This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Policy Brief On Principal Evaluations Essay

1253 words - 6 pages

Policy Brief:
Are Principal evaluations a true assessments of their leadership abilities?

Are principals’ evaluations a true assessment of their leadership abilities? Throughout this policy brief, justifications for principal evaluations are given, and the evaluation model is explained. Furthermore, a case is built to justify why the evaluation model needs to be reexamined to better represent a principal’s ability to positively lead a school. In addition, suggestions are given to adequately reflect principals’ abilities as leaders and to improve the overall effectiveness of the Tennessee evaluation process of administrators.
Justifications for Evaluations
...view middle of the document...

10-12). Principals’ performance assessments also provide central office administrators and the principal information with which to build professional learning plans and to chart professional growth. These assessments are also challenging because principal’s practices and influence on instruction are not always readily apparent.
Evaluation Model
The evaluation model in Tennessee has two phases. Both phases consist of the same steps but require different obligations depending on the level of experience. Phase one of the process is used to evaluate administrators new to the district, school, or level scoring. Phase two is used to evaluate veteran administrators new to their most recent evaluation. The steps included in the evaluation are self-reflection, formative assessment, observation and conferences, surveys, and summative conferences. Principals’ and assistant principals’ final evaluations are based on the following measures:
• 50% Qualitative:
• 35% -scores on a rubric is based on the standards outlined in the Tennessee Instructional Leadership Standards (TILS).
• 15% - assessment of the quality of teacher evaluations.
• 50% Quantitative:
• 35% -school-wide growth data. Value Added
• 15% - achievement measure agreed upon by the administrator and their evaluator. (Huffman)

Present Evaluation Model

Some principals believe the 35% in school- wide growth data is too high. They have stated there are schools that do not show a year’s worth of growth in value-added because their students are performing on grade level, and therefore should not receive a lower score. They feel that the largest single factor in principal evaluations should be school-level student outcomes. A principal's ability to attract, to develop, and to retain effective teachers must also factor highly. By using both student achievement and quality teacher recruitment and retention as primary measures, districts can ensure that school leaders are evaluated in what matters most: the level of teacher effectiveness in their school. (Gates, Hamilton, Connelly & Bartoloetti, 2013, p.7)
How can the evaluation process be reformed?
Something should be done to help our principals. In a recent survey in the American Teacher journal principals claim their jobs are only getting harder. There are 75 percent of principals who feel the job has become too complex and their job satisfaction has decreased in the last five years to 59 percent. Mel Riddile, Associate Director of National Association of Secondary School Principals, claims, “We have the perfect storm of implementation: Common Core State Standards, new teacher evaluations, and new accountability systems. It’s dramatically changed the role of a principal, instead of being an inspector of effective teaching they are now a builder of teacher capacity” (DeNisco, 2013, p. 16). Educators and parents want to see students

grow and master the necessary skills to be successful. To help principals feel...

Other Papers Like Policy Brief on Principal Evaluations

Whistleblower Essay

818 words - 4 pages model. Florida State University Law Review, 32, 571-615. Lane, J.E. (2003 ). Relevance of the principal-agent theory framework to public policy and implementation. Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy, National University of Singapore. Leruth, L., & Paul, E. (September 2006). A principal-agent theory approach to public expenditure management systems in developing countries. IMF Working Paper, International Monetary Fund. Waterman, W., & Meier, K.J. (1998). Principal-agent models: an expansion? Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 8(2), 173-202.

Public Policy Evalution Essay

2609 words - 11 pages evaluation provides additional opportunities for the myriad political interest groups and policy actors to attempt to influence the life of a specific policy. Favorable evaluations of the impact of a given policy will tend to perpetuate the implementation and life-cycle while unfavorable evaluations may give rise to change or possibly policy termination. Depending on the taste of any interest group or policy actor, the perception of how well a policy


2527 words - 11 pages research involving human subjects 6. comparative analysis, including cross-cultural research 7. analytical literature surveys, scoping exercises and content analysis 8. case studies 9. action research 10. evaluations. 3. A policy-based approach Adopting a policy-based approach would involve defining as socio-economic research any research that relates to social or economic public policies. These might include: 1. economic policy 2

Marketing of Insurance Services Agency Approach

1729 words - 7 pages an implied authority is the case of Marfit vs Royal insurance 1892. An agent of Royal insurance company issued a temporary cover in behalf of his principal who refused to accept the proposal, unaware even that within this period, fire had occurred, thereby giving rise to claim. The insurers argued that the agent had no right to issue cover or sell policy on their behalf. But previous covers so issued or sold by the insurers. The agent had an

