This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Out Of Necessity: The Compared And Contrasted Views Of Two Marital Relationships

782 words - 4 pages

Danika White
Donald Stanley
ENGL 1001
Assignment 3
February 26 2014

Out of Necessity: The Compared and Contrasted Views of Two Marital Relationships.
D.H Lawrence’s short story, “The Horse Dealers Daughter”, can be compared, as well as contrasted, to Ernest Hemmingway’s short story, “Hills like White Elephants”. Both of these stories have marital themes incorporated in, and present many similarities and differences. One striking comparison found within both is the implied marital necessity between the characters involved. The contrasted settings, both physical and emotional, in these short stories are also quite noticeable.
Lawrence’s character, Miss Mabel Pervin shows a ...view middle of the document...

(p.845). Therefore, we can conclude that the proposed marriage between Mabel Pervin and Jack Ferguson was initiated out of necessity, as opposed to romantic attachment.
Hemmingway’s, “Hills like White Elephants”, also carries the theme of marriage out necessity, as shown by his characters, the American and his companion, Jig. Throughout the story, the American persistently tries to convince Jig that an abortion is a simple and worthwhile operation. Although claiming he loves her, the American portrays that he is not ready to give up his carefree lifestyle, “That’s the only thing that bothers us. It’s the only thing that’s made us unhappy”. (p.663). However, Jig is unconvinced and verbally fights against the decision. Ultimately, she has two options: terminate the pregnancy as he wants, or go through with it and displease him. It would seem that if she disregards his wishes and keeps the child, a necessary marriage might become the result. The American would be responsible for supporting his child financially; and if he were as devoted to Jig as he claimed, marrying her would be the obvious answer. Unfortunately, the story ends without indication of what the couple decides. A safe assumption would be that if the result were marriage, it would have been out of necessity.
The two settings of these stories show great contrast, in both physically and emotionally. Emotionally, Mabel Pervin portrays a proud woman; it is not until the end that she reveals her...

Other Papers Like Out Of Necessity: The Compared And Contrasted Views Of Two Marital Relationships

The Necessity of Projects Essay

1391 words - 6 pages Introduction As a project manager, it is important to understand change in the organization that you are working within. The necessity of projects as vehicles to accomplish an organization’s strategic goals is imperative to an organization and a project manager. A project manager must also understand the evolving changes in the world and how they can affect the way a project is managed, what change will allow for improvement, and what

Familial And Marital Relationships In Beowulf

900 words - 4 pages Familial and Marital Relationships in Beowulf   Two Works Cited    To the reader of Old English Beowulf the familial and marital relationships are not so very obvious, especially when one is concentrating all of one’s mental energies on translating the thousand-year-old vocabulary of the poem. The following essay is intended to clarify those relationships while proceeding sequentially through the poem.   First

The Conflicting Views Of David And Daud

630 words - 3 pages The Conflicting Views of David and Daud The two views of these to two men, David and Daud expressed different beliefs. One (David), is a Jewish Israeli. The other man, Daud, is a very upset Palestinian Arab. Throughout the discussion they both are bringing up each of the countries faults and seeing if any of these points can maybe be resolved. It seems however as though, for right now they failed. I personally have to side with the

Theme Of Justice And Revenge Compared To The Odyseey

525 words - 3 pages Final Writing Assignment The theme of justice and revenge is played out in 3 stories that we have read through out the course of the year. First we have The Odyssey, in the story Odysseus the main character seeks out revenge and justice on the people that are trying to take over his family. The suitors of his home are taking his food, drinking his wine, and now they want to take control of his wife and son. But Odysseus will not let this happen

The Necessity of Alternative Dispute Resolution

596 words - 3 pages . (ADR) Page 1 Alternative Dispute Resolutions are frequently a necessity in any work environment where two or more associates are involved in an endeavor or project. There are a number of opportunities to support the need for alternative dispute resolutions that do not require a lawyer or courts and are being more readily used in some larger corporations. If a dispute can be

The Lack Of Usage And Necessity Of The Aristotelian Unities In Richard III

2152 words - 9 pages attributed to Aristotle, in actuality, Aristotle largely emphasized only the unity of action, providing mere suggestions as to time and place. The other two unities, in turn, were built upon by three Italian critics in the mid- to late-sixteenth century: Giraldi Cinthio, Vincenzo Maggi, and Lodovico Castelvetro (Frye 329). Between 1540 and 1545, Cinthio proposed limiting a drama to a single day, and in 1550, Maggi “recognized that a twenty-four

