This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Mercer V. Duke University Essay

1705 words - 7 pages

Mercer v. Duke University
The case of Mercer v. Duke University deals with the issue of women being allowed to play on contact sports teams. This case also raises issues of discrimination and whether or not federally funded institutions are prohibited from discrimination under Title IX. This is a very good case because it deals with a high-profile university and whether or not discrimination was an issue of one of the university’s college athletics.
The Mercer v. Duke University case was about a student named Heather Mercer who attended Duke University and tried out for the Duke Football team as a walk-on placekicker in the fall of 1994. Mercer was an all-state kicker at her former high ...view middle of the document...

” (Mercer v. Duke University ). Mercer also claimed that Goldsmith made offensive comments towards her such as why she was interested in football and why she didn’t want to “participate in beauty pageants rather than football and sit in the stands with her boyfriend rather than the sidelines. (Mercer v. Duke University ). At the start of the 1996 season, Mercer was informed by Goldsmith that she was no longer going to be on the football team and that she could try out for the team in the fall of the following year. When the 1997 season came around, instead of trying out for the team, Mercer filed a suit against Duke and Goldsmith.
The suit alleged sex discrimination in violation of Title IX of the Education Amendment of 1972, (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1681-1688), and negligent misrepresentation and breach of contract in violation of North Carolina law. Title IX states, “No person in the United States shall, on the basis of sex, be excluded from participation in, be denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any education program or activity receiving Federal financial assistance….” (Breaux, Breaux and Brooks). Congress also gave the Department of Health, Education, and Welfare (HEW) with responsibility for developing regulations in regards to how Title IX should be applied to athletic programs. Both Duke and Goldsmith filed a motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim under Title IX. The district court granted the motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim under Title IX on November 9, 1998. The district court also denied Mercer’s motion to alter judgment and Mercer went on the appeal the district court’s ruling.
The appeal was sent to the U.S. Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals. Mercer was the appellant and Duke and Goldsmith were the appellees. Duke and Goldsmith argued that because football was a contact sport, it was therefore excluded from Title IX coverage. Duke and Goldsmith said that under 34 CFR Sec. 106.41. Athletics, subsection (b) stated that:
Where a recipient operates or sponsors a team in a particular sport for members of one sex but operates or sponsors no such team for members of the other sex, and athletic opportunities for members of that sex have previously been limited, members of the excluded sex must be allowed to try out for the team offered unless the sport involved is a contact sport (Breaux, Breaux and Brooks).
Football was a listed as a contact sport, but the appeals court disagreed with Goldsmith’s and Duke’s attempt to appeal under the 34 CFR Sec. 106.41 (b) regulation. The reason why the court disagreed was because the appellees acknowledged that the athletic opportunities for women at Duke have been limited. The court also found that subsection (a) was met as well. Subsection (a) under the 34 CFR Sec. 106.41 regulation stated that:
No person shall, on the basis of sex, be excluded from participation in, be denied the benefits of, be treated differently from another person, or otherwise...

Other Papers Like Mercer V. Duke University

Duke Lacrosse Law Case Essay

589 words - 3 pages Zachary Weil Fundamentals of Business Law Short Paper 1/30/11 The legal decision being discussed in this paper is Evans v. City of Durham, where Duke University lacrosse players Reade Seligmann, David Evans, and Colin Finnerty were wrongfully charged with rapping a striper during a team party. The case, however, collapsed after Durham, N.C., District Attorney Michael D. Nifong deliberately withheld evidence that law and ethical rules

Consensual Relationship Agreements Essay

1272 words - 6 pages faculty-student relationships. The student teacher represents a special case, because the integrity of this relationship is of fundamental importance to the central mission of the institution (Duke University, pg. 1, 2002). The Penn State scandal is a recent and degrading example. In exploring why individuals engage in workplace romances, theories of attraction play a vital role in explaining the development of romances, and social psychology

Psy/475 Testing Worksheet

667 words - 3 pages psychological testing is the Griggs v Duke Power case of 1971. This case also influenced to the Civil Rights Act of 1964 (Hogan, 2007). During the time, discrimination against the African American race was still high although the Civil Rights Act was passed before the case and slavery was still at a high percentage (Hogan, 2007). The cases issues surrounded African Americans hiring for males and female alike, also treatment and fairness of minorities (Hogan

“the Worm of a Conscience”

1095 words - 5 pages accomplish this goal Richard, Duke of Gloucester, allies with many of his brother’s noblemen and plots to over throw the throne with nothing to stop him. Richard III is determined to achieve his goal at all costs and posses characteristics to meet his fortitude. Throughout the play Richard III, Richard has done many sinful deeds alongside his followers to obtain the crown. The audience were able to admire some of Richard’s traits however; a trait that

