This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Pay For Play Essay

1229 words - 5 pages

When Johnny Manziel appeared recently on the cover of Time magazine -- striking his Heisman pose with six simple words, "It's Time To Pay College Athletes" sharing his space -- the most universally agreed, yet universally debated, issue in all of non-professional sports returned to the front of the national discussion.

Yet the beauty of the debate is once again lost because the foundation of the argument sits on a fault line. There is no system of payment that can be put in place that is fair across the board to all students, all sports and all schools that participate in college athletics.

At this point, the debate over whether college athletes should be paid really doesn't change ...view middle of the document...

Athletes know what they're signing up for when they decide to play for a school. John David Mercer/USA TODAY Sports
Is the business of college athletics unfair to the people who play the games? Sometimes, yes. Unless there's proof that colleges and universities are improperly using athletic revenues, where is the real problem?

Every student who signs a letter of intent or agrees to accept a scholarship to play a sport knows going in that the school's job is to make the most money off of his or her efforts. They agree to that. It's no different than a professional athlete signing a contract.

The success of the program while that student is there is not guaranteed. But if Texas A&M stands to make an estimated $72 million alone off of branded merchandise in one year (as reported in Time magazine) connected to the success of Manziel and the football program, why is that a problem? Manziel and his family knew and agreed to the rules of the game when they chose the Aggies as the program they wanted to use to put the child-prodigy in position to get paid once his college career is over?

We need to stop looking at college as it relates to athletics as an educational aperture and look at it for what it has become: a business platform. One where going in, the laborer knows that he or she will be under-compensated and one that greatly benefits ownership, but one that has the mandatory training program that all must go through in order to financially capitalize on their own talents.

The bottom line is that athlete's should not be paid a salary. They should get something more than what they are currently getting for making their school loads of money. But if you compensate student-athletes monetarily, how do you decide who gets paid? Is it by performance or position? How do you fix one disparity without creating another?

We need to stop looking for fairness in this because there is none and there never will be. There are very few businesses that are fair across the board to the people who work for them. The business of college sports isn't one of them.

I spoke with a retired financial manager who has had some dealings with the NCAA, and he shot down my theory of the answer to the "pay for play" dilemma in college athletics. I suggested: Just treat all students on scholarships the same, give them all the same...

Other Papers Like Pay for Play

Pay to Play in High School

3484 words - 14 pages passed a law that no school district will charge fees for extra-curricular activities. Stealth versions of pay-to-play exist at many high schools around the country. Sometimes they are clothed as transportation fees, equipment fees or donations. Some schools blanket their fees by asking students to donate $150.00 to their booster club, such as Lakeside High School in Atlanta. Therefore, it is a considered a donation, and not a fee. (Brady) 2

Social Development Essay

683 words - 3 pages . 341). The last form of play occurs at the age of four and is categorized as cooperative play. Taking turns and helping peers is a key point in this form of play. Children learn to push each other on the swing and take turns being the “mommy” or “daddy” while playing house (Gibson, J.T., 1978, p. 301). A teeter-totter is an excellent example of cooperative pay where two children are engaging in an activity that provides a need for

Research Paper Rwt

2134 words - 9 pages to give the best effort daily in the work environment. With a gain share or profit sharing model, as is typically the case in manufacturing organizations where team performance is a necessary driver just as much as individual performance, the added incentive pay can play a large factor in production for the organization. It is also attractive in maintaining key employees and attracting new employees to the company - possibly even obtaining top

Pay for Performance, Financial Incentives, and Hr

977 words - 4 pages well-designed incentive-pay plan can also help pull people together, help point them in the direction you want them to go, and give that extra push that every company needs in today's competitive environment. In today's workforce one of the best ways to achieve these systems is with Human Resource Managers (HR). They can be a linchpin between management and front-line employees, and HR can play a pivotal role in pay for performance settings

Paid To Play

961 words - 4 pages can be partying and having a marvelous life, and decide to take college class instead? Is there a way to entice the youth that going to college instead of going to be a professional athlete is actually worth it, yes! The proposed plan was for colleges to pay up to five thousand dollars a year for student athletes to play their respective sport (Strauss). Young adults today are faced with a lot of decisions in their young adult life. For athletes

