Moral Lecture Essay

587 words - 3 pages

Readings discussed:
Precis of the lecture, including careful presentation of any explicitly formulated arguments.
The main topic of the January 22nd lecture was Ashley’s case. Ashley was a girl who was born with low mental capacity. Her condition made her family concerned that they wouldn’t have been able to take care of her if she continued to grow at such a rapid rate. In response to this concern, Ashley’s family gave her a high dose of estrogen to limit her growth. They had Ashley undergo a hysterectomy as well as have her breast buds removed. The way Ashley’s parents handled her condition raises a serious moral question of right and wrong. Were Ashley’s parents right to do what they did and was it even their decision to make in the first place; or was what they did wrong for mutilating Ashley’s body when she had no say in ...view middle of the document...

You could also argue that the decision Ashley’s parents made to give her the surgeries was morally wrong. Some might say that the decision to keep Ashley’s body small didn’t benefit Ashley at all, but rather was entirely beneficial to her family. Other arguments are that there were other options to take care of Ashley and that her disability didn’t justify the decision to mutilate her body.
Whichever way you view Ashley’s case, it brings up some issues about morality and tough moral questions. Moral questions cannot be answered by what the majority of people believe. Majority belief doesn’t always mean it’s the right answer. Legal arrangements also don’t determine what is morally right and wrong. People will always question what the law ought to be pertaining to certain situations. The answers to tough moral questions depend on what the facts are as well as what the consequences and alternatives are. While facts never vary between people per situation, consequences and alternatives do. These varying consequences and alternatives between people is what can cause people to have different moral views from one another. In this case, Ashley’s parents’ consequences and alternatives to not have the surgery for Ashley were much different from everyone else’s consequences and alternatives, including Ashley’s. It’s this difference that causes peoples’ views and beliefs on morality to vary from person to person. The answers to moral questions are not all equally correct. The fact that moral questions can be “real questions” with very different consequences and alternatives for every person is what makes people have different moral beliefs from one another. Sometimes people judge the rationality of their decision by weighing competing answers to the moral question. In other words, moral questions are “rationally resolvable”.

1) Not all moral answers are equally correct- there are “real questions”
2) It is possible to judge rationally between competing answers- “rationally resolvable”

Other Papers Like Moral Lecture

Morals Essay

301 words - 2 pages “When we judge other we leave no room to love them.” (Mother Teresa) Not one person should have the right to be a self-appointed moral guardian. Everyone has different morals and different aspects on life, if this would happen it would be a dictatorship basically. Every person in the universe is entitled to their opinions and should not have to be judged based off of their opinions. For instance, in “The Possibility of Evil”, Helen Crane has

Kingdom and Culture Essay

1730 words - 7 pages generally engaged to define the connection concerning Christians and the fundamental culture in which we reside (GCU, lecture). On the other hand, this disguises a significant opinion: similar when Christians discard their immediate culture, culture itself endures the average of their presence as they generate a Christian culture this essay focuses on “Yoder's and Niebuhr's views, respond to the aforementioned question? And was the "Christian situation

Ted Talks

286 words - 2 pages * Jonathan Haidt: The moral roots of liberals and conservatives In the first video Salvador Dali is used as an example of an artist who had an open mind. Although this was true, he was not clearly a "liberal" by Haidt's definition. I found it an interesting talk on the differences between liberals and conservatives in terms of importance of the 5 key values. One thing that stood out for me is the supposed rejection of authority by liberals as

Case Study, Fetal Abnormalities

616 words - 3 pages theories. These include the theories based on human properties, based on sentience, and based on relationships. Marco is believed to also fit into believing multiple theories. These include the theories based on cognitive properties, moral agency, sentience, and relationships. Maria can fit into believing two of the theories, being, the theory based on human properties and relationships. Lastly, Dr. Wilson fits to believe the theory of relationships

Research Analysis for Penguin

743 words - 3 pages fourth, how can we make decisions about technology that will get us to the future we want? Once we understand the role of technology in society and the world we want to build, we must develop strategies for getting us from here to there. __________________________________________________________ M/W Lecture Calendar Monday, January 12th Opening class (no readings) Wednesday, January 14th E.M. Forster, “The Machine Stops

