On Denoting The Use Essay

1597 words - 7 pages

CHUA, John Moses A. | PHLO 195 – T | Philosophy of Language | UPLB

On Denoting the Use

‘The King of France is bald.’ This proposition had been very famous and a very good example for describing theories if we are to discern on how we can or should recognize if a proposition consisting a non-existent subject be true or false, or how meaningful these kinds may be. This paper should aim to defend Russell’s On Denotation and Descriptions against Strawson’s On Referring. This should go through on how Strawson may have failed to prove that Russell’s theory of denoting and theory of descriptions is incorrect and hence should be abandoned.
But first, what is Russell’s theory ...view middle of the document...

This problem was figured out by Russell when he posed his theory of denoting. In this theory subjects or concepts within a proposition is presupposed to have no meaning; but can only have when equipped with denoting phrases. Now what are these denoting phrases? These denoting phrases are the ones that have meaning and have the ability to produce and equate meaning with relation to the proposition. Now applying this theory of denoting to the proposition, ‘The king of France is bald’. The exact reference of the subject king of France must be distinguished to distinguish the exact and accurate denoting phrase for it. Let us consider someone as the king of France that is bald and let that be x. It can be that: ‘X is the king of France and x is bald, such that x does not exist (for there is no king of France)’ is always true.[2] This kind of theory have been sufficient for the problem of vagueness or ambiguity that concerns any subject or focus of a proposition, as far as Russell is concerned though he was still aware that intellectual developments or some other intellectual creation can refute or modify his work.[3]
Bertrand Russell did not fail to anticipate problems for in 1950 Sir Peter Frederick Strawson produced a paper, also in Mind magazine aiming to debunk Russell’s work. How? Simply, Strawson pointed out that Russell failed to recognize what constitutes the meaning in a proposition. Strawson[4] proposed that expressions such that it is to “mention or refer to some individual person or single object... in the course of... making a statement about that person [or object]......”–which is parallel with Russell’s when Russell points the truthfulness or falsity of a
proposition–does not constitute meaning. For Strawson, aside from ‘expression’, there is also the ‘use’. It is the use, not the expression that is ‘uniquely referring’. In fact, Strawson went to a point where he determined that expressions do not refer at all and thus must have no meaning but it is the use that must have. Strawson included in his work the truth-value gaps that which is ignored by Russell when discussing Frege.[5] These truth-value gaps are those that cause some propositions to be neither true nor false; and one very good example is the case of ‘king of France’; for the reason that the king of France does not exist and thus we must accord its use before distinguishing its truth or falsity. He goes on to introduce two concepts within propositions: sentence-type and sentence token. Sentence-type is the ‘sentence’ itself which according to Strawson this is what Russell pertains to and thus have meaning; while sentence token is what Strawson means by the ‘use of a sentence’ that which is for him has the meaning.[6]
There are problems in Strawson’s work that lead him to fail on debunking Russell’s work. This is when he also failed to clearly understand what is Russell pertaining. Strawson may have a point in the eyes of the ordinary language theorist that...

Other Papers Like On Denoting the Use

The Motivation To Use Atomic Bombs On The Cities Of Hiroshima And Nagasaki

3450 words - 14 pages Debates on the use of the atomic bombs on the Japanese cities of Hiroshima and Nagasaki have been active for decades and continue to this day. The timeline of events and available evidence is consistent with the notion that the most compelling reason Pres. Truman authorized the use of atomic weapons was for diplomatic and political reasons, with an eye towards the Soviet Union, rather than bringing an early end to the war with the immediate

Overview on the Theory of Recruitment Process and the Use of Selection Tools

3199 words - 13 pages OVERVIEW ON THE THEORY OF RECRUITMENT PROCESS AND THE USE OF SELECTION TOOLS November 2015 PETER HORVATH CASS BUSINESS SCHOOL – MEMBASTUDENT NUMBER: 150000247 | Table of Contents Executive Summary 3 The Focus of this Paper 3 Recruitment Process 3 Selection Tools 6 Recommendations for My Firm 7 References 8 Executive Summary Human capital is a potential source of firms’ competitive advantage. To

What Has Caused the Increased Use of Digital Technology and Its Effects on Communication

871 words - 4 pages Introduction. Over a period of the last 20 years, the digital technology have had a rapid development and influenced the world deeply. It is a kind of science method which can show some information, images and sound through digital media like phones and computers. As the digital media grows, it gradually participates in the society and promotes the communication as a result. Cause One cause of why the use of the digital technology

"I Know Why The Caged Bird Sings" By Maya Angelou: An Analysis On The Use Of Diction Throughout The Story

1103 words - 5 pages We are all familiar with the widespread novel by Maya Angelou, I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings. Yet, do we really know? The connotations of the title can drastically alter the perspective of the novel and the meaning it leaves on the readers. Angelou wrote an amazing and entertaining autobiography, about her hard life growing up as a black girl from the South. Among the hardships are her "cages". These are things that keep people from succeeding

The Government Of The United States Of America Has The Right To Make The Decision On Whether Students Should Have A Dress Code Which Mandates The Use Of School Uniforms

