This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Nsa Ethics Of Mass Surveillance Essay

1358 words - 6 pages

The Ethics of the NSA Mass-Surveillance Program
University Name
Student Name
Course Number/Name
Professor Name

One of the most explosive scandals of the 21st century was involved the National Security Agency (NSA), and the revelations that the agency had set up a robust, warrantless mass surveillance program in the years after the 9/11 attacks. Designed to pick up bits of intelligence that could be used in order to thwart future 9/11 attacks, critics of the program argued that not only was it unconstitutional given the lack of warrants obtained prior to engaging in the program, but that it was ineffective at stopping any kind of real terrorism. Supporters pushed ...view middle of the document...

Similarly, the data splitters could gain access to phone calls and phone numbers of millions of unsuspecting Americans. This data was subsequently analyzed using the Naurus Semantic Traffic Analyzer, which essentially key word searched metadata in order to find terrorist related patterns and topics which could then be used as evidence to focus on individuals more closely (Dunn, 2015). This data gathering and analysis was conducted with no oversight, with no warrants provided.
Applying Utilitarianism
A first ethical theory that is pertinent to this case is utilitarianism. This ethical perspective argues that the ethical nature of a decision is based on the ultimate outcome associated with the choices made, rather than the choices themselves (Shaw, 2016). In essence, utilitarianism can be summed up by the phrase “the ends justify the means”. Proponents of this theory argue that if an action is taken that appears unethical in the process, this does not necessarily mean that the actions are unethical; it can only be judged based on the outcome. A simple example of utilitarianism is seen in harvesting an organ from a criminal in order to save a person who then goes on to cure cancer. On the surface, stealing an organ from anyone would appear unethical, but in this case the ultimate outcome saves millions, thus making the action ethical.
Utilitarianism is the ethical theory that tends to be preferred by proponents of the NSA’s Terrorist Surveillance Program. The belief is that if the surveillance program is able to stop a terrorist attack before it occurs, it will save lives. As such, the outcome of the surveillance program is ethical, even though the process of mass surveillance tramples on the Constitution of the United States, and the concept that the government needs to seek a warrant prior to beginning to conduct surveillance on an American citizen. This is a sacred duty that the American government has to its citizens, something that is enshrined in the Fourth Amendment which bars the government from engaging in illegal searches and seizures in pursuit of a criminal investigation (Dunn, 2015). A believer in utilitarianism would argue that the lives of American citizens are more important than adhering to a legal principle which demands a specific process be followed. Saving lives is seen as the ethical choice, superior to following the Constitution.
Applying Kantian Ethics
Traditionally, the ethical theory that is the diametric opposite of utilitarianism is Kantian ethics. Developed by Emmanuel Kant, this ethical theory holds that ethical rightness or wrongness is not determined by the outcome of actions, but by the ability of the decision maker to adhere to their duty (Shaw, 2016). The foundation of this theory is that it is virtually impossible to control the ultimate outcome of events, and a person should always be in control of whether or not they are making ethical choices. In this way, the theory holds that a person can always...

Other Papers Like Nsa Ethics of Mass Surveillance

Nsa- Edward Snowden Essay

978 words - 4 pages a former CIA technical assistant who has claimed responsibility for leaking headline-making information about the National Security Agency's (NSA) surveillance program. He revealed that the NSA has records of majority of calls made in America, including those who are making and receiving the calls phone number, conversations between people in emails, on Twitter, Facebook etc. They also have huge amounts of data on the internet including history

How Has the Nsa's Surveillance Impacted the Economy?

1871 words - 8 pages concentrates on simplistic debates evaluating the tradeoff between individual privacy and national security. However, it is an important time for the government and other stakeholders to begin weighing the benefits and costs associated with the surveillance more carefully. In spite of the strong defense by intelligence officials in favor of the NSA programs, the officials fail to table any credible evidence in support of the benefits they suggest

Iran Economic Swot

1804 words - 8 pages Risks identification Global risks Crime 26 Transnational crime 27 Terrorism   History: begins with first city (1st century ; Russia, Germany with anarchists) Linked with: Frustration  Fear of the others  Religious consideration  Ethnic or geographical disputes     Aim: use of terror to destabilize/disorganize the institutions => “innocent” targets Closely linked with mass media (threat/fear/disrupt

Downfall Through Technology

4873 words - 20 pages surveillance practice seemed to have shifted away from individual suspicion in favour of systematic, mass collection techniques. Information was collected from companies such as Microsoft, Verizon, Apple, Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, Google and more. These establishments did not have the option to deny the government’s request. The Foreign Intelligence Security Act of 1978, also known as FISA “ created a secret court that blesses information

