This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

On Being An Atheist Essay

1704 words - 7 pages

H. J. McCloskey's "On Being An Atheist"

PHIL 201 - B15
Professor C. Wayne Mayhall

Dorothy Thomas

Liberty University
July 9. 2010

Author H. J. McClosky gives us a negative answer in dealing with the question of God's existence. McClosky attempts to answer a different question. So he does not believe. How we face the world and create meaning for ourselves is the crutch of a divine benefactor. In the literature of disbelief by setting aside argumentation "On Being An Atheist", the article written by McClosky does little more to this reader than confirm a faith in God and the existence His role has in one's life.
     Granted it is well to know opposing ...view middle of the document...

We tend to reject religion, ideology, knowledge and science. Can we deny the need for love and compassion?
     Mr.McClosky has taken a negative stance on the existence of something such as the need to believe in God. This is a very impersonal approach to a very personal question; however, each person must and have the right to answer within their lifetime. The idea that we must all think alike is boring and not stimulating and portrays a world of dullness and lifelessness. Even the most knowledgeable and most respected astronomers and scientist of times have succeeded the idea that the possibility of God exist. Although much information obtained by using telescopes to look into space, men have used ideas and theories to explain the universe and how it operates. When Einstein developer developed his theory of relativity, the Nazis were taking over Europe. Forced to move to the United States he ended up at Princeton University in spite of anti- Jewish sentiment. Without his discoveries we may not have been able to study space and the stars as soon as we have, simply based on what he "believed" about God and religion.
     When McClosky talks about evil and uses the notion that Atheist are justified in their belief in a nonexistent God, we are confronted with the meaning of evil and its place in our world. The fact of suffering misfortune and wrongdoing as a source of sorrow, distress or calamity
in my heart and mind does not clarify the nonexistence of God. Was what happened to Einstein and many hundreds of thousands of Jews evil? Yes. There is no question of the existence of evil in the gas chambers used to kill the Jewish men, women and children simply because of their faith. The pain suffered by those and many others in history due to discrimination and the forces of evil are heart wrenching and sad. The idea that one person has the "right" to decide for another is unjust and evil in itself. Therefore, one could conclude the Atheist himself displays the very traits of which he criticizes others for, the human factor and the struggle between good and evil that rest within each of us.
Mr. Mcclosky uses the example of a child with meningitis who suffers a permanent impairment for the rest of her life. Would he then speak to the person or to the mother of the child to confirm faith in God? Having worked in a hospital with ill children and having seen the overwhelming power of prayer, this reader questions the legitimacy of the author's example in terms of faith and God. Just as McClosky argues against the existence, so can we not use the opposite approach for the existence and be on equal moral ground? Perhaps, McClosky is the father of the child described in the article and could we not then assume he is bitter or grieving? Then the argument would make sense. Without the human factor of love and compassion, we could conclude nothing. Assuming he is not, the father of the child the argument becomes vain and shallow resulting in little more...

Other Papers Like On Being an Atheist

Imagine You Were Present At Socrates' Trial. Write A Short Speech In Which You Either State Why He Should Be Declared Innocent Or Why He Should Be Found Guilty

652 words - 3 pages act in this way, nor did he ask for a fee in return for what they had learnt from him.Meletus was first accusing Socrates of being an atheist, he then went on to say that Socrates was corrupting the minds of the young by teaching them of supernatural beings which means that Socrates does believe in something and so is not an atheist. The only crime Socrates has committed is that of putting his obligation to Apollo before that to the people of

Apologetics Application Paper

617 words - 3 pages Final Paper: A) Introduction B) The New Atheist and Their Worldview 1) Truth Claims 2) Source of Authority 3) Source of Morality 4) Worldview on Christianity C) Evaluating the New Atheist Worldview 1) Internal Logical Consistency 2) Is it Coherent 3) Factual Adequacy 4) Existential Viability 5) Does it Inspire 6) Ad Hoc Readjustment 7) Complexity D

Existence of God

5172 words - 21 pages believer would use this as a foundation to argue for the existence of God as that controlling being. In this argument, the sheer complexity of the natural world, the universe, atoms, DNA, and so on are used to justify that there must be a God. For example, most people know and understand the basic physics rule for magnetism and electricity that opposite charges attract and like charges repel. When this rule is applied to the nucleus of an atom

Response Paper Phil201

1687 words - 7 pages Response Paper McCloskey Article Anthony Powers PHIL 201- C09 November 6, 2015 Response Paper McCloskey Article In his article, On Being an Atheist, H.J. McCloskey attempted to prove how that holding an atheistic pattern of thought was much easier than holding a theistic worldview. McCloskey even referred to theism as a “comfortless spine-chilling doctrine.” Since McCloskey stated that proofs do not hold a vital role in the belief of


