This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Patient's Rights And Medical Care Essay

1505 words - 7 pages

Patient's Rights and Medical Care


In the face of the threat of euthanasia, does the patient have the right to the final word? What are his rights in the area of medical care? This essay will explore this question, and provide case histories to exemplify these rights in action.


For legally competent adult patients, regarding medical care per se - according to Anglo-American law -- every competent adult has the freedom to seek or not to seek medical care and to refuse to consent to any specific treatment proposed, under the common law right of bodily integrity and intangibility:


1. Competent adults may reject even lifesaving care under the right of bodily ...view middle of the document...

Therefore court-ordered life-saving treatment is not a subordination of patient choice. The court will usually order lifesaving or ordinary care, but treatment that is extraordinary is not required.


Regarding minor children, Prof. John A. Robertson, of the Wisconsin University Law School, stated:

"Under traditional principles of criminal law the omission of ordinary care by parents, physicians and nurses creates criminal liability. The crimes committed may include murder, involuntary manslaughter, conspiracy and child abuse or neglect. Generally a person is criminally liable for homicide by omission if: 1) He has a legal duty to protect another; 2) with knowledge or gross negligence he fails to act; 3) and such failure proximately causes the death of the other. The pervasive practice of withholding ordinary medical care from defective newborns demonstrates we have embarked on a widespread program of involuntary euthanasia." (Robertson)


Discussion of the following actual cases is concerned only with whether or not the decisions are legal or illegal and not with their moral implications; whether the cases involve ordinary care or extraordinary care, and whether the decisions given would be legal or illegal:

1. An infant is born with Down's syndrome, indicating probable mental retardation. He needs very low-risk surgery for an easily correctible intestinal defect. If untreated the baby will not be able to retain food and will die. The parents refuse surgery, stating that the mental retardation will mean a less than meaningful life for the baby.

Answer: This case involves ordinary care; illegal decision: Parents may not refuse ordinary care; the refusal of surgery would result in the proximate cause of death for the child they have a legal duty to protect. Courts, however, usually have ruled in favor of parents' refusal.

2. A seven-year-old girl, auto-accident victim with severe internal bleeding, needs an immediate blood transfusion to prevent death. Her parents refuse consent because blood transfusions are forbidden by their religion (Jehovah's Witnesses).

Answer: This case involves ordinary care; illegal decision: Parents may not invoke their right to free exercise of religion to refuse lifesaving care for their child, for that would be a violation of the child's unalienable right to life, which takes precedence over all other fundamental rights.

3. A baby is born with anencephaly (part or most of the brain matter absent), with a prognosis of living only a few weeks or months. A decision is made to withhold all nourishment by mouth or other means.

Answer: Ordinary care; illegal decision: Ordinary care is mandatory for all patients regardless of prognosis. However, in practice, many children like this are starved.

4. A 55-year-old man with severe circulatory problems has gangrene of the leg. Amputation is necessary to save his life. The man refuses consent.

Answer: Ordinary care - with qualifications....

Other Papers Like Patient's Rights and Medical Care

Hcr 230 Claims Process Essay

918 words - 4 pages numerous implications of unrestricted access to a patient's medical record. There is the most obvious, that a patient's information could be stolen. There is always the chance that someone requests information about you that is not authorized to have it, and a mistake is made and the information is given to them. Privacy Rights Clearinghouse states, “ Your medical information is shared by a wide range of people both in and out of the health care

Ethical Dilemmas Essay

969 words - 4 pages career is their patient's belief system. One example is the familiar dilemma of when a patient has a strong religious belief that interferes with sound evidence base medical practice. For example Jehovah Witnesses forbid blood transfusions under any circumstance. Even when it's the difference between life and death, the answer will always be no blood transfusion. Most knowledgeable and experience nurses will attempt to explain the necessity and

Aft2 Task 3

4479 words - 18 pages within its defined time frame. (See also RC.01.03.01, EP 3) | RC.01.03.01EP 3 | The hospital implements its policy requiring timely entry of information into the patient's medical record. (See also PC.01.02.03, EP 2) | PC.01.02.03EP 3 | Each patient is reassessed as necessary based on his or her plan for care or changes in his or her condition. Note: Reassessments may also be based on the patient's diagnosis; desire for care, treatment, and

End Of Life

1367 words - 6 pages under which living wills are valid and set forth the rights and obligations of patients and health care providers under the documents. See Choice in Dying, Refusal of Treatment Legislation (1991 & Supp.). The states without living will legislation are Massachusetts, Michigan, and New York. Ibid. (11) See In re Westchester County Medical Center (O'Connor), 72 N.Y.2d 517, 531, 534 N.Y.S.2d 886, 892 (1988).