Criminal Profiling: the Public Face of Forensic Psychology

2216 words - 9 pages evaluations is normally narrowed to become fully focused on gaining pertinent information regarding the psych legal elements being reviewed in the evaluation (Kalmbach & Lyons, 2006). The main reason that leads to the requirement of psychological evaluations is commonly centred on identification of aspects of human behaviours which fall outside what can be described as normal behaviour. Such behaviours commonly cause disturbances upon the involved

Hazelwood School District V. Kuhlmeier, 484 U.S. 260 (1988)

405 words - 2 pages LEGAL BRIEF Hazelwood School District v. Kuhlmeier, 484 U.S. 260 (1988) 5-3; Justice White for the majority FACTS: Three former Hazelwood East high school students who were staff members of Spectrum, the school newspaper are suing Robert Reynolds, the principal of Hazelwood High School and Howard Emerson, their Journalism II teacher. The students believed that their school officials violated their First Amendment rights by removing two

Grading System

872 words - 4 pages time consuming in terms of recording grades, computation using of calculator. If some records are lost, they never retrieve it in case of unexpected calamity. Accuracy and security is not been so defined. BRIEF DESCRIPTION Sto.Niño Elementary School has a colorful History. Starting from a two-room wooden building built in 1940, it gradually grew and expanded up to sixteen buildings, its very first building was located on a less than a

Supervision for Successful Schools: the Norm

1103 words - 5 pages that could be used to improve teacher performance. The ultimate concern in this environment is creating a happy staff. The final category is collegial. Today’s schools focus their efforts on this category because it is professional and student outcome based. These schools believe that success is based on professional work accomplished together and the end product which is the achievement of students. In these schools, the principal role is


1173 words - 5 pages issue in this case is whether Ms. Attired’s failure to remove her tattoo when instructed to do so by her employer constitutes “misconduct” as defined by N.M. Stat. Ann. §51-1-7. Also, if Ms. Baker provided proof of Natalie’s appearance having a negative effect on the business, causing sales/profits to go down. Brief Answer: Natalie’s refusal to remove the tattoo does not constitute misconduct. There was no rule or policy forbidding tattoos. Ms

Btec Research Project

2799 words - 12 pages functions that you might never have witnessed if you were in the office for a brief interview or meeting. You may see changes in the business pace at different times of the day, such as how food and beverage workers shift into high gear as they prepare for a dinner rush, or how bank operations pick up near the close of business. An in-depth interview gives you the opportunity to ask substantive questions based on your observations. The chances are

Btec Research Project

2799 words - 12 pages functions that you might never have witnessed if you were in the office for a brief interview or meeting. You may see changes in the business pace at different times of the day, such as how food and beverage workers shift into high gear as they prepare for a dinner rush, or how bank operations pick up near the close of business. An in-depth interview gives you the opportunity to ask substantive questions based on your observations. The chances are

Related Essays

Grading System Versus Written Evaluations Essay

644 words - 3 pages Grading system versus written evaluations The grading system has been embedded in our education system for many generations now. Students have been assessed based on their knowledge and skill of various subjects based on their performance on a piece of paper. From that, they are awarded grades with A’s being the best signifying superior knowledge and F’s being the worst. Recently however, many have started to wonder how written evaluations

Online Evaluations Essay

3644 words - 15 pages which students complete course and faculty evaluations through a website, out of class and usually on their own time. The adoption rate among schools rose from 2% in 2000 to 33% in 2005, with the most common reasons cited being the cost and time savings (Guder & Malliaris 2013). Despite these potential benefits, many professors fear repercussions in the form of lowered response rates and biased scores. This paper aims to examine these concerns

Evaluation Model Paper

923 words - 4 pages based on frequency of evaluations, with summative evaluations monitoring a policy that has been implemented for some time and formative evaluations continuously monitoring the implemented policy. Under these two evaluations, they both control direct and indirect input and output variables. Under direct control, variables can be manipulated. Where as in a social experiment the group being monitored can be changed from under 18 years old to over

Mediocre Teaching Essay

1558 words - 7 pages quality of evaluations will vary greatly depending on which category a particular principal falls into. How can schools really improve if the institution forces the principal and assistant principal to be the primary evaluators, while maintaining an overwhelming amount of competing responsibilities? Another institutional deficiency is that many new administrators do not receive enough mentoring in their new field. Pete Hall is a principal of