This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Outline And Evaluate Research Into Obedience

598 words - 3 pages

Outline and evaluate research into obedience to authority
(12 marks)

Milgram recruited 40 male participants who were volunteers to take part in a study that supposedly focused on how the role of punishment affects learning. The participants were paid $4.50 and told that they would receive this even if they quit during the study. The procedure involved the real participant in addition to two confederates; the experimenter (who posed as an authority figure) and a 47 year old accountant who played the part of the 'learner.' The teacher was told that he must administer increasingly strong electric shocks to the learner each time he got a question wrong on the learning task. The machine was tested on the learner to show him that it worked. The learner sat in another room, gave mainly wrong answers and received his fake shocks in silence until they reached 300 ...view middle of the document...

5%) stopped at that point, the point when the learner first objected. These findings demonstrate that ordinary people are surprisingly very obedient to authority, even when asked to behave in an inhumane manner. This suggested that it is not evil people who commit atrocities on a mass scale but decent and ordinary people who are just obeying orders. The experiment highlighted the underlying cause to why millions of Jews were massacred at Jewish concentration camps in Auschwitz in Germany.

Milgram deceived his participants by telling them that they were involved in a study of the effects of punishment on learning, rather than telling them the true purpose of the experiment. Although he argued that the experiment would have been meaningless without some degree of deception, which meant the participants had to be denied the right to informed consent. Despite this, many of the participants subsequently felt that had learned something which was of personal importance as a result of their participation. In Milgram's study it was not clear to what extent participants knew they were free to leave at any time, as demonstrated by the fact that they had the right to withdraw. Baumrind (1964) attacked Milgram's study claiming he placed his participants under great emotional strain, causing psychological damage to them that could not be justified. In addition Darley (1992) proposed a chilling effect of participation in Milgram's study. He suggests that the experience of administering shocks (even though they were not real) may activate a previously dormant aspect of an individual's personality such that they feel more able and more motivated to repeat the actions. According to Orne & Holland (1968) there is doubt about the internal validity of Milgram's research, e.g. despite the fact that the learner cries out in pain, the experimenter remains cool and distant. Leading the participants to suppose that the victim cannot really be suffering any real harm- and this who so many of them were ready to administer all the shocks.

Other Papers Like Outline and Evaluate Research Into Obedience

Outline And Evaluate Research Into The Effects On Stress In The Immune System

722 words - 3 pages Outline and Evaluate research into the effects on Stress in the Immune System (12 marks) Stress is an environmental event or situation (a stressor), which can induce a stress response in us. When someone is experiencing a stressful situation, all the body's resources are diverted and this suppresses the immune system because of the high levels of stress hormones, corticosteroids, which shrink the thymus glands preventing the growth of T

Outline and Evaluate the Working Memory Model

539 words - 3 pages Outline and evaluate the working memory model In the working memory model, there are four main components; The central executive is the most important component as it is involved in problem solving and decision making. It controls attention and plays a vast part in planning and processing information from subsidiary systems and LTM. It is flexible and can process information. It has a limited capacity and can only contain a limited amount of

Outline and Evaluate the Relationship Between the Workplace and Stress

777 words - 4 pages Outline and Evaluate the relationship between the workplace and stress Many people believe work affects their health. Defining what is stressful in the workplace is not easy, because individuals react quite differently to the same situation. However, some common factors have been found in many workers that cause them stress and in some cases lead to illness. These include the level of control they have (low control = stress), the amount of

Outline and Evaluate the Multi Store Model of Memory

531 words - 3 pages Outline and evaluate the multi store model of memory (12 marks) Information from the environment is transferred through one of our five senses into the sensory memory (encoded depending on the type of information we receive). The sensory memory is a store suggested to be large in capacity but the duration the information is held for is the problem, lasting only fractions of a second. When attention is paid to information it enters the short

Outline And Evaluate Realist Approaches To Crime (50 Marks)

1350 words - 6 pages Outline and evaluate realist approaches to crime (50 marks) Right realism sees crime as a growing problem that destroys communities, undermines social cohesion and threatens society’s work ethic. Right realists take a harsh approach in the fact that they try to reduce crime by reinforcing control and punishment, rather than trying to rehabilitate offenders when they leave prison. They see prisoners as a lost cause therefore they do not wish

