This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Ncaa Football Pay To Play Essay

4655 words - 19 pages

Table of Contents

1 The Ethical Issue – Whether to Pay NCAA Football Student-Athletes 3
1.1 The Case For Maintaining the Current System - Not Paying NCAA Football Student-Athletes 4
1.2 The Case For Paying NCAA Football Student-Athletes 6
1.3 Conclusion 11
1.4 References 13

The Ethical Issue – Whether to Pay NCAA Football Student-Athletes

Top college football programs make hundreds of millions of dollars in revenues each year, all without having to pay the people who actually play the game. Is it ethical for colleges to not pay their football stars for playing their hearts out on the field, building popular branding images for themselves and their ...view middle of the document...

[iv] (Exhibit 1) Additionally, starting in 2014-15, the college football postseason will consist of bowl games along with two national semifinal games and a national championship game - all of which recently earned television contracts amounting to approximately $5.5 billion over 12 years.[v] The multibillion-dollar college football industry is booming, and doesn’t show signs of slowing down anytime soon.
Yet college football players are not entitled to traditional forms of compensation for their work since the NCAA classifies Division I football players as amateurs instead of professionals. Therefore, we pose the question of whether college football players, hoping to become part of an elite group of professionals, end up becoming indentured servants to their schools during their college careers without payment, or simply the beneficiaries of a cost-free and potentially premium level of experience and education.

1 The Case For Maintaining the Current System - Not Paying NCAA Football Student-Athletes

The NCAA as a whole generates $6 billion annually, and as mentioned above, athletic conferences and coaches make millions of dollars in the process.[vi] However, there is a misconception that athletic programs in general are always profitable. Only a fraction of the programs are profitable while others operate at a cost to the universities. So the argument of pay arises in reference to student-athletes more specifically within the sports of football and basketball in institutions with high profile, high-income athletic programs. “The argument is that since such institutions receive millions of dollars from the student’s performance, their student-athletes should be paid.”[vii] Yet universities are not sports franchises and hence are required to consider all educational departments and sports equally. It would be problematic to only pay student athletes in revenue-earning sports such as college football, and not for others. Additionally, NCAA football players are indirectly paid through various benefits they receive including a free education. Therefore, the existing system of not paying NCAA college football players should not be changed.

“Collegiate sports are neither careers nor professions. It is the students’ vehicle to a higher education degree.”[viii] NCAA football players are offered scholarships and receive free tuition, room, food and money for books and other expenses. Additionally, some universities offer academic counseling and tutoring. Student athletes also receive free professional coaching, strength and fitness training, and support from athletic trainers and physical therapists, which “exceeds the equivalent of $100,000 per year in value.” [ix] Therefore, in economic terms, the above benefits constitute a form of indirect compensation, while many other students graduate “with the burden of large student loans.”[x]

Of course, the opportunity to receive a college education is worth more...

Other Papers Like Ncaa Football Pay to Play

Should We Pay Ncaa Athletes Essay

635 words - 3 pages players have just as much reason to think they should be paid. First off, NCAA division I football nationally generates 12 billion dollars a year. That’s like taking the top grossing films of the last 15 years. Combine them, and don’t pay the movie stars a penny. The NCAA basketball March Madness tournament alone makes $800 million. The players also argue that they are more than just Student Athletes. Turn on ESPN on a Tuesday night and you could

Should Student-Athletes Get Paid? Essay

1207 words - 5 pages student-athletes cannot work a job and play their respective sports. It is just too much and cannot be done because of the traveling that is done during the season due to away games. The National Collegiate Athletic Association, also known as the NCAA, is a nonprofit organization founded by Theodore Roosevelt in 1906. Since then the NCAA has grown into one of the most popular organizations in the sports world. College basketball and football play

Pay College Athletes

1794 words - 8 pages greater good of all college sports, according to London. Some believe that this is the way that college sports operate, however Kyle Veazey completely disagrees in his article, “Pay for play.” Veazey exposes the truth of how much these athletes are actually pulling in, he also exposes how much the coaches, some of teams that are not above a .500 winning percentage, are making. According to Veazey, “ the University of Tennessee football team made

Pay for Play

1766 words - 8 pages common than they are. What if the reason why student-athletes aren’t majoring in more difficult subjects is because they have to practice all the time and can’t fully apply themselves to school? The NCAA claims that student-athletes graduate at a higher rate than the general student body but does that count all the athletes who leave to play professionally? “Approximately 1 percent of NCAA men’s basketball players and 2 percent of NCAA football

