This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Performance Pay For Mgoa Physicians Essay

552 words - 3 pages

SHR 355 – Strategic Human Resource Management
Case Assignment Questions
Performance Pay for MGOA Physicians (A)

1. Using equity theory and expectancy theory, discuss the potential advantages of MGOA proposed pay-for-performance compensation system relative to the current base-pay compensation system (2x2=4 points).

The advantages for a pay-for-performance compensation system would lead to repeated positive performance. This is because the doctor’s pay would correlate directly with the number of surgeries they can perform in a given quarter. This compensation system would reduce the protection provided to low performers; the individual would be compensated based on their activity and not spread amongst the group.
The doctors knowing this would be motivated to work more efficiently instead of relying on the base ...view middle of the document...

2. MGOA has hired you as a consultant to get a second opinion on the proposed pay-for-performance compensation system before implementing it. Please address the following two issues:

a. Discuss TWO potential problems associated with MGOA’s proposed pay-for-performance compensation system. Be sure to justify your answers (3x2=6 points).

Although there are advantages to this form of compensation, pay-for-performance also has some downsides. Employee may become goal oriented to fulfill a requirement and develop single-mindedness. Doctors would be come caught up with the financial incentives that they begin taking shortcuts and try to speed up their procedure to meet their quota. This presents a great liability; doctors who overwork themselves tend to make more mistakes. Which could lead to potential lawsuits and more expenses to the firm. This would bring more harm then good if doctors become more careless with their procedures.
This leads up the other potential problem, the quality of the work the doctors put in. With a performance-based compensation, the expectation would shift form quality work to quantity of work. Doctors would have more of incentive to handle surgeries more quickly, which would result in poor judgment and increase of liabilities.

b. Recommend a solution to each of the problems you have identified. Be as specific as possible in your recommendations (3x2=6 points)

A solution to prevent single mindedness activity, I would propose that doctors are given a cap on the financial incentives and minimum amount of procedures that can be done. This would allow the doctors to just fulfill what are expected of them, without them feeling pressured of being more efficient. Also if a cap was placed those who do go beyond their expected workload will no longer be motivated to become more efficient since at some point the financial incentives would no longer be in place.

Other Papers Like Performance Pay for Mgoa Physicians

Pay for Performance in the Healthcare System

735 words - 3 pages Pay for performance essentially is pay is based off of performance (Mathis, p. 377). Pay and incentives are structured to compensate performance variances among employees; while exceptional performers will be rewarded with greater pay and rewards than employees with acceptable level (Mathis, p.377). Unfortunately, if employee’s performance is below standards than the employee may not receive any compensation, be placed on a performance

Mgoa Physicians Case Essay

2054 words - 9 pages Case Preparation Summary - Performance Pay for MGOA Physicians Short-Cycle Summary Who: Dr. Harry Rubash (chief of orthopaedics); Dr. James Herndon (chairman of Partners Orthopaedics); 12 MGOA surgeons; MGOA billing center employees What: Dr. Rubash needs to lead the process of improving the financial position and sustainability of MGOA by properly incentivizing the MGOA employees. Why: MGOA has been running annual deficits of several


1852 words - 8 pages to the forefront of policy agendas by the Institute of Medicine’s (IOM) report in 2000 titled To Err is Human (Mayes, 2006). In the report, the IOM estimated “as many as 98,000 patients die annually in U.S. hospitals due to preventable medical errors” (Mayes, 2006, p.17). Pay-for-performance is “a reimbursement method under which some physicians and hospitals are paid more than others for the same services because they have been deemed to

Reflect Paper

2601 words - 11 pages MODULE 1: CASE ANALYSIS – CPOE at EMORY HEALTHCARE ID: 59255426 The differences between the types of physicians Compared with the full-time and directly employed physicians in other settings at Emory, most physicians at EUHM were not directly employed. The positions in EUHM were more like “part-time contractors”. In addition to work for EUHM, these physicians also took jobs from other area hospitals. Many of them were already familiar

Steve Jobs

629 words - 3 pages with their jobs because some clinics receive more patients than others. I believe it’s better to pay physicians with an Hourly Standard Plan instead of them getting paid for every patient because it benefits both the physician and the clinic as well. 3 When it comes to linking incentive pay to individual performance in an organization, we could say it is fair for the employee and the organization but it depends on how well the organization

