Order Vs. Freedom In Political Systems

2009 words - 9 pages

Order vs. Freedom in Political Systems

Order and freedom are both necessary and beneficial towards the citizens and society with the aim to promote harmony, yet they both contradict each other. This contradiction has existed throughout many years and it is still hard to decide which one is ideal for the society. This essay will discuss and analyze if order or freedom is more important for political systems.

Many believe that order should be applied by the government; though it should be allowed to a certain limit and should not interfere in a citizen’s personal life. However others believe that full freedom should be given to individuals and that nothing should be enforced as it brings ...view middle of the document...

Therefore, he believed that to enforce order and ensure the equality of citizens, the use of power and violence can be necessary at times:

“Freedom can, he said, be restored either gradually or by violence ... by violence, when the change is made all at once and the opponents of democracy are ruthlessly cut down” (Plamenatz, 1963, p.39)

Hence this shows that Machiavelli was a strong believer of imposing order amongst citizens to assure the harmony within society. Additionally, Machiavelli rejected the idea of natural law; he criticized Rousseau and alleged that if humans were given complete freedom, then there would be a lot of contradiction amongst each other which will lead to an unequal society (Plamenatz, 1963, p.4). However, people have criticized Machiavelli’s approach and said that bringing cruelty and violence into society to enforce order is exceedingly controlling citizens and this behaviour cannot be justified in any way (Plamenatz, 1963, p.36). Conversely, supporters of this policy say that enforcing strict rules with the consequences of violence in certain situations could help improve societies and promote equality as people would think thoroughly before committing crime.

Another philosopher who supported the idea of order in society was Plato. Plato had very distinct views from other philosophers; he believed that in order to have equality and justice within society, only kings and philosophers should rule the government and make political decisions. Plato alleged that only educated citizens of the society should rule the government because they would be able to make better decisions than those who are uneducated or who are unaware of any politics. Plato highly apposed democracy and freedom; he criticized Athenian democracy by saying that it was unsuccessful to defend the expert roles required for Justice and it was only based on what the individuals wanted. However, critics argued that no one can distinguish which philosopher or citizen is more educated and knowledgeable than others, therefore it is wrong to say that only certain individuals can be rulers. Furthermore, it is also been questioned that how can educated men criticize and undervalue those who have been a victim of poverty or harsh upbringing which has affected their education when it is truly not their fault. Furthermore critics have argued on how it can be determined that kings and philosophers are not ruling in their self interest and in which way their power should be tested.
Furthermore, another aspect which has been greatly supported and criticized by many great philosophers is freedom. Freedom is where there is no power or control over the citizen’s decisions. Every citizen is entitled to free speech and their right to interfere in political decision making. Additionally, the Athenian democracy ideology supports the freedom theory. The main aim of this democratic thinking was to give the power to the majority rather than the minority as this would...

Other Papers Like Order Vs. Freedom In Political Systems

Notes for CRJ Essay

1324 words - 6 pages crime Young residents of lower-income communities  likely to be victimized by a crime Higher crime areas without being able to afford home security systems. More likely to travel to & from work in the evening Race & social status in the U.S. – African Americans are more frequently victimized by crime than are whites Women – crimes against women usually committed by acquaintances or relatives of victims MOST – teenaged African Americans

Socialism Vs. Capitalism Essay

2335 words - 10 pages across the world; Hong Kong, Singapore, Australia, Switzerland, and New Zealand, in order, are the five freest political systems in the world(Heritage House). On the opposite side of the economic spectrum is a centrally planned economy. In a planned economy industry is owned and managed by the government. The government controls what is brought to market and what price the commodity or service will be sold for. The theory of supply & demand does

Stage Theories of Development

758 words - 4 pages In Developmental Psychology, stages are a series of abrupt changes from one period to another. Through these stages all children must pass in the same order. Some of the most famous developmental stage theories are: Piaget’s theory of cognitive development, Kohlberg’s Stages of moral development and Erikson’s stages of psychosocial development. Piaget’s theory of cognitive development Piaget justified four stages of cognitive development

Introduction to English and American Literature

2051 words - 9 pages , cultural identity, colonialism  political criticism: historical reality – literary representation  cultural studies: literature as one sign system among others cultural systems 2. Poetry Shakespearean/ English sonnet consists of 14 lines divided into 3 quatrains and 1 heroic couplet written in iambic pentameter usual rhyme scheme: abab alterante rhyme turn in argument in line 13 The Petrachan/ Italian sonnet Metrical feet xI iamb Ix

