Multiculturalism And The Canadian Identity Essay

2590 words - 11 pages

Multiculturalism and the Canadian identity.
What is Canada? What is a Canadian? Canada, to employ Voltaire's analogy, is nothing but “a few acres of snow.”. Of course, the philosopher spoke of New France, when he made that analogy. More recently, a former Prime Minister, Joe Clark, said that the country was nothing but a “community of communities”. Both these images have helped us, in one way or another, try to interpret what could define this country. On the other hand, a Canadian could be a beer, a hockey-playing beaver or even a canoe floating in a summer day's sunset. A Canadian could also be a “sovereigntyphobe”, refusing to see the liquefaction, albeit political, ...view middle of the document...

In the province, the word multiculturalism announces pejorative meanings. This was due, in part, to the fact that “a federal commission which was charged several years ago with the task of developing policies for Canada, based on its bicultural and bilingual character emerged with a recommendation that Canada think of itself as a multicultural and bilingual country.3”. Francophones, on the other hand, felt that this concept placed them at the same level as minority ethnic groups, thus erasing their thoughts of being seen as one of the country's founding nations.

Religious symbolism and governmental position
In 1985, a request, made by Baltej Singh Dhillon, who asked to allow the addition of a religious symbol to the RCMP's emblematic red uniform, changed the way the force was perceived, in the country. This gesture begged one question: Would a religious symbol be accepted, in any given governmental environment, where religious attire is often seen a source of tension? For many, the RCMP was seen as the pinnacle of Canadian identity. As a result, many groups felt that a turban would not have the same level of symbolic sanctity as the Stetson hat, worn by RCMP officers. The Canadian population also felt that allowing a member of the RCMP to wear a turban would compromise the country's institutionalized identity. Professor Fred Bennett “thought the decision wrong, arguing that ordinary people will perceive a turbaned Sikh as compromising the neutrality of the RCMP.”4. He also “argued that such a change in a state's national institution needs to be resisted, even at the cost of equal opportunity for a small minority.5”. Oppositely, it was argued that “because the RCMP is a national symbol, it should allow the turban to symbolize the country's officially endorsed multicultural identity.6”. The case got through the RCMP's hierarchical layers and the Commissioner at the time, Norman Inkster, got wind of the situation. As a result, Inkster gave his support to Dhillon. This support given by the commissioner echoed in the House of Commons. On March 16th 1990, the Solicitor General, Pierre Cadieux, stated that the policy was amended, thus allowing Dillon to wear his turban in the line of duty. Bruce Ryder stated that “the RCMP changed its uniform policy (in 1990) to bring it into conformity with the concept of equal religious citizenship that had emerged in Canadian human rights law.7”. By taking this decision, Cadieux and the Mulroney government wanted to “accommodate the changing ethnocultural, racial and religious character of Canada.8”.
However, this decision did not please all groups within the Canadian population. For example, a group of retired RCMP officers argued, in federal court, that a turban would infringe their constitutional right to have a secular state, free of all religious symbols. The nucleus of the protest came from the Western part of the country, where the RCMP's symbolization is quasi-sacred. Elspeth...

Other Papers Like Multiculturalism And The Canadian Identity

Describe The Similarities And Differences In The Way Identity Is Conceptualised By The Psychosocial Theory Of Identity And Social Identity Theory

1896 words - 8 pages Part 1 Essay Describe the similarities and differences in the way identity is conceptualised by the psychosocial theory of identity and social identity theory. I will start this essay by explaining both theories, Psychosocial theory and Social Identity Theory mentioning what is understood by identity and answering my essay question describing their similarities and differences. Identity is a major area of study for

Racism And Identity In Ralph Ellison’S The Invisible Man

2308 words - 10 pages invisible man!” (13). throughout the novel, the search for identity becomes a major aspect for the narrator’s journey to identify who he is in this world. The speaker considers himself to be an “invisible man” but he defines his condition of being invisible due to his race (Kelly). Identity and race becomes an integral part of the novel. The obsession with identity links the narrator with the society he lives in, where race defines the characters in the

The Hopeless Plight: Edna's Struggle with Identity and Society

853 words - 4 pages , and the identity of a mother-woman does not provide that. In contrast to Adele Ratignolle, Mademoiselle Reisz offers Edna an alternativeto the role of being yet another mother-woman. Mademoislle Reisz has in abundance the autonomy that Adele completely lacks. But Reisz's life lacks love, while Adele abounds in it. Mademoiselle Reisz's loneliness makes clear that an adequate life cannot build altogether upon autonomy. Although she has a secure

Why the Decriminalization and Legalization of Cannabis Would Improve Canadian Society

1488 words - 6 pages Why the Decriminalization and Legalization of Cannabis Would Improve Canadian Society Criminology 101 - Section 02 Nikaya Mirhadi-Pathon Capilano University Cannabis, the plant from which marijuana is derived, is the most widely used, produced and trafficked drug worldwide (Ducatti Flister, 2012). The decriminalization of marijuana has been a widely debated topic on a global scale as many advocate for it’s therapeutic purposes. In the

History, Culture And Identity Of Mothers And Daughters In Amy Tan’S The Joy Luck Club

1471 words - 6 pages History, Culture and Identity of Mothers and Daughters in Amy Tan’s The Joy Luck Club     Amy Tan’s The Joy Luck Club is a novel that deals with many controversial issues. These issues unfold in her stories about four Chinese mothers and their American raised daughters. The novel begins with the mothers talking about their own childhood’s and the relationship that they had with their mothers. Then it focuses on the daughters and how they

How The Renaissance, Reformation And Nation-States Contributed To The Concept Of European Identity?