Case Study: Trust Issues Glaxo Smith

925 words - 4 pages deceive and defraud physicians, patients, regulators, and federal health care programs such as Medicare to prescribe and receive payment for drugs such as Paxil, Wellbutrin SR, and Advair. When we are children we are taught that doctors and nurses are supposed to make us feel better. They are the ones that make all the “boo boo’s” go away. But, what happens when someone puts their trust in a doctor, nurse, or medical professional and that trust is

Electronic Medical Records

1429 words - 6 pages employees have to go to, to remind them about the importance of following the organization’s policies. Another way for maintaining a skilled workforce is having great leaders who will motivate their employees to do their best. Anyone can be a leader but only certain people are born to be great leaders. If employees are not happy about their job, then they will most likely not do their job right. Pay for Performance When an employee performs their

Balanced Scorecard at St. Elsewhere Hospital

670 words - 3 pages Balanced Scorecard at St. Elsewhere Hospital 1. What is the Balanced Scorecard/What is its purpose? - The Balanced Scorecard provides a framework for strategic management by transforming a company’s strategic goals into an integrated collection of objectives and performance indicators. The performance indicators are grouped into four perspectives which include: Financial, Customer, Internal Business Process, and Learning & Growth

Retainer Medicine

1738 words - 7 pages The Argument for using Retainer Medicine as a Means of Improving Primary Care Huddle, M.D., PHD, Centor, M.D. (2011) “Retainer Medicine: An Ethically Legitimate Form of Practice That Can Improve Primary Care.” Annals of Internal Medicine, Volume 55, Number 9 In retainer practices, Primary Care Physicians (PCPs) contract with patients who are willing to pay a flat annual fee either for all primary care services or for services beyond those

Cottage to Control Panel

1023 words - 5 pages and Regulating Health Care in the United States  The Role of Joint Commission on Accreditation of Hospitals  Accreditation is required for Licensure  The Joint Commission Approach to Quality Assurance  Improving The Performance of Quality Improvement Teams My working title : Craftsman to Scientist : Working Through a Quality Transition. Working thesis : The manner in which physicians manage

Pay System

1087 words - 5 pages performance. Also, an important TDR related to this position is that of generating and monitoring one’s own sales ideas. The organization should provide individual bonuses to the employees who are proactive in generating different sales ideas for the firm. As this is a subjective offering by the employee rather than a physical output, again, the individual bonus incentive pay seems to be the most effective way to motivate employees in this field

Related Essays

Pay For Performance In Healthcare Essay

1031 words - 5 pages system upgrades in order for facilities to properly document and capture the quality measures. System upgrades and staff training will cost money. The cost benefits occur over time but will cost facilities money upfront if the systems are not equipped to document the quality benchmarks set forth by pay for performance Quality and Efficiency Setting parameters for what constitutes quality care can be a restrictive tool for physicians. Physicians

Reimbursement And Pay For Performance Essay

2113 words - 9 pages pay-for-performance plan supports the physician/patient relationship and emphasizes that physicians must use sound medical judgment. Physicians ethically must place the best interest of the patient as the foundation of services provided. The P4P plan shall not limit access to improvements in health care. The plan shall not indirectly or directly inhibit access to care based on ethnicity, culture, socio-economic status, medical condition, or affect

Pay For Performance, Financial Incentives, And Hr

977 words - 4 pages ways to accomplish this and one of those ways is by implementing the the resources and abilities of HR. Corporations are looking for new ways to improve employee performance as well as remain competitive. Pay for performance is one method some businesses are utilizing to improve employee performance. Performance-based compensation exists when compensation is tied directly to that portion of an individual’s performance that can be effectively

Pay For Performance Through Strategic Planning

3802 words - 16 pages Pay for Performance through Strategic Planning Introduction Because studies have shown time and again that pay represents one of the most important factors involved in retaining qualified employees, it is little wonder that there has been a great deal of attention focused on how best to compensate employees for their performance in recent years. Moreover, because employee performance and productivity is inextricably related to organizational