This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Negative Impact Of The Marine Life Protection Act On Native American Tribes

1259 words - 6 pages

Craig Jones
Professor Middleton
NAS 001
11/20/2014

In a response to poor water quality, soiled beaches, and a dwindling marine life population on the coast of California, Governor Gray Davis in 1999 proposed his solution. It was called the Marine Life Protection Act (MLPA), and its aim was to restore coastal regions of California to their former glory. Since its inception the MLPA has received much criticism, as it has violated the rights of many native tribes whose places of traditional practices overlap in these Marine Protected Areas (MPAs). (California Marine 11/17/14) The conflict has only gotten worse as new initiatives were passed which allowed privatized use (drilling, ...view middle of the document...

(The Yurok Tribe 11/17/14)
There have been many different strategies implemented by many different tribes in Northern California to try and regain access to their sacred and traditional rights. Many tribes, like the Yurok began by trying to show that the passing and implementation of the MLPA would be in direct conflict with both the American Indian Religious Freedom Act (AIRFA) and many different articles in the Declaration On The Rights Of Indigenous Peoples. (Lobo 2007:468-475) Both domestic and international law has declared the prevention of Native Peoples’ religious and traditional practices to be illegal. (Harjo 2004:337-341) In July 2010, more than 300 people (many of which were Yurok) peacefully overtook a MLPA task force meeting in Fort Bragg. According to Yurok Tribal member Frankie Meyers, “Whether it is their intention or not, what the Marine Life Protection Act does to tribes is systematically decimate our ability to be who we are… The MLPA process completely disregards tribal gathering rights and only permits discussion of commercial and recreational harvest.” (Klamath Justice 11/17/14) As a result of this protest the task force rejected an amendment that would have restricted the Yurok Tribe’s traditional fishing and gathering rights. Another way that the Yurok tribe has tried to combat the MLPA is by trying to address the questionable scientific data, used by the Schwarzenegger administration as the basis for their initiative. One example of this can be seen in 2010, when the MLPA science advisory team turned down a request by the Yurok tribe to make a presentation that would have provided contradictory scientific evidence on the marine reserves. Yurok Tribe senior leader, John Corbett, stated that the presentation would have shown that there was no statistical difference between the diversity of marine life when looking at harvested and un-harvested areas of the coast. Despite having a large tribal scientific community with numerous resources, no tribal scientists have ever been allowed to serve on the MLPA Science Advisory Team. (Yurok Tribe 11/17/14) Today many activists regard this act as blatant “institutionalized racism” by not recognizing tribes as political entities, or regarding Tribal scientists as legitimate. As a result of failed attempts to fight the MLPA with legal action, many members of the Yurok tribe have decided to just ignore the regulations that would prohibit them from traditional gathering of seaweed, mussels, and fish. The tribal elders all agreed that the Yurok have been hunters, fishermen, and gatherers on these coastal areas before the west even knew they existed. (Dan Bacher 11/17/14) They all state that California has no right to restrict what the Yurok have been doing for centuries. Daniel Wildcat in his book Red Alert,...

Other Papers Like Negative Impact Of The Marine Life Protection Act On Native American Tribes

The Impact of Sputnik and the Ndea on American Education

2385 words - 10 pages , strengthen resistance to totalitarianism, and enhance the quality of American leadership on an international level. The Act is also a contract that establishes a partnership of federal and state governments in education, the former assisting with funds and counsel, the latter exercising full control over their own educational systems and programs (Flemming, 1960, pg 132). Each Title of the NDEA at stimulating and strengthening American education

Media Consolidation And The Negative Impact On The Internet

1579 words - 7 pages implications and effects of media consolidation on businesses and citizens are both positive and negative. Media consolidation via the Internet is damaging to society, and the federal government should close the door on the continuing consolidation of electronic media. Works Cited Anderson, Byron. "Media Consolidation." American Library Association. May 2002. Web. Sept. 13. . Common Cause

Native American Inflence on Sports

980 words - 4 pages 11/10/11 Foundations of HPE 8:00 Native American Influence on Sport Looking at today's sports it would be hard to guess that Native Americans had any type of influence on sports and recreation. The famous sports today make it hard to notice any type of culture mix other than a large debate about mascots. The larger and better known sports (football, baseball, basketball) all have hardly been influenced by Native Americans. Although

Native American Influences on Modern American Culture

741 words - 3 pages Americans adopted" some of the Europeans' ways. and the Europeans adopted some of their ways. As a result. Native Americans have made many valuable contributions to American culture. particularly in the areas of language. art, food. and government. Native Americans left a permanent imprint on the English language. The early English speaking settlers borrowed from several different Native American languages words for the new places and new objects