Obna St-Ange

2360 words - 10 pages institution. A patient is not just reflected as someone who is under medical care or treatment but, also someone who is a client of any medical service. As a patient, an individual should be considered as a partner in your hospital care. With this being said, they have personal preferences and values that a medical establishment should encourage and respect. As a patient, one has certain privileges, patient rights, of which are basic rules of conduct

Excellence In Patient Care Depends Upon: The Application Of Sound Ethical Principles, Good Communication And The Understanding, Participation In And Utilisation Of Research Findings

2674 words - 11 pages communication with patients is essential and can help establish trust and co-operation to effective care and relationship of trust.Information relating to the procedure or a patients condition before, during, and following the procedure is required. This should be documented in the medical record and utilised by all members of the healthcare. Information such as who, what, where, when, how and why concerning the patient's care must be included. The


1347 words - 6 pages if that increases the likelihood that the patient will die. Thus, no one needs to be hooked up to machines against their will.Neither the law nor medical ethics requires that "everything be done" to keep a person alive. Insistence, against the patient's wishes, that death be postponed by every means available is contrary to law and practice. It is also cruel and inhumane.There comes a time when continued attempts to cure are not compassionate

Clinicals 1

667 words - 3 pages - INCORRECT Which of the following is one of the four basic concepts of medical ethics? Your Answer: Kindness Respect for patient autonomy Rationale:Respect for patient autonomy means that healthcare providers have a duty to protect the patient's ability to make informed decisions about his or her own medical care. Question 9 - INCORRECT Which of the following best meets the legal definition of sexual harassment under Title VII

Ana Code of Ethics

1247 words - 5 pages , whether an individual, family, group, or community. • 3. The nurse promotes, advocates for, and strives to protect the health, safety, and rights of the patient. • 4. The nurse is responsible and accountable for individual nursing practice and determines the appropriate delegation of tasks consistent with the nurse's obligation to provide optimum patient care. • 5. The nurse owes the same duties to self as to others, including the responsibility

Communication Opinion

925 words - 4 pages . The reason for effective communication between both the patients, and the doctors can mean the difference between life and death. Without the proper communication skills, the patient could receive the wrong diagnosis from the physician. When the patients communicate the medical history, the doctor will make his or her proper diagnosis of the patient condition. Effective communication is a must in health care delivery when lives are at stake

Applying Ethical Frameworks

832 words - 4 pages information. Find out exactly what and who you are dealing with, is it a power of attorney seeking medical rights? Is it a patient in an abusive situation? Step two and three: identify the type of ethical problem and the ethic approach to analyze it. Does the family member want medical information we legally cannot expose? Are adult protective services needed to be involved? Is it truly necessary for us as medical providers to divulge this

Related Essays

Explain The Concept Of Equality, Diversity And Rights In Relation To Health And Social Care

1790 words - 8 pages P1 – Explain the concepts of equality, diversity and rights in relation to health and social care It is said that every person is unique. We are born and raised in a particular culture, society and religion, have specific friends and family, go through particular life and work experiences, have our own thoughts and beliefs, live a specific lifestyle, enjoy particular food and this is what makes us individuals. We are diverse in many things

Understand Employment Responsibilities And Rights In Health, Social Care Or Children And Young People’s Settings

2719 words - 11 pages Unit 201 Understand employment responsibilities and rights in health, social care or children and young people’s settings Outcome 1: Know the statutory responsibilities and rights of employees and employers within own area of work * List the aspects of employment covered by law: * Minimum wage * Hours worked * Holiday entitlements and maternity leave * Redundancy and dismissal * Union rights and

Unit 2: Equality, Diversity And Right In Health And Social Care P1 Explain The Concepts Of Equality, Diversity And Rights In Relation To Health And Social Care

1786 words - 8 pages P1 Explain the concepts of equality, diversity and rights in relation to health and social care Abuse – This can be where any action can cause harm or injuries to another person. It is not all physical abuse there is mental abuse, sexual abuse, financial abuse, substance abuse, elder abuse and psychological abuse. Linking this to a health and social care setting someone who has a different religion or is a different coloured skin who works in a

Level 3, Unit 2: Equality, Diversity And Rights In Health And Social Care Understand How National Initiatives Promote Anti Discriminatory Practice

1002 words - 5 pages Assignment 4 Unit 2: Equality, Diversity and Rights in Health and Social Care Understand how national initiatives promote anti-discriminatory practice Conventions, Legislations and Regulations The Disability Discrimination Act is law that is in place to ensure that disabled people are treated fairly. The law also says that disabled people must not be discriminated against. The disability discrimination act reduces discrimination