1290 words - 6 pages The Government of The United States of America has the right to make the decision on whether students should have a dress code which mandates the use of school uniforms.The government of The United States of America has the right to make the decision on whether students should have a dress code which mandates the use of school uniforms. The debates of whether use of school uniforms should be enforced have been going on for years. There are a

Show How The Author Of "Memoirs Of A Geisha", Arthur Golden, Portrays The Effects Of Japanese Society On The Individual, Sayuri Nitta, Through His Use Of Effective Language Techniques

2259 words - 10 pages "Memoirs of a Geisha" by Arthur Golden, is a beautifully written epic tale which envelopes the reader instantly; revealing Golden's ability to include a realism inside an engrossing, yet fictional narrative, resulting in the novel becoming a bestseller enjoyed the world over. Through his use of delicately descriptive and poetic language, Arthur Golden superbly portrays the effects of the harshness of Japanese society on the individual, Sayuri

“Budgetary Control Is Part of Overall Organisation Control and Is Concerned Primarily with the Control of Performance. the Use of Budgetary Control in Performance Management Has of Late Taken on...

2202 words - 9 pages company. This situation would prove to be unhealthy to an organisation in the long run and as such, pressure from investors should be handled in a discreet, appropriate and efficient manner by the management. Flexible Budget The use of a budget would require day to day changes depending on the business environment. The idea of a flexible budget grew on investors and shareholders as it provided a clearer view of the organisations results and it

Assess How Branding Has Increased in the Last Few Decades. Think of a Brand; Analyze How the Organization Developed Its Brand Equity. Assess the Influence of Branding on an Organization’s Imc. Must...

629 words - 3 pages in a pure form. Brand Equity Evaluation System (BEES) is based on eight brand equity determinants – brand sales, net operating margin, perspectives of brand development, international orientation, advertising investment, brand strength in the sector, brand image and pre-tax earnings, noted Salinas, G. (2011). In order to compose brand quality factor, we should utilize such elements as sales, net operating margin and perspectives of brand

Coco Chanel

722 words - 3 pages Gabrielle Bonheur "Coco" Chanel (19 August 1883 – 10 January 1971)[1] was an influential French fashion designer, founder of the famous brand Chanel, whose modernist thought, practical design, and pursuit of expensive simplicity made her an important and influential figure in 20th-century fashion. She was the only fashion designer to be named on Time 100: The Most Important People of the Century.[2] Legacy as design revolutionary As early as

World History

720 words - 3 pages foreign countries or supplying merchandise to a particular trade. Monotheism: the doctrine or belief that there is only one God. Nation: a large aggregate of people united by common descent, history, culture, or language, inhabiting a particular country or territory. Neolithic: of, relating to, or denoting the later part of the Stone Age, when ground or polished stone implements prevailed, the Neolithic period. Nobility: the quality of being a

What Is Pi?

1115 words - 5 pages questions from topics such as Numerical Mathematics, Geometrical Mathematics, Trignometry and Beezganit (Algebra). He also worked on indeterminate equations of Beezganit (Later in West it was called Algebra). He was the first to use Vyutkram Zia (Which was later known as Versesine in the West) in Trignometry. He calculated the value of pi correct upto four decimal places. He was first to find that the sun is stationary and the earth revolves

Related Essays

The Use Of Narratives And Its Effect On Stories

787 words - 4 pages The Use of Narratives and Its Effect on Stories The use of narrative view are important for an author. It determines how the reader interpret the story and ultimately understanding the theme. In the work of “Hills Like White Elephant” Ernest Hemingway uses third person objective point of view to present the conflict of a young couple over the difficult decision of whether to have an abortion. In comparison to Hemingway’s work, “Great Falls

The Use Of Internet Creates Adverse Influence On Teenagers

1552 words - 7 pages Running Head: INTERNET AND TEENAGERS The Use of Internet Creates Adverse Influence on Teenagers Tabassum Akhter 13304131 Sec: 08 Course: English 102 Date of Submission: 14th August 2013 BRAC University The Use of Internet Creates Adverse Influence on Teenagers On Christmas Day, 1990, in a lab at Cern in Geneva, Switzerland, Tim Berners-Lee finished building the tools to create the World Wide Web (Krotoski, 2010

Drug Use And The Media: What Is The Influence On Society?

2963 words - 12 pages In recent years, television programs that focus on heavy drug use have been on the rise. One show in particular, Breaking Bad, has been a major hit with teens and young adults. A total of 10.3 million viewers tuned into watch the show’s series finale, 5.2 million of which were adults age 18-49 (Entertainment Weekly). Focusing on the drug business regarding crystal meth Breaking Bad depicts a thrillingly dangerous lifestyle. The show has

Poison Gas And Its Use In Breaking The Stalemate On The Western Front

1250 words - 5 pages of chlorine and they failed to follow up the success of the chlorine attack. What did occur at Ypres was a deliberate use of a poison gas. Now, the gloves were off and other nations with the ability to manufacture poison gas could use it and blame it on the Germans as they had been the first to use it (despite the French tear gas variant). The first of the Allied nations to respond to the Ypres gas attack was Britain in September 1915. The