Affirmative Action

1202 words - 5 pages minority groups. This is one of the most misunderstood civil rights issues of our time. The universities that utilize affirmative action for student enrollment are Harvard University, Brown University, the University of Chicago, Dartmouth College, Duke University, the University of Pennsylvania, Princeton and, Yale University. These colleges joined together in 2003 to voice their support for the continued use of race-conscious admissions programs


2176 words - 9 pages : Its Customs, Growth, & Ceremonies. CPH, 1967. Koenker, Ernest B. The Liturgical Renaissance in the Roman Catholic Church. CPH, 1954. Kolb, Robert. For All the Saints: Changing Preceptions of Martyrdom and Sainthood in the Lutheran Reformation. Mercer University Press, 1987. Krispin, Gerald. "Odo Casel and the Kultmysterium" The Confessional Lutheran Research Society Newsletter (Easter 1991), 1-4. Kunze, Gerhard. "Die Lesungen" in Leiturgia


1114 words - 5 pages supervision, including Charlotte. According to the Civil Rights Project, an average black student in 1991 attended to a school that was evenly split, racially. Two decades later, a black student attends a school with 76 percent minority student body. North Carolina is becoming increasingly multiracial. But efforts to balance student bodies to reflect that population have been subsided or met with little success. A study from Duke University finds

Oil and Gas 2

1270 words - 6 pages . Representative nubots include the several DNA walkers reported by Ned Seeman's group at NYU, Niles Pierce's group at Caltech, John Reif's group at Duke University, Chengde Mao's group at Purdue, and Andrew Turberfield's group at the University of Oxford. [edit] Positional nanoassembly Nanofactory Collaboration[10], founded by Robert Freitas and Ralph Merkle in 2000, is a focused ongoing effort involving 23 researchers from 10 organizations

Special Measures for Australian Indigenous

3378 words - 14 pages Indigenous Australians, Discussion No. 193, (Professor Jon Altman), The Australian National University, Canberra, 2000. [ 2 ]. Ibid 5. [ 3 ]. Renata Grossi, ‘Racial discrimination protection in Australian law: a snapshot.’ (2009) 21 (3) LegalDate. [ 4 ]. Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld). [ 5 ]. Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld). [ 6 ]. Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld) s11(4). [ 7 ]. 401 US 424 (1971). [ 8 ]. Griggs v Duke Power Co 401 US

Creationism vs

1232 words - 5 pages very complex and has not been solved in the scientific community. Religion, however, has been shown to cause significant damage to the brain. “In March of 2012, Amy Owen and her colleagues at Duke University conducted a scientific study on the effects of religion to the brain. They evaluated the MRIs of 268 men and women aged 58 and over. The results showed significantly greater hippocampal atrophy in individuals reporting a life-changing

Case Of The Unpopular Pay

7368 words - 30 pages misleading, incorrect, or sometimes botb at tbe same time. Tbe result is that businesspeople end up adopting v/rongbeaded notions about bow to pay people and wby. They believe in six dangerous myths about pay-fictions Jeffrey Pfeffer is the Thomas D. Dee Professor of Organizational Behavior at the Stanford Graduate School of Business in Stanford, California. He is the author of The Human Equation: Building Profits by Putting People First (Harvard

Related Essays

Women In Sports Essay

1291 words - 6 pages Second Division team. She not only played for Team Canada Hockey (of which she contributed to several gold medals), she also played for Team Canada Softball as well. Heather Mercer was a football place-kicker who could kick approximately 35 yards - pretty good for a woman - who attended Duke University. However, she was not allowed to play for the men's team after trying out due to controversial issues with her gender. Although she was not

Mergers & Acquisitions The Role Of Hrm

1759 words - 8 pages research by Nick Holley, Henley Business School 2009 The role of HRM in cross-border M&A’s – by Ruth V. Aguilera and John C. Dekker (Int. J. of HRM 15:8 December 2004) M&A’s- Understanding the Role of HM – by Craig W. Fontaine, Ph.D., July 2007(Northeastern University) B&Q Asia – Role of HR Managers in M&A’s – by Tracy O’Connell, HR Director, April 2006 (Kingfisher) 1 2 Why HR Can Make or Break Your M&A - Andrew F. Giffin and Jeffrey A

T He Beginning Of Seattle History Essay

1843 words - 8 pages up from another of his bordellos in San Francisco (Meier 1990). Others soon joined the industry of sin, amongst them were respectable citizens such as Asa Mercer and his “Mercer Belles” and even woman began to realize their share of financial success in the industry. Mary Anne Conklin, soon to be known as “Madame Damnable”, quickly established herself as one of the foremost brothel owners in the city. Conklins clapboard Felker House was erected

Affirmative Action Essay

3156 words - 13 pages affirmative action policies began to evolve and shape, many landmark cases came about to further improve and challenge the legislation. In the Griggs v. Duke Power case in 1971, the Supreme Court ruled against Duke Power’s employment requirement of high school diplomas for unskilled jobs, a practice which had a disparate impact on minority workers. Most importantly, the case set a precedent that employers may not engage in hiring practices which