Nature Vs Nurture Debate Essay

1421 words - 6 pages

The Nature versus Nurture Debate
Sharon Turzai
Western Governors University

The Nature versus Nurture Debate
Nature versus nurture, a debate of the influence of genetics compared to a persons’ environment has been, and continues to be a debate of scholars over many years. On one side of the argument there stands “heritability, a measure of the degree to which a characteristic is estimated to be influenced by heredity” (Wood, Wood, & Boyd, 2011, p. 247). The individuals’ environment or how, where and with whom the person was raised would be the other side of the discussion. On one hand, some believe that nature, the genetics of a person is what decides how a person shall end ...view middle of the document...

There has always been social and political conflict regarding whether or not education is not as good in a poor school district versus a more affluent one, and if a child has a higher chance of being successful in life if they are able to go to one of the wealthier schools. One issue that seems to have become more popular in more recent years is whether or not being homosexual is due to genes or upbringing. These examples are all part of the controversy surrounding the nature versus nurture debate over time.
Success is highly regarded in the US. In order to have this success, many would argue that this begins with a good, solid education. “In 2012 the median of earnings for young adults with a bachelor's degree was $46,900, while the median was $22,900 for those without a high school credential and $30,000 for those with a high school credential. In other words, young adults with a bachelor's degree earned more than twice as much as those without a high school credential (105 percent more) and 57 percent more than young adult high school completers” (National Center for Education Statistics, 2014, para. 3). This “fun fact” as the website states is not always so fun to young people that feel that higher education is not a possibility for them due to the simple fact of being born into low income situation. Intelligence is usually attributed with a person’s level of education. This topic in the nature versus nurture debate has had a lot of attention. This essay will focus on the two aforementioned examples above.
In a study by Rouse and Barrow it is argued that nurture, not nature is what will decide a student’s academic success and whether or not children born into “wealthier” families fair better in education and complete college more than their counterparts that are born into families living in poverty. The authors discuss that where a child lives, how much money their parents make and how much a parent is able to spend with their children (due to work constraints, daycare etc.) will inevitably decide the academic future of the children, not the genetic makeup of the child. “In the United States, the school a child attends is largely determined by the neighborhood where he or she lives” (Rouse & Barrow, 2006, para. 2). This study seems to conclude that the authors believe nurture, or environment to be the contributing factor to success.
J. Michael-Bailey and Richard Pillard published a study in the Archives of General Psychiatry on the prevalence of homosexuality among twins in December of 1991. The study was conducted to argue whether or not homosexuality was genetic and not due to environmental factors. Those running the study focused on groups of male twins and non-twin siblings to try and decide whether identical twin males were more apt to both be homosexual than those male siblings that do not share identical genetics. This study seems to be a solid argument that homosexuality is inherent, meaning that the person is...

Other Papers Like Nature vs Nurture Debate

Nature vs. Nurture Essay

1553 words - 7 pages Running head: NATURE VS. NURTURE/CULTURE The Ongoing Debate of Nature vs. Nurture/Culture Psychology 3520 Social Psychology Abstract In compiling information from our class text and a variety of journals in the Capella library, I have come up with some interest notions on the age old controversy of nature vs. nurture. Biologists declare nature as an innate trait given to all human being (e.g., reflexes and primary needs). Which

Nature vs. Nurture Essay

1039 words - 5 pages Brad South English 15 (Section 002) 5/1/2009 “Formal Argument” The Mysteries of Nature vs. Nurture The argument of nature versus nurture has gone on for also long as humans started to contemplate the world around them. Within this debate there are two main controversies. The first main controversy is whether or not social behavior is contributed to genes or how a person is raised. There have been many studies done to show that

Nature vs Nurture

628 words - 3 pages The Nurture side of the debate Emily Lankin Nature vs. Nurture a debate that has been discussed for centuries. When it comes to how we behave it is evident that nurture plays a much larger role. Firstly, when a child is born they have the potential ability to communicate and to walk but it is human interaction that teaches them these tasks. Secondly no human is born being a genius everyone is capable of being very smart but it is how are raised

Nature Vs Nurture

2630 words - 11 pages Nature vs. Nurture - Twin Studies Eimy Ramirez PSY304 Prof. Reed April 11, 2015 Abstract The exponential growth of scientific and biological knowledge over time has facilitated the genesis of fields of specialization, namely biological determinism, sociobiology and eugenics, just to mention a few. The common thread between these fields is their proponents collectively postulate that all human traits, including

