Organ Donation Essay

1285 words - 6 pages

Pro’s and con’s of organ donation
-Theis

TEXT 1: We must change the organ donation system – An article written by Denis Campbell, published in The Guardian News.
The narrator Denis Campbell stays very neutral to the issue throughout the whole article and he only seems interested in knowing other peoples opinion. As a result of such he interviewed two different persons and had their opinion on the matter.
Sir Liam Donaldson, the chief medical officer in England – States that he wants the current system switched in the UK. He, among many people in the UK thinks change is overdue. The current system for organ donation in the UK have an opt-in system that only allows retrieving of organs ...view middle of the document...

Truog, published in The New England Journal of Medicine.
Robert D. Truog is unlike Denis Campbell giving the reader his own personal opinion on organ donation. He believes that there are three categories of organ donation and each of them carries along ethical concerns which, in his opinion, make organ donation most wrong. He lists the three categories as this: 1. directed donation to a loved one or friend, 2. non-directed donation, in which the donor gives an organ to the general pool to be transplanted into the recipient at the top of the waiting list, 3. directed donation to a stranger, whereby donors choose to give a specific person with whom they have no prior emotional connection.
He claims that the first category leads to intense pressure on the donor. As an example he explains how a donor who is very closely connected to the receiver can feel coerced to donate their organs even though they don’t want to because they feel a pressure from their conscience or their family. That pressure might lead the donor to find some sort of medical excuse so that he/her can escape the unpleasant situation. The problem of that situation is when the donor afterwards feels the conscience tear him/her apart.
He explains how the second category can affect people to do things that are mostly unneeded and stupid. He gives an example where a man was obsessed by the idea of donating everything, from money to organs, to a random stranger. That idea would by many be considered heroic but when the incident makes the donor wondering how he can donate all of his organs in a dramatic suicide it seems questionable… The donor’s motivations of donating organs can also be questioned. Is the donator really into helping another person or is the donor actually just trying to get attention through the media? Compensate for his/hers own low self-esteem? Or is the donor even hoping of becoming involved in the receivers life after the donation? A lot of questions that’s questioning the very meaning of organ donation, to give life to another human.
The third category deals with the ethics of organ donation as an actually good deed from one human to another or a simple and greedy way of getting money. An organ is very expensive and Robert D. Truog questions the donor’s motive of donating organs. He describes organ donation as a “gift of life” and not some common commodity and he’s therefore terrified to see that the whole transplantation community is changing into some kind of market where people are dealing with organs.
The most ethically...

Other Papers Like Organ Donation

Organ Donation & Obesity Essay

634 words - 3 pages looking for a profit so even though they know it is not good for consumers to provide unhealthy fat food, it will continue to occur when the profit is there. Organ Donation Article 1. What does a "nudge" in the right direction for organ donation mean? It means to have more and more people apply to be an organ donor. Having ads like the Illinois donation ad is a good way to nudge the public in the right direction. People do what other

Organ Donation Shortage- Problem-Solution Essay

2623 words - 11 pages Organ donation shortage Organ donation shortage When receiving a driver’s license in the United States, there is a section on the back in which it asks if the licensed driver would like to become an organ donor. Most people overlook this option. Nothing is really pushed forth for people wanting to become organ donors. Today in the U.S, thousands of people need organ transplants. Unfortunately, there is a growing shortage of donated organs

The Case Of Paying For Organ Donation

616 words - 3 pages Outline Critical Analysis The Case of Paying for Organ Donation Opening summary Article’s purpose and thesis: Dr. Sally Satel is a psychiatrist and professor at Yale University. Dr. Satel’s essay on “The Case of Paying for Organ Donors,” shows how there is a shortage of organ donors in society. Dr. Satel, suggests that financial and other incentives should be introduced to raise more transplant organs. In The Case for

The Principal of Family Determination in Organ Donation

4064 words - 17 pages PART A: The Principal of family determination in organ donation ABSTRACT: This article is written by Mingxu wang,, Wen zang, Xueliang Wang. In this article the point which is stressed upon is that wether family should be given the right to give consent for organ donation of a person if he himself has not stated any statement regarding his will on organ donation. Many ethical views of different societies are discussed