381 words - 2 pages CORM falls under the rhetoric device of argument from celebrity. There were also a few visual images used in the presentation. Matt ended his part of the presentation with a video which involved Richard Dawkins an atheist. This is an example of argument from celebrity. In the video Richard Dawkins got into a serious argument with the interviewer. This was an example of argument from outrage. The next part of the presentation was the pros

Phil 201 Week 6 Study Guid

3971 words - 16 pages Being: God is not limited by or dependent on any other being God does not just happen to exist Contingent Being: something that does not exult in and of itself but depends for its existence upon some other being Principle of Sufficient Reason: anything that happens does so for a resaon Teleological Argument: begins from the fact that the natural world appears to exhbit purposive order or design, and infers that its cause must therefore be an


1181 words - 5 pages choice on what we think is right and wrong, and we must choose to them there were no prewritten guidelines we must trust our own conscious. There are also those who do not believe in God and say morality is a man made concept to control the masses so the few can control the many. I even found references of atheist who do believe in a collective morality that every living being is born with that all humans and animals without being taught what is

Response Paper

1106 words - 5 pages Phil- 201 Response Paper The argument of whether or not it is possible to prove or disprove God’s existence has been going on for hundreds if not thousands of years. Many scholars, atheists, and non-believers throughout the years have argued against the existence of God, but in H.J. McCloskey’s, On Being an Atheist, he shows a much deeper look at his argument by discussing what he thinks might be the overarching argument of Gods existence

Response Paper

1431 words - 6 pages The article by H.J. McCloskey, titled “On Being an Atheist” is certainly a controversial topic for those of the Christian faith, especially those with very strong beliefs. We as Christians believe that God is almighty and there is really no need to believe in any other being or even question that he exists. In this article from McCloskey, he talks about God’s existence and if there truly is a God, then why is there evil in world? This essay will

Just Joining

2477 words - 10 pages Reply Paper to H.J. McCloskey’s Essay: On Being An Atheist H.J McCloskey makes many bold statements in opposition to the most common arguments for theism. To say the least, his bias shows through, even to the point of not seeing the deeper picture. He makes claims against the cosmological and teleological arguments. He then makes a point on how evil speaks against the existence of God. He then concludes with a statement that may or may not be

Re 290 Religion Articles

955 words - 4 pages solid argument. Question 3 Aquinas makes two arguments about the morality of suicide that an atheist may find convincing. First, he points to the fact that everything naturally loves itself and wants what is best for itself. In this way suicide contradicts nature and natural law. Secondly, he speaks to the fact that every part belongs to some whole. By killing oneself, one also hurts the community they were apart of. These two

Related Essays

Mckloskey's "On Being An Atheist" Essay

1844 words - 8 pages A response to H.J. McCloskey's Article, "On Being an Atheist" In 1968 H.J. McCloskey wrote an article to his fellow atheists entitled "On Being an Atheist".  His purposes for writing this article were to inform other atheists of the supposed inadequacies of theists' belief in God, and to address accusations that the position of atheism is "cold" and "comfortless”. The author intends to show that in fact, it is theism that is the cold and

Molly Essay

411 words - 2 pages lack of imagination, meaning that he does not fully understand why he is dying, and that is because he is an atheist Miss the better story- The story Martel is referring to is the bible. Continuing with his thought that the agnostic person is missing out on a portion of his life, he refers to God or the bible as a “story” that the agnostic is missing out on. By saying so Martel is his extreme disapproval for those who chose not to believe in God, and saying that the story of God is better than the “story” that does not involve God.

Response Paper

2252 words - 10 pages Corey Rivera Dr. Matthew Arbo Phil 201-D20 December 7, 2013 Response Paper Does a belief in an all-knowing, all-good, all-perfect, and all-powerful God provide one with all the answers to life’s inexplicable questions? Conversely, does a belief in atheism offer any insight into life’s inexplicable questions? According to an article titled “On Being an Atheist,” written by the Australian philosopher H.J. McCloskey, atheism seems to do just

The Persecution Of Atheism In America

1453 words - 6 pages What is atheism? Why would someone be an atheist? Why do people fear and dislike atheism? Simply stated, atheism is the lack of belief in a god or gods. Granted, atheists are each individuals and undoubtedly each of them prescribe [to] many different philosophies on life, politics and morality as do Christians. However, though atheists may choose to gather collectively for whatever purpose, unlike Christianity, atheism is not a belief system. An