This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Mureriwa Isiah: Case Note Of Mildred Mapingure V Minister Of Home Affairs And 2 Other Ministers

4229 words - 17 pages


The High Court of Zimbabwe, sitting at Harare on the 12th of December 2012 handed down judgement number HH 452/12 in the case of Mildred Mapingure -v- Ministry of Home Affairs, Ministry of Health and Child Welfare and Ministry of Justice, Legal and Parliamentary Affairs. In pronouncing the written judgement the court simply stated that the applicant‘s application for default judgement is dismissed with no order as to costs. I happened on that morning to have been seated next to the applicant, who not only seemed to be shocked by the outcome, but clearly ...view middle of the document...

Born of an unlawful and deplorable conduct, being born after such a long and protracted attempt to prevent her from being. That is what one could regard as a tragedy. A careful reading of this judgement, however, clearly shows that these other interpretations of his reference to “a tragedy’’ were very far from the judge’s imagination when he made that brief pronouncement. There is no doubt in my mind that what the judge referred to as tragic are the facts of the case he then was seized with and nothing more.
I take a different look at this. l do not mean to down-play the tragic nature of the facts, the tragedy of being born under the circumstances of Vimbainashe nor do l intend to down-play the tragedy of the multitude of woman finding themselves in the position of Mildred. With all due respect, l find the judgement of Bere J itself as a tragedy and borrowing from his own words, this judgement is no doubt a tragedy. It is a tragedy not only to the applicant in this matter. The judgement is tragic to the administration of justice in Zimbabwe. It is a tragedy to Zimbabwean jurisprudence, a real tragedy to the realization of the special needs of women in our jurisdiction (and the need for our courts to authoritatively declare our government’s internationally accepted obligation to ensure the protection of women exposed to violence from the consequences of the violence visited upon them). It is indeed a true tragedy to our legal history and in the few pages that follow herein l shall endeavour to show how tragic this judgement really is to our law.

In Plaintiffs Further Supplementary Heads of Arguments page 8, l quoted verbatim, Robert E Keeton, writing as early as 1962 (Creative Continuity in the Law of Torts Harvard Law Review, Volume 75 Number 3 (1962) page 463 when he wrote as follows:-
‘’Any legal system to remain viable over a span of time, must have flexibility to admit change. To find solutions for a succession of differing problems in a continuously changing context, it must be creative. Creativity must build upon a solid foundation of continuity. Modern developments in tort law present acutely the problems of accommodating (these) competing demands for creativity and stability.’’
In those words Keeton, clearly shows how tragic the judgement and not just the facts in Mildred Mapingure-v- Minister of Home Affairs and 2 Other Ministers, is to Zimbabwean law.

For the sake of space, I will not repeat the facts of this matter as they are clearly set out in the judgment of Bere J. I refer the reader to pages 1 through to pages 4 of the judgment with the single correction that on page 2 thereof, in the place of the phrase “terminate pregnancy” as used therein by the Honourable Judge, should be replaced with the phrase “prevent pregnancy” in compliance with the exact words used by the applicant in her application and affidavit of evidence.

On pages 4 – 5 of the judgement, Bere J pointed out...

Other Papers Like Mureriwa Isiah: Case Note of Mildred Mapingure -V- Minister of Home Affairs and 2 Other Ministers

Department of Veterans Affairs Essay

2023 words - 9 pages The Department of Veterans Affairs Information Management System: Serving those that Served Punefuolemotu E.L. Aiumu Everest University MBA Degree Program Information Management System Abstract I selected this title because I served in the United States Army from 2003 to 2010. I was deployed to Iraq in support of Operation Iraqi Freedom and several other operations. However, when I left the Service it became clear to me years later that

Psychology Phenomenon of My Love Affairs

1168 words - 5 pages Psychology of My Love Affairs Taking this course is probably the first time that I truly discover Psychology and I found it very applicable in our daily lives. As I go through the lectures, interestingly I found that many of the concepts and theories could be used to explain my behavior in a relationship that I had, which is currently over. I would like to share with you my discoveries and thoughts in this journal. The first thing that I

Case Study Analysis Of Palsgraf V. Long Island Railroad Company

858 words - 4 pages Case Study Analysis of Palsgraf v. Long Island Railroad Company Michael J. Roberts Liberty University Palsgraf v. Long Island Rail Company is a case where the plaintiff, Ms. Palsgraf, was on one end of a train platform when a package was knocked out of the hands of another passenger who was attempting to board a moving train with the assistance of a guard, the defendant, on the other end of the train platform. The package being knocked

