This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Overtime Vs. Hiring Additional Employees Essay

1801 words - 8 pages

Overtime vs. Hiring Additional Employees
Emily L. Slaugenhoup
Butler County Community College

Today’s economy is certainly struggling. With hard times, many employers are faced with tough decisions on how to save money. One area to be considered is the number of employees, their salaries, benefits, and bonuses. A company can save money depending on whether they hire additional employees to cover shortages and additional work or by simply paying current employees overtime to get the work done. There are numerous pros and cons to both. However, there is not always a clear answer.
According to the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA), an employer must pay an employee overtime pay ...view middle of the document...

additional personnel in the case of the city of Riverside fire department. He found many issues associated with the dilemma including health risks, city budget issues, and department protocol. Ellen Perlman of Governing magazine stated that “overtime remains a key way of controlling staff levels to ride out revenue rollercoasters” (Perlman, 1997, p. 43). However, Earley concluded that overtime surpasses many firefighters’ salary, and this could lead to issues within the city if the firefighters become the highest paid employees. This could ultimately lead to budgeting problems when contract negotiation starts. (Earley, 2001, p. 11) Leeanna Mims, author of “Overtime Cost Reduction with Alternative Work schedules,” found that city officials are worried about an overabundance of overtime costs (Mims, 1999, p. 4). She discussed her city officials’ recommendation to switch the fire department’s schedule to twelve-hour shifts. Earley found other research that suggested ten-hour day shifts and fourteen-hour night shifts are overall more beneficial to the employees and the budget. Twenty-four-hour shifts leave firefighters fatigued and more accident-prone (Earley, 2001, p. 11). According to Mims, a twelve-hour shift reduced the cost of overtime and use of sick days and increased safety (Mims, 1999, p. 14).
Mr. Earley also included the findings of a few other researchers (Earley, 2001, p. 12). Robert Brown assessed the cost of hiring additional employees or paying overtime and found that it was 13.10% cheaper to pay overtime. He based the cost of hiring additional employees on their salary, benefits, and hiring costs (Brown, 1998, p. 9). Thomas J. O’Connell used his research to conclude that “limited and judicious use of overtime spending coupled with strategic planning, data analysis and readily retrievable information” provided the best use of finances (O'Connell, 2000, p. 30). John Selberg determined that finding the cost of variables, such as sick leave, injuries, holidays, incidents, training, unscheduled shortages, and other benefits is crucial in estimating overtime costs. In doing this, Selberg established a “breakeven point” in which the fire department should hire employees to a certain point then pay overtime for the rest. (Selberg, 1992, p. 9).
Looking at all angles of the issue, Earley found that overtime pay certainly has its disadvantages. After being used for so long, overtime can be hard to get rid of because it becomes standard routine. It also hurts employees physically and mentally after long hours, increasing the risk of incident. He even reported the findings of L. Glazner that showed “a correlation to firefighter work schedules and injuries with fatigue being associated with those injuries and mistakes of firefighters.” (Earley, 2001, p. 14) Earley had a hard time deciding the better of the two, overtime or additional personnel, after his research.
Steve Earley went on to compile his own cost research...

Other Papers Like Overtime vs. Hiring Additional Employees

Basic Rights of an Employee Essay

1206 words - 5 pages agreement * Not deduct money from your wages, without your agreement in writing * Provide a safe workplace for you to work in * Not discriminate against you. One of the main principles of the law on employment is called “good faith”. This means that employers, employees and unions must deal with one another honestly and openly. Minimum terms and conditions vs negotiable terms and conditions All employees, regardless of the type of work

Electroparts Manufacturing, Inc Essay

318 words - 2 pages impact of the new wage on the product cost and profit is important on their company’s product price. In that case their wages will increase from the minimum wages that will cost another expense in their company. They need an alternative solution. By hiring more qualified staff. Lessen overtime jobs and expenses caused by the overtime pay since there are more workers to finish the jobs. It will help EMI cope with the demands since they have more

Apple Make vs. Buy Decision

673 words - 3 pages Running Head: Apple’s Make-vs.-Buy Decision Apple’s Make-vs.-Buy Decision Apple’s best approach regarding hiring employees for their top technology or engineering positions would be private employment agencies. Since there is a huge secrecy that surrounds Apple’s

Rights for Part Time Employees

1253 words - 6 pages being treated less favourably to those full time employees for the company pension. But this treatment does not prevent the part time employee from entering an agreement with their employer allowing them to be able to apply for pension scheme. They are entitled to overtime, if a comparable full time employee exceeds their maximum hours and gets paid overtime. Employers can specify that part time employees can claim for overtime only if they have

