Plea Bargains Essay

1380 words - 6 pages

Plea bargains play a major role in the criminal justice system. The use of plea bargains has become quite controversial with valid points argued by those who support and those who oppose their use. Before making a decision to agree or disagree, one must compare the arguments regarding the use of plea bargains as well as understand the purpose of the plea bargain, types of plea bargains, and the positive and negative aspects of each type of plea bargain.
Purpose of Plea Bargains
A plea bargain is an arrangement made for a criminal case in which the prosecution proposes a deal to the defendant in exchange for a guilty plea. A plea bargain allows individuals who have been accused of ...view middle of the document...

This category of plea bargaining puts pressure on the defendant to plead guilty, and only offers the hope of possible leniency (Meyer & Grant, 2003).
There are three types of plea bargains available: charge bargaining, sentence bargaining, and count bargaining. All of these plea bargain options offer some type of reduction in the defendants’ sentence. When the defendant and their attorney agree to use charge bargaining, the parties will approach the prosecution or judge with a request for a reduced sentence if the defendant agrees to plead guilty. However, charge bargaining is associated with a significant negative aspect. For example, if the defendant were originally charged with a felony offense, he or she could take a plea bargain that offers a lesser misdemeanor charge (Meyer & Grant, 2003).
Sentence bargaining occurs when the defendant agrees to plead guilty with the condition that the prosecution make a promise to request an alternative or lighter sentence. However, the agreement made between the defendant, and the prosecution is not guaranteed. It is the judges’ decision to approve or deny the plea bargain (Meyer & Grant, 2003). Sentence bargaining has both positive and negative aspects associated with it. For example, a negative aspect of sentence bargaining occurs when a defendant who is charged with a capital offense receives a plea bargain that reduces his or her sentence to life in prison with the chance of receiving parole. This could result in the victim of the defendants’ crime feeling like the system failed because it basically rewarded the defendant for committing a crime just because he or she admitted his or her guilt. Despite the negative aspect, sentence bargaining is a very important part of the system. This type of plea bargain is effective in cases in which the prosecution does not have a strong enough case to guarantee a conviction, or if they lack sufficient evidence for the case to qualify for a death penalty sentence. By using sentence bargaining in these types of cases, the conviction and punishment of the defendant is guaranteed.
When a defendant is faced with multiple charges, the prosecution may offer a plea agreement known as count bargaining. Count bargaining occurs when the prosecution offers to reduce the amount of charges or dismiss the charges if the defendant agrees to plead guilty. For example, an individual is arrested and charged with multiple counts of driving under the influence, but he or she is given the opportunity to have it reduced to one charge if he or she agrees to plead guilty. However, this type of plea bargain has several negative aspects associated with it. Count bargaining allows defendants charged with multiple counts of violent crimes to be rewarded by reducing the amount of charges, results in an incomplete criminal history, and provides a severely reduced punishment. The only positive aspect of count bargaining is that it simplifies the case for...

Other Papers Like Plea Bargains

Plea Bargaining Essay

909 words - 4 pages negotiate with the defendant in terms of the charges that could be filed.” (University of Phoenix, 2011). “Sentence bargaining occurs when a defendant agrees to plead guilty in exchange for a less serious sentence.” (University of Phoenix, 2011). “Plea bargains are extraordinarily common in the American legal system, accounting for roughly 90% of all criminal cases.” ("Find Law", n.d.).  There are advantages and disadvantages to plea

Plea Bargaining Essay

823 words - 4 pages Of Plea Bargaining In America. In Plea Bargaining's Triumph: A History Of Plea Bargaining In America (pp. 162-166). Stanford University Press. Thompson, S. (2006, September 17). What is a Plea Bargain and How Do Plea Bargains Work? Retrieved August 19, 2013, from Yahoo! Inc.: http://voices.yahoo.com/what-plea-bargain-plea-bargains-work-75495.html?cat=17

A Review of the Literature: Plea Bargaining and Ethics in the Criminal Justice System

1939 words - 8 pages : explicit plea bargaining and implicit plea bargaining (Schmalleger, 2012). Explicit plea bargaining arises when the prosecution propose that the suspect be charged with a less significant offense in exchange for a guilty plea. With implicit plea bargains, no compromise of leniency is assured by the prosecutor. This classification of plea bargaining merely suggests the possibility of leniency if there is a plea of guilty by the defendant (Bibas