Case Brief/Kelo V. City of New London

669 words - 3 pages Kelo v. City of New London, 125 S. Ct. 2655 (2005). Facts: The city of New London, CT hired an independent agency to revitalized one of its waterfront properties. This revitalization was intended to create jobs and generate tax revenue for the city. To accomplish this, the independent agency was given authority to acquire the properties by buying them or eminent domain. The independent agency acquired majority of the properties, but some

Analysis of the Samsung Galaxy Note Commercial

857 words - 4 pages RUNNING HEAD: ANALYSIS OF THE SAMSUNG GALAXY NOTE COMMERCIAL Analysis of the Samsung Galaxy Note Commercial BUS 620 Managerial Marketing Dr. Patricia A. Ryan February 20, 2012 Analysis of the Samsung Galaxy Note Commercial Advertising is defined as, “Any paid form of non-personal (i.e. through some medium, such as radio, print, direct mail, or e-mail) presentation and promotion of ideas, goods, or services by an identified sponsor

Case Brief #2 : Foxconn V Byd, Part B

409 words - 2 pages Case Brief #2 : Foxconn v BYD, Part B After four individuals were convicted due to stealing trade secrets of Foxconn, the case took a dramatic turn when prosecutors dropped all criminal charges against BYD in December 2008. At the same time, the global manufacturing industry was hit hard because of the severe global recession starting in late 2008. To generate extra revenues for survival from the global recession, one of Foxconn's strategies

Philosophy of Life and Other Essays

2394 words - 10 pages governed by self-interest. Morality is a code of conduct to ensure that our actions are not just governed by self interest, but the interest of other members of the society is also taken into consideration. Morality has relevance only in context of society. No action is moral or immoral for a man living in isolation. Mans observance to this code of conduct, which we call morality or goodness, partly comes from within himself and partly results from

Pastoral Counselling Competencies of the Convention Baptist Ministers’ Association Janiuay-Badiangan Circuit Members


Comparison "Soldier's Home" and "Speaking of Courage"

1140 words - 5 pages Comparison "Soldier's Home" And "Speaking Of Courage" To be engaged in war is to be engaged in an armed conflict. Death is an all too ordinary product of war. It is an unsolicited reward for many soldiers that are fighting for their country’s own fictitious freedom. For some of these men, the battlefield is a glimpse into hell, and for others, it is a means to heaven. Many people worry about what happens during war and what will become of their

Problem of Other Mind

2303 words - 10 pages one can say that he has opened a Pandora’s box; the fact it that since the discursion on the mind by Descartes, the world of philosophy is not quite the same. Descartes postulates that a person’s own mind is primarily what they are and knows best, this does not account for the existence of other minds. However there is an underlying reality to which we all will ponder: can we really prove definitively that there are other minds other than

An Analysis of the Supreme Court Case: Fisher V. University of Texas

1808 words - 8 pages as a factor when judging the students individually, which in reality would only affect the University of Texas. The other outcome is to declare affirmative action unconstitutional. This outcome would have a greater impact since it would affect all other public schools. The precedent of Gratz v. Bollinger would be overturned and they would have to abide by the new ruling instead. The last possibility is that there is a tie since there is a

Related Essays

Case Note Takamore V Clarke

1716 words - 7 pages v Clarke’ | The Court of Appeal judgment explained the decisions of the minority and majority judges in greater depth. Demonstrates the procedural history of the case. | Takamore v Clarke [2012] NZSC 116, [2013] 2 NZLR 733. | Westlaw; case title search ‘Takamore v Clarke’ | The Supreme Court judgment was the basis of my case note. It was my primary source of information. I used it to ascertain the majoirty and minority judgements. | Murdoch

Baker V.Canada Minister Of Citizenship And Immigrtion

598 words - 3 pages Baker v. Canada Minister of Citizenship and Immigration 1. 2. 3. 9 Simpson J. certified the following as a “serious question of general importance” under s. 83(1) of the Immigration Act: “Given that the Immigration Act does not expressly incorporate the language of Canada’s international obligations with respect to the International Convention on the Rights of the Child, must federal immigration authorities treat

'ministers Have Considerable Power And Opportunity To Restrain A Prime Minister'. Discuss

713 words - 3 pages MP’s have the opportunity to influence policy at various stages of the legislative process. The legislative process begins with the first reading of a bill, in which the original bill is published and read out to the commons. This is followed by the second reading, which provides opportunity for debate from MPs, which follows with a vote to proceed to committee stage. The committee stage gives the chance for a public bills committee, created

Veterans Affairs And Loss Of Private Information

446 words - 2 pages security data theft immediately to their respective high ranking officials or high ranking personnel such as VA Secretary R. James Nicholson. On the other hand, the data analyst who took home the data and resulted for being stolen had been fired due to his action has violated agency procedure. The agency has estimated that it will cost between $100 million to $500 million to prevent and cover possible losses from the data theft. Though