Onflicts Of Law And Equity In The Merchant Of Venice William Carlos Williams Once Said That “Shakespeare Is The Greatest University Of Them All” (Qtd. In Kornstein Xiii). This Is Especially True With Respect To The Law:

1955 words - 8 pages

onflicts of Law and Equity in The Merchant of Venice

William Carlos Williams once said that “Shakespeare is the greatest university of them all” (qtd. in Kornstein xiii). This is especially true with respect to the law: a dedicated scholar can discover a wealth of information on legal issues in Shakespeare’s works. Measure for Measure and The Merchant of Venice are, of course, explicitly “legal” in content, but more than twenty of the plays have some form of trial scene (Kornstein xii). Virtually all of the plays are tangentially concerned with some aspect of the law; at the very least, Shakespeare uses complex legal jargon to elicit a laugh. When one of the title characters in The Merry ...view middle of the document...

I submit, however, that the converse is also true: that the study of Shakespeare can lead to a deeper understanding of the fundamental nature of law. A play like The Merchant of Venice has a great deal to offer in the course of such a reading. The action of the play is concerned with contract law, but issues of standing, moiety, precedent, and conveyance are also raised. At the most fundamental level, though, the trial scene in Act IV illustrates the conflict between equity and the strict construction of the law.

Equity, in the legal sense, is “justice according to principles of fairness and not strictly according to formulated law” (Gilbert 103). This definition, while easily understandable, presents us with a problematic – even dangerous - structure of opposition. Law and fairness are set at extreme ends of some continuum of justice, and are exclusive. The definition implies that one can have justice according to “fairness,” or justice according to “formulated law.” Yet if law is not inherently fair, if there is need for a concept of equity, how can the law be said to be fulfilling its purpose? And if “fairness” is not to be found within the confines of “formulated law,” from whence does it come? This is not a new argument, of course; the conflict between law and equity was recognized even in medieval England.

From earliest childhood, we are indoctrinated with a sense of justice, of fairness, of right and wrong. Every schoolyard echoes with cries of “No fair cheating!” We seem to know instinctively that some things are fair, some things are not, and our moral outrage is awakened when injustice is perpetrated.

It is this indignation, this sense that principles of fairness have been violated, that arouse many to question the theories and practices upon which our system of law and justice have been built. Some would claim, for example, that rape is a crime no less egregious than that of murder, and thus call for the execution of convicted rapists. Yet no state allows such execution solely for conviction of rape. It has become a fundamental tenet of American law that the state may not take the life of a felon unless the crime involved the taking of a life; rape alone, while devastating the life of the victim, does not result in death without some intervening act. The search for equity – for fairness – within codified law has led to some bizarre and arcane practices in Western courts; when drunk drivers spend more time in prison than some murderers, this fact becomes painfully apparent.

Equity, in fact, has become so intertwined with law in the justice system that it is difficult to see the lines of demarcation. We must remember, however, that such was not always the case. When Shakespeare wrote The Merchant of Venice, there were actually separate courts in England for the administration of law and equity. One appealed to the Court of Common Law to seek redress under codified law, or to the Court of Equity to avail oneself of the...

Other Papers Like Onflicts of Law and Equity in the Merchant of Venice William Carlos Williams Once Said That “Shakespeare Is the Greatest University of Them All” (Qtd. in Kornstein Xiii). This Is Especially True with Respect to the Law:

Title Of This Book Is "Lord Of That Flies" And The Author Is William Golding. This Essay Shows, Who Is The Best Leader In The Story

769 words - 4 pages In the novel, "Lord of the Flies" which was written by William Golding, a group of boys are stranded on an island and a brave boy called Ralph steps up to become chief. On the other hand a boy called Jack also wants to be chief, and after a couple of arguments, he leaves the boys to start his own tribe. Ralph clearly reveals that he is the better leader because he shows that he is responsible, has courage, and shows integrity. All of the

Frodo, The Greatest Little Hobbit Of Them All

838 words - 4 pages Frodo’s adventure is not one of originality. It follows a cookie-cutter character through its journey to save that which is dear to him. In the case of Frodo he must protect the shire from devastation, and potentially all of Middle-Earth, by throwing the ring back into the fires of Mordor. This quest takes Frodo through a series of plot elements that famous Greek heroes have followed, his mission to rid Middle-Earth of ominous forces

Comparing The Characters, Portia And Helena, In Shakespeare's 'Merchant Of Venice' And 'All's Well That Ends Well'

1006 words - 5 pages emulates the purest form of love shown to all by God. Portia starts out sad, but because she has self-knowledge, she knows she is sad because of love. Once chosen by Bassanio, she shows she will sacrifice everything for him. She confirms her sacrificial love when she gives him a ring and says that “this house, these servants, and this same myself/Are yours—my lord’s! —I give them with this ring” (3.2.170-71). She surpasses Bassanio’s understanding

Notes on "Merchant of Venice" by William Shakespeare

620 words - 3 pages only if he signs the bond saying that if the money isn’t paid back on time, Antonio is to give a pound of his own flesh to Shylock.Good friendship was shown in Act III Scene 2 between Antonio and Bassanio. Antonio agrees to sign the bond that Shylock made because Bassanio needed the money badly and he was confident that he would be able to pay him back before time. Bassanio travels all the way to Belmont for his love Portia and wins her and

Athens and Forest Reading Through a Midsummer Night’s Dream, Written by William Shakespeare, It Is Easy to Find Out That the Play Can Be Separated by Two Sides Generally. One of Them Is Near World,...

764 words - 4 pages performances for their wedding. Those multifarious ceremonies are used to entertainment and invocation. In addition, civility is very important and complexity. Talking with people who have higher rank, they have to use many humble words to show their respect. Beside near world, mystical kingdom does not have that much propriety. Spirits do not need many ways to disport. They are so simply that even a mirror can make them happy. William Shakespeare

To What Extent Should the Law Reflect a Moral Vision, Even When This Involves an Interference with the Rights of Individuals Who Might Disagree with That Vision?”

2082 words - 9 pages who may not agree with this vision. Costello J agrees with the moral vision reflected by Article 40.3.3°, and thus his arguments are in favour of the way in which the 8th amendment was set. However, through the situation that X found herself in, as an observer it is clear that her moral vision on what the right thing to do in that situation wasn’t in compliance with the law set down. Conclusion As it is fundamentally impossible for the law to

Social Media Is the Platform That Reaches All Consumers in This Day and Age

699 words - 3 pages consumers in this day and age. Technology is an ever rising advancement that continues to make the lives of its consumers more convenient. Having said that, due to devices such as tablets, cell phones and laptops, consumers are do not require their home computers (desktops) as often anymore. They will be able to have excess to the Internet on the go. One of the reasons why this is such an essential part of marketing these days is because

"Let Me Not To The Marriage Of True Minds", By William Shakespeare

1016 words - 5 pages ''Let me not to the marriage of true minds'' by William Shakespeare is an Elizabethan sonnet of 14 lines divided in three Quatrains and the habitual rhyming couplet. In this particular poem Shakespeare uses a complete different approach, luring the reader by achieving a dramatic change of style.Although keeping the simple A/B/A/B/C/D/C/D/E/F/E/F/G/G rhyming scheme, providing the sonnet with an harmonious, fluid sound and giving it the pleasant

Using Act 1 Scene 3 As A Starting Point, Assess The Importance Of Venice In The Tragedy Of "Othello"- William Shakespeare

2403 words - 10 pages that falls foul of Iago, a manipulator who is ruthless in what he does. Iago brings out emotions that Othello cannot handle; jealousy and rage replace rationality and wisdom, and this leads to his downfall. Cyprus contrasts with Venice to show how different the places are and how they can change personalities to such a degree that it can make people into murderers.Bibliography:(1) Shakespeare, William; "Othello"; Wordsworth Classic(2) http

C.L. Barber Argued That Comedy Is All About Pleasure and Merrymaking. How Do You React to This Idea in Your Study of Much Ado About Nothing?

2652 words - 11 pages significance and importance of this allegation, as with a loss of honour, a man who once loved Hero so dearly is prepared to ruin her life in consequence of her supposed actions, as Claudio claims she is a ‘rotten orange’, indicating that he believes she is of no good to anyone any longer, including her family as he pronounced his view so proudly in front of them. This makes the audience understand the importance of a woman’s virtue and honour to a

‘Countries at Very Low Levels of Economic Development Face Such Huge Challenges That They Cannot Hope to Address Them Without Assistance from the Rest of the World’. to What Extent Do You Agree with...

1474 words - 6 pages example of where trade has worked is China, as it is an NIC that has experienced rapid growth especially in manufacturing and tertiary industries in recent years. In conclusion these countries do face rather large problems which may be too hard for some of them to tackle on their own without the assistance of aid but there have been some circumstances where countries have used trade as means of developing. Trade can offer more for a country as

Related Essays

The Life Of William Carlos Williams

1183 words - 5 pages “aesthetic imagism.” This approach to poetry emphasized concrete ideas over abstractions. This is one of the key qualities that make William Carlos Williams different from most other poets. Another way Ezra helped Williams become a great poet is that he brought him to a literary circle that was run by the poet Hilda Doolittle. Hilda showed Williams that poetry wasn’t all about writing about nature and memories, but just random everyday things. A good

Merchant Of Venice: Law And Love

2268 words - 10 pages it in me to … this strife / become a Christian and thy loving wife” (II.iii.16-21). Jessica cannot stay in Venice, so she and Lorenzo, victims of love, must make their way to Belmont, the true residence for all the lovers in Shakespeare’s The Merchant of Venice. The final struggle between law and love residing in the same city prevails during the court scene. The entire cast is present in the courtroom including the leading couples, which

Discuss The View That Religious Experiences Must Be True Because There Is A Common Core To All Of Them

772 words - 4 pages Religious experience can conjure up a wide variety of images. Many claim having had experienced god in ways that ranges from saying a prayer, to attending a service in a place of worship, to hearing the voice of God. Through one perspective, religious experience is plausibly real and true especially for those who have experienced its reality. Through another view, validating any concept such as religious experience is an oxymoron of many

A Discussion Of Shylock's Portrayal In The Court Scene And The Rest Of The Play, In The Merchant Of Venice By William Shakespeare

525 words - 3 pages In this scene, Shylock is portrayed as a hateful man. He wishes death on Antonio, preferring to accept a "weight of carrion flesh" to three thousand ducats. Previously, in Venice, he wished that his "daughter were dead at [his] foot", and that his "jewels [were] in her ear".He is also portrayed as an unmerciful person. After Portia asks him to "render the deeds of mercy", he replies that he is not compelled to do so, and refuses to. Earlier in