This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Moral Luxuries Essay

1277 words - 6 pages

Monica Baker
Instructor Elgersma
Philosophy 103 Section 07
26 April 2014
Moral Luxuries
Opinions are inevitable when discussing any topic and they can change throughout a discussion depending on the person. However, definitions cannot change and are set in stone. Philosophies are just like definitions, the ideas are set in stone and each philosopher has made it their own. The idea of morality that embodies most philosophies is trickier and is a mix of both a definition and opinion. No matter what the definition is, one persons’ opinion could interpret that definition in many different ways. Trying to establish the morality of an action is even trickier than the idea of morality itself. ...view middle of the document...

This is the view that we ought to act for the sake of pleasure. In laments terms, John Stuart Mill believes that the end is pleasure and happiness equals pleasure.
To begin analyzing the question of the morality of expending resources on luxuries from the standpoint of John Stuart Mills, you have to take utilitarianism in its broadest sense and then break it down from there. In its broadest form, the utilitarian philosophy is a specific form of consequentialism; focusing on the consequence of the act to determine the morality of that said act. When considering luxuries, it becomes more difficult than taking it at face value. You have to consider different levels of class and what resources are essential for surviving for each of the different classes.
If someone in the upper class buys a high end suit, it would be considered a luxury but in the eyes of Mill, it would be morally justifiable because it promotes happiness and does not have any negative consequences. The action does not harm anyone and it was done for the sake of pleasure. The suit was also bought to keep up an image that is required for certain businesses and if you do not adhere to the image you could lose your job which would produce the reverse of happiness.
Narrowing utilitarianism down a little bit, you have both act-utilitarianism and rule-utilitarianism. You can use the same example of the high end suit to show how Mill would find the expenditure of resources on luxuries would be morally justifiable by both act and rule utilitarianism. For act-utilitarianism, the reasoning is very similar to that of utilitarianism in its broadest form. The consequences of the action, buying the suit, are evaluated by the principle of utility. Meaning, acts are right as they promote happiness and wrong as they do the opposite. Buying the suit is promoting the happiness of the person and the business as a whole by keeping up the image and allowing for the survival of both the business and all of its employees.
For rule-utilitarianism, the act would be considered morally justifiable because it was evaluated based on rules after the rules had been established on the principle of utility. When the person bought the high end suit, he was following suit with the rules and or code of conduct of the business. If you do not dress correctly, you could lose your job because you would not be following the code of conduct that you agreed to when joining the company. Losing your job would produce the reverse of happiness, so it was morally correct to buy the high end suit instead of using resources to provide other persons with the necessities of life.
When you break down Mill’s utilitarianism even more, you get to the fact that Mill was also an ethical...

Other Papers Like Moral Luxuries

Week 2 Assingment Essay

1335 words - 6 pages Famine Andrea Knowles Ethics and moral reasoning PHI 208 Edwin Teall 10-29-2013 Explain Singer`s goal in this article, and then present Singer`s argument that supports his position. I think Singer`s goal here is to inform people of the famine of a Bengal, starving country, and to show us that making certain decisions, proper decisions or contributions from the more wealthy will not only benefit ourselves but the others around us

Famine, Affluence, and Morality Essay

1256 words - 6 pages . Singer thinks that wealthy nations and their citizens should, instead of spending excess funds on luxuries donate that money to the needy. He does not consider this a charitable act of good but an obligation, because without this these people will not survive. That is where the moral categories are upset, what is good but ok not to do. Charity is thought of as generosity but not giving is not looked down upon. Another objection to Singer is

Free Trade

1247 words - 5 pages begun: prices were dropping, and luxuries were becoming a separate category of goods themselves (Gross, 2014). Though still at war with other European powers, Britain was engaged in foreign trade that was essential to its economic prowess. Adam Smith saw opportunity in foreign trade. As Smith would agree, it makes no sense for a state, even one as big and powerful as the British Empire, to try and obtain all land and its resources. Its other fixed

Using Material from Item a and Elsewhere Assess the Contribution of Religion to Social Change (18 Marks)

1030 words - 5 pages their success performed a psychological function for followers to cope with their salvation panic. Also due to their driven work force they accumulated wealth efficiently but did not allow themselves to spend it on luxuries. Instead they reinvested into their businesses which grew more and gained more profit which was again reinvested and so on. In Weber’s view this is the very spirit of modern capitalism – where the object is simply the acquisition