Plea Bargaining Paper

1020 words - 5 pages , or to one of many charges in order to have other charges dismissed from their case; or it could also mean that the defendant will plead guilty to the original criminal offense in return for a lighter sentence. Plea bargains allows both parties to avoid a lengthy criminal trial and may allow criminal defendants to avoid the risk of conviction at trial on a more serious charge. For example, in the legal system in the United States, a criminal

Plea Bargaining

1207 words - 5 pages for crime they did not commit, which they are going to take the blame and pay for someone else’s mistake. Because of the negativity effect of plea bargaining, some states have banned plea bargains and other states set a deadline a plea bargain may be made (Siegel, Schmalleger, & Worral, 2011).  The reason for doing this is to allow defendants to a fair trial by jury and for the prosecutor to prove the defendant in question is guilty of the charges

My Reflection

833 words - 4 pages has many favorable aspects especially when it comes down to the government saving some money. I would have to agree with those who believe that plea-bargaining does corrupt the American system of justice. The people who are receiving these plea bargains are just looking for an easy way out and the government is looking to save a few bucks. Timeline Reflection In Boykin v Alabama, The entry of the plea must be knowledgeable and the trial record

Probation and Punishment

697 words - 3 pages are resolved by way of a plea bargain. Plea bargains (also known as negotiated dispositions, plea agreements, or deals) involve the defendant entering a plea of guilty (or no contest) to one or more charges, usually lesser charges, in exchange for a promise of a substantially reduced sentence. But even when the prosecutor and the attorney cut a deal, sentencing is always decided by the court. Sometimes, a client will go to trial and be found

Court Issues

1465 words - 6 pages victim, the opportunity to decline speedy trial for the offender would allow the criminal justice system to have more justifiable sentences. Although altering plea bargains may put a burden on court administrators by having more cases on the docket as well as costing taxpayers more money, it would also send a message that plea bargains are not the answer for all cases. Taking away plea bargains for certain crimes could have an effect on crime rates

Right to Counsel

1152 words - 5 pages advise the client of what can be done to help them win the case and to determine if their rights have been violated in any way. Attorneys are also there to make plea bargains for their client. In many cases, a plea bargain can help the client as well as help the justice system, but if they are not careful they can make a bad deal for their client. Making a bad deal for their client not only hurts their client, but it can also hurt their

Criminal Justice

4145 words - 17 pages Discrimination- A situation in which the length of a sentence appears to be influenced by a defendant’s race, gender, economic status, or other factor not directly related to the crime that he/she has committed Judges in the Court System: * Trial judges- determine if there is enough probable cause, evidence, bail, pretrial motions and plea bargains * Also play the role of administrators and are responsible for the day to day functioning

Criminal Justice

1283 words - 6 pages officers take reports of crimes that happen in their area. They investigate, gather, and protect evidence of a crime. They make arrest, give testimony in court, and conduct follow-up investigation. Prosecutors are lawyers who represent the state or federal. Prosecutors review evidence that the law enforcement gathers; and decides on if any charges are going to be filed. They present evidence in court, question witnesses, and negotiate plea

Related Essays

Pros And Cons Of Plea Bargining

738 words - 3 pages Pros and Cons of Plea Bargains Linda-Jean Wilder CJA/224 August 23, 2010 Pros and Cons of Plea Bargains Throughout history those that have committed crimes against society have tried to make deals to obtain the charges against themselves reduced through bargaining with the prosecution before going to trial. The Constitution of the Unites States provides for the right to a speedy trial and a trial by a jury of one’s peers but with trial

Judge Interveiw Essay

899 words - 4 pages Today I will interview a judge on his role in major criminal cases from his role beginning with first contact dealing with a plea bargain. The reason I choose to focus on that of plea bargains is because based on the videos I viewed this is the first initial contact the defendant has with the judge and most of the most memorable parts of many criminal court cases. Q: Good afternoon, one thing that stands out to me is why do we have so many

Criminal Justice Essay

861 words - 4 pages Today I will interview a judge on his role in major criminal cases from his role beginning with first contact dealing with a plea bargain. The reason I choose to focus on that of plea bargains is because based on the videos I viewed this is the first initial contact the defendant has with the judge and most of the most memorable parts of many criminal court cases. Q: Good afternoon, one thing that stands out to me is why do we have so many

Plea Bargaining Essay 1165 Words

1165 words - 5 pages defendant is allowed to plead guilty to a lesser charge rather than risk conviction for a graver crime in order to avoid a protracted trial or to win the defendant’s cooperation as a witness (“Plea Bargaining”, 2014). Now a plea bargain can mean everything to nothing towards a case. The prosecution would use these types of bargains for leverage against the defendant. What is meant by this is that the defendant can be offered to give a testimony of