Nsa Surveillance

1226 words - 5 pages for other, more secure partners. According to a report released last week by The Information Technology & Innovation Foundation, NSA surveillance could cost the U.S. cloud computing industry anywhere from $22 to $35 billion over the next three years if "foreign customers decide the risks of storing data with a U.S. company outweigh the benefits." And trying to find privacy-protecting workarounds appears to be getting more difficult, as

Case Study

554 words - 3 pages 2013, Snowden began copying top-secret NSA documents while at work, building a record of practices that he found invasive and alarming. The documents contained enormous and pejorative information on the NSA's domestic surveillance practices, including spying on millions of American citizens under the name of programs such as PRISM. (Edward Snowden biography) Snowden later forwarded these documents to journalists, from where on June 5th Guardian

Nsa Eavesdropping and Data Mining

4977 words - 20 pages or even a reason other than the blanket term used “For the greater good.” There has been a new development into surveillance of a person phone and now including email and text messages. You would think just like anything that there would be some sort of court order when in fact no, all the NSA requires is based on an analyst’s decision which is sufficient to them to continue snooping. (McCullagh, 2013) Based on the information given about

Snowden Note

935 words - 4 pages Page 1 Edward Joseph Snowden is a former National Security Agency (NSA) contractor who disclosed a global surveillance by the NSA, such as PRISM, XKeyscore, Tempora, and the interception of US and European telephone metadata. Page 2 1. In May 2013 Snowden took a leave of absence, telling his supervisors he was returning to the mainland for treatment, but instead left Hawaii for Hong Kong on May 20. 2. On June 22, US officials

Does Edward Snowden Deserve To Be Given Amnesty?

1048 words - 5 pages Why Edward Snowden should be given amnesty In June 2013 the former NSA employee Edward Snowden, leaked a number of classified intelligence documents to journalists at The Washington Post and The Guardian and has been living in Russia ever since. Because of his decision to not take part in illegal surveillance practices, he has been labeled a traitor. However, everyone who has sworn to uphold and defend the Constitution of the United States

Dr. Phill

1455 words - 6 pages Devin Smith LEG 500 Law, Ethics, Corp Goverance Dr. Terry Phillips 7/18/11 Explain where an employee can reasonably expect to have privacy in the workplace. If there is a policy in place of the employer related to workplace including privacy issues that policy is legally binding. For example the employer may communicate that employees may enjoy privacy in certain demarcated areas of the office. The employee can enjoy privacy in those

Electronic Surveillance of Employees

1740 words - 7 pages . Some business may just need to install them for the safety of their employees. Reference Halbert, T., & Ingulli, E. (2009). Law & ethics in the business environment: 2010 custom edition (6th ed.). Mason, OH: South-Western Cengage Learning. Osborn, J. Jr. (Writer), and Perlee, Clyde and Miller, Roger Leroy (Concept). (2008). Electronic Surveillance of Employees [Videotape]. Wouth-Western Cengage., retrieved October 13, 2011.

Related Essays

Spying Of The Nsa, Public Speaking Report

1922 words - 8 pages illegal because it's unacceptable. The NSA can surveillance anything we do through all these social sites and most of us have Facebook and a Google account (gmail) so think about it, everything you send or receive has been read by someone at the NSA, this is not right, it shouldn’t even happen. If other people are being punished for spying and invading people their privacy, why is it ok if the NSA is doing it? Not because they are a higher power

Internet Surveillance Essay

1548 words - 7 pages well. One of the ways we can counteract mass internet surveillance is the use of greater encryption of data. Eventually, it is possible to apply encryption to all web traffic instead of certain services like online banking, or shopping. In other words, we need innovation in internet security to put locks in more places and make the existing locks harder to pick for the NSA. If done successfully, the interception of traffic between any two

Surveillance: A Double Edged Sword Essay

577 words - 3 pages NSA and other agencies has produced some occurrences that clearly shows that it has some time stepped over the line and violated the privacy of nationals. The age of digital media justifies this yet people have other view. This makes the Surveillance a double edged sword hanging on the citizens. They can’t deny it yet they can’t take it. The problem In age of technological development you can never be sure that who is keeping a eye on us. The

Infringing The Fourth Amendment: Edward Snowden And The Nsa

2066 words - 9 pages Mass surveillance by the United States Government has been a predominant reoccurring issue since classified government documents were leaked in May of 2013. These leaks lead to one of the most significant debates about an individual’s daily life in decades; the constituent’s right to privacy. According to the fourth amendment of the United States’ Constitution, section 1, “the right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers