Mencius And Xunzi On Cultivation Essay

2172 words - 9 pages

Confucius inspired a humanistic and ethical outlook that was developed further by prime disciples Mencius and Xunzi. This development took place amidst the background of arguments against other thinkers or in response to their criticisms of Confucianism. However, there was a disagreement within the Confucian school, as well, as shown by Xunzi’s critique of Mencius. It may be perceived that Mencius has the dominant position in the Confucian tradition as Mencius’s belief that human nature is originally good has often been interpreted into certain sayings of Confucius. Additionally, Xunzi’s claim that human nature is “evil” and that people can be transformed to become good may be inconsistent, ...view middle of the document...

If man were not innately good, Mencius argued, how could he possibly learn to be a good citizen? (De Bary 142) Mencius nevertheless maintained that the individual must cultivate and the state must nurture, guide, and help maintain his goodness (De Bary 123). For Mencius, the “great person is one who does not lose the child’s mind” (De Bary 141). Thus, in order to be a worthy nobleman, man should carry his childlike innocence and simplicity into his adulthood. Mencius believes that in the original nature of man there are tendencies that would prompt him to act in a moral way:
The goodness of human nature is like the downward course of water. There is no human being lacking in the tendency to do good, just as there is no water lacking in the tendency to flow downward. Now by striking water and splashing it, you may cause it to go over your head, and by damming and channeling it, you can force it to flow uphill…It is the force that makes this happen. While people can be made to do what is not good, what happens to their nature is like this (De Bary 147).
The trees on Ox Mountain were once beautiful. But being situated on the outskirts of a large state, the trees are hewn down by axes. Could they remain beautiful? Seeing this barrenness, people suppose that the mountain was never wooded. But how could this be the nature of the mountain? So it is also, with what is preserved in a human being: could it be that anyone should lack the mind of humaneness and rightness?
These passages establish that Mencius regards human nature as innately good. To say that human nature is good; however, is not to say that all people behave well. To guide human beings toward goodness is like guiding a stream of water to flow downward. Just as the natural tendency of water is to flow downward, so the natural tendency of human beings is to be benevolent and good. Indeed Mencius agreed that he lived in decadent times rife with evil as various states competed violently against one another for mastery of China, however, the question is not whether evil flourishes; it is whether evil is “natural” or a perversion.

Xunzi was a skeptical thinker; known for his theory that human nature tends toward evil, he argued forcefully for the importance of ritual and education. Although Xunzi’s theory seems to directly contrast Mencius’s, they had much more in common than their differences. Xunzi’s most famous essay begins as follows:

Human nature is evil; goodness derives from conscious activity. Now it is human nature to be born with a fondness for profit…[o]ne is born with feelings of envy and hate, and, by indulging these, one is led into banditry and theft, so that the sense of loyalty and good faith with which one was born disappears. One is born with the desires of the ears and eyes and with a fondness for beautiful sights and sounds, and, by indulging these, one is led to licentiousness and chaos, so that the sense of ritual, rightness, refinement, and...

Other Papers Like Mencius and Xunzi on Cultivation

Inherently Evil: A Look At Dictators

1006 words - 5 pages followers. He was educated in various Islamic schools and became a Shi’ite scholar and teacher. Khomeini produced numerous writings on Islamic philosophy, law, and ethics. It is his religious teachers that influenced him in such a way that he had an uncompromising advocacy for Islamic purity, which also got him his initial following in Iran. Khomeini spoke out against the shah’s reduction of religious estates and the emancipation of women

Germany Greenhouse Market Future Outlook and Statistics, 2018

617 words - 3 pages Germany Greenhouse Cultivation Market Outlook to 2018 - Government Initiatives to Propel Growth provides a comprehensive analysis of the various aspects such as market size of the Germany Greenhouse Cultivation Market, market segmentation on the basis of vegetables, fruits, flowers and tree nurseries grown by number and area covered and macroeconomic factors affecting the industry. The report also covers the market shares and revenues of major

Buddhism Term Paper

2246 words - 9 pages out. He emphasis that he is not saying that people can’t do otherwise, as learning to become bad, but out nature is good. He gives a proof that all people are inclined towards the good – Our natural first impulses are going to be toward the good. – Imagine a little baby playing on the edge of very deep water well, one slight movement will cause her to fall and die. Mencius argues that any human being that will see this scenario will feel an

Queen’S Sport Staff Motivation

3801 words - 16 pages were surveyed. 2. Literature Review It could be argued that as soon as man organised himself into a working unit the role of leader and worker or manager and employee was born. The ancient philosopher Mencius (370 – 286 BC) recognised this division of labour defining it as; “Those who labour with their minds govern others; those who labour with their strength are governed by others” The Chinese Classics: Vol. 2 the Life

