RUNNING HEAD: PRO CHOICE 1
Pro Choice or Pro Life?
Richard W. Emmendorfer
Dr. Stephen Carter
28 October 2013
Abortion, sometimes viewed as a permanent solution to a temporary problem, should be or remain legal for specific cases involving victims of rape, significant medical conditions that would jeopardize the safety of the birth or guarantee severe birth deformities. Unwed adolescent parents are who are deemed unfit or who would not be able to provide adequate care should also be determined as a qualifying circumstances. Victims of rape would have a constant reminder of the experience weighing heavily on their mental health and would hold prejudice ...view middle of the document...
Political parties or religious groups are the perfect example of a cultural lens. Conservatives will almost always argue the “Pro-Life” point of view, while Liberalists will typically support the “Pro-Choice” standpoint. This segues into the issues within large organizations such as political parties and the group thinking approach, which will not be discussed here, but allows perspective into why seemingly simple problems have complex solutions.
The well being of the mother is in question when forced to have the child of a rapist. Age of the rape victim is also a factor. Coupled with the enforcement of the State or laws that would require full gestation of the child conceived by rape, and the potential frame of mind that the mother would be in due to the tragedy, Anxiety, insecurity, and several other mental instabilities could result.
Related to abortion but not directly related to a rape situation, an example of how significant the choice is to women would be the 1973 case of Roe v. Wade. “The Court deemed abortion a fundamental right under the United States Constitution, thereby subjecting all laws attempting to restrict it to the standard of strict scrutiny”. (Anonymous, Roe v. Wade, 1973)
Even though there have been several other cases similar to the Roe v. Wade trial, US public opinion still stands split in favor and opposition at around 56% in favor and 40% opposed according to the Harris Poll which has tracked the public opinion of the Roe v. Wade case since 1973. Victims of rape should have a legal right to decide how to move forward after such a traumatic experience whether it be to abort the child or not.
Some women are incapable of giving birth with out serious risk to their life or have created or developed conditions that clearly identify a severe birth deformity that would result in the mother or child living an abnormal life.
Women’s hips can be too narrow to safely carry or give birth. Cephalopelvic disproportion (CPD) occurs when a baby’s head or body is too large to fit through the mother’s pelvis. Generally, CPD is a rare diagnosis, but it is a factor in the health or well being of the mother or baby. (American Pregnancy Association, 2005) A family history of genetic problems can result in Down syndrome. Tests by medical professionals can detect some defects. Excessive drug and alcohol usage and malnutrition can effect the development of the fetus and lead to infant mortality. Children born with significant or severe defects have the potential to live most of their life on some sort of medical device or even incubated. Cases like these require several surgeries and procedures that have a smaller percent of success than failure and typically end in infant mortality. Some women who are at risk to die during gestation or birth do not find out about these conditions until after conception.
There are medical solutions for almost any medical issue or problem, for that matter for almost any...