Essay Questioning The NCAA And Its Policies Such As Title IX And The BCS System

1676 words - 7 pages the time." Taylor also called the NCAA "crooks" who make money off athletes but refuse to pay them. (Luhm). Granted, not all college athletes feel this way, but it is safe to say that a great number do. At the time, coach Steve Fisher assembled the 'Fab Five'; a group widely considered the most talented freshman class in NCAA history. It has recently been discovered that these players accepted money and other gifts in exchange for playing

Pay Student Athletes

3120 words - 13 pages that happened last year when the NCAA investigated Cam Newton and his father for allegedly wanting money to have Cam play at Auburn (NCAA). But when Cam played for Auburn he was wearing an under armour football uniform with 15 corporate logos as a part of Auburn’s $10.6 million deal with Under Armour (Branch). Another player named Terrell Pryor, he was a Quarterback at the Ohio State University; he sold some of his memorabilia, such as big ten

Should College Athletes Be Paid

1258 words - 6 pages , college athletes should not be paid for playing their respective sport because athletes already have positive benefits of being able to be in college and playing a sport. There are many negative aspects of paying college athletes. We can start with financial cost within the NCAA industry. This issue has mainly started with men’s basketball and football players. The issue is that if the NCAA is to pay men’s basketball and football players, they

Paying College Athletes

1777 words - 8 pages need money to spend on everyday living expenses and have the opportunity to get a job to pay for these. The NCAA needs to change their policy about giving additional money to college athletes, besides just an athletic scholarship Works Cited Dohrmann, Geroge, and Thayer Evans. "Oklahoma State Football." Sports Ilustrated n.d.: n. pag. Web. 31 Jan. 2014. Eder, Steve, and Greg Bishop. “Under Pressure, N.C.A.A. Weighs Momentous Changes.” New

Compensation of College Athletes

1806 words - 8 pages example, think about how much money the University of Georgia makes just from one home football game. The University of Georgia’s stadium, Stanford Stadium, holds 92,756 people. All of the people that attend the game have paid for a ticket to watch the athletes play and will buy food and drinks throughout the game. The money that the fans pay to get into the game and the money that they spend during the game goes to the university’s athletic program

Essay on College Athletes

2089 words - 9 pages financial opportunity and college athletes take advantage of their school’s benefits by asking for more. Some will say that the argument against allowing the pay of studentathletes comes from greed and self-interest, but I believe that it is for the better of the students. College athletics is not a stepping-stone to the professional level, but a steppingstone to a career for the future. If the NCAA continues on this path of becoming a sports

Should College Players Get Paid to Play

1673 words - 7 pages proposals that outline means to promote pay-for-play in NCAA Division I football and men’s basketball will be presented. The arguments that follow are specifically tailored for those two sports at schools who receive bonus money from the NCAA, as those universities and their coaches enjoy considerable revenue from TV contracts and sponsorships generated by bowl games and “March Madness” appearances. Collegiate athletes lay it all on the line

Related Essays

College Football And Pay For Play

2325 words - 10 pages | College Football and Pay for Play | | | | | | Introduction “The rising dollar value of the exploitation of athletes is obscene, is out of control.” -Roger Noll, Economics Professor Emeritus, Stanford The whole purpose in researching this topic was based on the fact that the researcher is a fan of college sports, football and basketball especially. As the researcher has grown into adulthood and come to

Pay To Play Essay

1170 words - 5 pages of a CEO, which in this case that would be the head coaches of these programs. Playing sports for a student should not be any different. Acordding to the New York Times, the top 15 paid coach in the NCAA football made $54.3 million combined. That hardly seems fair to the 13,877 of the division 1 college football players that made a $0 combined.The two-facedness that soaks big-money college sports takes your breath away. College football and

Pay To Play In High School

3484 words - 14 pages The Issues Surrounding “Pay-to-Play” and its Effect on Students in the United States Outline Science, Technology and Human Values Topic: Pay-to-Play I. Introduction A. About Pay-to-Play 1. “Pay-to-Play” is a policy implemented by school districts to help cover the cost of extra-curricular activities, such as sports, clubs, cheer and dance, and even some honor programs. It dates back to the 1970’s although it became more

Bcs Vs Playoff An Argumentative Essay On The System Used To Decide The Ncaa Division I College Football Champion

1026 words - 5 pages of schedule, and if a team has beaten any of the other top ten teams. A computer then adds it all up and ranks the teams accordingly; the two top teams then play each other for the national championship. Many people argue that a playoff system is a better way to find the national champion, while others are perfectly happy with the BCS system currently used. The question that many involved with college football ask is whether or not a playoff