Managerial Analysis and Communication

2436 words - 10 pages abiding by the terms and conditions set by the panchayat. c. Let the tank be allowed to be used for cultivation purpose. • Mr. Nishar Saiyed shouldn’t do anything and be passive. • Allow long term cultivation on terms and conditions set by panchayat. EVALUATION OF ALTERNATIVES Alternative 1: Saving the tank and prohibiting any kind of cultivation in the area Advantages: • Village tank is used for

Self Awareness

795 words - 4 pages cues in the environment and how our emotions affect our way of relating to others. Social work is a profession that is founded on the ability to cultivate positive relationships with people who may be very different from us. There may be differences in age, race, personality, gender, socioeconomic status, health, sexual orientation, rank, power, and privilege, as well as beliefs regarding religion and politics. The experience of these

Aboriginal Society Pre Settlement

1722 words - 7 pages used and adapted to local needs. Aborigines never put out their fires. Indeed Clarke (1992:8) argues that Aborigines possessed no methods of controlling fires once they had begun an as such they were inevitably left to burn out on their own or until it rained.Fire-stick farming is a rather passive form of existence and it is often questioned why Aborigines never developed any form of tillage or cultivation of cereal grains or fruit (Clarke 1992:9

Food Inflation

597 words - 3 pages pluses are higher then why the farmers are not concentrating on growing those more in order to earn more profits. Reasons for low non-cereal output are:- Pulses: - Pulses are fundamentally different from cereals since they need more nutrients and energy for synthesizing both proteins and carbohydrates unlike cereals that need to synthesize only carbohydrates. This makes them more vulnerable to the vagaries of weather than either rice or wheat

Biol 120 Lesson 02 Assignment

518 words - 3 pages Questions for Submission (75 pts total) Answer each of the following questions as completely as possible. Your answers should be no longer than a few sentences. (15 pts) 1. Make a list of all the foods you consume in one typical day. Break your list apart and try to determine what different species of plants you consume on a daily basis. Using the table in your text as a guide, estimate what percentage of your diet is accounted for by the

importance of music

575 words - 3 pages Govt.Music has a religions origin everywhere. So there is something in music that exalts and ennobles our heart and keeps under control the baser propensities or tendencies. Children have a natural taste for music and it is certainly desirable to introduce music as a compulsory subject of study in the lower stages of our school, to foster and encourage the cultivation of music from the earliest years. It will have a salutary effect on the entire

Fijian Pottery Analysis

602 words - 3 pages carried with them more advanced subsistence skills such as building fortified villages. According to the Fijian researcher Palmer, who conducted field investigations, hypothesized that based on their distribution in alluvial flatlands, ring ditch forts were a post European response to European contact, population increases, and agricultural intensification Upland fortified sites were dependent on shifting cultivation for subsistence. It was

Related Essays

Mencius And Xunzi On Human Nature

1042 words - 5 pages in the ability of humans in general to aspire to higher personal cultivation. Mencius states, “if one does what is not good, that is not the fault of ones capacities” (149) and similarly Xunzi also claims, “The man on the street can become a Yu” (183) meaning any man on the street has the natural endowment needed to understand virtue.

Confucianism Essay

1209 words - 5 pages Chunqiu, the only work reputedly compiled by Confucius himself, is a chronicle of major historical events in feudal China from the 8th century BC to Confucius's death early in the 5th century BC.The Shih Shu (Four Books), compilations of the sayings of Confucius and Mencius and of commentaries by followers on their teachings, are the Lun Yü (Analects), a collection of maxims by Confucius that form the basis of his moral and political

1. “Human Nature Is Bad.” Xunzi / "人之性惡." 荀子 Explain Why You Agree Or Disagree With Xunzi's Statement

1190 words - 5 pages Human’s unspeakable history of savagery, murder and war – be it the Nazi genocide of six million Jews in World War II or the gang rape and murder of a mentally-challenged woman in India this year – appears to be in substantiation of Xunzi’s notion that human nature is bad. Nonetheless, there is no lack of incidents shedding light on the empathy, selflessness and righteousness of humans in such cases as the engineers on RMS Titanic discharging

Shifting Cultivation Essay

435 words - 2 pages Journal of Forestry Research (2012) 23(4): 623−630 DOI 10.1007/s11676-012-0303-z ORIGINAL PAPER Shifting cultivation effects on creek water quality around Barkal Upazila in Chittagong Hill Tracts, Bangladesh Shyamal Karmakar • S. M. Sirajul Haque • M. Mozaffar Hossain • Sohag Miah Received: 2011-07-20; Accepted: 2012-07-20 © Northeast Forestry University and Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2012 Abstract: We report the