Out of the Ordinary

561 words - 3 pages get you in big trouble. And in addition to the actual laws in place, there are technological advances that now allow parents to install driver cams that show them in real time exactly what you’re doing while you’re driving. This could get you in even bigger trouble. So, teens, as you prepare to get out on the roads, let your biggest worry be whether you’ll pass your driving test, not whether you’ll end up in an accident due to texting and driving. Let it wait. Pull over. Or just put your phone out of reach until you get where you’re going. When you respond to your BFF’s text of “where r u?”, you don’t want your answer to be “in an ambulance.”

The Necessity Of Censorship And How It Applies To "The Catcher In The Rye"

588 words - 3 pages very moment we feel a sudden gust of rage or anger erupting from within us. A certain rage or anger that forces out a question, which unfolds a series of other questions. Why was this movie or book censored? Who carried out the act of censoring? How did this person or group of persons know what to censor? Why don't they let me decide what is good for me and what isn't? The very thought of censorship disturbs us because we feel that our freedom is

Compare a Necessity and Commodity Product, Identifying the Availability of Sbstitutions for Coffe

758 words - 4 pages How People Make Economic Decisions Juan D. Agramonte ECO/212 Principles of Economics August 4, 2010 Instructor: Robert Waremburg How People Make Economic Decisions Marginal costs and benefits are two important concepts that govern economics. Marginal cost is important in determining the need to adjust the rate of production. Whereas, marginal benefits are considered as the gain that will be earned if the rate of production will be

Power of Love and Relationships

1262 words - 6 pages differently and the factor of attraction is not present. “The need to belong has two components: (a) the need for frequent positive contact with others, and (b) the need for enduring connections marked by mutual concern for the welfare of the other” (Feenstra, 2013). People readily form relationships with others without being paid or forced to do so, and do so even under adverse circumstances. For example, infants and children will form attachments to

Hamlet And Char. Horatio The Man Of Thought Compared To Fortinbras A Man Of Action

957 words - 4 pages quest to revenge his father's murder.Through out the whole play Hamlet, there are two kinds of men. Horatiois a man of thought who rarely acts, but is effective and has a has a place insociety as a man of thought. The man of action is Fortinbras who, unlikeHoratio, acts without thinking as to the consequences of his actions. The maincharacter of the play, Hamlet, was a man of both thought and action. Hamletwas a failure because he was both. In the play Hamlet, it is shown that it isokay to be a man of thought or a man of action, but to be both iscounterproductive.

Related Essays

Marital Destruction Out Of Dysfunctional Marriage And Othello’s Characters

1930 words - 8 pages Course: College English 2 Date: 12/4/12 Marital destruction out of dysfunctional marriage and Othello’s characters William Shakespeare is(1564-1616) widely regarded as the greatest writer in the history of English literature and the most pre-eminent dramatist around the world. Among all his works, many literary critics regard Othello as the peak of his tragedies. Othello is not only a tragedy of family, but also a tragedy of love. Jealous

The Effects Of Marital Stress Essay

1227 words - 5 pages The Effects of Marital StressStress is on everyone's mind. It is not just on the mind, but the body as well. What causes stress? Stress comes from many different sources. Whether it comes from the workplace or home life, it can lead to many other serious problems. Marriages, and our bodies, can be severely affected by stress.Stress can devastate a marriage and lead to severe complications, such as health issues. Many things happen inside the

The Value And Necessity Of Public Relations

1790 words - 8 pages the company is up to and how things are running. Customers can always find out if the company is planning to launch a new product or thinking of innovations on already made products. Additionally, customers can find out about events revolving around a certain product. Therefore, the customer can attend the events that are supporting a charity or a product. Likewise, Public Relations promotes brand image by holding events and plastering the brand

Necessity Of The Scriptures Essay

1818 words - 8 pages God’s incomprehensibility and the need of communication between God and Man are the main reasons for the necessity of the Scriptures. The inmate behavior of the fallen man to distort an oral comprehension of the divine truth required a written revelation to teach the human generations about the complexities of the sacred Word of God. The Holy Bible is the way God made a Statement to Man about his fallen state and the Way of Redemption from that