Annotated Bibliography

1672 words - 7 pages order of academic studies; International education; where teachers will review materials and compare them to how those the system runs other countries, comparative education: where the masters would have to select two systems and comparer their differences and similarities, by utilmo the history of education; where is confirmed as the present education system was started or formed. Brickman believe in academic freedom (page 26. 2) cfomparative

Why Must It Hurt

1493 words - 6 pages Chapter 12: Power Violence, & Crime Thomas Hobbes’ theory on state? Believed that society must establish a powerful “Leviathan”—the state –in order to curb the savage instincts of human beings. Negative view of human nature. A nature that must be controlled by the state if anarchy is to be prevented. The difference between assassination and murder? Assassination is the murder of a prominent person or political figure by a surprise

International Business

4164 words - 17 pages authoritarianism and fascism. 3. The standard of freedom: freedom house is an independent organization that promotes liberty worldwide. Freedom is possible only in democratic political system in which the governments are accountable to their own people; the rule of law prevails; and freedoms of expression, association, and belief, as well as respect for the right of minorities and women, are guaranteed. It identifies 3 types of systems

Argumentation Paper

914 words - 4 pages Social Media vs. Freedom of Speech Since the Bill of Rights was ratified in 1791, freedom of speech has been a hallmark of American democracy and freedom. Obviously the U.S. in 2014 is a radically different place from the nation the Founders knew. Yet, the U.S. is governed essentially by the same Constitution adopted in 1787. There have been times when our freedom of speech was tested. The Alien and Sedition Act of 1790 prevented writing

The Netherlands' Poltical System

1192 words - 5 pages to speak on behalf of the general welfare of a country. Due to the fact that Political party leaders are forced address demands, and develop and propose plans's of action in order to be elected. Two party systems differ in many aspects, first are where many small parties exist that are highly competitive and represent very particular points of view, "such as communist, fascist, Catholic, Protestant; and where no one of the parties is large

Anarchy, Freedom, Liberty

1244 words - 5 pages , anarchy and totalitarianism can be mistaken for three words whose meanings have nothing to do with each other. In the next pages, we will demonstrate that, on the contrary, they are very strongly connected not only in a philosophical sense, but also at a political level. In order to relate the three concepts, we must define each one of them. FREEDOM The word freedom implies the absence of necessity, coercion, or constraint in choice or

Alexis de Tocqueville

2434 words - 10 pages involved with the revolutionary events that took place in France. After he studied law, Tocqueville worked for King Louis-Philippe which caused tension in his family. The tension probably added to Tocqueville’s desire to leave France. His trip to America was described “as more than just an aid to detached observation.” He found the political order that had combined democracy and political freedom which France, currently destroyed by crisis, did

Related Essays

Concept Of Freedom In Political Theory

1684 words - 7 pages own minds best and it was not for the state to interfere. However, he did not advocate complete freedom, saying that power should only be exercised on another person against his will in order to prevent harm to others. The concept of freedom is so fiercely contested in political theory in the West because it is one of the core tenets of democracy and is at the heart of so many other key debates such as those about justice, rights and

World Trade Organization Essay

2473 words - 10 pages political, economic, and legal systems of a country are interdependent; they interact and influence each other, and in doing so they also affect the level of economic well-being. Political system – we mean the system of government in a nation. Collectivism vs Individualism. Democratic vs Totalitarian. Collectivism – refers to a political system that stresses the primacy of collective goals over individual goals. Socialism – Manage state-owned

Knowledge Workers Essay

1108 words - 5 pages the Eastern bloc, freeing millions of people. At once, people in many former communist countries could enjoy greater freedom. For many companies, this meant a tremendous increase in potential customers as well as access to a huge, talented labor pool in the former Eastern bloc countries. Around the same time, Microsoft released the first version of the Windows operating system, which over time became the world standard in PC operating systems

Governments Censoring Internet Content Essay

1843 words - 8 pages within a country, discrimination would be prezen. As a result, censoring content on the Internet violates people rights, and limits educational purposes. Each country should preserve democratic rights in order for its people to be equal. No political reason should prevail when it comes to freedom of speech since it is people’s right to be informed with what is going on within their country, even the bad news. We all live in a world where we value