Outline and Evaluate the Behavioural Approach to Psychopathology

619 words - 3 pages Outline and Evaluate the Behavioural Approach to Psychopathology The behaviourist approach assumes that all behaviours are learnt. It suggests that there are three ways in which this learning can happen, these are classical conditioning, operant conditioning and social learning. The first method is classical conditioning this is when behaviour is learnt through association; via a stimulus and a response. This is an explanation for phobias, an

Outline And Evaluate The Role Of Genes And Hormones In Gender Development (24 Marks)

540 words - 3 pages Outline and evaluate the role of genes and hormones in gender development (24 marks). The biological approach of gender development believes that an individual’s gender is decided at the same time that their sex is decided. An individual’s gender is influenced by their chromosomes and hormones. The pair of sex chromosomes dictates whether the foetus will be male or female. The female chromosome pair is XX and the male chromosome pair is XY

Outline and Evaluate One or More Explanations of Why People Obey

719 words - 3 pages legitimate authority of the experimenter and so were less prepared to obey his orders. A limitation of using Milner’s results is that his research may be culturally or historically biased. Some critics say that the results show more about the historical and cultural climate of the USA at the time -when McCarthyism was at large and people feared being accused of being communist spies- than fundamental psychological principles. The study was

Outline and Evaluate the Evolutionary Theory of Sleep (8+16 Marks)

1147 words - 5 pages The basis of the evolutionary theory is that animals sleep because it serves some adaptive function. The notion of the adaptive nature of sleep comes from the theory of evolution. The idea is that any behaviour that has continued into an animal’s gene pool must have been naturally selected because it has, in some way, aided the survival and reproduction of the animal that possesses that characteristic. One explanation of sleep that the

Outline and Evaluate the View That the Family Diversity Has a Positive Impact on Society (33 Marks)

990 words - 4 pages society and people who are born into traditional families have more stable personalities & closer identification with each other, therefore diversity & choice may not be such a good alternative for society. Therefore, we have family diversity because people are no longer willing to participate in traditional family life. Evaluation of Study 3 However, Functionalists Murdock (1949) would argue against family diversity as they believe in the

Outline the Particular Strengths and Weaknesses of Research Questionnaires, Panel Studies, Lab Experiments, and Field Experiments

721 words - 3 pages bottom line is that there is no final conclusion as of yet but there is preliminary data that should not be ignored. The first type of study we will look at is the research questionnaire or survey. A questionnaire is basically a series of questions designed to gather data from the people who participate. The advantages of questionnaires are that they are inexpensive, do not require much effort from the questioner, and often have standardized

Related Essays

Outline And Evaluate Research Into Conformity

435 words - 2 pages Outline and evaluate research into conformity: (12 marks) Asch carried out a key study in the field of conformity in 1951, looking at whether people will conform to the group and give an incorrect answer to a simple question. Asch used 50 male college students overall, and in each group there were 7 students - one oblivious participant, and 6 confederates of the experimenter. Asch showed each group a series of cards in pairs - one card had a

Outline And Evaluate Research Into Cross Cultural Variations In Attachment

829 words - 4 pages Outline and evaluate research into cross cultural variations in attachment. There are three main experiments that deal with the hypothesis of cross cultural variations in attachment by using the basis of the Strange Situation test. Van Ijzendoorn & Kroonenberg (1988) these two men created a meta-analysis which is where they collect already completed experiments and compare them too each other on a specific topic. This allows researchers to

Outline And Evaluate Research Into The Affect Of Anxiety On The Accuracy Of Eye Witness Testimony

1038 words - 5 pages Outline and Evaluate Research Into the Affect of Anxiety On the Accuracy of Eye Witness Testimony (6+6) Eyewitness Testimony refers to witnesses who are asked to give testimonies in court or police interviews to particular crimes. Eyewitness Testimony consists of : the eyewitness encoding the information they have witnessed the very second it happened, making sure they are describing the order of the events and the people involved. It also

Outline & Evaluate Research Into The Relationship Between The Immune System And Stress Related Illness

642 words - 3 pages Outline & evaluate research into the relationship between the immune system and stress-related illness (12) AO1 - COHEN ET AL investigated the role of general life stress on vulnerability to the common cold virus. 394 participants completed questionnaires on the number of stressful life events experience in the previous year. They also rated their degree of stress and level of negative emotions such as depression. The 3 scores were