Nature vs Nurture

559 words - 3 pages There has always been the ongoing debate as to whether nature or nurture plays a role in criminality. Some individuals may be predisposed and have a higher risk of developing criminal behavior due to some biological factors. Psychologists have been able to identify patterns using twin or adoption studies finding links with genetic testing which shows aggressiveness or the lack of self-control of one’s behavior. A meta-analysis preformed on 12

Nature Vs. Nurture

2523 words - 11 pages Untitled Final Exam There has always been debate about whether the various progressions in development during the first three years of life are the result of experiences in the environment (nurture) or whether they occur somewhat independently of experience and more so as a result of genetics (nature). Today, it is accepted that both nature and nurture play a role in the development of a human being. My views of nature and

Nature vs Nurture 6

1081 words - 5 pages , feels that children cannot be control constantly and with all the research talking place parents should rely on the one tool they have and that is their parental instinct. Centuries have passed and the debate over nature vs. nurture is still going strong in the field of psychology. Professor Jerome Kagon discovery is somewhat shocking to me but at the same time refreshing. I did not have a set opinion on the two but I use to thing that

Nature vs Nurture 7

992 words - 4 pages EXECUTIVE BUSINESS ACADEMIC WRITING NATURE Vs NURTURE NATURE Vs NURTURE I. Human behaviour and development is determined by the interaction of biological factors and environmental conditions II. Importance of biological influence A. Historical background, 1st theory/discovery Charles Darwing. B. Biological factors 1. Physical characteristics. 2. Science of

Nature vs Nurture

702 words - 3 pages shows environmental behavior of the person that is, the society they live in could be good but surrounded environment could still turn them bad if it is bad. Nature and nurture has been playing huge important role in each and every person’s life till today, and is still playing. These terms have become a huge controversial issue in today’s world, it has even affected politically and emotionally. It has still been an unclear debate of how it

Leadership: Nature vs. Nurture

1351 words - 6 pages Leadership: Nature vs. Nurture Kathleen Jessee BUS318: Organizational Behavior Professor Thomas Tonkin May 25, 2015 Leadership: Nature vs. Nurture Even though leadership can be learned, science has found that most leaders have a genetic commonality. Interestingly, leadership means the most within an organizational context. Leader follower relationships are one of the ways leadership behavior evolves and is defined. The two most

Nature Vs. Nurture. A Comprehensive Evaluation

1506 words - 7 pages There is much controversy in respect to the theory of how human development can be effect by one's environment versus their biological predisposition. Thephase "Nature vs. Nurture" has been debated for many years by Psychologist and Biologist alike. Professionals in the field have energetically argued the ideas associated to the root of ones personality traits i.e.; shyness, sexual orientation or intelligence. Both sides have valid and well

Related Essays

Nature Vs Nurture Debate Essay

2226 words - 9 pages Nurture Debate Continues” – Yahoo Voices (2005) Retrieved November 20, 2013 “The Four types of Parenting Styles” – Section 04 and 05 F11 PSY 1001 (2011) “Parenting Styles Influence Child Development and Social Mobility” – Social Mobility- Parenting Evidence Briefing (2007)

Nature Vs Nurture Essay

863 words - 4 pages Describe the basic elements of the nature-nurture controversy. The amount of influence that genes have on personality verses the influence of learning experiences is not only related to genetics but also psychology. The debate of nature- nurture controversy has been studied for over 130 years and is still being researched. “After studying many prominent English families, Galton concluded that intelligence is inherited- that nature, not

Nature Vs Nurture Essay 1631 Words

1631 words - 7 pages Nature vs. Nurture There is an issue that has been conferred upon by philosophers in the past and still so by scientists today. This issue is whether heredity or environment plays a greater role in the determining or shaping of an individual's behavior. It is known as the nature versus nurture debate. Numerous generations before us have deliberated on the reasons behind the development of human behavior. There have been many theories

Nature Vs. Nurture Essay

1692 words - 7 pages Nature vs. Nurture in Psychology PSYCH 101 Nature vs. Nurture in Psychology What makes you think, feel, and behave the way you do? Were you born predisposed to live the life you are currently living, or were you born a blank canvas upon which your experiences gave shape and expression to the person you are today? These are the types of questions the Nature vs. Nurture debate has posed and scientists have probed