This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Mixing Law And Medicine Essay

3081 words - 13 pages

Mixing Law and Medicine:
A Lethal Combination

“First do no harm” is the foundations that medical practices are based on, but there times in which the lines are blurred and physicians must question their ethical, legal and moral participation in procedures. Physician participation in executions of convicted criminals is explored in this paper. The history of the death penalty, including the early involvement of physicians is surveyed. The pros and cons as well of the legal and ethical grounds for medical professionals are weighed ultimately present the necessity for qualified medical professionals to carry out state sanctioned executions regardless of one’s position on ...view middle of the document...

X. Being for or against capital punishment is not the issue.
XI. Conclusion

Laws, rules, and any semblance of such are a necessity in order for society to function on even the most basic level. From the rules of table top Monopoly to the Supreme Court interpreting the Constitution, guidelines must be created and enforced to achieve a more uniform functioning world (Judson, 2006, p. 7). When policy is created, the primary concern is generally the focus on which the body is attempting to govern. The task of trying to consider all the possible conflicts with other associations would be impossible. While the laws of the land serve as a pillar for the legal system, the code of ethics serve as the pillar for the medical associations. Because policy of governing medical associations often conflict with Federal law or local statues concerned with physician’s involvement in court ordered executions, physicians potentially find themselves with the difficult decision of upholding the ethical foundations of their professions or using their competent medical training to implement in the most humane way in the final turn in the wheels of justice. Even though physician’s participation in the implementation of court ordered executions are in direct violation of the fundamental directive of the Physician’s Code of Ethics, “First, do no harm…,” it is a necessary product of the practice to ensure a “good death” for the convicted.
Due to the influence of English Common Law, executions have been employed by the United States of America since its inception. Primitive forms of executions exercised in the United States included being pressed to death, drawn and quartered, and burned at the stake. In 1608, the first person was sentences to death by hanging in the American Colonies. Even in these early archaic devices, physicians had their influence in executions for justice (Banner, 2002, p. 5). Just such a device is the Guillotine, a device used to behead the convicted person. In 1792, the guillotine was fueled by Dr. Joseph Guillotine who purposed to the English government that the death penalty should be imposed on the guilty who had committed crimes punishable by executions regardless of social rank and that such punishment should be carried out in a swift action to eliminate any undue suffering. The government quickly adopted his idea and commissioned building the “Guillotine” device (History of the Guillotine). Such primeval executions were defined as “cruel and unusual punishment” and were banned in the U.S. with the ratification of the Eighth Amendment of the United States Constitution in 1789 (Banner, 2002, p. 231). Death by hanging remained the loan permissible form of execution until the invention of electricity (American College of Physicians; Physicians for Human Rights, 1994). In 1881, Dr. Albert Southwick, a dentist, happened to witness a drunken man inadvertently make lethal contact with the terminals of an electric...

Other Papers Like Mixing Law and Medicine

Ventria Bioscience Essay

1211 words - 5 pages product,the crop and tissues in which the plant-made medicine is produced, and the environment in which the crop is grown. Ventria’s rice crop faces numerous risk factors, they are: (1) pollen drift may fertilize nearby food or feed crops of the same species; (2) commingling of plant-made medicine crops and food or feed crops may occur as a result of improper labeling, mixing of seed during planting, harvesting, transportation, or processing

The Dialogue with Alternative Medicine Essay

534 words - 3 pages indeed far longer history than conventional one that had sprung from the former. One of their differences is in their respective philosophy and methodology. Conventional medicine is mainly based on analytic and positivistic approach toward human body. Medical doctors regard a human body as a mechanism regulated by scientific law. Human body is supposed to be measured and controlled (without exception, in principle) by scientific method


895 words - 4 pages (m) = # of moles of solute per kilogram of solvent NOT temperature dependent. Represents a ratio of solute:solvent molecules at all times. [pic] Exercise 1 Various Methods for Describing Solution Composition A solution is prepared by mixing 1.00 g ethanol (C2H5OH) with 100.0 g water to give a final volume of 101 mL. Calculate the molarity, mass percent, mole fraction, and molality of ethanol in this solution

Learning Disability, Eugenics and the Social Model Approach

1864 words - 8 pages care’. The 1601 Poor Law was also instrumental in bringing about the rise of Poor Law Hospitals and asylums (Rushton, 1988). The institutionalisation of learning disabled people began with the Poor Law Amendment Act of 1834, which introduced the concept of the workhouse. By the 1790s there were 127 workhouses in England. Workhouses favoured ‘idiots’ over ‘lunatics’ as they were better workers and generated lots of revenue for the owners. In some