2018 words - 9 pages MERVE DENİZ 13735009 How the Renaissance, Reformation and Nation-States Contributed to the Concept of European Identity? 1. Introduction I would like to study the connection between the material culture that sprang to life after the Reformation in Europe and the urbanization that came with the Industrial Revolution in order to see if or if not it had any effects on constituting the European Identity

Outlined to Different Psychological Approaches to Identity. What Are the Strengths and Weaknesses of Each

2167 words - 9 pages Outline two different psychological approaches to Identity. What are the strengths and weaknesses of each? If asked most people would have an opinion about identity and what it means to them. In this essay two different approaches are outlined which are Psychosocial theory by Eric Erickson and James Marcia and the Social Constructionist theory which as ‘diverse origins in a number disciplines and as many perspectives’ (p69 book 1). In

The Rubicon of Sexual Identity: Capitalist Predialectic Theory and Debordist Image

625 words - 3 pages perceptions of society. It could be said that any number of discourses concerning capitalist predialectic theory exist. Parry[3] states that we have to choose between precultural rationalism and dialectic materialism. But Debordist image implies that art is elitist. Many theories concerning the collapse, and some would say the stasis, of posttextual sexual identity may be discovered. 3. Madonna and capitalist predialectic theory The

Identity Crisis in Adolescence as Portrayed by Erik Ericson in Relation to Stories of "The Catcher in the Rye" and "Ragged Dick"

1652 words - 7 pages Identity Crisis in Adolescence as Portrayed by Erik Ericson in Relation to Stories of "The Catcher in the Rye" and "Ragged Dick" Erikson defines identity crisis as “a time of intensive analysis and exploration of different ways of looking at oneself” (Erikson, 20-27). He studied cultural life among various indigenous tribes such as the Yurok of Northern California and the Sioux of South Dakota from which he developed the theories of

A Sense of Belonging Is Integral to the Development of Identity. Is This Your View? in Your Response, Refer to Core Text and One Additional

1070 words - 5 pages A sense of belonging is integral to the development of one’s identity. However, this is an oversimplification of what constitutes to the development of one’s identity. Both belonging and identity complement one another, thus if one is unable to belong, then their ability to form and relate with their identity is compromised. It is only through finding a sense of identity, that contentment can be achieved, thus, belonging enriched. Within the

Hesse Biber- Am I Thin Enough Yet? The Cult of Thinness and the Commercialization of Identity

1707 words - 7 pages . There are also extremities or positions of higher authority with extreme involvement in cults, much like the level of devotion in The Cult of Thinness.      Daily actions of checking and critiquing can be performed in many ways. Body monitoring offers an array of resources. Constantly weighing one’s self is a way of achieving quantitative precision. Being able to pinpoint an exact gain or loss is a necessity in this

Related Essays

Identity, Olympics, And The Canadian Myth (1st Year Cultural Studies Paper)

1131 words - 5 pages I'm A Stranger Here Myself: Identity, Olympics, and the Canadian Myth In this essay I am going to look at Olympic line of products, and what they represent about identity and consumer culture. For the purposes of this essay, I focus only on the knitted Cowichan sweater (Please see Appendix A), and the red wool mittens (Please see Appendix B), since these are the things that have come to define “campus cool” and the Canadian Olympic identity

Mgmt 415 Multiculturalism And The International Company

1412 words - 6 pages Multiculturalism and the International Company MGMT - 415 American InterContinental University January 13, 2013 Abstract This paper will cover issues that a company may face in a foreign country, as well as what can happen if cultural barriers and diversity is ignored, the importance of diversity in the international arena and the importance of these items in PPQ Parts expansion in Germany and Japan

Canadian Morality And The Law Essay

3078 words - 13 pages Canadian Morality and the Law     In legal theory, there is a great debate over whether or not law should be used to enforce morality.  The sides of the debate can be presented as a continuum.  At one end, there is the libertarian view, which holds that morality is an individual belief and that the state should not interfere in the affairs of the individual.  According to this view, a democracy cannot limit or enforce morality.   At the

Describe The Similarities And Differences In The Way Identity Is Conceptualised By The Psychosocial Theory Of Identity And The Social Identity Theory

1723 words - 7 pages Describe the similarities and differences in the way identity is conceptualised by the psychosocial theory of identity and the social identity theory. This paper looks at two identity theories, Psychosocial theory and The Social Identity Theory. Beginning with an overview of each, then discussing similarities and differences including the background of the researchers, their research methods and the evidence they found. Erik Erikson