Impact Of Language On Asian American Health

3118 words - 13 pages Running Head: Impact of Language on Asian American Health Impact of English Language Proficiency (ELP) on Health and Health Care Among Elderly Asian Americans Amoldeep Kaur Written Assignment #2 Epidemiology/Public Health 240 Winter 2013 The elderly population is the fastest growing population in the United States, and the number of immigrants that fall within this group has nearly doubled (Ninez, Hsys, & Cunnigham (2005

The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act

1785 words - 8 pages Health Services Strategic Marketing Valerie Grant Strayer University HSA 505 Dr. Gwendolyn Francavillo October 23, 2011 The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, otherwise known as health care reform or the Patient’s Bill of Rights, was signed into law by President Barack Obama in March 2010. The law has generated much discussion and concern on the part of all stakeholders. The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA

Americans And The Monsanto Protection Act

2461 words - 10 pages Americans are angry in regards to the signing of the Farmer Assurance Act on March 27, 2014. This act also goes by the nickname Monsanto Protection Act. The company Monsanto is well known for its production of GM seeds, or genetically modified seeds. Numerous Americans are currently protesting and creating petitions because genetically modified organisms may be at risk of contaminating organic foods in the near future. In addition, food that

The Children’S Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA)

1761 words - 8 pages The government has passed some laws which are intended to protect children on the internet. The Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA) and Children’s Internet Protection Act (CIPA) are to give protection for children who are accessing the internet. There are requirements and protective information for both COPPA and CIPA. Both acts are similar and different in ways to protect children but needed to be done with two acts. There are

Impact of Ct on Private Public Life

619 words - 3 pages COMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGY LATEST This era, the all-powerful, communication tool is growing so rapidly and quickly. As we know, technology is growing from day to day. Technology development propagating in all areas of life, especially in the field of communication. Communication system itself is a concept where there is meaning in the communication of the information and other devices such as signals, codes are abstract and arbitrary. In a

Obama Care : the Facts of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act

1551 words - 7 pages OBAMACARE: The facts of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act Affordable Care Act (ACA), better known as Obamacare, is the president’s answer to the increasing healthcare costs. The purpose of this plan is to promise better quality healthcare at a more affordable cost to the Americans, and also regulate private insurance company to ensure Americans get more rights and protections on their

An Optimistic Comparison Of British National Healthcare And The Patient Protection And Affordable Care Act

1072 words - 5 pages An optimistic comparison of British National Healthcare and the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act During the past 5 years we have heard a great deal of rhetoric regarding socialism and healthcare as a result of the passing of the Affordable Care Act, particularly in how ACA compares to socialized medicine in England and the UK. The concerns of the people regarding socialism are important as our country is founded on capitalist

Related Essays

Negative Impact On Children Of Divorce

879 words - 4 pages chooses to be absent from the child’s life altogether. When the parent outside of the home misses several arranged visits or stops visiting completely this can create a confusing and disappointing environment for the child. The purpose of this essay was to examine divorce and its negative impact on the family, especially children who are left to cope after the divorced is finalized. Overall this study has provided helpful and meaningful information

The Negative Impact Of Healthcare Politics

1749 words - 7 pages What is at stake: The negative Impact of Healthcare Politics Feb. 23, 2011 A surgeon tears out of an operating room red-faced, and extremely aggravated. He proceeds to stomp down the hallway with a vengeance; his destination, the nurse’s station. He works up all his anger and releases it into the face of the charge nurse. “My God!" he clamors, “you have got to have some of the worst underlings in the history of

The Effect Of The Expansion Of Cotton Culture On Slave And Native American Population

496 words - 2 pages The Effect of the Expansion of Cotton Culture on Slave and Native American Population Overview: To understand the effect of the expansion of cotton culture on slave population. Intro: Cotton was a profitable crop, but was not grown on a large scale because of the slow and difficult process of removing seeds from cotton bolls in order to produce a usable fiber. Plantation owners determined slave labor was needed to operate the southern

The Impact Of The Hippie On American Society

2423 words - 10 pages institutionalized American society were to either participate in mass protests with their alternative lifestyles and radical beliefs or drop out of society completely. The government and the older generations could not understand their way of life. Hippies were often portrayed as criminals, subversive to the morals and best interest of the public. Although misunderstood, the hippie had a great impact throughout the country, still surviving