Understanding Alternative Medicine

4101 words - 17 pages Understanding Alternative Medicine Modern medicine is in a period of profound change. Everyday, more and more ideas from other cultures are being transferred and integrated into our society. Many treatments that people are now familiar with have come from other traditions. Aspirin and quinine are two familiar examples of treatments that have been “westernized” by science. Alternative medical traditions will not replace western medicine, but

Free Euthanasia And Doctor-Assisted Suicide Essay - Assisted Suicide

1023 words - 5 pages complex and has profound consequences for all. Because the subject involves the discipline of medicine (diagnosis, treatment, prognosis, medical ethics and so on) as well as the discipline of law, the general public will have difficulty understanding it without some knowledge of these matters.   We begin with the definition of terms: * Euthanasia: traditionally, an easy, painless death. Now used to mean "mercy killing," "assisted suicide

Perveted Justice

897 words - 4 pages Analysis of “Perverted Justice” by Jacob Sullum Name College Tutor Course Date The issues evident in Jacob Sullum’s article are very critical and need careful examination if we are to achieve a just society. Most of the issues he has brought concern provisions in the Megan law which has provided for registration of sex offenders. According to Jacob, registration of sex offenders has gone way too far. To him

Law, Tort Law, Criminal Law, Contracts, And Civil Procedure

1720 words - 7 pages consumer could not claim in circumstances such as a manufacturer negligently mixing poison into a drink. Lord Buckmaster referring to the dicta of Brett MR in Heaven v. Pender and the decision in George v. Skivington (1867) LR5 Ex 1 (which were applied by Lord Atkins): ". It is in my opinion better that they should be buried so securely that their perturbed spirits shall no longer vex the law." You must take reasonable care to avoid acts or

"Briar Rose", by Anne Sexton - Analysis

605 words - 3 pages begins applying some of today's modern day medicine to the story, by saying that Briar Rose would be unable to sleep "...without the court chemist mixing her some knock-out drops" (lines 106-107). From that point on, Anne Sexton slowly applies her life to the poem, and adds the parts of her like that she has trouble with into her poem. It seems as though she does this almost unconsciously and unintentionally.By line 120, Anne Sexton has completely

Fr E3 Sample Copy

3577 words - 15 pages chemical kinetics. The iodine-clock reaction aims to explain concepts of reaction rate and show the effects of major factors in the reaction rates including the concentration, temperature and presence of catalyst between persulfate and iodide ion. Five different runs with different concentrations of S2O82- and I- were prepared to find the reaction order of each reactant using the initial rate methods and graphical methods. The rate law established

Plessy V. Ferguson

994 words - 4 pages 1. What are the important and relevant faces of the case? 2. What issues is the court addressing? What is the legal problem? 3. What law is the court applying? 4. What is the court’s decision, analysis, and rationale? For this week, you need to find a case that deals with Due Process, the Equal Protection Clause or Delegation. Plessy v. Ferguson (1896) What are the important and relevant faces of the case? The Case is based

Related Essays

Mississippi Childhood Obesity Essay

588 words - 3 pages medicine for a diagnosis as simple as leg cramps. For many years, this been has been the number 3 one recommendation for pain, and still is today. The drug is also known as an analgesic that is more effective and sensitive to the stomach than aspirin. In 1994, the court case between Benedi vs. McNeil, alleging McNeil Laboratories failed to warn the public of possible dangers when mixing alcohol and Tylenol together causing bodily harm

Nursing: Consent To Share Essay

2149 words - 9 pages professional indemnity insurance. It is explained by Griffith, R. and Davies, R (2003) that the law requires, for the administration of medicines, that satisfaction is given on four areas of accountability: To the Public (Consumer Protection Act, 1987) To the Patient (Human Rights Act 1998) To the Employer To the Profession (NMC Code of Conduct 2008) In this particular instance, the issue is one of covert administration of medicine. Whilst

Memorandum Essay

989 words - 4 pages the leader in Energy Drink sales I believe we should be industry leading in making standards within our industry higher regarding warning labels. I also believe we can be a responsible corporation by working with legislatures to write and make into law regulations for our industry. As a consumer I will be much more vigilant in my consumption of not only energy drinks but, all natural ingredient containing foods and beverages not only alone but, with in regards to mixing them with other foods, beverages, and medications.

Health Care Information Technology Benefits And Problems

974 words - 4 pages protects each patient form information leaking out or being missed used in anyway. With transferring information from one system to another this needs to be done carefully. Mixing patient records can cause miss-diagnosis, billing information and possible financial harm on the patient. To prevent this we need to make sure the information we enter is correct with the patient that had the services done. With a new healthcare system coming on board and