Establishing Strategic Pay Plans

2959 words - 12 pages , commissions, and bonuses) and indirect financial payments (financial benefits like employer-paid insurance and vacations). Two basic ways to make direct financial payments to employees: 1. Time-based pay 2. Performance-based pay Legal Considerations in Compensation Various laws specify things like minimum wages, overtime rates, and benefits. For example: 1. 1931 Davis-Bacon Act allows the secretary of labor to set wage rates for

Working on the One

641 words - 3 pages herself with no man telling her what she needed to do. She was so powerful that she could just leave everything behind and start anew. Also the financial part come into the lay when Torvlad got the new job and Nora had her own debt to pay off because of her husband. Which one could see that it lead to her beginning empowerment because no women had debt because they could not take loans out. Well overall this play was very good and I would recommend it to many people to read just for the issues that are brought up because for its time it was very edgy and controversial. So in the end I give it an 8 out of 10.

Compensation And Benefit

1560 words - 7 pages an organization or above average. In cases and situations where the output produced or sales produced by an employee are hard or difficult to be empirically determined, performance pay is most applicable; for examples in the teaching profession. In cases of performance payment, individual performance is usually reviewed regularly through a process called performance appraisal. Performance appraisal helps in establishing and identifying if the

Pay for Performance Through Strategic Planning

3802 words - 16 pages Pay for Performance through Strategic Planning Introduction Because studies have shown time and again that pay represents one of the most important factors involved in retaining qualified employees, it is little wonder that there has been a great deal of attention focused on how best to compensate employees for their performance in recent years. Moreover, because employee performance and productivity is inextricably related to organizational

Why Do Women Earn Less Than Men

1828 words - 8 pages pay gap. The next section will concentrate on the measures that can be done to narrow the pay gap. Additionally, this essay will end with a discussion about the pay gap between women and men. First of all, women have undergone sexual discrimination in the workplace for many years. So the most important reason for the pay gap is the historical tradition. According to the Economist (2009)“a generation ago, working women performed menial jobs

College Athletes Should Be Paid

1764 words - 8 pages their classes due to the tournaments they participate in” (“NCAA”). College athletes should receive some type of pay for this because they are risking the quality of their education to play in these NCAA tournaments. Also, many colleges put their student athletes in these tournaments to bring revenue to the school. Yes, playing a sport for your school so it can earn money is great, however, student athletes should be receiving a fraction of the

Related Essays

Pay For Play Essay

1766 words - 8 pages It’s March Madness baby! This is the time of year hundreds of college basketball players take to the floor in hopes of winning a national championship. Millions of fans invest time, money and energy cheering for their favorite teams. Billions of dollars are made by the television and advertising industries, the food and beverage industries and the College and University “industry”. We watch these young men and women play their hearts out never

College Football And Pay For Play

2325 words - 10 pages | College Football and Pay for Play | | | | | | Introduction “The rising dollar value of the exploitation of athletes is obscene, is out of control.” -Roger Noll, Economics Professor Emeritus, Stanford The whole purpose in researching this topic was based on the fact that the researcher is a fan of college sports, football and basketball especially. As the researcher has grown into adulthood and come to

Pay To Play Essay

1170 words - 5 pages the best of both worlds of college. Free educations to play a game and special treatment on campus are some of the many reasons that experts are against paying student-athletes. I do not feel the same way. There is much more that goes in to practicing, playing and particapatating in sports at the collegiate level. Student-athletes should be compensated with some form of monetary payment for their efforts and all they sacfice on a day to day basis

Ncaa Football Pay To Play Essay

4655 words - 19 pages revenues each year, all without having to pay the people who actually play the game. Is it ethical for colleges to not pay their football stars for playing their hearts out on the field, building popular branding images for themselves and their school, and for the collective big-money earnings and prestige that often comes to their schools? Or is indirect payment to these players in the form of a free undergraduate education and college degree