Morality In Huckleberry Finn

1659 words - 7 pages Morality has always been defined as having either a good or evil conscious. There is always a choice that a character makes that defines their moral integrity in a literary work and distinguishes them as the hero. In Mark Twain’s story, “Adventures of Huckleberry Finn”, not only does Huck encounters a number of moral circumstances where he or other characters displays situations in which moral ethics is called to questioned, but it proves that

Civic Education

850 words - 4 pages Civic Education   Gordon Gee in The Grace Adams Tanner Lecture in Human Values on April 28, 1999 mandates that the modern university "must provide the moral, intellectual, social cultural, and emotional framework into which [students] can properly place the pieces of the puzzle of life. We [the university] must help our students accommodate not only their hopes and aspirations, but also the inevitable fears, disillusionment, the

Lifecycle of an Empire

913 words - 4 pages Abstract Dynasties or empires have a natural life span just like humans and usually only last three generations. There are many reasons as to the decline; bureaucratic corruption, inequitable economic burdens, costly technology, moral decline or even external enemies to name a few (Upshur, Terry, Holoka, Goff, & Cassar, 2002, p. 171). Whatsoever the reason, what an empire leaves behind can be contributed to the spread of ideas and practices

Lecture Today

719 words - 3 pages Lecture Today He worked at Yum Foods under KFC. From there, he met with the CEO of Pepsi (Rogers something) to talk about how they could fix their system. Workers at Yum food were stealing from Pizza Hut or KFC and getting fired but were getting hired at other Yum restaurants and did the same thing. The issue was that the franchises were not integrated together so they couldn’t keep track of these people. Another issue was the delivery

Business Eyhics In Cisco

962 words - 4 pages . This activity clearly links back in with the four pillars of business ethics, Rights being the most obvious point of contact. Cisco has a moral obligation to ensure the safety and well-being of their employees of whom do so much work contributing to the companies success. Under the pillar of rights its states “Good things are done because they are the right thing to do” (Lecture notes, 2016). A few highlights from the the audit from 2015 shows that

Womens Rights

410 words - 2 pages Women's Rights Conventions met in Worcester Massachusetts. Female Quakers local to the area organized the meeting along with Elizabeth Cady Stanton, who was not a Quaker. They planned the event during a visit to the area by Philadelphia based Lucretia Mott. Mott a Quaker, was famous for her oratorical ability which was rare during an era which women were often not allowed to speak in public. The meeting had six sessions included a lecture on law

Related Essays

Ethics Essay

1765 words - 8 pages going to say that our good will is guided by reason which prevents us from acting on the wrong kinds of motives. This is where Kant transitions to moral worth being determined by duty. Performing a duty is simply acting in accordance with moral law which is essentially his definition of a good motive. (Supported by lecture notes-11/14) One might ask what determines a duty. The categorical imperative explains this. A categorical imperative will

Nancy Etcoff: Happiness And Its Surprises

526 words - 3 pages achieves his or her biological needs they can rise above themselves and be motived to reach self-actualization in life. Finally Nancy ends her lecture with a few quotes; the moral of her lecture was to show us the different ways people experience happiness in their life.

What Is Human Memory? Essay

610 words - 3 pages Instructor: Slaton Psych 2 Fall 2009 General Psych Study Guide: Exam 2 Chapter 4 and Lecture What is the definition of human memory provided in your textbook and lecture? Describe the results of Sperling’s experiment on the storage capacity of sensory memory. The results of the Sperling experiment suggest that the storage capacity of sensory memory is how many items? On average (plus or minus 2) what is the storage capacity

Ile E104 Ethics Essay

1143 words - 5 pages ]. Chaplain Weed, Sean. "Resident E104 Video Ethics Presentation: Moral Objectivism and Ethical Relativism." Lecture, CGSC from US Army, Fort Leavenworth. [ 5 ]. "Louis P. Pojman; An Argument Against Ethical Relativism." E103 Reading A. Accessed March 15, 2015. https://cgsc.blackboard.com/bbcswebdav/pid-180453-dt-content-rid-684489_1/institution/CGSC/AY13-14/ADL_PH1/E103/E103RA.pdf. [ 6 ]. ADRP 1, The Army Profession. 14 June 2013. Chapter 1; 1-23. [ 7 ]. ADRP 1, The Army Profession. 14 June 2013. Chapter 1; 1-24-1-29.