Moral Issues In "A Time To Kill"

1113 words - 5 pages

Moral Issues in Film: A Time to Kill
Jamienail Wood
Embry Riddle Aeronautical University

HUMN 330
Professor Cheryl McKinley
February 15, 2015
A Time to Kill
The film “A Time to Kill” was released in 1996. The story is very intriguing and well-written. The movie is about racial inequality. Two white men, Billy and James, approached a 10 year old black girl named Tonya from the street, raped and nearly murdered her. Tonya’s family and community was devastated, especially her father, Carl Hailey (played by actor Samuel Jackson). Carl inquired about the case with a white local town lawyer, Jake Brigance (played by actor Matthew McConaughey). Brigance spoke of the possibility ...view middle of the document...

The story starts off with a situation that captures its audience’s attention. A 10 year old black girl is raped and nearly murdered by two white men in a community where blacks are not treated so equal. What happens next? What will her family do? The main cast of the films are faced with moral dilemmas that all affect their lives and the lives of those around them.
Carl Hailey
Carl Hailey faces an ethical dilemma. Should he leave it up to his local justice system to sentence the two suspects or take the law into his own hands? He approaches Jake Brigance, a white local lawyer, who spoke of the possibility that the suspects might walk. This factor might have convinced Carl Hailey to take the law into his own hands. He might have also been persuaded more by a logical fallacy, a hasty generalization. He might have thought that because a similar case in another town where suspects of raping a black girl walked away, the same outcome will result in his daughter’s case.
Carl Hailey takes the law into his own hands. He shot the two men in broad day light and accidentally injured the police escort. The way Carl Hailey was thinking can fall under the theory of utilitarianism. Utilitarianism is the principle of utility: Choose the course of action that will maximize happiness and minimize unhappiness for the greatest number of people (Rosenstand, p232, 2013). By taking the lives of those two men, he prevented the possibility of them being out in the streets, raping other children, and taking advantage of the justice system. According to David Hume, nothing is good or bad in itself, not even murder and that the goodness lies within the feelings toward the act (Rosenstand, p205, 2013). What we want to happen is morally right and Carl Hailey saw that avenging his daughter is what he wanted, morally right in his eyes.
Jake Brigance
Jake Brigance, a white local town lawyer, represented Carl Hailey in the murder case. Jake faced an ethical dilemma when approached by Carl Hailey. Carl Hailey had given Jake the impression that he was about to commit a crime. However, Brigance failed to report this to the local authorities. As a result, Carl went through with his plan and committed murder. Brigance...

Other Papers Like Moral Issues in "A Time to Kill"

Prejudice in to Kill a Mockingbird

784 words - 4 pages Prejudice in To Kill A Mockingbird Prejudice is a strong word. In the novel, To Kill A Mockingbird, a black man, Tom Robinson, was accused of raping a white woman, Mayella Ewell, and was brought to trial. There were distinct views concerning Tom Robinson's innocence – views influenced by prejudice. The townspeople of Maycomb believed in Tom's guilt while Atticus and the children believed in Tom's innocence. The townspeople

Inherent Evil in to Kill a Mockingbird

1056 words - 5 pages To Kill a Mockingbird Analysis The age old argument of nature or nurture continues still today. what makes up the person is it nurture or nature? By nature the traits of evil are inherently imbed into their DNA, and that is not true. The fact is that the environment plays a larger role in the development of the personality. Which determines whether the person turns into a good or evil person. IN Harper Lee’s To Kill a Mockingbird, she conveys

Change in to Kill a Mockingbird

864 words - 4 pages Change “Change is a necessary part of growing up” Discuss how change is reflected in the experience of growing. As we get older, change is an important part of growing up. Whether it is physical, mentally or personality wise. Viewing the prescribed text, ‘To Kill a Mockingbird’, there are many changes to be found. Some people think of change as distasteful and redundant, however without it, where would we be? Change is a

Symbolism in to Kill a Mockingbird

1158 words - 5 pages Harper Lee effectively uses symbolism throughout her novel, To Kill a Mockingbird. Jem's nursing of the flowers denotes his courage that he nurses in order to be able to tolerate people's criticism of his family, especially of his father. He was forced to take care of the camellias just as he was forced to live with anger, disappointment and a big question mark in his young heart about the workings of grownups. Atticus "never thought Jem'd