Assignment 2

1571 words - 7 pages that are placed before them. Crime in other areas of the community is at six year low so, why do we need these officers? With the hiring of these new officers will the overtime pay for the existing officers decrease, stay the same or increase this is a factor because with the overtime pay there is more money being paid out to the existing officers making it very hard to finance the new officer’s packages. Another objection would be how are we

Employment Laws

928 words - 4 pages . | | |members in employment decisions. | | |Banned wage and job discrimination |Shultz vs. Wheaton Glass Co. |The Act was designed to promote |If similar jobs are being performed by| |Equal Pay Act |based on sex, race, and other | |fairness amongst employees than do |both a man and a woman, then pay

Hrmt386 Memo for Human Resources Planning

559 words - 3 pages overtime pay to redistribute tasks to our employees every time a position becomes open, adding additional work and stress to the workers. By not using temporary workers we’ll also save on training costs as these flex-time positions are permanent, meaning our training dollars stay within the organization. The amount we’ll save not sourcing temporary agencies to provide us with workers will be put directly toward the additional training these new

Riordian Manufacturing

525 words - 3 pages right amount of employees to avoid the tangible and intangible costs of hiring and laying off employees due to not needing them. This strategy allows the company to be able to focus in meeting the demand for the goods and not needing to provide overtime to its employees or have to invest additional money in training new employees. This strategy can have a drawback if Riordan has inaccurate forecasts causing having excessive inventory. Supply

Hra 545 – Case Assignment 7

535 words - 3 pages company officials where he may be reached is not working while on call. (Armour & Co. v. Wantock, 323 U.S. 126 (1944); Handler v.Thrasher,191 F. 2d 120 (C.A. 10, 1951); Walling v. Bank of Waynesboro, Georgia, 61 F. Supp. 384 (S.D. Ga. 1945)) (29 C.F.R. § 785.17) (2) § 778.100 The maximum-hours provisions. Section 7(a) of the Act deals with maximum hours and overtime compensation for employees who are within the general coverage of the Act and

Strategies Shortage & Surplus of Premier Bank of Bangladesh

543 words - 3 pages Current staff over time: In the shortage manpower cases, Premier Bank offers their employees to do overtime to finish the goal of the month. For this reason they offer high incentives to their employees. Hire temporary employees: To fulfill the goal of bank, Premier bank hire some temporary employees in different cases. But the rate of hire temporary employees is not so high. For the occasional cases they recruit those employees to perform some

Consulting Plan Memo

986 words - 4 pages TO: Marylee Luther, HR Director Clapton Commercial Construction FROM: Cindy Sanchez, Consultant Atwood and Allen Consulting DATE: March 17, 2014 SUBJECT: Compliance Planning Atwood and Allen Consulting (AAC) understand that Clapton Commercial Construction (CCC) have plans to expand their existing company of 650 employees located in Detroit, Michigan into the state of Arizona, adding 130 additional employees (20%). This consulting firm

Related Essays

Macdonald Refrigeraton Case Analysis

2144 words - 9 pages needed for the month without having any excess inventory * Provides continuity and avoids the tangible and emotional costs of the hiring and firing process Weaknesses: * Excessive overtime might lead to employee exhaustion in the high demand months * Idles workers during slow months even though they continue to receive full pay * During slow months employees might become bored, which could lead to high turnover and/or a decline in

Employee Rights Essay

1066 words - 5 pages filing a legal case for overtime pay violations. If the courts find that employer has done this they can suffer criminal and civil consequences. In both circumstances, employees can also sue for additional damages, plus reimbursement for court costs and attorney's fees (Department of Labor 2004). A employer does not have the right to adjust the overtime laws. Employer can not by law have a no overtime pay policy to avoid paying overtime or

Mandatory Over Time For Nurses Essay

3499 words - 14 pages such as, unit types, work shifts, number of patients, frequency of patient census fluctuation, nurse’s hourly wage, the occurrence of nursing shortages in their respective nursing units and their hiring practices. She further adapted five questions from an existing British Workplace Employee Relations Survey (1998) and found that the “top two reasons for working overtime among nurses were (a) not to let down their co-workers (68%) and (b) because

Employer’s Duty Of Care Essay

933 words - 4 pages movements and awkward postures that Jake probably would have had to perform in order to change the oil for so many vehicles in one day. Per the video footage, there were over 20 cars lined up for service and he was expected to fulfill this task in one day. Explain whether or not Jake should be paid the overtime. Jake should not be paid for his overtime worked. “Numerous exemptions exist which remove certain types of employees from specified