Hamlet- Loyalty Essay

1201 words - 5 pages is destined to avenge his father’s death, ‘How all occasions do inform against me, And spur my dull revenge’ and yet his moral values, formed on the basis of his Christian ethics, hinders his actions of vengeance. Hamlet’s Christian morals form the basis of his dilemma. The belief in the existence of ghosts and the presence of supernatural forces of good and evil leads to Hamlet’s resolve to seek more convincing evidence and ‘catch the conscience

First Empires

865 words - 4 pages League * Peloponnesain League ** The Funeral Oration of Pericles Athens 1. Trade/luxuries 2. Freedom values/democracy 3. State honors dead a. payed for funeral, education, etc of children 4. family ties important 5. welcome outsiders 6. glorifying their city/patriotic 7. military strength/intellegents 8. way fo life causes military 9. poverty recognize/need to fix 10. within

Assess How Useful Sources C and D Would Be for an Historian Studying the Impact of Total War on the Home Fronts During World War I

702 words - 3 pages , would not affect the home front, however as the war progressed the home front was met with a serious reality check. All luxuries were no longer available and all metals and coal were focused at the war effort. The source describes this by stating the lack of coal and explaining the reasons for the public places closing was so the coal was not wasted. The source is only focused on the German home front and does not give an indication on the

Madame Bovary

934 words - 4 pages both by the weakness of her own character and by the repressive moral standards of her age. At the same time, the book levels a scathing attack on nineteenth-century bourgeois values, exposing what Flaubert perceived to be the self-righteousness and crassness of middle-class society.” (LitFinder) According to the Oxford English Dictionary, a “satire” is a poem or a novel, film, or other work of art which uses humour, irony, exaggeration, or

Adam Smith

3597 words - 15 pages Introduction Known as one of the founding fathers of economics, Adam Smith is one of the most influential writers of his time. His works seem to be able to transcend time and cultures to the extent that his books are still in circulation today and are heavily debated. From his first famous work “Theory of Moral Sentiments” to “An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations” Adam Smith showed that he was a leading mind in


1373 words - 6 pages Canada and attempts are made to teach Naomi to be more outspoken and to form strong moral values. Due to this Naomi is tossed between the guidance of her two aunts, Obasan and Emily, through their differing forms of communication, lifestyle traits and Nisei and Sansei traditions, as a result she forms her own lifestyle path and discovers her complete identity.The differing forms of communication by the two aunts play a role in Naomi's lifestyle

Crime And Deviance

1123 words - 5 pages Evaluate Marxist explanations of Crime and Deviance Labelling theory paved the way in understanding how deviance was something defined by social processes. In this way social agencies such as the police defined what was deviant. Marxists took this view even further by examining the power of certain social groups to define deviance and create the laws which secured social conformity. Marxists see crime and deviance as not coming from moral or

Related Essays

The Nature Of Justice In Society And The Individual According To Plato

2358 words - 10 pages corresponding types in society,” (Plato 54). Therefore, Plato makes his case through his plan for an ideally just society. Plato believes that in many ways a minimal state is best; it provides for benefits of specialization, division of labor, and the capability to meet the needs of the people. The problems with a minimalist society are that some people within the society will always want luxuries, some people outside the society will want to

Slavery In The Chocolate Industry Essay

525 words - 3 pages misrepresentation.I believe that Scrushy lacked moral character altogether. Moral is defined as "the standards that an individual or a group has about what is right and wrong or good and evil." This writing made it sound as though Mr. Scrushy enjoyed all the luxuries of the lifestyle he afforded himself and did not care too much about what he had to do to keep it. He was worried about image and image alone. Unless Beam was lying and Scrushy really didn't

On Singer's Solution Essay

636 words - 3 pages need as much as possible. Singer presents moral issue by raising the concern that innocent beings are dying from hunger around the world, while people from developed countries are pouring money into luxuries simply for pleasure. It could be argued that those people value superficial substances over lives of children. Thus, they fail to live up to their moral obligations. Furthermore, the money donated to charitable agencies could make a life-or

Opium War Essay

555 words - 3 pages . Luxuries such as tea, silk and porcelain were just a few of the hot commodities coming from Chinese ships. China’s moral opposition to this trade, once China realized what opium did to its people, didn’t sit well with western countries because it implied less or no more trade. It was at this point that rules were thrown into treaties. Rules like ‘tariff autonomy’ and ‘most favored nation’ made sure the British were getting the best of the best of