Moral and Ethical Issues in Business

781 words - 4 pages when a person works for a company that requires a large amount of time for business out side of work. If there is an unreasonable demand for the time the employee needs to focus on work it can cause issues with a spouse or partner, family, and children. These are considered moral issues by many people. This situation puts the person in a difficult situation. They have to choose between ethical obligations to their employer and moral obligations

Ethical and Moral Issues in Business

639 words - 3 pages how a business is run. Those operating within ethical norms are the most successful. Ethics and morals are separate issues and within the business environment personal ethics should not dictate business decisions. To arrive at ethical solutions in the business environment one should be objective and view the situation from all sides. However, our moral compass will always guide how these decisions are made. No matter how ethical we are

Ethical And Moral Issues In Business

507 words - 3 pages Ethical and Moral Issues in Business In today’s business environment employees and manager feel pressure to compromise his or her ethical and moral beliefs. In industry, businesses are encountering issues that are wide spread throughout the industry. On the company side managers are dealing with company specific issues. What are some of the common ethical problems businesses are dealing with today? Knowing the difference between ethical and

Ethical and Moral Issues in Business

946 words - 4 pages external factors are modified. Ethical and moral issues differentiate, depending on the character and behavior of the individual influenced by the environment he or she is in. Personal ethics display a commitment to values important to the individual. This could include honesty, integrity, and trustworthiness. In the corporate environment business ethics include expectations of employee personal conduct and if this is in compliance with ethical

Ethics and Moral Issues in Business

674 words - 3 pages Ethical and Moral Issues in Business Moral and ethical issues greet us each morning in the weekly paper, meet us at our jobs, and bid us good night on the nightly news. We are faced with the rights of the homeless and abortion, and sexual morality. Dealing with these moral and ethical issues is confusing particularly when people are trying to think through an ethical issue and defining what questions to ask and what causes should be reflected

Ethical and Moral Issues in Business

534 words - 3 pages both were hired. The nurse knows even though this physician is a long time acquaintance and is a well respected physician that he violated the hospitals policies by stealing from the hospital. The nurse knows that this well respected Physician is breaking that code of conduct by stealing and in fact, stealing is against his own personal code of beliefs, however, it is also against her moral code to rat out a well respected physician. This is the

To Kill a Mockingbird

935 words - 4 pages The most important theme of the 1960 Pulitzer Prize winning novel To Kill a Mockingbird is author Harper Lee’s tenacious exploration of the moral nature of people. Lee tenaciously explores the moral nature of human beings, especially the struggle in every human soul between discrimination and tolerance. The novel is very effective in not only revealing prejudice, but in examining the nature of prejudice, how it works, and its consequences

Related Essays

The Message Of Moral Responsibility In To Kill A Mockingbird

1598 words - 7 pages The Message of Moral Responsibility in To Kill a Mockingbird Not only is To Kill a Mockingbird a fun novel to read, it is purposeful. Harper Lee wrote the novel to demonstrate the way in which the world and its people should live together in harmony through a basic moral attitude of treating others with respect and kindness. The novel received the Pulitzer Prize in 1960, which places it among the best adult novels ever written; although it

To Kill A Mockingbird Vs. A Time To Kill

1446 words - 6 pages later died. Tom was falsely accused, and his death was untimely and could have been avoided. But he accepted his fate calmly, as if he knew no matter what he would be convicted. The defendant in A Time To Kill, Carl Lee was accused of murder of the two men who raped his daughter. Carl was found not guilty, even though he did kill those men, and later on in life will have to deal with his actions. Both men had to deal with what the court brought against them, and they both did. Carl and Tom dealt with multiple issues, but the prejudices of their race, and the time they were tried ultimately determined their fates.

Moral Issues In Business Essay

1062 words - 5 pages * Moral Issues In Business * Environmental Protection Why Is The Issue of Environment Crucial To Us Today? The resources of this planet are finite and limited – as also its capacity to absorb and dispose of all the waste and garbage we generate. ‘Growth’ ‘Progress’ and ‘Development’ have spelt out one thing: increased consumption of material goods. Increased consumption of material goods has led to irreversible exploitation of

Families In To Kill A Mockingbird

651 words - 3 pages descriptors and try to show the values of the other dysfunctional families found in Maycomb: The Ewells are "the disgrace of Maycomb for three generations" in part because of the lack of a mother as the Finch, its a single-parent family Bob. they too are a single-parent family. But in contrary to Atticus, Bob spend little time with his children. he's sometimes drunk and He turns over the parenting responsabilities to his oldest daughter Mayella who