The Current Organ Donation System Is Not Working

651 words - 3 pages 2009 TEST PAPER 1. A `word' is made by writing the seven letters used to spell `EXAMPLE' in some order. Find how many different `words' are possible in each of the following cases. i. The first letter and the last letter are each “E”. [1] ii. The two letters “E” are next to each other. [1] iii. The two letters “E” are not next to each other. [2] 2. Janet and John wanted to compare their daily journey times to work

Engl 123 - Reflective Writing Assignment

970 words - 4 pages number is up. This has increasingly problematic for those in need. Background information “Organ donation is the process of giving an organ or a part of an organ for the purpose of transplantation into another person.” [ (Organ Donation) ] To become an organ donor, one must be listed as an organ donor prior to the catastrophic event. Before an organ donation can take place, circumstantial events must take place. The donor must die from a

Flour for Your Grave

1020 words - 5 pages Organ donation 1. Write a summary of “I am donating my kidney to a stranger” (text 3) in about 150 words. The text main character is Paula MacKinnon and lives in Scotland. The text is about MacKinnon and how she had donated a kidney to a stranger, which is called altruistic. Her parents and her friends think that she is being foolish and they are worried about her. She knows that it is just because they care about her and that’s why they

Donnor Speach

869 words - 4 pages Topic: Organ Donation Specific Purpose: To persuade my audience to donate their organs and tissues when they die and to act upon their decision to donate. Thesis Statement: The need is constantly growing for organ donors and it is very simple to be an organ donor when you die.   I.  INTRODUCTION A.  Attention material/Credibility Material: Do you ever feel like you have no power? Like things are going to happen the way they happen and you

Organ Shortage: to Market or Not to Market

1925 words - 8 pages out of donation and transplantation of organs. Currently, people who choose to donate do so because they sincerely want to help others. There is nothing encouraging them to make a decision other than the one they consistently feel is the right choice. Introducing financial gain in order to increase organ donation, both from living and non-living donors, would blemish the do-gooder view of those who donate an organ. Is saving reputation really a

The Price Is Right

1151 words - 5 pages transplant organs in the United States is accredited to many reasons: the unwillingness of families to approve donation after the donors death, even if the patient has wished to do so; religious objections; disinclination of medical personnel to approach families after the death; and the crookedness of the medical system. The need for organs far exceeds the number of donated organs, the dilemma becomes apparent: Should Organ Donors &/or Their

Artificial Organs

985 words - 4 pages . Although the likely hood that the patient will die before receiving a human donation. Another con of artificial organ is the all to common joint replacement surgery. Joint replacement is an elective procedure with many risks and complications. Some of the complications are blood clots, pain, medications after the surgery, recovery time, and anesthesia. After surgery (depending) on the patients age there is no benefit to having let’s say for

Related Essays

Organ Donation Essay

1258 words - 6 pages Topic: Organ donation Thesis Statement: Becoming an organ donor after death is not only an important decision for yourself, but it is also an important decision for the life that you may have the power to save. Specific Purpose: To persuade my audience to consider becoming organ donors after death.   Introduction: Almost everyone would want to be able to say “I have saved a life.” But by becoming an organ donor, you can be able to say “I

Organ Donation Essay

835 words - 4 pages Organ Donation 1. ”I’m donating my kidney to a stranger” is an article written by journalist Richard Wilson in 2008. The article is about Paula MacKinnon, who is thought to be the first altruistic organ donor in Scotland. Paula’s mother, Katherine, suffered kidney failure in 2007, and Paula wanted to donate her kidney to her mother. However their blood groups weren’t compatible, so Paula decided to donate her kidney anyway, to whoever might

Organ Donation Essay

1000 words - 4 pages Organ Donation 1 ORGAN DONATION: A QUESTION OF LIFE OR DEATH (not all caps) A paper Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for NU 307 Psychosocial Concepts in Nursing in the College of Nursing and Health Sciences, Jacksonville State University JACKSONVILLE, ALABAMA 2008 Organ Donation 2 Organ Donation: A Question of Life or Death Organ donation is a rather controversial issue and should be

Organ Donation Essay 1942 Words

1942 words - 8 pages Upon receiving a new drivers license in the United States, there is a section in the paper work, which asks if the licensed driver would like to become an organ donor. Most individuals skim past this option as there is little information regarding the positive aspects of organ donation presented to the new driver. Today in the United States, there are thousands of people waiting for organ donations and unfortunately there is a shortage on