.
This theory is widely criticized as most people don’t believe in Adam and Eve anymore, as it doesn’t fit with the scientific evidence we have for evolution. Also...

Other Papers Like Problem of Evil

Critically Expose The Problem Of Evil

2413 words - 10 pages EMMANUEL SAGWETE (916)DPL 314 PHILOSOPHY OF RELIGIONFR. A. RUTSVIGA28 OCTOBER 2010Critically expose the problem of evil.Evil is a privation of the good. The problem of evil "arises from the paradox of an omnibenevolent, omnipotent deity's allowing the existence of evil" (Pojman 1987: 151). The Judeo-Christian tradition affirmed that God is omnipotent, omniscient and perfectly good. The same tradition also affirmed the existence of evil. The

Hamartiology: the Problem of Evil (Theodicy)

708 words - 3 pages Short Essay #1 Hamartiology: The Problem of Evil (Theodicy) The problem with evil is that it is hard to believe that in a world created by a God that is supposed to be an all loving all power full God then why would he allow evil to be in the world. Why would he allow for killings and cancer and natural disasters? Evil is a byproduct of free will, because we are free to choose between doing the right thing, that equates to good, and

The Problem of Evil (~1100 Words)(Not Great Writing)

1186 words - 5 pages “All the evil in the World shows that an all-good, all-knowing, all-powerful God does not exist” Epicuris is associated with one example of a formulation of the problem of evil, it is usually schematized as follows If an all-powerful and perfectly good god exists, then evil does not. There is evil in the world. Therefore, an all-powerful and perfectly good god does not exist. Various philosophers have expanded upon this to create

The Problem Of Evil: Free Will Vs. Faith

519 words - 3 pages The Problem of Evil: Free Will vs. Faith Sheri Rinker Walden University 23-Mar-16 The Problem of Evil: Free Will vs. Faith "I don't understand why people believe in God when there is so much pain and suffering in the world." This is a statement often heard and often contemplated. We will look at the notion of the meaning of this statement and postulate from the Free Will View. This view states that evil and suffering are the results of

The Problems with the Problem of Evil Argument

1491 words - 6 pages Hawkins, Kevin 12/5/12 The Problems with the Problem of Evil The purpose of this essay will be to evaluate the argument against the existence of God based on the evidences provided in the atheistic standpoint of the problem of evil in the world. This is a very common argument and is in no way unique to those who firmly believe that there is no God. I have met many people in and out of Christianity and other faiths who have expressed

A Study of: John Hick’s “the Problem of Evil” and Arthur C. Clarke’s “the Star”

1452 words - 6 pages Fall Term (2008) Essay Assignment A Study Of: John Hick’s “The Problem of Evil” and Arthur C. Clarke’s “The Star” Audrey Scott 4272258 PHIL1F91 Andrew T. Seminar 10 The Problem of Evil as outlined as John Hick is that “if God is perfectly loving, he must wish to abolish evil; and if he is all-powerful, he must be able to abolish evil. But evil exists; therefore God cannot be both omnipotent and perfectly loving” (Hick, 1963). In this

Response to Fallacious Solutions

1258 words - 6 pages 14169748 Word Count: 1132 RESPONSE TO FALLACIOUS SOLUTIONS 1 Response to Fallacious Solutions According to Robbins (2012), the problem of evil states that if God exists and he is omnibenevolent and omnipotent, he would eliminate all evil from the world. However, since evil obviously exists, as we see people suffering and bad things happening everyday, if God existed, and he was

Response to Fallacious Solutions

1258 words - 6 pages 14169748 Word Count: 1132 RESPONSE TO FALLACIOUS SOLUTIONS 1 Response to Fallacious Solutions According to Robbins (2012), the problem of evil states that if God exists and he is omnibenevolent and omnipotent, he would eliminate all evil from the world. However, since evil obviously exists, as we see people suffering and bad things happening everyday, if God existed, and he was

God and Evil

1281 words - 6 pages   PHL 101 11 March 2012 A Summary of the problem of evil and a critical evaluation of how it is said to undermine the traditional characteristics of God. This paper will attempt to review the philosophical quandary of the existence of evil and if evil exists can God exist and if so can this God still be declared perfect? The epistemological issue that arises is One’s knowledge of God and the validity of God’s existence. What is good

Hamartiology

1056 words - 5 pages Hamartiology: The Problem of Evil (Theodicy) – Your neighbor Sam greets you outside as you return home from church one Sunday. After the usual chitchat, he confides in you that he has been troubled with the news, recent reports of natural catastrophes, wars, disease, and so on. He asks if you could help him make sense of the presence of evil in the world - if indeed God exists.

 Keeping this scenario in mind, answer the following questions

Explain the main themes of theodicies in the augustinian tradition

1193 words - 5 pages Leibniz’s idea that this is the best of all possible worlds. A theodicy is a philosophical or theological study which attempts to satisfy the problem of the existence of evil and suffering alongside that of an omniscient, omnipotent and omnibenevolent God. The Christian approach to the problem of evil has largely been based on two Theodicies, the Irenaean and the Augustine. Both use the defence of free-will as their basic answer to the

Related Essays

Problem Of Evil Essay

1443 words - 6 pages What is the “Problem of Evil”? What is the difference, if there is a difference, between so-called “moral evil” and “natural evil”? How exactly does John Hick, in his essay “Problem of Evil”, solve the problem of both “Moral evil” and “natural evil”? Do you think that either or both, of Hick’s solutions is really able to solve what appears to be a unique problem of evil in Arthur C. Clarke’s short story, “The Star”? Unhappiness, as a whole

The Problem Of Evil Essay

925 words - 4 pages Name: Leah Drumheller_____________ Writing Style Used: ____________MLA________________ Course and Section Number: ______THEO 202 B22 LUO________ Hamartiology: The Problem of Evil (Theodicy) An age-old question that has been and is being asked from various religions, cultures, and socioeconomic backgrounds is how can a loving and good God allow evil to come into the world? It is a problem that has come up

Problem Of Evil Essay

995 words - 4 pages Bobby Rappach Mr. Klockner Problem of Evil The Problem of Evil I feel that the problem of evil isn’t evil itself but people and their applications of evil in the world. When thinking of evil the first thing that comes to mind is sin and the devil and it should be normal to do so. Satan was the first to sin and it became a legacy that every human tends to do and some more than others. Satan may have directly disobeyed God with the intention

Problem Of Evil Essay

1963 words - 8 pages One well known philosophical dilemma, that causes much of humanity significant grief and frustration towards religious beliefs, is the problem of evil. John Hick explains in his essay, “The Problem of Evil”, that this ‘crisis’ so to speak is based on three characteristics that Christians claim God has. Christians believe that God has infinite knowledge, power and love. The question that is then raised is: Why is life on earth filled with vast